**preview**has

**blurred**sections. Sign up to view the full version! View Full Document

**Unformatted text preview: **Users Manual for
Isoplot/Ex
version 2.2
A Geochronological Toolkit for Microsoft Excel
Berkeley Geochronology Center Special Publication No. 1a K e nn e th R . L ud w ig
Rev. February 21, 2000 2455 Ridge Road, Berkeley CA 94709 FAX (510) 644-9201; Email kludwig@bgc.org
TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION....................................................................................1 ISOPLOT/EX 2 R EQUIREMENTS AND P ERFORMANCE .......................................................................1 EXCEL BUGS AFFECTING ISOPLOT/EX .........................................................................................2 Windows...........................................................................................................................2 Macintosh.........................................................................................................................2 C HANGES FROM VERSION 1......................................................................................................2 C HANGES IN VERSION 2.06......................................................................................................3 C HANGES IN VERSION 2.1........................................................................................................3 C HANGES IN VERSION 2.2........................................................................................................3 INSTALLING AND INVOKING ISOPLOT/EX. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Memory Settings for Macintosh Computers............................................................................4 THE INPUT DATA-RANGE.......................................................................4 HEADER R OWS ......................................................................................................................4 DATA IN A S INGLE, C ONTIGUOUS R ANGE ..................................................................................5 DATA IN DISCONTINUOUS R OWS...............................................................................................5 DATA IN DISCONTINUOUS C OLUMNS .........................................................................................6 EXCLUDING DATA WITH F ONTS IN S TRIKETHROUGH ....................................................................6 EMPHASIZED P LOT -SYMBOLS WITH BOLDED F ONTS .....................................................................6 S PECIFYING S YMBOL C OLORS WITH F ONT C OLORS ......................................................................6 EARLY VERSUS LATE DATA SELECTION .......................................................................................6 NUMERIC OUTPUT FROM ISOPLOT..........................................................6 GRAPHICS FROM ISOPLOT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 HIDDEN WORKSHEETS C REATED BY ISOPLOT ...............................................................................7 ADDING NEW DATA TO AN EXISTING C HART ..............................................................................7 MODIFYING C HARTS ..............................................................................................................8 Selecting and modifying simple data-point symbols and outline error-symbols...............................8 Adding Data-Point Labels.....................................................................................................9 Moving and shrinking charts to worksheets.............................................................................9 Superimposing charts..........................................................................................................9 USING FILLED ERROR-ELLIPSES AND ERROR-BOXES ........................................................................9 C OLOR-SCALING OF FILLED SYMBOLS .......................................................................................10 EXPORTING CHARTS TO OTHER PROGRAMS.................................................................................11 THE MAIN ISOPLOT/EX DIALOG BOX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 2 CLASSICAL X - Y REGRESSIONS AND ISOCHRONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 7 R EGRESSION MODELS ...........................................................................................................17 Model 1.........................................................................................................................17 Model 2.........................................................................................................................18 Model 3 Fits...................................................................................................................18 A WORD ABOUT 3-POINT ISOCHRONS ......................................................................................18 C OMMENTS ON R EGRESSIONS WITH LOW P ROBABILITIES -OF-FIT ...................................................19 EXAMINING RESIDUALS OF REGRESSIONS..............................................20 ROBUST REGRESSIONS.........................................................................20
U-PB CONCORDIA PLOTS......................................................................21 C ONVENTIONAL VERSUS TERA-WASSERBURG C ONCORDIA R EPRESENTATIONS.................................21 ERRORS OF C ONCORDIA -INTERCEPT AGES .................................................................................22 Symmetric......................................................................................................................22 Asymmetric.....................................................................................................................22 Monte Carlo....................................................................................................................23 S HOWING DECAY-CONSTANT ERRORS IN THE C ONCORDIA C URVE ................................................23 THE CONCORDIA AGE ........................................................................................................23 Calculating a Concordia Age...............................................................................................24 Concordia Age MSWDs....................................................................................................24 Concordia Age Errors........................................................................................................25 Effect of Decay-Constant Errors on Concordia Ages and Errors..................................................25 THREE-DIMENSIONAL R EGRESSIONS FOR U-PB C ONCORDIA ..........................................................26 Planar Regressions............................................................................................................26 Linear 3-D Regressions (the Total Pb/U Isochron)................................................................27 PB-PB ISOCHRONS AND GROWTH CURVES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 8 THE
230 230 230
TH/U SYSTEM.............................................................................29
TH/U ISOCHRONS WITH VARIABLE 234U/238U...........................................................................29 TH/U ISOCHRONS WITH S ECULAR EQUILIBRIUM 234U/238U.........................................................32 S INGLE-ANALYSIS 230TH/U AGES ............................................................................................32 WEIGHTED AVERAGES OF A SINGLE VARIABLE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 3 ARGON-ARGON STEP-HEATING PLOTS AND PLATEAU AGES.......................34 USER-SPECIFIED P LATEAU S TEPS ............................................................................................35 CUMULATIVE PROBABILITY PLOTS AND HISTOGRAMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 5 UTILITY FUNCTIONS FOR ISOTOPIC DATA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 6 ACCESSING ISOPLOTS USER F UNCTIONS ...................................................................................36 URANIUM -LEAD F UNCTIONS ..................................................................................................37 URANIUM S ERIES F UNCTIONS .................................................................................................40 OTHER R ADIOGENIC-ISOTOPE F UNCTIONS ................................................................................41 S TATISTICAL F UNCTIONS ......................................................................................................41 R OUNDING F UNCTIONS .........................................................................................................42 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS...........................................................................42 REFERENCES......................................................................................44 APPENDIX I: TIPS ON MINIMIZING PLOT-CONSTRUCTION TIME..................46 APPENDIX II: TOOLBAR-ONLY FUNCTIONS..............................................47 INDEX................................................................................................50
February 21, 2000
1
Introduction
Isoplot/Ex (an Add-In program than runs under Microsoft Excel) is a flexible tool for the interpretation of radiogenic-isotope data. In addition to the plotting (at publication quality) and calculation of the usual (Rb/Sr, Sm/Nd) isochrons, Isoplot/Ex can: Construct U-Pb concordia plots and calculate ages using conventional concordia intercepts, the Concordia algorithm, 3-D planar concordia intercepts, or 3-D linear (Total U/Pb) isochrons; Calculate uranium-series isochron ages using 3-D or 2-D isochrons and construct 234 U/238U evolution curves and isochrons; Construct single-stage growth-curves for plots of common-Pb data; Construct cumulative-probability/histogram plots; Calculate and construct plots for error-weighted and robust averages of a single variable; Calculate both conventional (analytical-error weighted) and robust (nonparametric) x-y regressions for classical and Pb-Pb isochrons; Expand the range of Excel functions with more than 35 additional functions for radiogenic-isotopes, including 16 for U/Pb and 8 for 230Th-234U-238U. Isoplot/Ex is available without charge contact Ken Ludwig directly1. I s o p l o t / E x 2 R e qu i re m e n t s a n d P e rf o rm a n c e Isoplot/Ex requires Excel 97 (Windows) or Excel 98 (Macintosh). Neither Excel 5 nor Excel 7 is compatible. For Windows, any Pentium processor should give sufficient speed, though a 166 Mhz or faster CPU is recommended. For the Macintosh, you should have at least 32 Mb physical RAM and a 90 Mhz Power Mac (200 Mhz recommended) or (much better) a G3 or G4 Mac. For a given task, the rapidity of calculation and plot generation under Isoplot is very dependent on not only the CPU of the computer, but also the operating system, Excel version, and size/complexity of the workbook in use. Some benchmark speed-tests (from the Benchmarks sheet in Testdata.xls) are given below. If you find that plot construction time is slower than you would like, see Appendix I (p. 46) for speed-up tips. Platform PowerMac5 PowerMac5 PC clone 6 PC clone 6
1 2 3 4 5 230
Th/238U-
CPU PPC 604e G3 Pentium MMX Pentium II
Speed (Mhz) 200 266 200 233
Numeric 1,2 24.7 9.4 7.2
Basic Plot 1,2 13.6 6.7 0.9
Error Ellipses 1,3 15.9 9.4 6.2
Seconds. 2500 Monte Carlo concordia-intercept solutions, 6 points with decay-constant errors. Construction of autoscaled plot-box plus 2 error boxes, no superscripts in axis labels. Plotbox plus 100 filled error ellipses. System 8.5.
