Six months ago the region of Forestville increased the speed limit for vehicles traveling on the region's highways by
ten miles per hour.
Since that change took effect, the number of automobile accidents in that region has increased by
But the speed limit in Elmsford, a region neighboring Forestville, remained unchanged, and automobile
accidents declined slightly during the same six-month period.
Therefore, if the citizens of Forestville want to reduce
the number of automobile accidents on the region's highways, they should campaign to reduce Forestville's speed
limit to what it was before the increase.
The agrument is well-presented, but not thoroughly well-reasoned.
By making a comparison of the region of Forestville, the
town with the higher speed limit and therefore automobile accidents, with the region of Elmsford, an area of a lower speed
limit and subsequently fewer accidents, the argument for reducing Forestville's speed limits in order to decrease accidents
However, the citizens of Forestville are failing to consider other possible alternatives to the increasing car accidents after the
raise in speed limit.
Such alternatives may include the fact that there are less reliable cars traveling the roads in Forestville,
or that the age bracket of those in Elmsford may be more conducive to driving safely.
It is possible that there are more
younger, inexperienced, or more elderly, unsafe drivers in Forestville than there are in Elmsford.
In addition, the citizens
have failed to consider the geographical and physical terrain of the two different areas.
Perhaps Forestville's highway is in
an area of more dangerous curves, sharp turns, or has many intersections or merging points where accidents are more likely
It appears reasonable, therefore, for the citizens to focus on these trouble spots than to reduce the speed in the
Elmsford may be an area of easier driving conditions where accidents are less likely to occur regardless of the
A six-month period is not a particularly long time frame for the citizens to determine that speed limit has influenced the
number of automobile accidents in the area.
It is mentioned in the argument that Elmsford accidents decreased during the
This may have been a time, such as during harsh weather conditions, when less people were driving on the road
and therefore the number of accidents decreased.
However, Forestville citizens, perhaps coerced by employment or other
requirements, were unable to avoid driving on the roads.
Again, the demographics of the population are important.
possible that Elmsford citizens do not have to travel far from work or work from their home, or do not work at all.
more people in Forestville than there were sic months ago?
If so, there may be an increased number of accidents due to more
automobiles on the road, and not due to the increased speed limits.
Also in reference to the activities of the population, it is