2007-10-12 An Alleged Blunder in the Stealth Bomber's Design

2007-10-12 An Alleged Blunder in the Stealth Bomber's...

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
AN ALLEGED BLUNDERIN THE STEALTH BOMBER'S DESIGN Managerial economics is of great use in the aerospace industry, but this does not mean that errors sometimes will not occur. The B-2 "Stealth" bomber has cost billions of dollars to develop. According to Joseph Foa, an emeritUS professor of engineering at George Washing- ton University, its design is fun- damentally flawed because two aerodyn~micistS made °a mistake: they mistook a minimum. point for a maximum point. The B-2 is basically a jet-pow~ ered "flying win~' aircraft. In a secret study for the Air Force, the two aerodynamicists, William Sears and Irving Ashkenas (then at the Northrop Corporation}, used mathematical formulas to deter- mine how an aircraft's volume should be proportioned between wing and fuselage in order to maxi- mize its range. Taking the der- ivative oJ range with respect to vol- ume, they found that this deriva- °tive equaled zero when the total volume was almost all in the wing. Hence, they concluded that a
Background image of page 1
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: II ly-ing wing" design would maximize range. But in a subsequent analysis, Foa showed that the second derivative was positive, not negative, under these circumstances. Thus, the "flying wing" design miIlimized range; it didn't marimize it. In Foa's words, "The flying wing was the aerodynamically worst possible choice of configuration." This is a very interesting exam-ple of how important it is to look at the second derivative to make SUIe that you do not confuse a maximi-zation point with a minimi7:ation point. While the backers of the B-2 bomber claiIn that it is a good plane despite this error, no one denies that the error is an embarrass-ment. .-This discussion is based on W. Biddle, "Skeleton Alleged in the Stealth Bomber's Closet." Science (May 12, 1989). 00...
View Full Document

This note was uploaded on 09/08/2008 for the course EAC 101 taught by Professor Tyler/ralston during the Fall '08 term at University of Louisville.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online