1
Berkeley Geochronology Center, Berkeley CA 94709. FAX: (510) 644-9201; Email: kludwig@.bgc.org.
February 21, 2000
2
6
Windows 95.
Ex c e l Bug s A f f e c t i ng Is o pl o t / Ex Windows A bug in the generation of the shapes used for filled error ellipses/boxes forces Isoplot to use a slower, klugey workaround to avoid crashes. If you run into crashes when working with filled symbols, make sure that the Slow button for Filled error ellipses, boxes is selected in the Options/Fonts dialog box. This should not be a problem on the Macintosh with Excel 98. If you change the setting to Fast error ellipses/boxes and Isoplot encounters problems, the setting should automatically revert to Slow. Problems have been reported in running non-U.S. versions of Excel running under Windows NT. Macintosh Excel 98 corrupts the position of superscripts in non-horizontal text. Therefore, under Excel 98, depending on the S uperscript isotopes in axis labels setting specified in Isoplots Options/Fonts dialog box, Isoplot will either orient Y-axis labels with isotope-superscripts horizontally, or leave isotope-numbers un-superscripted. Closing Excel or unloading Isoplot.xla can take a very long time - a minute or more It seems to help to periodically trash the Excel Settings and Excel Toolbars files which are found in the System Preferences folder of the Macintosh. If all else fails, try re-installing Excel from the original CD.
With some G3 Macs running System 8, Excel (and thus Isoplot) may slow down to the point of uselessness if other programs are running, regardless of the memory allocated to Excel. If you experience such a problem, you will be forced to close some (possibly all) other programs to run Isoplot. Oddly, when these problems exist, users with Eudora must have Eudora open at some point (either before Excel is opened or while it is open), and then close Eudora to restore Excel performance. These problems may arise because of some particular extension if anyone can shed light on annoyance, I would be grateful.
C h a n g e s f ro m V e rs i o n 1 Excel 5 is no longer compatible. Error ellipses, error boxes, and concordia bands can now be plotted as filled shapes rather than outlines, giving true publication-quality graphics. Outline-symbols can be converted to filled symbols at a later date, if desired. The range of selectable data-symbol colors has been increased to take advantage of the filled shapes. The isoplot-related toolbar-menu items have been collected into a single drop-down menu, labeled Isoplot2.
2
The Isoplot menu may disappear when worksheets containing macros are closed. To restore the menu, invoke Isoplot with Ctrl-I.
February 21, 2000
3
Before chart completion, headers and footers are automatically removed, and (optional, for color plots) paper margins reduced to the minimum. Plotting and calculation speed is improved. False-color scaling (to reflect the values of a Z parameter for each point) can be applied to filled error ellipses/boxes. The outlier-rejection algorithm for weighted averages is more conservative. The effect of decay-constant errors is shown for U-Pb concordia-intercept ages.
C h a n g e s i n V e rs i o n 2 . 0 6 Two bugs have been corrected: first, a typographical error in the coding of the error algorithm used for York X-Y regressions (most isochron and U-Pb concordia, and all 3-D and Monte Carlo errors were unaffected, but some combinations of data-dispersion and errors did yield invalid Yorkfit errors). Second, the default values for model-age calculations (viewable from Isoplots CONSTS dialog-box) were likely to have been corrupted.
C h a n g e s i n V e rs i o n 2 . 1 One-sigma error ellipses are now plotted correctly as 68.3%-confidence ellipses, rather than halfsize 95%-confidence ellipses. A separate Isoplot toolbar is included. New Put functions (one-click functions that put their results directly on the worksheet adjacent to the source data) are included for Pb-Pb ages/errors and weighted averages. Stacked Cumulative-Gaussian curves are enabled.
C h a n g e s i n V e rs i o n 2 . 2 Robust (nonparametric) procedures for x-y regression/isochrons amd for averaging are included. More Put functions (available from the Isoplot toolbar) have been added: error-weighted x-y regressions (Yorkfits), robust x-y egressions and robust single-parameter averaging.
Installing and Invoking Isoplot/Ex
If you have been running Version 1 of Isoplot/Ex, you must first find the old Isoplot.xla file and either delete it or (preferably) rename it (e.g. Isoplot1.xla). If you have an earlier version of Isoplot/Ex installed, you should find and delete the Isostat file which the earlier version will have placed in the folder containing the Excel application (usually Microsoft Office on a Macintosh, or \Program Files\Microsoft Office\Office in Windows). Start Excel, and from an open Worksheet, select T ools/Add- Ins. If Isoplot.xla is not in the list of available Add-Ins, select B rowse to locate it. Isoplot will now be loaded every time you start Excel (if not wanted, un-check Isoplot2.XLA from the add-in list before exiting Excel). To invoke Isoplot/Ex, first open the Worksheet that contains your data, and select (with the mouse or keyboard) the data-range that you want to work with (including any header-row). Then, either 1) press the Isoplot button, on Excels Standard toolbar (the one at the top of the screen), 2) choose R u n Isoplot from the T o o l s menu, or 3) Press Ctrl-I.
