HW4 - Chapter 3 Solutions Solutions for Section 3.1 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6(a(b(C i Observational ii Descriptive i Observational ii Comparative iii

HW4 - Chapter 3 Solutions Solutions for Section 3.1 3.1 3.2...

This preview shows page 1 - 3 out of 3 pages.

Image of page 1

Subscribe to view the full document.

Image of page 2
Image of page 3

Unformatted text preview: Chapter 3 Solutions Solutions for Section 3.1 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 ' 3.5 3.6 (a) (b) (C) i) Observational. ii) Descriptive. i) Observational. ii) Comparative. iii) Response: Baby’s birthweight. Explanatory: Mother’s weight gain during pregnancy. i) Experimental. ii) Comparative. iii) Response: Occurrence of heart disease. Explana- tory: Amount of fiber in diet. 4» (d) I.) Observational. ii) Comparative. iii) Response: Annual rate of return. Explanatory: (a) (b) (b) Group of mutual fund. i) Observational. ii) Descriptive. i) Experimental. ii) Comparative. iii) Response: Proportion of contributors. Explana- tory: Fundraising method. i) Observational. ii) Comparative. iii) Response: Presence of respiratory problems. Explanatory: Whether or not the subjects cook on a gas stove. i) Observational. ii) Descriptive The lower death rate may be due to heightened awareness of the staff to heart patients, a change in patient mix over time, or changes in medical treatments, and not the new screening procedure. Proofreading accuracy may decrease over amount of time spent proofreading. Also, a high error rate in the beginning may motivate readers to be more vigilant in the later part of the document. For each person, one should randomize the order of the low or high error rate sections of text to avoid this confounding. Nonresponse bias is present. The extra practice is voluntary, and participants are more likely to be serious runners than nonparticipants. Therefore, the practice improvement could be confounded with commitment or ability level. Because of the cost of living in a retirement community, elderly in a retirement commu- nity are generally more affluent than those in the general community. They have more money for medical care, and may maintain a higher level of health, confounding the effect of retirement community living. Response: Mortality rates among heart attack survivors. Explanatory: Exercise. Con- founding factors: Diet, weight, and age could all be correlated with willingness to join the exercise program, and could affect mortality. The control group is inappropriate because: i) Physician disapproval of exercise program could be because of other health concerns, and ii) Lack of interest in exercise program could reflect a lack of motivation to control diet and take medication reliably. Response: Risk of heart disease. Explanatory: Coffee consumption. Confounding factor: Smoking. Solutions for Section 3.2 3.7 -36- (a) i) Survey. ii) Descriptive. (b) i) Retrospective Study. ii) Comparative. iii) Response: Term of pregnancy. EM Mother’s smoking habits. (c) i) Survey. ii) Descriptive. (d) i) Survey. ii) Descriptive. 3.8 ‘ (a) Self-selection bias: People who didn’t participate value their time more, and w b wealthier and able to eat difi'erent and more expensive foods. Bias in interview: The high interviewer turnover and the lack of training could hl h biases in how the questions were asked. Bias in sampling: If the design was disturbed, then the sample is suspect of not bag: representative random sample of the target population. (b) See above description of each type of bias. 3_9 The timing of the poll is during morning rush hours, whenmost listeners are peoph vii regular working hour jobs, creating a convenience sample of employed, more afflueur all-Is. This only samples this particular segment of the population and induces bias in the sung results. Also, in call-in polls, people who feel strongly for or against a particular issue a: more likely to voice their opinion. The results reflect proportions of people with sing opinions which may differ from the overall proportions for or against an issue. 3_10 Bias will be a problem. Elderly people alive at the end of 6 years are generally hmkfi: and in less need of nursing home care than those who died. This would underestimate th use of nursing home services. 