Brains Matrioshka Some Intermediate Stages in the Evolution of Life
The name is taken from Matryoshka1 those Russian dolls embedded in each other because it might be expected that these brains might be shells of matter embedded within each other.
1
This attached picture is taken from http://www.natashascafe.com/html/doll.html.
An artists conception of what such a brain may look like2. Sometimes the literature refers to them as Jupiter brains they need not necessarily be shells, but can be constructed of a different architecture or materials. A solid or semi-solid diamandoid structure consisting of atoms and molecules at normal (everyday) densities. A solid structure made of degenerate matter this material could be supported through electron or neutron degeneracy
2
http://www.aeiveos.com/~bradbury/MatrioshkaBrains/MatrioshkaBrains.html#KardashevCivilizations.
Artists conception is taken from
pressure (remember Pauli exclusion principle). This provides huge orders of magnitude increase in information density, processing speeds, and bandwidths. The shell of normal matter surrounding a star or other energy source? Black holes it is believed they can store information and process it as well, using the laws of thermodynamics. These brains are essentially megascale computers operating (so it is believed) at a capacity at or very near the physical or thermodynamic limits of their constituent materials, OR EVEN AT THE LIMITS PLACED BY THE UNIVERSE ITSELF THE BEKENSTEIN LIMIT.
Important Aspects of Matrioshka (or Jupiter) Brains3
The important, universal factors limiting the processing ability and information storage of these brains are the following. These limits are derived from physical arguments and upper limits on what we know about atoms, degenerate matter, and quantum mechanics. We make NO other sets of assumptions such as what exactly this brain is made of, how it operates, etc. 1. Processing and information density limited by materials used and the sizes of individual components or by laws of physics. a. Normal matter (~1 gm/cm3 density) 1021 bits/cm3 for a diamondoid substance. b. Degenerate (white dwarf) matter 1030 bits/cm3. c. Degenerate (neutron star) matter, or quark-gluon plasmas, or some weird condensates (details can be found in the paper and references therein) 1040 bits/cm3. 2. Processing speed limited by, again, the time scale for natural processes4. a. Molecular devices (may include organic or semiconductor or diamondoid), which are limited by energy to break up bonds 10-15 seconds. b. Nuclear matter devices (in degenerate matter) are limited by the time scale of nuclear reactions 10-24 seconds or slower. c. Planck time on time scales at which quantum gravity becomes important, essentially where time becomes grainy 10-43 seconds or slower. 3. Communication delays arising from size and placing an upper limit on computational speed. a. Either the brain needs to be small, to minimize the delays between disparate parts of the brain. b. Distributed, heierarchical computation our brain is a rudimentary example of this. That is, the single
3
Taken from The Physics of Information Processing Superobjects: Daily Life Among the Jupiter Brains, by Anders Sandberg (1999). 4 Can be used in determining the energy of a specific computation, and using the Heisenberg uncertainty principle to calculate the time scales.
superbrain might consist of separate regions which are largely self-contained (on say, time scales of individual components) which then interact with larger regions, which then interact with other regions. c. Maybe disjointed brain independent compartments that interact with each other only rarely? d. Combos of the above? 4. Energy supply remember, energy is required for all of these computations to occur, and determined by the energy source. a. Can be a star simplest thing we know of. b. Radiation from black holes again, this may be collected by a similar Dyson sphere, this time surrounding a mini black hole. c. Other, exotic more sources of material. d. Recall, the minimal energy required for performing a calculation is Emin kBT .
Sizes and Communication Delays of the Matrioshka Brains Themselves
Upper limits on solid materials placed by the limiting pressure at which a material breaks down for a diamondoid brain, this is 10000 km. An easy way to calculate this is the limit at which the pressure equals the binding energy density of the material at the core. Absolute limit the minimum size at which something becomes a black hole, or the Schwarzchild radius:
RS 2GM / c2
Where G = 6.673 x 10-11 kg-1 m3 s-2 is gravitational constant, M is the mass of the object, and c = 3 x 108 m/s is lightspeed. A good measure is the coherence of a given computer. This factor is described as:
S
size
(time)(velocity )
(size) refers to the maximum dimensions of the system. (time) the time to perform one calculation. (velocity) velocity of signal propagation cannot be faster than lightspeed. For human brain: (size) = 10 cm, (time) = 10-3 seconds, (velocity) = 100 m/second, so S = 1. High S means the system is incoherent, in that we have asynchronous processing (the left hand does not know what the right hand is doing) Low S coherent system, such as in computer chips, so that computer acts as one element. Matrioshka brains, if they are Dyson spheres or anything larger than mini black holes, suffer from high incoherence thus, perhaps heierarchical processing (as in human brain).
Absolute Bandwidth Limits
The different parts of the brain need to communicate with each other, since these brains are incoherent (have a very high S >> 1). No intrinsic reason to communicate in radio. The bandwidth of signal propagation is given by the frequency of propagation. Radio propagation, frequency ~ 109 Hz, so 109 bits/second from radio. Visible has higher frequency, hence higher transmission rates. Possible limits based on the production of electron-positron pairs from the light used something like 1029 1030 bits/second? Quantum limits on propagating information through photons5 -BW = 2.03 x 1017 (P/1 W)1/2 bits/second, where P is the power output of the transmitter. The Planck bandwidth limit, transmission rate of 1043 bits/second (probably very little transmission from photons for reasonable (?) detectors). The noise power level received by any detector is given by
P ~ kBTNoiseBW , wher...