February 21, 2000
4
The items in the Isoplot drop-down menu can also be accessed from a special Isoplot toolbar. To access the Isoplot toolbar, select View/Toolbars from the Standard (top) Excel toolbar and check the Isoplot item. The toolbar below will then appear on the screen:
To learn the functionality of the a toolbar button, pause the mouse-cursor briefly over the button, and a text summary of its use will appear. The First 11 buttons duplicate the items in the drop-down isoplot menu; use of the last seven, whose functions are accessible only via the toolbar, are described in Appendix II (p. 47). You can move any of Isoplot toolbars buttons to any of Excels other toolbars, so that they will always appear when you run Excel, with the following: 1) Select Tools/Customize from the Excel Standard toolbar; 2) While holding down the option key (Macintosh) or control key (Windows), so that the button is copied rather than permanently moved, drag and drop any button you wish from the Isoplot toolbar to any other toolbar. The changes will be permanent, until you either remove the button (by following the same procedure as above, except drag and drop the button to any area outside a toolbar) or Excel crashes. You can move the Isoplot toolbar anywhere on the worksheet, change its shape from horizontal to square or vertical (using the triangular-shaped handle at the lower right of the toolbar), or dock it at the top, bottom, or sides of the Excel workspace (drag and drop with the upper, stippled part of the toolbar). Avoid invoking Isoplot by double-clicking on the Isoplot.xla files icon, because 1) in some cases this can result in more than once copy of Excel running at the same time, and 2) the only way to unload a directly-invoked Isoplot from Excel is to quit the Excel program. The speed of Isoplot can be greatly affected by the size of the active Excel workbook. If you have a lot of worksheets in the workbook, or a worksheet becomes very large and complex, Isoplot will slow down to a crawl, even when just displaying dialog boxes. Memory Settings for Macintosh Computers If youre running System 7.x, make sure that the Modern Memory Manager is turned Off (select Memory from Control Panel). The Modern Memory Manager will dramatically degrade Excel performance in general, and can even crash the system entirely when Isoplot is run. 5) Make sure that Virtual Memory is enabled (or that RamDoubler is installed), no matter how much physical memory you have. 6) Set the Preferred Memory size for Excel to at least 8 Mb (with the Finder active and the Excel application program selected, select Get Info from the File menu).
T h e Input Data-Range
H e a de r R o w s If you include a header row with the data-range, Isoplot will try to recognize the type of plot and type of errors from the information in the header row (see TestData.XLS for examples). To determine the type
February 21, 2000
5
of plot, Isoplot looks for isotope ratios in the X- Y- (Z-) columns that define a supported plot type for example, X- and Y-column headers consisting of either 147/144 143/144 or of 147Sm/144Nd 143Nd/144Nd will convince Isoplot to select an Sm-Nd isochron plot as the default plot-type. Isoplot will also try to recognize the type and sigma-level of the errors from the header rows, and offer its best guess as the default error type. D at a i n a S i n g l e , C o n t i g u o u s R an g e The simplest data range is a contiguous rectangular block of cells comprising a header-row at the top (optional), and 2 to 9 contiguous columns containing the data, errors (optional) and error correlations (optional). For isochron or 2-dimensional concordia data, the simplest way to arrange the columns is: X X-error Y Y-error RhoXY
where RhoXY is the X-Y error correlation; or X or simply as X Y X-error Y Y-error
If you dont supply columns for errors, Isoplot will ask you for values to apply to all of the data in the range. The errors can be either absolute or percent, 1σ or 2σ. Missing error correlations are assumed to be zero, except for conventional Concordia plots and Normal Pb-Pb plots, where you will be required to enter nonzero values. For Argon-Argon Step-Heating data, 3 columns are required: Cumulative 39Ar-Fraction Age Age -error
where the 39Ar gas-fraction can be expressed as percent if desired. For weighted averages or cumulative probability distributions, the columns must be: X X-error
For 3-dimensional regressions, use either 9, 6, or 3 columns, in the order: X or X or just X Y Z X-error Y Y-error Z Z-error X-error Y Y-error Z Z-error RhoXY RhoXZ RhoYZ
Blank rows will be ignored in all cases. D at a i n D i s c o n t i n u o u s R o w s To use only the data in certain rows, select a range with two or more discontinuous areas; for example:
February 21, 2000
6
A3:E3,A6:E9,A12:E22
selects the 5 cells in row 3 from column A to E, then rows 6 through 9 of the same 5 columns, then rows 12 to 22. To do this with the mouse, hold down the Control (Windows) or Command (Macintosh) key, select A3:E3, then A6:E9, then A12:E22. D at a i n D i s c o n t i n u o u s C o l u m n s If (and only if) your data are in contiguous rows, you can select a range with discontinuous columns to satisfy Isoplots requirements. For example, if your data were arranged in rows 1 through 11, with columns: A 143Nd/144Nd B C D 1 4 3 / 1 4 4 %err
1 4 7 S m / 1 4 4 N d 1 4 7 / 1 4 4 %err
your range selection would be: B1:C11,A1:A11,D1:D11 so that as interpreted by Isoplot the data would be arranged as: 147Sm/143Nd 147/144 %err 143Nd/144Nd 143/144 %err
E x c l u di n g D a t a w i t h F o n t s i n S t ri k e t h ro u g h If you dont want to use a discontinuous-row selection to exclude certain data-rows (perhaps because you want to use discontinuous columns, or just to simplify the range-selection), you can exclude any datarow by using a font in Strikethrough mode (Fo rmat Ce lls Font Strike through) for the excluded data-cells. E m p h a s i z e d P l o t - S y m b o l s w i t h B o l de d F o n t s If the font for a data-row is bolded, Isoplot will emphasize the plot-symbol by making it solid instead of open (circle, square, diamond, and triangle symbols), or by constructing the symbol with thicker lines (unfilled [outline] error ellipses and error boxes). However, no symbol-by-symbol emphasis is possible for filled error-symbols, or for the error-cross, +, or X symbols. S p e c i f y i n g S y m b o l C o l o rs w i t h F o n t C o l o rs Normally, a single color is specified for the symbols of all of the data points in a plot. You can use different colors for each data-point, though, by using the desired colors as the font color for each data-row, and specifying Font Color as the symbol color from the Isoplot dialog-box. E a rl y v e rs u s l a t e da t a s e l e c t i o n Usually, you will find it easiest to select the desired data-range before invoking Isoplot. On a Windows platform, you can also select the data range with the mouse after Isoplot is invoked (provided the Range edit-box is active). On Macintosh platforms, such late data-selection via mouse is not possible. You can type in the range or range-name after Isoplot is invoked, though, for either platform.
Numeric Output from Isoplot
The results of a calculation are always shown first in a popup-box such as the one below:
February 21, 2000
7
with or without buttons/checkboxes to select additional information or calculations. These popups are ephemeral, but all contain a checkbox labeled S how results with data, Concordia-constrained linear 3-D isochron If S how results with data is checked, the information in the results-box will be transferred in a text-box to the worksheet containing the source-data (at the upperright of the source-data range), and look something the box at right. These text-box results arent very easy to use for further spreadsheet calculations. However, in many cases, Isoplot also supplies a user-available arrayfunction (see p. 37) that will place the results as numbers directly in worksheet cells.