3_11 People with more education are more likely to have access to, or even recognize the need to consult, a medical specialist. This gives a selection bias of people with AD that is rehial to education level. People with more education are overrepresented as AD patients in tb specialist’s studies. Solutions for Section 3.3 3.12 (a) SyStematic sampling. (b) Stratified sampling, by oldest child’s year in school. (c) Simple random sampling. (d) Multistage cluster sampling. The high schools are stratified by elementary/high school, then a sample taken of each one, forming a cluster. Further clusters of the grade levels within each school are formed, and finally a SRS is taken within this sampling frame; _13 The first three are conceptually simple sampling plans. Stratified sampling in (b) may give more precise estimates than (a) or (c) if preferences on dealing with growth are related to the age of the oldest child in school. Systematic sampling in (a) and SRS in (c) are equally efficient, but (a) may be easier to implement. Plan (d) is more complicated, first stratifying by high school/ elementary school, then taking a cluster sample within each type of school, and within each school selected, taking a cluster sample of the grade levels to form the sampling frame. The stratification of high school/elementary school can improve the precision of the estimate if a child’s age is related to parent’s opinions on school growth. Plan (d) may be easier to implement than plan (b). -37- w, 3.14 3.15 3.16 3.17 3.18 (a) Systematic sampling. (b) Simple random sampling. (c) Stratified sampling by gender. SRS: choose each customer randomly. Systematic: Choose one out of the first 10,000 cus- tomers on the lists, and then go through the lists selecting each 10,000th subsequent cus— tomer. Stratified: Within each ”local” area, choose the appropriate proportion of customers based on the number of people based in the area. Cluster: Choose a sample of ” local” areas, then choose a sample of customers within each area. Stratified sampling will give the most precise estimates but is the most dificult to implement. SRS and systematic sampling give less precise estimates than stratified sampling for the same sample size, but systematic sampling is easier to implement. Cluster sampling is the most convenient to implement, but gives the least precise estimates for the same sample size relative to the other sampling methods, and it may be very biased if it omits the major city. SRS: Each member surveyed is chosen randomly from the pooled member list. Systematic: A starting point is chosen from'the pooled member list, then each kth member after that is surveyed. Stratified: Within each local chapter, a SRS is chosen. Multistage Cluster: A sample of states is chosen. Within each state, a sample of local chapters is chosen, and within each chapter, a SRS of members is selected. Stratified sampling is will give the most precise estimates but is the most difficult to imple— ment because every chapter will need to be contacted for the survey. Systematic sampling could give a more precise estimate than SRS for the same sample size, if the overall member- ship list is grouped by chapter, thereby insuring that a lot of difi'erent chapters are sampled. Cluster sampling is the most convenient to implement, but gives the least precise estimates relative to its sample size of all the sampling methods, and it may be very biased if it omits the largest chapters. A 2-stage stratified sample: Create 4 strata of 100 male managers, 50 female managers, 1900 male employees, and 1450 female employees. Since the sample size relative to the population size is 700/3500 = 1 / 5, from each strata sample 1 / 5th of the people. This sample will reflect the proportion of males and females in management. (a) Stratified sampling using job category strata, because computer usage is highly depen- dent on job classification. (b) Systematic sampling, because it is logistically easy to interview every 10th patient. Also, the sample can be collected on an ongoing basis. In contrast, a SRS requires the total population size to be identified before a sample can be drawn. (c) SR3 or Systematic sampling. (d) Multi-stage cluster sampling, with college as a cluster, because there are too many _ colleges to use each college as a stratum. Solutions for Section 3.4 3.19 Response: Fabric strength (loss in fabric weight). Treatments: Chemical agent, wash times. Blocks: Martindale wear tester batches and bolts of fabric. -38- ...
View Full Document

  • Spring '08
  • SAWYER

What students are saying

  • Left Quote Icon

    As a current student on this bumpy collegiate pathway, I stumbled upon Course Hero, where I can find study resources for nearly all my courses, get online help from tutors 24/7, and even share my old projects, papers, and lecture notes with other students.

    Student Picture

    Kiran Temple University Fox School of Business ‘17, Course Hero Intern

  • Left Quote Icon

    I cannot even describe how much Course Hero helped me this summer. It’s truly become something I can always rely on and help me. In the end, I was not only able to survive summer classes, but I was able to thrive thanks to Course Hero.

    Student Picture

    Dana University of Pennsylvania ‘17, Course Hero Intern

  • Left Quote Icon

    The ability to access any university’s resources through Course Hero proved invaluable in my case. I was behind on Tulane coursework and actually used UCLA’s materials to help me move forward and get everything together on time.

    Student Picture

    Jill Tulane University ‘16, Course Hero Intern

Ask Expert Tutors You can ask 0 bonus questions You can ask 0 questions (0 expire soon) You can ask 0 questions (will expire )
Answers in as fast as 15 minutes