DDI.09.Impacts.Generic - Impact Generic 1 Dartmouth 2K9 IMPACTS IMPACTS.1*TERMINAL IMPACTS.5 AIDS.6 Air Pollution.7 Anthrax.8 Biodiversity.9

DDI.09.Impacts.Generic - Impact Generic 1 Dartmouth 2K9...

This preview shows page 1 out of 310 pages.

You've reached the end of your free preview.

Want to read all 310 pages?

Unformatted text preview: Impact Generic 1 Dartmouth 2K9 IMPACTS IMPACTS................................................................1 **TERMINAL IMPACTS**................................5 AIDS........................................................................6 Air Pollution............................................................7 Anthrax....................................................................8 Biodiversity..............................................................9 Bioterror.................................................................10 Bioterror.................................................................11 Bird Flu..................................................................12 Constitution............................................................13 Democracy.............................................................14 Dehumanization.....................................................15 Disease...................................................................16 Economy................................................................17 Freedom.................................................................18 Genocide................................................................19 Heg.........................................................................20 Human Rights Credibility......................................21 Oceans....................................................................22 Ozone.....................................................................23 Patriarchy...............................................................24 Poverty...................................................................25 Racism...................................................................26 SARS.....................................................................27 TB (1/4).................................................................28 TB (2/4).................................................................29 TB (3/4).................................................................30 TB (4/4).................................................................31 TB..........................................................................32 Terror.....................................................................33 Warming.................................................................34 **HEG**..............................................................35 Kagan.....................................................................36 Decline Inev...........................................................38 Econ T/...................................................................39 **WAR IMPACTS**...........................................40 Turns Everything...................................................41 AIDS......................................................................42 Animal Rights T/...................................................43 Biodiversity............................................................44 Cap.........................................................................45 Civil Liberties T/....................................................46 Allen PK: Home of the Curiously Strong,, Minty Fresh Nose 1 Impact Generic Dartmouth 2K9 2 Dehumanization T/................................................47 Democracy T/........................................................48 Disease T/..............................................................49 Disease T/..............................................................50 Domestic Violence T/............................................51 Econ T/...................................................................52 Edelman.................................................................53 Environment..........................................................54 Environment..........................................................55 Fascism..................................................................56 Gendered Violence T/............................................57 Health T/................................................................58 Heg T/....................................................................59 Homelessness.........................................................60 Homophobia..........................................................61 Inequality...............................................................62 Mental Health T/....................................................63 Poverty...................................................................64 Poverty...................................................................65 Woman Rights T/...................................................66 Racism...................................................................67 Rape.......................................................................68 Rights T/................................................................69 Rights T/................................................................70 Social Service T/....................................................71 Starvation...............................................................72 Terror.....................................................................73 **X TURNS CASE**..........................................74 AIDS T/ Readiness................................................75 AIDS T/ Readiness................................................76 Disesase T/ Readiness............................................77 Disease T/ Readiness.............................................78 Disease T/ War.......................................................79 Ecodestruction T/ Disease.....................................80 Ecodestruction T/ Disease.....................................81 Ecodestruction T/ War...........................................82 Ecodestruction T/ Agriculture................................83 **NUCLEAR WAR SCENARIOS**.................84 Central Asian Conflict...........................................85 China-US...............................................................86 Economic Collapse................................................87 India/Pakistan War.................................................88 Iraq Pullout............................................................89 Iran.........................................................................90 Allen PK: Home of the Curiously Strong,, Minty Fresh Nose 2 Impact Generic 3 Dartmouth 2K9 Japanese Relations (Spratly Islands).....................91 Japanese Relations (Middle Eastern Conflict).......92 Japanese Relations (China/Taiwan Conflict).........93 Japanese Relations (Korea)....................................94 Japanese Relations (Sino-Russian Ties)................95 North Korea...........................................................96 Pakistan Collapse...................................................97 