Age = 298.37 ± 0.92 Ma MSWD = 1.4, probability =0.17 Common-Pb plane intercepts at 206Pb/204Pb = 20.01 ± 0.11 207Pb/204Pb = 15.698 ± 0.021 error correl. = +0.45 Stacey-Kramers Age = -854 Ma Stacey-Kramers Mu = 9.85
Graphics from Isoplot
If the P lot checkbox of the main Isoplot dialog-box is checked, Isoplot will construct an X-Y plot (or Chart in Excel nomenclature) of the data on a separate sheet in the same workbook as the source-data. The time it takes to do this can vary greatly from a less than a second (400 Mhz Pentium II) to more than a minute (90 Mhz PowerMac), depending on the computer, the operating system, and the complexity of the graphical elements in the plot (error ellipses are a particular drag). H i dde n W o rk s h e e t s C re a t e d b y I s o p l o t The data plotted in Isoplots charts is tied not to the source-data whose range you specified when invoking Isoplot, but to data in hidden worksheets (one per plot) named PlotDat1, PlotDat2 The data in these worksheets is not linked live to the source-data, so that the plot will not change if values in the sourcedata range are changed. If you delete one of Isoplots chart-sheets, the associated hidden worksheet is no longer needed; to remove any such orphaned hidden-worksheets, use the Delete Unused Isoplot Sheets item in the Isoplot menu (or the corresponding button on the Isoplot toolbar). A ddi n g N e w D a t a t o a n E x i s t i n g C h a rt You can add a second series of data points complete with regression lines and age-results, to most Isoplot charts. To do this,
February 21, 2000
8
1) select the range of the new data (the new data must be in the same worksheet as the charts primary data); 2) switch to the Isoplot-created chart-sheet to which you want to add data; 3) select A dd Data -Points from the Isoplot menu; 4) specify what you want done with the new data, how to plot it, and click OK. You can also plot data along a secondary axis whose label and axis-ticks are at the right-hand side of the plot box, so that, for example, the first data-series for 207Pb/ 204Pb values, with Y=15.4 to 15.8 are plotted as usual, and a second data-series consisting of 208Pb/ 204Pb values, with Y=36 to 39, are plotted according to the range and axis-ticks of the right-hand axis. To do this, 1) select the range of the new data (the new data must be in the same worksheet as the charts primary data); 2) switch to the Isoplot-created chart-sheet to which you want to add data; 3) select A dd Data -Points from the Isoplot menu; 4) select any plot symbol but an error ellipse or error box (these will not work with a secondary axis); 5) select the new data-series on the plot (you may have to scroll through the plot-elements with the up or down arrows to do this, if the data are not visible on the plot); 6) select Format/Selected data series, and click on the Axis tab; 7) specify S econdary axis; 8) double-click on the new axis to adjust its formatting and scale. M o di f y i n g C h a rt s You can modify any graphical element of a chart by simply clicking on the element (say the Y-axis, or a regression line), pulling down the F ormat menu, and selecting the desired graphical element (usually the first one in the list, if you pre-selected an item). You can then change the foreground/background colors of the object, line colors, line styles, line widths, numeric format, font, font size, and so on. You can also add a limited range of graphical objects to the plot (arrows, textboxes, circles, polygons, curves, lines) with the Drawing button on one of the Excel toolbars. Selecting and modifying simple data-point symbols and outline error-symbols For data plotted as a symbol without error information that is, a circle, square, diamond, triangle, + , or X clicking on any member of the data-series will select the whole data series, so that any formatting changes will affect the symbols for all of the members of the data series. To select an individual member of such a data series, first click on any plot-symbol within the data series, then repeatedly press the right-arrow key to step through the individual data-points. For error ellipses and boxes plotted as outlines (unfilled symbols), you can only select one data-point at a time; to step through the different data points, use the upand down-arrow keys.
February 21, 2000
9
Adding Data-Point Labels If youre not sure which symbol on the chart belongs to which data-row on the source-data sheet, Isoplot can attach a label to each plotted point. To do this youll need a column of data-point labels somewhere on the source-data sheet (just to the left or right of the data itself would be fine). From the Chart sheet, select Label Data Points from the Isoplot menu. Select where you want the labels to appear (relative to the corresponding data points) and, if you have more than one data-series plotted, which series to label. Finally, enter the range containing the labels (must match the data-point range in both number and order). After plotting, the labels can be reformatted or moved as desired. Selecting individual labels: Plots with U-Pb concordia curves, U-series evolution curves, or Pb-isotope growth curves all contain labeled age-ticks on those curves. The labels will often be positioned inconveniently, so that you will want to move or delete some or all of them. To select an individual label for moving deleting, or formatting first select all of the labels by clicking on one of them. Wait a second, then click on the particular label you want to change, and hold down the mouse button. After about a second, the individual label will be selected. Moving and shrinking charts to worksheets If you would like the chart to be part of the worksheet containing its source-data, switch to the chartsheet and select Attach Chart to Source-Data Worksheet from the Isoplot menu. The chart will be shrunk about 4 times and moved to the source-data worksheet, just to the right of the source-data range. You can further re-size the chart from the worksheet by first selecting the chart itself, then the various chart elements. Once you have done this, you can also cut/paste the chart to a blank worksheet and assemble a page of nothing but reduced-size charts (and any related commentary, such as figure legends (you may want to turn off the worksheet gridlines to improve appearance, using Tools/ Options/View/Gridlines). Or, you can copy/paste the moved/shrunk chart to within an existing chart-sheet, so as to create an inset (as in the cover figure). Superimposing charts You can also superimpose charts for example, if you need an inset showing a magnified view of a part of a chart. To do this, first have Isoplot create the master chart, in the usual way (as a separate chartsheet), then create the chart to be inset, also in the usual way. Move/shrink the inset chart as described above, then cut/paste (or copy/paste) the resulting reduced-scale chart onto the master-chart sheet. Reformat the superimposed inset-chart as desired. Alternatively, just select one or more charts and copy/paste them to a worksheet in the usual way (note that the size of the pasted chart depends on the zoom-ratio of the destination worksheet). Shrink and superimpose the charts as required. U s i n g f i l l e d e rro r- e l l i p s e s a n d e rro r- b o x e s Error ellipses and boxes will be plotted as either a simple outline or as a filled shape, depending on the status of the filled Symbols checkbox in the main Isoplot dialog-box. There are important differences in the way outline and filled error-symbols can be used, as listed below: Outline symbols are always accurately plotted, no matter how or when the plot is re-scaled or re-sized; Filled symbols will become slightly but noticeably mislocated whenever the magnification (zoom) of the chart is changed;
February 21, 2000
10
Filled symbols do not respond to re-scaling or re-sizing of the chart, and so will become significantly mislocated when you change either the physical dimensions of the plot or the logical scale of either axis; The only changes that can be made to the visual appearance of outline symbols are to modify the outline color and thickness; Filled symbols can be modified in many ways, including not only their outline color/thickness and fillcolor, but also the pattern, color gradient, and transparency of the fill. Outline symbols cannot be moved, even temporarily (though they can be deleted); Filled symbols can be temporarily or permanently moved in the usual click-and-drag way. This can be especially useful if you want to see what lies underneath a filled symbol
To rectify the location of filled symbols after any re-scaling or re-sizing action, or after any zoom-in or zoom-out, select Rescale Filled Symbols from the Isoplot menu on the Chart or Worksheet menu-bar. Any filled errorboxes or error-ellipses will then be accurately relocate and resized. You can also stack these symbols according to their size (actually, the length of their diagonal), so that smaller ellipses or boxes will lie on top of progressively larger ones, using the Sort Filled Symbols by Size menuitem. To change the order yourself, rightclick (Windows) or Control-click (Macintosh) a filled symbol to bring up the menu at left, select the Order item, then the desired placement with the resulting sub-menu (above). You should always re-scale filled symbols before printing to make sure that they are accurately placed. In some cases, you may need to first zoom in to the maximum (400%) to eliminate any residual offset. C o l o r- s c a l i n g o f f i l l e d s y m b o l s If your data are plotted as filled error-ellipses or error boxes, you can use color scaling (or grayscaling, if not a color plot) to represent the value of a third, z-parameter. To use color scaling: Plot your data in the usual way; Select a columnar range of cells to use for the color scalingfor example, a ppm Uranium column. Make sure that the number of valid cells in this range matches exactly the number of data symbols in your plot; Select the plot again, and select Color Scale Filled Symbols from the drop-down Isoplot menu; Re-select the scaling range if necessary; Select how you want the colors scaled. Use Autoscale to use the lowest- and highest-values of the color-scaling range define the lowest (pure blue) and highest (pure red) colors.
