This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.View Full Document
Unformatted text preview: Cloning to Save Lives- Clone to produce individuals compatible for transplants Objections to Cloning It would be wrong to create mindless organ banks. Tooley claims that the clones can be created without minds, and are not real people and the idea that it would destroy a potential for personhood is unsound. The Cloning of Humans to Produce Persons Wrong to person created- no, only rights involved is those of the donor. Brave New World- the idea that one could produce an army is absurd. Psychological Distress- The clone may feel distress because of their lacking uniqueness but the fact remains the clone can compare themselves to their donor and realize that premise is wrong. Failing to Treat Individuals as Ends in Themselves- Note the many unplanned children who endingly, are deeply loved by their parents. Interfering with Personal Autonomy- It may be wrong to tinker with biological autonomy. But, its alright to tinker in attempts to prevent disease. Premise is false....
View Full Document
- Fall '07
- person, Micheal Tooley