TheWaterCure

TheWaterCure - THE WATER CURE Debating torture and...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–2. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
THE WATER CURE Debating torture and counterinsurgency—acentury ago. By Paul Kramer Ma n y Americans were puzzled by th e news, in 1 902, th a t Uni t e d S t a t es s oldi e r s we r e t o rturin g Fili p i nos with wa te r . T h e United St a tes, th roug h o ut i t s e m e r ge nce as a w o rld pow er, h a d spo k en th e la n g uag e of l i b e rati o n , rescue, a n d f ree d o m . Th is was t h e la n g u age th a t , w h e n co up le d w ith expan din g mi litar y a nd co mm e rc ia l a mb i t ions, h ad h e lp e d l a unch t wo ve r y diff eren t w a r s . The fir s t had be e n in 1898 , aga inst Sp a i n, wh ose r e mainin g e mpir e w as c rum b lin g i n th e fa ce of p o pular r evo lt s in t wo o f it s co l o ni e s , C ub a a n d t h e Ph i l ip pin es . Th e br ief ca mp aign was pit c h e d t o th e Am eri ca n p u b li c i n t e rm s of f r e edom a nd n a ti o n a l h o n or ( the U . S. S. M ai ne had bl o wn up mys teriou s l y i n H ava n a Harb or), r ather th a n o f sugar a nd n ava l b ases, an d re s ult ed i n a for m a ll y i n d epe ndent Cub a . T h e Ame r ica n s we r e n o t d o n e lib era t i n g. Ri s in g t ra d e in E as t As i a s u gges t e d to i m p e ri a li s t s th a t th e Philip p in es , Spain 's large s t colony, mi g ht se r ve a s an e ff ec ti ve " s teppin g s t o ne " t o Ch in a ' s m ar ket s. U.S . n ava l pl a n s in c l ude d p r ovis i o n s f o r a n a tt ac k o n th e S p a ni sh Navy in t he even t of wa r , a nd l e d t o a d ec i s i ve v i c t o r y aga in s t th e Sp a ni s h fl ee t a t M a nil a Ba y in Ma y , 189 8. Shortl y a fterw a rd, Comm o dore G eorge D ewey r eturn e d the ex il e d Filipin o r evo luti o n a r y E mili o A g uin a ld o t o t he i s l a nd s. Ag u i n a ld o d efea ted S p an i s h fo r ces o n l a nd , d ec l a r e d the Phil i ppin es in d e pend e nt in Ju ne , a nd organ ized a g o ve rnment l e d by th e Philippi n e elite . Durin g th e ne x t h a lf y ear , it b eca me c l ear that Ame r ica n a nd Filipin o v i sio n s f or t he is l an d s ' futur e we r e a t o dd s . U . S. f orc e s s ei zed Man il a fr om Spain-k ee p i n g t he arm y o f th e ir os ten s ibl e a ll y A g u i n a ldo fr o m ent e rin g the c it y - a nd Pr esi d e nt William M c Kinle y r e fus e d to r ecog ni ze F ili p in o c l a i ms to ind e p e n- d e n ce, pu s hin g hi s n ego ti a t o r s t o de man d th a t S p a i n c ed e sove rei gn t y ov e r the i s l a nd s t o t he U n ited S t ate s, whi l e t a l k i ng a b ou t F il i p i n os ' n eed for " benevo l en t a ss i m i la t io n . " Ag u in a ldo a nd some of hi s a d v i sers , who h a d b ee n in sp ir e d b y th e U nit e d S t a t es as a model r e public an d h a d greete d it s so l die r s as li be r a t ors, be c am e i nc r eas in g l y s u spicious of Ame r ican mo t iva t io n s . W hen, after a pe r iod of m o unt i n g t e n s i o n s , a U . S. sen t r y f i re d o n F ilipin o so ldi e r s o
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
Image of page 2
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

This note was uploaded on 04/19/2008 for the course HIST 112 taught by Professor Keithknutson during the Spring '08 term at Viterbo.

Page1 / 9

TheWaterCure - THE WATER CURE Debating torture and...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 2. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online