February 21, 2000
11
Figure 1: Plot with color scaling to indicate the values of a z-parameter.
E x p o rt i n g c h a rt s t o o t h e r p ro g ra m s Simply using Copy/Paste to export Excel charts to another application generally results in unacceptable quality, because of the default Windows/Mac Clipboard resolution of 1/72. For some graphics programs e.g. CorelDraw/Windows), using Excels Copy P icture method (invoke the E dit menu from the chart sheet with Shift depressed) will yield acceptable resolution in the exported graphic; for others (e.g. Canvas/Mac) resolution will remain unacceptable. Even if useful resolution is maintained, though, some graphic elements such as dashed lines, curves, and (unfilled) ellipses will generally not be recognized as objects by the drawing program, but rather will be a collection of short, hideously inconvenient individual line-segments. Another strategy for exporting charts (which works particularly well with a Macintosh) is to print the chart or worksheet to a file with a PostScript printer specified, thus creating an Encapsulated Postscript (EPS) file with high-resolution graphics (thanks to Peter Gromet for this suggestion). You can then either insert the resulting image directly into, say, a word-processing program, or import it into a drawing program such as Adobe Illustrator (the best solution if you intend to do much additional manipulation with the graphic) or Adobe Acrobat (the full version, not the Reader). Drawbacks of this method are: 1) Many drawing/graphics programs cant convert PostScript graphics to their own vector graphics format; 2) Of those drawing/graphics programs that can import PostScript graphics, at least some (e.g. Canvas) will manage to corrupt most of the text elements, and may change curves and outline ellipses into ungrouped collection of short line-segments; 4) If exported into a word-processing document, the documents size will increase dramatically (about 800 Kb for each imported chart), unless the document is saved with links to the EPS files instead of specifically including the graphics; 5) Word processing programs for Windows (but not for Macintosh) will typically not display the imported image in the document, and will only print the image on a PostScript printer. 6) When imported by Adobe Acrobat into a PDF file, the high-resolution EPS file will be severely degraded. The Adobe Distiller program (included in the full Acrobat) can be used to get around this
February 21, 2000
12
limitation, however just set Job Options/Compression/Downsample to a reasonably high resolution (say 200-300 dpi). If you use this method, make sure that you specify printing to a file, select Inclusion of All Fonts, and (for a Mac) select Mac Enhanced Preview. Another method (used for this manual) is to import Isoplots charts as a bitmap using a screen-capture utility. If you have such a utility, before capturing the screen select V iew/Fu ll Screen from the chart sheet, then enlarge the plot-box as much as possible. After pasting the image into your document and shrinking it 4x or more, you should have acceptable (though not really publication quality) resolution.
T h e Main Isoplot/Ex D i a l o g B o x
When Isoplot is invoked, you will see:
If you included a header-row with the data-range that was selected when you invoked Isoplot, some of the choices will already have been correctly made; others require some thought. Your choices will include some or all of: Input R ange: The range, if any, that was selected when Isoplot was invoked . You can type in any other range as well, e.g. A10:E22, MyData, B3:F6,B8:F8, B14:F22. On Windows platforms, you can also use the mouse to select a range after invoking Isoplot. The ranges can included discontinuous rows (so as to exclude unwanted data in a contiguous sequence), or discontinuous columns (so as to rearrange the column-order to meet Isoplots requirements), but not both. Rows without numeric data are ignored, as are rows whose data are shown with the Strikethrough attribute. Isochron or Plot Type: Select from the drop-down list:
February 21, 2000
13
For isochrons (including U/Pb concordia), Normal plots yield the age from the slope of the linear regression, and initial ratios from one of the intercepts, whereas the opposite is true of Inverse plots. The plot-types offered by Isoplot are:
U-Pb Concordia
Data for a Normal (207Pb/ 235U - 206Pb/ 238U, or conventional, or Wetherill) Concordia plot, or for an Inverse (238U/206Pb - 207Pb/ 206Pb, or TeraWasserburg) Concordia plot. The data points can be regressed using a modified York two-error regression algorithm (York, 1969), and the resulting concordia-intercept age-errors can be calculated using either a first-derivative expansion approach or (if there is no excess scatter) a more-reliable Monte Carlo approach. If an Inverse Concordia plot, you can also include Z-axis (204Pb/ 206Pb) data for either planar 3-D or linear 3-D (Total Pb/U Isochron) regressions. Finally, you can select the Concordia Age method to calculate ages and X-Y means for 2-D data that are both concordant and X-Y equivalent. Argon-Argon isochron data, where Normal is Inverse is 36Ar/40Ar versus 39Ar/40Ar.
40
Ar-Ar Rb-Sr Sm-Nd Re-Os Lu-Hf K-Ca 207Pb-206Pb 208Pb-206Pb 238U-206Pb 235U-207Pb 232Th-208Pb 230Th-234U-238U
Ar/36Ar versus
39
Ar/36Ar, and
Classical 87Rb/ 86Sr - 87Sr/ 86Sr isochron (Normal only). Classical 147Sm/ 144Nd - 143Nd/144Nd isochron (Normal only).
187 176 40
Os/188 Os-187Re/188 Os isochron (Normal only). Hf/177Hf - 176Lu/177Hf isochron (Normal only).
Ca/42Ca - 40K/42Ca isochron (Normal only).
207
206
Pb/ 204Pb chron.
206
Pb/ 204Pb (Normal) or
204
Pb/ 206Pb 204
207
Pb/ 206Pb (Inverse) iso-
Pb/ 204Pb - 208Pb/ 204Pb (Normal) or 208Pb/ 206Pb sion.