Sino-Russian Conflict............................................98 Sunni/Shiite Conflict.............................................99 Russia-US............................................................100 Taiwan/China War...............................................101 Taiwan..................................................................102 Terrorism → Nuclear Escalation.........................103 Terror = Extinction..............................................104 **NUKE WAR IMPACTS**............................105 Nuclear War Disease.......................................106 Nuclear War Extinction...................................107 Nuclear War Pollution.....................................108 Nuclear War Phytoplankton Scenario.............109 Nuclear War Ozone Scenario..........................110 Nuke War Oceans............................................111 Nuclear War Biodiversity Scenario (1/2)........112 Nuclear War Biodiversity Scenario (2/2)........113 **NUKE WAR PROBABILITY**...................114 Nuclear War Evaluated First................................115 Schell...................................................................116 Nuclear War Likely..............................................117 Nuclear War Likely – Escalation.........................118 Nuclear War Likely – Middle East Prolif............119 Great Power War Likely......................................120 Nuke War Not Likely...........................................121 Nuke War Not Likely – US Russia......................122 Nuke War Not Likely – Rising Costs..................123 Nuke War Not Likely – Deterrence.....................124 Nuke War Not Likely – International System......125 Nuke War Not Likely – North Korea...................127 Nuke War Not Likely – Pakistan.........................128 No Nuclear Terror................................................129 No Escalation - Nuclear Taboo Won’t Be Broken (1/6) No Escalation - Nuclear Taboo Won’t Be Broken (2/6) No Escalation - Nuclear Taboo Won’t Be Broken (3/6) No Escalation - Nuclear Taboo Won’t Be Broken (4/6) No Escalation - Nuclear Taboo Won’t Be Broken (5/6) No Escalation - Nuclear Taboo Won’t Be Broken (6/6) 130 131 132 133 134 135 Allen PK: Home of the Curiously Strong,, Minty Fresh Nose 3 Impact Generic Dartmouth 2K9 4 AT: Schell.............................................................136 AT: Schell.............................................................137 AT: Schell.............................................................138 **IMPACT TAKEOUTS**...............................139 AT: Giligan...........................................................140 Extinction Impossible..........................................141 Nuclear War.........................................................142 Biological Attack Not Probable...........................143 Indo-Pak...............................................................144 Iran.......................................................................145 **IMPACT CALCULUS**..............................146 Impacts Exaggerated (1/2)...................................147 Impacts Exaggerated (2/2)...................................148 Prob. Evaluated First (1/2)...................................149 Prob. Evaluated First (2/2)...................................150 Prob Before Mag Ext...........................................151 Systemic Impacts First.........................................152 Probability Evaluation Key..................................153 AT: Rescher..........................................................154 Predictions Bad - Policymaking..........................155 Predictions Bad – Background Beliefs................156 Predictions Bad – Irresponsibility.......................157 Predictions Bad - Monkeys..................................159 Predictions Bad – Decisionmaking Spillover......160 AT: Monkeys........................................................161 Predictions Good (1/3).........................................162 Predictions Good (2/3).........................................163 Predictions Good (3/3).........................................164 Mag. Evaluated First (1/3)...................................165 Mag. Evaluated First (2/3)...................................166 Mag. Evaluated First (3/3)...................................167 Role of Ballot = Magnitude.................................168 Extinction Evaluated First...................................170 **PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE**...........171 Precautionary Principle Good- Risk Avoidance. .172 Precautionary Principle Good- Risk Fails...........173 Precautionary Principle Good – Risk Fails..........174 Precautionary Principle Good- AT Innovation Stultification 175 Precautionary Principle Good- AT Zero Risk......176 Precautionary Principle Good- AT Cost...............177 Precautionary Principle Good- AT Bad Science. .178 **AT PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE**.....179 Allen PK: Home of the Curiously Strong,, Minty Fresh Nose 4 Impact Generic Dartmouth 2K9 5 Precautionary Principle Bad- Paralysis (1/3).......180 Precautionary Principle Bad- Paralysis (2/3).......181 Precautionary Principle Bad- Paralysis (3/3).......182 Precautionary Principle Bad- Innovation (1/3)....183 Precautionary Principle Bad- Innovation (2/3)....184 Precautionary Principle Bad- Innovation (3/3)....185 Precautionary Principle Bad- Pandemic..............186 Precautionary Principle Bad- Militarism.............187 **UTIL**............................................................188 Util O/W Rights...................................................189 Util Good – K2 Policymaking.............................190 Util Good - K2 Determine Rights........................191 Util Good – Best Interest.....................................192 Util Good – Concrete Decisionmaking................193 Util Good – Prevents Nuke War..........................194 Util Inevitable......................................................195 Survival Instinct Good – Extinction....................197 Consequentialism Good.......................................198 Consequentialism Fails........................................199 Consequentialism Fails........................................200 **AT UTIL**.....................................................201 Util Bad – No Equality/Justice............................202 Util Bad – Mass Murder......................................203 Util Bad – Annihilation........................................204 Util Bad – VTL....................................................205 Util Excludes Rights............................................206 Survival Instinct Bad – Destroys Humanity........207 **RIGHTS/DEONTOLOGY**........................208 Must Evaluate Human Rights (1/2).....................209 Must Evaluate Human Rights (2/2).....................210 Deontology O/W Util...........................................211 Deontology O/W Util...........................................212 Deontology O/W Util...........................................213 Deontology O/W Util...........................................215 Deontology Good – K2 