04Aristotle - Raphael's Scuola di Atena Raphael' Socrates...

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: Raphael's Scuola di Atena Raphael' Socrates c. 469 - 399 Plato Aristotle 427-347 384-322 Teleological Perspective Everything seeks or strives towards some goal - Everything has a natural function or purpose - Its `end' (or telos) is part of what a thing is end' telos) -- Value and purpose are inherent in all things Ex: Artifacts, like knives Aristotle's Ethics Aim is to find the telos of human beings - Focus is not on right and wrong (innocence and guilt) - Focus is instead on noble and base ("proper pride" and shame) pride" Instrumental and Intrinsic Goods Why come to class? Perhaps: To get a good grade Instrumental good Why seek good grades? grades? Perhaps: To get a good job Instrumental good Why seek a good job? job? Perhaps: To gain wealth Why seek to gain wealth? wealth? Perhaps: Wealth is good Intrinsic good A single "chief good" (or telos) What if there are multiple intrinsic goods? What if they conflict? -- Deliberation requires a basis - a further end to aim at (like the archers I.2.i) -- This is the chief good for human beings - Eudaimonia = Flourishing (or happiness) 1 What is Flourishing? Is it pleasure? pleasure? No: This is a sign of flourishing, not its essence -- It is available to the beasts How to Identify Flourishing Find the special function of human beings (I.7.v) (Aristotle's teleology at work) (Aristotle' -- Not nutrition and growth (shared with plants) -- Not perception (shared with animals) Instead: "Life of the rational element" element" -- Life of reason, deliberation, agency - Not mere capacity - Not governed by impulse Is it honor? honor? No: We only want this as a sign of actual worth Is it power and wealth? wealth? No: These are only instrumentally valuable Flourishing Human function is activity in accord with reason Good human function is therefore: "activity of the soul exhibiting excellence" (I.7.v) excellence" Soul = Rational nature Excellence = Virtue Flourishing is virtuous action, or a life of virtue What is a Virtue? Not just doing the right thing -- Could be accidental, or for the wrong reason Not just being able to tell right from wrong -- Different from a skill or an art Not just doing the right thing because it is right -- Must also be reliable A virtue is: A stable disposition to do the right thing because it is right (II.4.iii) How to Become Virtuous? Virtues are not innate -- do not develop automatically Potential for virtue is innate -- but requires teaching and habit (habits make all the difference II.1.iii) What are the Virtues? Aristotle claims no authority here - Denies the possibility of a definite answer or formula -- Ethical wisdom is uncodifiable Tool for identifying virtues: Doctrine of the Mean Only through performance of virtuous acts can we become virtuous 2 Doctrine of the Mean For any sphere of human activity, activity, Find the mean between a deficiency and an excess Sphere of Vice of Activity Deficiency Facing danger Sharing wealth Cowardice Miserliness Virtue (mean) Bravery Generosity Vice of Excess Foolhardiness Wastefulness 3 ...
View Full Document

This note was uploaded on 08/08/2008 for the course PHIL 1304 taught by Professor Wjfitzpatrick during the Fall '05 term at Virginia Tech.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online