Technical BIOMED Design Rubric Term 1
Course: _______________________________________ Date: _____________________
Student(s): ______________________________________________________________________________ 3 - Excellent Identification of the problem
Score:
The problem has been shown (not just stated) to exist with supporting factual evidence.
2 Good
A problem statement has been stated.
1 - Adequate
The problem statement has weak support.
0 - Inadequate
Problem has not been stated clearly and lacks any supporting evidence.
Research and information gathering
Score:
Existing solutions to the problem, including their good and bad points, have been stated.
Existing solutions have been stated. Additional discussion may be warranted in places.
A complete review of existing solutions and research related to this problem is not presented.
Connection between references and what is written is not clear. Little investigation has been done.
Definition of the project
Score:
There are clear expectations of the specific outputs or deliverables for the project. A set of measurable performance requirements has been created. A comprehensive listing of critical design criteria is provided All design criteria have been justified All design criteria have been associated with requirement A plan stating the cost, completion date, and required resources has been presented. Gantt charts and a budget spreadsheet have been generated. A significant portion of project this involves technical information outside the scope of the undergraduate curriculum.
Expectations have been stated. Some objectives may not be measurable.
Expectations have been stated. Most objectives are not measurable.
Expectations are not clear. Expectations are not measurable.
Development of a plan
Score:
A comprehensive listing of critical design criteria is provided Majority of design criteria have been justified Majority of requirements have been identified Some aspects of the plan have not been fully developed.
The comprehensive listing of critical design criteria is incomplete or inadequate. Some of the design criteria are justified Some requirements have been identified Few aspects of the plan have been developed.
The comprehensive listing of critical design criteria is incomplete or inadequate. Design criteria are not justifie...