238 238 235 235 232
Pb/ 206Pb (Inverse) regres-
U/204Pb - 206Pb/ 204Pb (Normal), 204Pb/ 238U - 206Pb/ 238U (Inverse Type-1), or U/206Pb - 204Pb/ 206Pb (Inverse Type-2) isochron. U/204Pb - 207Pb/ 204Pb (Normal), 204Pb/ 235U - 207Pb/ 235U (Inverse Type-1), or U/207Pb - 204Pb/ 207Pb (Inverse Type-2) isochron.
Th/204Pb - 208Pb/ 204Pb (Normal), 204Pb/ 232Th - 208Pb/ 232Th (Inverse Type-1), or 232Th/208Pb - 204Pb/ 208Pb (Inverse Type-2) isochron. For 3D 230Th/U isochrons (required if 234U/238U cannot be assumed to be in secular equilibrium!), any combination of 232Th/238U - 230Th/238U - 234U/238U as the X-Y-Z axes. For 2D 230Th/U isochrons (requires all 234U/238U=1), either X=238U/232Th,
February 21, 2000
14
Y =230Th/232Th or X= 232Th/238U, Y = 230Th/238U. Also permitted is X = 230Th/238U, Y = 234U/238U (for plotting only), in which case one or more 230Th/U evolution curves (for user-specified initial 234U/238U) can be requested.
Other X-Y [-Z] Weighted Average Cumulative Prob Ar-Ar Step-Heating
Any other X-Y or X-Y-Z plot, X-Y isochron, or X-Y-Z regression. Classical inverse variance-weighted average, with two approaches for dealing with excess scatter, plus the Tukeys Biweight robust estimator. Constructs the cumulative Gaussian probability curve for an assemblage of single-valued data and errors, with or without a histogram for the data. Constructs the classical Ar-Ar step-heating diagram (age versus 39Ar gas-fraction), and identifies the best plateau defined by the data.
Action/Plot: Check the P lot box in the Action group to obtain a plot as a separate Excel Chart-sheet. Action/Calculate: Check the Calcu late box in the Action group to have Isoplot perform a regression or other calculation on the selected data. Results will be included in the plot, if one is specified. Action/Robust Regr: Instead of calculating the best-fit line, isochron, or chord using the usual 2-error regression (Yorkfit), use a robust (nonparametric) regression which makes no assumptions about the nature or distribution of the scatter about a straight line. Not available for U-Pb Concordia or 230Th-234U-238U isochrons (see p. 20). Input Errors: Specify the type and sigma-level of the errors you have assigned to your data here (if you will be regressing the data, or plotting with error-symbols). Be especially careful to correctly specify the errors as absolute or percent. The sigma-level is important for (nonrobust) regressions, as the resulting MSWD will be affected by a factor of 4. Also, if you have specified (from the Options/Lines dialog box) that error symbols are to be plotted at the sigma-level of the input-data, the sizes of error ellipses, error crosses, and error boxes will reflect the sigma-level you specify (see p. 16). Plotting Symbols: The available plotting symbols are: shown in the Symbols drop-down: Note that error cross and error box symbols are not enabled for plot types whose X-Y data-errors are always significantly correlatedthat is, for conventional concordia Pb-Pb isochron plots. The line connect option constructs a line connecting the data points, in the same order that they appear in the worksheet, but without any data-point symbols. By default, the line is smoothed. Double-click on it to cancel smoothing. The line connect option is useful for plotting custom curves, such as non-single stage Pb-isotope growth curves3.
3
The age ticks could be added by plotting a data range corresponding to the age ticks as circles, then invoking Isoplots Label Data-Points menu-item to label the ticks.
February 21, 2000
15
Plot-Symbol Colors: Select the outline-color of the plot-symbols from the Symbol/Colors drop-down.
You can have the symbol-outline colors vary for each data-point by selecting Font Color, in which case the symbol color will match the color of the font used for each data-point. For non-filled symbols, the default interior color of polygonal, non-error plot-symbols is white; to use filled symbols of this type, use a bold font for the data.
Other/Color: Check this box if you want the plot to use the colors specified in Options/Colors; leave unchecked for a black-and-white plot. Other/Autoscale: Check this box to have Isoplot select the X- and Y-limits of the plot-box, based on the range of the selected data. Leave unchecked to specify these limits yourself.
Other/Anchored (Two-dimensional Concordia plots only): Check this box to (1) force one of the Concordia intercepts to be a specified age; (2) force the regression line to intersect the 207 Pb/ 206Pb axis at some specified common-Pb ratio (Inverse Concordia plots only); or (3) construct a reference chord between two specified ages, using the dialog-box at right:
Other/PbGrowth (207Pb - 206Pb or 208Pb - 206Pb isochrons only): Check this box to specify construction of a single-stage Pb-isotope growth curve. From the dialog-box (p. 29) that appears later, you can specify Stacey-Kramers parameters, or any other initial age, Pb-isotope ratios, and Mu for the growth curve. Other/Reject OK (Weighted-averages only): Check this box to permit outlier-rejection using a modified 2σ criterion. Options/Fonts: Specify the default fonts for different elements of the Isoplot charts: If youre working with a large worksheet, you also may want to check the Inhibit Recalculation During Dialog-Box Displays box to speed up Isoplot interaction. If you check S uperscript Isotopes in Axis Labels, number-prefixes of common geochronologic isotopes will be superscripted in the usual way (e.g. 87Sr/ 86Sr). For Macintosh platforms, this has the disadvantage
February 21, 2000
16
that: 1) the Y-axis labels will be oriented horizontally instead of vertically (because of a bug in Mac Excel 98), and 2) there will be slight but discernible time-penalty. If (Macintosh only) you find that the horizontal Y-axis labels resulting from allowing superscripted isotopes on a Mac take up too much horizontal space, check Stack isotopes in Y-axis label. Options/Colors: Specify the default colors for the various elements of the Isoplot charts. Options/Lines: Specify various features of the lines in the Isoplot charts: Ellipses & curves: Fine results in a large number of line-segments defining the curves and ellipses, and also a slight penalty in speed; Coarse is the fastest, with a slight compromise on linesmoothness. Dont judge the quality of the outline curves/ellipses at low magnification, though to evaluate, zoom to 400% and temporarily change the linethickness of the curve/ellipse to the thinnest available. Error Symbols: You can specify that error symbols (error ellipses, error boxes, and error crosses) be plotted at 2-sigma, (regardless of the sigma-level of the input-data), or at the sigma-level of the input-data. Thus the only way of plotting 1-sigma error symbols is to have the input-data errors at 1-sigma and also to specify at sigma-level of input data in the Error Symbols group of Options/Lines. The E nd-caps on error crosses box specifies whether or not error crosses will be terminated by a short, horizontal line in both the X- and Y-error directions. Clipped Ellipses: If checked, error ellipses will be clipped at the plotbox borders; if unchecked, they will continue beyond. Dont use clipped ellipses if you might re-scale the plot-limits laterif you do so, the clipped ellipses will be revealed as arcs (outline ellipses) or abruptly terminated shapes (filled ellipses). Slow/Fast