herodotus1

herodotus1 - The Ionian Revolt As Told By Herodotus The...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–3. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
The Ionian Revolt As Told By Herodotus The credibility of Herodotus' text is without doubt a source of much debate amongst classical scholars . For almost any given tale within the text, there are arguments from scholars both for and against the historical accuracy of that particular passage . One of the most debated passages is Herodotus' telling of the Ionian Revolt and his account of Aristagoras , the tyrant of Miletus turned rebel leader . In fact one of the few premises that are agreed upon by scholars is that "The deficiencies of Herodotus , as a historian, if he is measured against modern standards, are notorious". 1 This view is supported also by Evans , who suggests that "The imperfect character of the information which Herodotus furnishes with regard to the story of the great revolt is so evident that the historian himself must have been conscious of it". 2 Herodotus gives us one of the only sources of information for this event, but even so, his account of the events which transpired in this early battle between the Greeks and Persians is considered incorrect in many respects and aspects. One of the most highly debated stories is Herodotus' account of the Ionian leader Aristagoras. There are however some elements of the life of Aristagoras that are generally agreed upon as being historically accurate . These include the fact that that there was a tyrant of Miletus named Aristagoras, that he was a key political figure in the Ionian Revolt , that he was involved in an unsuccessful military campaign against the island of Naxos prior to the outbreak of the revolt , and that when the Ionians were clearly losing impetus in the Revolt , Aristagoras left Miletus for Myrcinus. Just how significant a figure Aristagoras in the the leadership of the Ionian Revolt is a matter of some conjecture however . There is no doubt that Mabel Lang is of the opinion that Aristagoras was a selfless patriot dedicated to the liberation of Ionia . In a somewhat romantic explanation of the course of the Revolt, Lang purports 1 Chapman, G.A.H. "Herodotus and Histiaeus' Role in the Ionian Revolt" Historia 21 (1982): 546 2 Evans, J.A.S. "Herodotus and the Ionian Revolt", Historia 25 (1976): 25
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
that the Ionian Revolt was a revolutionary movement led jointly by Aristagoras and Histiaeus which was defeated less by the Persians and the ambition of its leaders than by a lack of cooperation on the part of the Ionians . 3 The opinions of Lang however , are strongly refuted by Chapman, who considers that while Aristagoras may have a large amount of text dedicated to him by Herodotus , he in fact did not play a major role in the Revolt . 4 Blamire also notes that the concept of a conspiracy between Histiaeus and Aristagoras with the purpose of instigating the Ionian Revolt is not very realistic . 5
Background image of page 2
Image of page 3
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

This essay was uploaded on 04/17/2008 for the course GH 131 taught by Professor Knowlton during the Fall '08 term at Stonehill.

Page1 / 8

herodotus1 - The Ionian Revolt As Told By Herodotus The...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 3. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online