INDEPENDENT CIVIL ACTION50. Lim vs. Kou Co Ping, GR No. 175256, August 23, 2012Facts:FR Cement Corporation (FRCC) issued several withdrawal authorities1for theaccount of cement dealers and traders, Fil-Cement and Tigerbilt (FCCT). FCCTthen sold the withdrawal authorities covering 50,000 bags of cement torespondent Co for the amount of P3.15 million or P63.00 per bag. Co then sold thesame withdrawal authorities to petitioner Lily Lim for the alleged amount of P3.2million or P64.00 per bag. Lim, using the withdrawal authorities, withdrew 2,800bags of cement from FRCC. He then sold some of the withdrawal authoritiescovering 10,000 bags back to respondent Co. Sometime within the same year,FRCC no longer allowed Lim to withdraw the remaining 37,200 bags covered bythe withdrawal authorities. According to Co and the manager of FCCT, the plantimplemented a price increase and would only release the goods once Lim paid forthe price difference or agreed to receive a lesser quantity of cement. Lim