Ellipses: A Windows bug in the generation of the shapes used for filled error ellipses/boxes forces Isoplot under Windows to use a slower, klugey workaround to avoid crashes. If you run into crashes when working with filled symbols under Windows, make sure that Slow is selected (should not be a problem with Macintosh/Excel98). If the setting is Fast and Isoplot encounters problems, it will automatically revert to Slow. Rescale shapes w hen done: Check this box to have the filled symbols in the plot automatically rescaled and ordered by size just before the plot is finished. Because this takes extra time, if your plots take more than a few seconds to construct you may want to leave this box unchecked (make sure to rescale the plot from the Isoplot drop-down menu before printing). Minimum sheet margins: Check this box to get the maximum colored-background area on the plot sheets (for best appearance of slides and transparencies), at the cost of a few seconds extra on slow computers. Options/Constants: Permits the user to specify all of the geochemical constants used by Isoplot, including decay constants and errors, model-age parameters, and minimum gas-percent for Ar-Ar plateaux:
February 21, 2000
17
C l a s s i c a l X -Y R e g r e s s i o n s a n d I s o c h r o n s
R e g re s s i o n M o de l s Unless Robust Regr. were checked (p. 20), two-dimensional (x-y) data are initially regressed using the algorithm of York (1969), with errors propagated using the (maximum-likelihood estimation) algorithm of Titterington and Halliday (1979). If the probability of fit of the regression is low, other approaches (Models) for weighting the data-points may be used. The 3 Models used by Isoplot are: Model 1 The Model 1 fit is Yorks original algorithm, and assumes that the assigned errors are the only reason the data-points scatter from a straight line. The points are therefore weighted proportional to the inverse square of these errors (taking into account the error correlations). A test of the Model 1 assumption is provided by the Probability of Fit calculated by the program. If this probability is reasonably high (more than 15%), then the Model 1 assumptions are considered justified, and the regression is complete. If the probability is low (less than 15%), you may choose another model. The Probability of Fit is actually the probability that, if the only reason for scatter from a straight line is the analytical errors assigned to the data points, the scatter of the data points will exceed the amount observed for your data. If you accept the Model 1 fit even though the Probability of Fit is less than 15%, Isoplot then calculates the 95%-confidence errors from the observed scatter (thus invoking the use of the Students-t multiplier to convert from estimated errors equivalent to the a priori errors multiplied by the square root of the MSWD4 to 95%-confidence errors). Note that in this case, weighting of the data points remains inversely proportional to the square of their analytical errors.
4
MSWD = Mean Square of Weighted Deviates. This does not refer to porcine perverts; it is, roughly, a measure of the ratio of the observed scatter of the points (from the best-fit line) to the expected scatter (from the assigned errors and error correlations). T h e M S W D p a r a m e t e r c a n n o t b e c o m p a r e d t o t h e c l a s s i c a l R 2 p a r a m e t e r , a n d i s n o t a m e a s u r e o f h o w h i g h l y c o r r e l a t e d t h e X - a n d Y - v a l u e s a r e . If the assigned errors are the only cause of scatter, the MSWD will tend to be near unity. MSWD values much
February 21, 2000
18
Isoplot will always attempt a Model 1 fit first. In the results-box, the a priori errors are the errors in the slope and intercept calculated by propagating only your assigned errors for the points; therefore, no matter how much the points scatter, the a priori errors will not increase. The including scatter errors, however, are calculated from the actual scatter of the points from a line, and are independent of the assigned errors. These errors, given at the 1σ level, are provided mainly for comparison purposes with the output of other implementations of Yorks algorithm. The only geologically useful errors for data sets with few points are the ones given as 95% Confidence-Limit errors. How the 95% confidence-limit errors are calculated depends on the probability that the assigned datapoint errors can account for the observed scatter. If the probability is greater than 15%, the 95% confidencelimit errors are given as simply 1.96 (Students-t for an infinite number of points) times the a priori errors (the reason for this is discussed by Brooks and others, 1972). Model 2 A Model 2 fit (not supported for classical isochrons such as Rb-Sr or Sm-Nd) assigns equal weights and zero error-correlations to each point. This is seldom justified by any real mechanism, but at least avoids the mistake of weighting the points according to analytical errors (see above discussion of Model 1 regressions) when it is clear that, in fact, some other cause of scatter is involved. The 95% confidence-limit errors are calculated from tn-2 times the including scatter errors. If you know little or nothing about the dominant cause of the scatter of the points, and about the statistical form of that cause, you should probably use this model. Model 3 Fits A Model 3 fit (for classical isochrons such as Rb-Sr or Sm-Nd) assumes that the scatter is due to a combination of the assigned errors plus an unknown but normally distributed variation in the Y-values. This model (similar to the Model 3 algorithm of McIntyre and others, 1966) may be realistic in the case of Rb-Sr or other isochron data for rocks whose initial ratios were variable. For this model, the program will solve for the unknown Y-variation (= initial-ratio variation) as well as for the best-fit line, so you can judge whether or not the solution is realistic. Remember, though, that it is physically quite possible (even likely) that the initial ratios of the samples were significantly correlated with their Rb/Sr (or other parent/daughter ratio), in which case the Model 3 assumptions are not valid. For an extended discussion of the problem, see Zheng (1989a), or Juteau and others (1984) for an excellent example. A W o rd A b o u t 3 - P o i n t I s o c h ro n s You should be aware that the reliability of isochron ages for regression lines with only 3 or 4 data points and no resolvable geological scatter can be significantly less than suggested by the uncertainties calculated by most regression algorithms, including that of Isoplot. The reason for this is that with only 1 or 2 degrees of freedom (3 or 4 data points), the probability of getting an MSWD of close to 1 even though some geological scatter exists in the population is significant. For such data sets, the lack of statistical resolution of this geological scatter can be expected to occur in a significant number of cases, and, because the use or non-use of a very large (12.7 for N=3) Students-t multiplier is involved, can lead to a large underestimate of the true isochron uncertainties.
greater than unity generally indicate either underestimated analytical errors, or the presence of non-analytical scatter. MSWD values much less than unity generally indicate either overestimated analytical errors, or unrecognized error-correlations.
