for Institute War and Peace Reporting
Vacancies Vacancies Internships Internships Reporting Reporting Research & Training Research & Training Mentor Programme Mentor Programme Safety & Security Safety & Security Current Programmes Current Programmes Past Programmes Past Programmes Aims & Activities Aims & Activities Staff Staff Board of Trustees Board of Trustees Supporters Supporters Partner Organizations Partner Organizations Thursday, February 12, 2004
Kyrgyz Metal Mystery Parliamentary deputies claim corrupt officials are blocking their efforts to improve regulation of export market. By Leila Saralaeva in Bishkek (RCA No. 264, 11-Feb-04) Kyrgyz deputies struggling to introduce a draft law to reduce exports of scrap metals believe they are being hindered by corrupt officials. Rising prices have led to a steep rise in demand for metals in the former Soviet republic leading to crime as people steal electricity cables and even dig up radioactive machinery to sell to scrap dealers. One teenager, who is currently on trial for theft in the town of Sokuluk, is alleged to have emptied a metal canister belonging to a cattle breeding company in order to sell it to a scrap dealer for 18 US dollars. Unknown to him, the bull semen he threw away was worth around 1,200 dollars. As this greed for metal has led to shortages in some areas, and serious power cuts after vital cabling has been stolen, parliamentary deputy Zamirbek Parmankulov proposed a temporary ban on exports of ferrous and non-ferrous metals in an attempt to reduce the demand. Until a new law is passed, I suggested a temporary ban but only 26 deputies supported me, five votes less than needed, Parmankulov told IWPR. There are people in our chamber who oppose the passing of this law. I am confronting an organised group of people who possess enormous capital. Anything could happen and I have already been threatened, he said. There are suspicions that some senior government officials are making too much money from the metal trade to want to regulate it, as the high demand
is in their favour. Vladimir Tolokontsev, who holds a seat in parliament as an independent, told IWPR, There have been occasions when entire freight cars of metal with inadequate documentation were seized, but when law enforcement agencies start investigating, high-ranking officials appeared and the freight cars were mysteriously allowed to go on their way. Deputies have been trying for two years to pass legislation which would control the process of purchasing and exporting metal. It was even approved in our chamber, but it never reached the president. Another opposition deputy Dooronbek Sadyrbaev also alleges that some high-ranking officials have a vested interest in allowing such a profitable business to flourish. I cannot tell you specific names, but the financial interests of some very important people are involved there, Sadyrbaev told IWPR. Tolekan Ismailova, head of the Civil Society Against Corruption association, believes that the purchase and export of metal represents a clear example of corruption. It is a regulated system managed by high-ranking officials who take advantage of their status to block any questions from the law enforcement agencies. Therefore, it is beneficial for the government to pretend that there is no problem, she said. Metal is a lucrative business even at the lowest end of the scale, and an increasing number of people are becoming more and more daring in their attempts to steal it. A spokesperson for the joint stock company Severelectro told IWPR that around 12 people a year are killed by electrocution while trying to steal cables to sell on to scrap metal yards. In 2003, criminals stole some 72 kilometres of cable worth more than 50,000 dollars, Severelectro secretary press Natalia Orlova told IWPR. On January 15, Severelectro petitioned the government to ban the purchase and export of ferrous metals. Analysts say that the damage done by such thefts is hard to repair since power companies are desperately short of cash reserves. As a result, many districts suffer ongoing power cuts and supply difficulties for months at a time. The Karabalta Mining Combine is also concerned by the metal industrys lack of regulation. Its director Vladimir Mashenko told IWPR, We have existed for 50 years, and all our unserviceable equipment is buried because of uranium contamination. Now scavengers are digging up these radioactive items to sell to metal yards. All kinds of metals are at risk of being stolen by enterprising thieves. In the capital Bishkek, manhole covers are routinely stolen from the streets more than 100 in 2003 alone with the result that pedestrians are increasingly falling down the holes. Internal affairs ministry spokesman Joldoshbek Buzurmankulov told IWPR, In the last year 1,583 thefts of non-ferrous and ferrous metal were recorded in Kyrgyzstan. Around half were thefts of wire and cable, the rest involve pots, pans and other aluminium items being taken from members of the public. If one goes in the direction of the Kyrgyz-Chinese border, a never-ending procession of huge trucks loaded with scrap metal can be seen. Our metal goes to China for a meagre price, but comes back in the form of various goods which we buy for 10 times more, he claimed, adding that he believed it was time for the government to introduce strict limitations on issuing licenses for the sale and purchase of metal. The state enterprise Temir - which for two years has been managing the licensing purchases and exports of metal - denies that it is in any way to blame for the burgeoning illegal market.
Its deputy director Nariman Tuleev went so far as to lay the blame for many incidents on employees of power companies. Cable thefts are committed by electricians themselves, because a non-professional wont climb up the power lines for fear of electrocution, he alleged. Leila Saralaeva is an independent journalist in Bishkek. Send this article to a friend Previous article Recent IWPR Stories of Related Interest: Kyrgyzstan: Fury Over Sales Tax By Natalia Domagalskaia, Gulnura Toralieva and Dina Maslova in Bishkek (RCA No. 240, 10-Oct-03)
Past Reports
2003Issue No. Dec250-254 Nov243-249 Oct239-242 Sep231-238 Aug221-230 Jul213-220 Jun208-212 RCA Archive Spotlight on the Batken New at IWPR Round table reports: Sexual Exploitation of Minors: Problems and Solutions, Bureaucrats Forced to Speak Kyrgyz, Bishkek The Lessons of Georgia and Azerbaijan, Bishkek Russias new attempt to reassert its influence in post-soviet area, Bishkek
Dushanbe
Maps & Country Profiles
IWPR Profiles: The faces behind the stories IWPR in the News
Sunday Times names iwpr.net best alternative news website in 2003
"Good war reporting will always find an outlet. The invaluable work of IWPR is already charting the way forward." Robin Lustig RUSSIAN Encoding To view articles in russian you may need to go to View > Encoding > Cyrillic (Windows) Support
To support IWPR's work in Central Asia, contact Jonathan Campbell, or make an online donation. IWPR thanks the following for their generous support of IWPR's Central Asia programme.
Institute for War & Peace Reporting Lancaster House, 33 Islington High Street, London N1 9LH, UK Tel: [phone] Fax: [phone] The opinions expressed in IWPR Online are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of the Institute for War and Peace Reporting. Registered as a charity in the United Kingdom (charity reg. no: 1027201, company reg. no: 2744185)