Policy............................216 Deontology Good – K2 VTL...............................217 Callahan (1/2)......................................................218 Callahan (2/2)......................................................219 Callahan Ext.........................................................220 Moral Justice First...............................................222 Moral Rationality First........................................223 Rights Absolute....................................................224 Rights/Liberty K2 Rationality.............................226 Moral Resolution O/W Util.................................227 Allen PK: Home of the Curiously Strong,, Minty Fresh Nose 5 Impact Generic Dartmouth 2K9 6 Morals Compatible With Util..............................228 No Rights = Violent Backlash.............................229 Right To Health O/W...........................................230 Poverty Moral Obligation....................................231 Action Key – End Result Irrelevant.....................232 **AT DEONTOLOGY/RIGHTS**.................233 Rights Violation Inev...........................................234 AT: Rights First....................................................235 AT: Rights First....................................................236 AT Rawls..............................................................237 AT Rawls..............................................................238 AT Rawls..............................................................239 AT: Liberty/Rights First.......................................240 AT: Morals First...................................................241 AT: Gewirth.........................................................242 AT: Gewirth.........................................................243 AT: Gewirth.........................................................244 AT: Gewirth.........................................................245 AT: Gewirth.........................................................246 AT: Gewirth.........................................................247 Ethics Bad............................................................248 Ethics Bad............................................................249 Ethics Bad............................................................250 Deontology Bad – No Assume Nuke War...........251 Deontology Bad - Policy.....................................252 Deontology Bad - Policy.....................................253 Deontology Bad - Democracy.............................254 Deontology Bad -- Conflicts................................255 Deontology Bad – Subjective Rights...................256 Extinction O/W Deontology................................257 Deontology Bad - Absolutist...............................258 Deontology Bad - Absolutist...............................259 Ethical Action/Legality Mutually Exclusive.......260 Ethical Action/Legality Mutually Exclusive.......261 **AT EGAL**....................................................262 Egalitarianism Frontline (1/2)..............................263 Egalitarianism Frontline (2/2)..............................264 Public Sphere Ext – Arg Plurality........................265 Hierarchies Inevitable..........................................266 Egal = Envy.........................................................267 Egal = Infinite Redistribution..............................268 Egal Biased..........................................................269 Rejection of Egal K2 Check Abuse.....................270 AT: Moral Egal....................................................271 Allen PK: Home of the Curiously Strong,, Minty Fresh Nose 6 Impact Generic Dartmouth 2K9 7 AT: Democratic Egal............................................272 AT: Radical Egal..................................................273 AT: Egal = Util.....................................................274 Inegal Solves........................................................275 Econ Turns Egal...................................................276 Sufficientarianism Good......................................277 Sufficientarianism Good......................................278 Sufficientarian Perm............................................279 **AGENCIES**................................................280 Generic Agencies Fail..........................................281 NGO’s Key Federal Sucess.................................282 Administration for Children and Families...........283 Agriculture Department.......................................284 Department of Health and Human Services........285 Department of Education.....................................286 States Solve Education........................................287 Department of Interior.........................................288 Department of Interior (Natives Link).................289 Department of Interior (U.S. Territories DA)......290 Housing and Urban Development.......................291 Department of labor.............................................292 Department of Justice..........................................293 Environmental Protection Agency.......................294 Office of National Aids Policy.............................295 Office of National Aids Policy.............................295 Social Security Administration............................296 ICE.......................................................................297 Veterans Health Administration...........................298 Ineffective Agency – Political Capital Link........299 **INTERNATIONAL LAW**..........................300 Int’l Law Good....................................................301 Int’l Law Good....................................................302 Int’l Law Impact..................................................303 Int’l Law K2 Rights.............................................304 Int’l Law Bad..........
View Full Document

  • Spring '12
  • Weaver
  • ........., Nuclear weapon

What students are saying

  • Left Quote Icon

    As a current student on this bumpy collegiate pathway, I stumbled upon Course Hero, where I can find study resources for nearly all my courses, get online help from tutors 24/7, and even share my old projects, papers, and lecture notes with other students.

    Student Picture

    Kiran Temple University Fox School of Business ‘17, Course Hero Intern

  • Left Quote Icon

    I cannot even describe how much Course Hero helped me this summer. It’s truly become something I can always rely on and help me. In the end, I was not only able to survive summer classes, but I was able to thrive thanks to Course Hero.

    Student Picture

    Dana University of Pennsylvania ‘17, Course Hero Intern

  • Left Quote Icon

    The ability to access any university’s resources through Course Hero proved invaluable in my case. I was behind on Tulane coursework and actually used UCLA’s materials to help me move forward and get everything together on time.

    Student Picture

    Jill Tulane University ‘16, Course Hero Intern

Stuck? We have tutors online 24/7 who can help you get unstuck.
A+ icon
Ask Expert Tutors You can ask You can ask You can ask (will expire )
Answers in as fast as 15 minutes