White Plains Coat - an existing contract for an alleged...

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
5. a. Facts i. White Plains alleges that it had five-year exclusive service contracts with customers and that, knowing of these arrangements, Cintas induced dozens of the plaintiff’s customers to breach their contracts and enter into agreements with them. ii. White Plains demanded that Cintas discontinue servicing White Plains’ contract customers, enclosing a list of customers solicited improperly. Cintas denied knowledge of any contracts and continued its solicitation. iii. White Plains sued Cintas for tortious interference with existing contracts. iv. The District Court granted summary judgment and dismissed the complaint, concluding that White Plains had to show that Cintas acted with malice, which White Plains was unable to do. b. Issue i. Does a generalized economic interest in soliciting business for profit constitute a defense to a claim of tortious interference with
Background image of page 1
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: an existing contract for an alleged tortfeasor with no previous economic relationship with the breaching party? c. Holding i. No. d. Reasoning i. A defendant who is simply plaintiffs competitor and knowingly solicits its contract customers is not economically justified in procuring the breach of contract. ii. The Court does not agree with the notion that the only answer is to go out and do it also to the other guy. iii. New York Pattern Jury Instructions say: When the defendant is simply a competitor of the plaintiff seeking customers and the plaintiff has a customer under contract for a definite period, defendants interest would not justify inducing the customer to breach the existing contract. iv. Protecting the contracts does not negate a competitors right to solicit business just to limit improper inducement of a third party to breach its contract....
View Full Document

Ask a homework question - tutors are online