February 21, 2000
19
C o m m e n t s o n R e g re s s i o n s w i t h L o w P ro b a b i l i t i e s - o f - F i t Exactly how to quantitatively and qualitatively interpret a regression with a low probability-of-fit (sometimes referred to as an excess scatter regression) is a thorny issue, with no real consensus among the geochronological community. The problem centers around two points: 1) If the only reasons for scatter about a regression line are truly the errors assigned to the data points, then the only relevant regression-line uncertainties (of slope and intercept) are those propagated solely from the assigned data-point errorsin other words, the a priori regression-line errors; 2) If the probability-of-fit (that the assigned data-point errors can account for the observed scatter of the data-points about the regression line) is very low, one must abandon the presumption of (1), and use the actual scatter of the data-points to estimate the regression-line uncertainty. The first point was emphasized by Williamson (1968), who unfortunately did not address the complications of the second point, which are: 1) How low should the probability-of-fit be before a priori regression-errors are abandoned? 1%? 5%? 15%? 2) If the assigned errors are not the reason for (most of) the observed scatter, how should the datapoints be weighted? 3) What is the significance of an isochron whose scatter arises from geologic/geochemical complications rather than analytical error? The answer to (1) above is necessarily arbitraryIsoplot chooses 15%. In some cases, an objective weighting algorithm (for scatter clearly in excess of analytical errors) can be applied to deal with (2) above (e.g. Model 3 below), though often not. Fortunately, (assuming a normal distribution of the data-point scatter) use of an invalid weighting algorithm will not bias the regression, but merely fail to make the most efficient use of the data, in the sense that one could have obtained a more precise regression if the true errors of each data-point were known. This is why, if the probability-of-fit of a regression is low, expansion of the a priori regression errors by the square root of the MSWD (which takes into account the actual scatter of the points) and a Students-t factor (which takes into account the fact that the true scatter of the data-point population is only estimated from a finite number of actual points) can be justified. The question of weighting and of intuitively-offensive probability break-points for regression-errors can be avoided by using a distribution-free or robust regression approach, in which no assumptions are made about why the data-points scatter from the regression line. The drawbacks of robust regressions, however, are that a) they tend to be inefficient for the typically small data-sets of geochronology when the (normally distributed) data-point errors are quite adequate to explain the regression-line scatter; and b) the geologicalsignificance question raised by point (3) above. The significance of a low probability-of-fit regression is perhaps the most difficult question of all to address, since there are no mathematical or algorithmic approaches that are really relevant. One should perhaps start with the simple statistical meaning of a correctly calculated error of such a regression say 8 points whose regression gives an isochron age of 320 ± 8 Ma at 95% confidence which can be stated as something like: If one were to repeat the sampling and regression procedure an infinite number of times, the probability that the grand mean of the resulting isochron ages would fall between 312 and 328 Ma is 95%. Notice that this statement does not say that the true age of the samples has a 95% probability of falling between 312 - 328 Ma, only that the mean of the infinitely-replicated regressions would yield an isochron age within this interval. Thus even the most robust, assumption-free regression algorithm will yield a biased isochron age if the samples comprising the isochron do not meet the basic isochron assumption of a closed system (except for the special, unlikely case of random redistribution of parent and daughter elements among the samples). The assumption of an invariant initial isotope-ratio need not be true for the isochron age to be unbiased, however, so long as the variation is not correlated with the parent-daughter ra-
February 21, 2000
20
tio. For U-Pb concordia or Pb-Pb isochrons, however, it is difficult to conceive of geochemically reasonable mechanisms that would yield both an unbiased and very low-probability regression. In sum, I recommend treating the errors assigned by Isoplot to ages derived from a low probability-offit regression as a lower bound on the true errors, rather than a reliable, mathematically firmly-constrained uncertainty. I also recommend treating age uncertainties in the literature that were derived from low (say <5%) probability-of-fit regressions as geochronologic disinformation if either 1) the a priori regression errors were used, or 2) the regression comprises only a small (say <5) numbers of points and 1-sigma regression errors were used.
Examining Residuals o f Regressions
You can look at the weighted residuals 5 of any of Isoplots regressions by checking the Insert WtdResiduals Column box when it appears in one of the dialog boxes. A new column will be inserted in the input-data sheet to the left of the input-datas X-values, and will contain the weighted residuals for each of the data-points selected for the regression. By definition, the MSWD of an error-weighted regression will equal the sum of the squares of the weighted residuals, divided by the degrees of freedom of the regression.6
Robust Regressions
Classical isochrons and x-y regressions assume that the residuals (observed scatter) of the data-points from a straight line have a normal (Gaussian) distribution, either because of the assigned analytical errors (Model-1 fits) or other causes. If this assumption is invalid, or even if a true, Gaussian form of the expected scatter of each data point cannot be modelled, the analyst is traditionally expected to take responsibility for whatever data-trimming is required to restore the legitimacy of the initial assumptions. When such data-trimming becomes uncomfortably arbitrary or extreme, yet the data-set is still believed to contain age-information worth extracting, the analyst may prefer instead to use a robust, nonparametric regression that makes no assumptions about the cause(s) of the observed scatter of the data from a straight line, and that requires no arbitrary7 decisions about what data should or should not be included in the regression. In such cases, Isoplot offers a robust regression option8 via the Action/Robust Regr checkbox. The robust regression algorthm used by Isoplot is that of the median of pairwise slopes9, with 95% confidence errors calculated using Kendalls S statistic following Vugrinovich (1981), and Rock and Duffy (1986).
5
ˆ Defined here as y y σ
i
yi
where ˆ is the value of y predicted by the regression. y
i
6
For York (X-Y) regressions, this will be true only for Model-1 fits; for Model-2 fits the MSWD calculated from the values in the Wtd Resids column will be meaningless, and for Model-3 fits will be very close to unity.
7 8 9
Though a priori criteria such as chemical or mineralogical characteristics are always fair. Not offered for U-Pb Concordia data.
Originally suggested by Theil (1950), discussed in Hoaglin et al., (1983, p. 160), and advocated for isochrons by Vugrinovich (1981) and Rock and Duffy (1986).
February 21, 2000
21
U-Pb Concordia Plots
There are 3 possible U-Pb concordia plots: Conventional (Wetherill, 1956), with
x = 207Pb/ 235U x = 238U/ 206Pb x = 235U/ 207Pb
y = 206Pb/ 238U y = 207Pb/ 206Pb y = 206Pb/ 207Pb
z = 204Pb/ 238U , z = 204Pb/ 206Pb z = 204Pb/ 207Pb
Tera-Wasserburg (Tera and Wasserburg, 1972), with
and its variant (Tatsumoto and others, 1972), with
(the z coordinate is relevant to the discussion of 3-dimensional concordia, pages 26-28). Isoplot/Ex supports both Conventional and Tera-Wasserburg concordia in their 2-dimensional forms, and just Tera-Wasserburg for 3-dimensional concordia. If you intend to calculate concordia-intercept ages by regressing a suite of discordant analyses (as opposed to calculating a Concordia Age for a suite of concordant analyses), make sure that the ConcAge box in the main Isoplot dialog-box is unchecked. C o n v e n t i o n a l v e rs u s T e ra - W a s s e rb u rg C o n c o rdi a R e p re s e n t a t i o n s Tera-Wasserburg concordia diagrams are mathematically equivalent to Conventional concordia diagrams. Tera-Wasserburg plots can have advantages in visualization, however, because the errors in their Xand Y-values are generally much-less correlated than those of the Conventional concordia diagram, so that the relative scatter of their error ellipses is more (visually) apparent. Moreover, as long as the magnitude of the common-Pb correction is small, and the error in the 206Pb/ 238U ratio is significantly greater than for the 207 Pb/ 206Pb ratio, error correlations for Tera-Wasserburg concordia data can be satisfactorily approximated by zero, whereas a precise and accurate value for error correlations is always essential for conventional concordia-data. A disadvantage of Tera-Wasserburg concordia is that it is difficult to show data with a large range of U/Pb ages (say from 100 Ma to 2700 Ma), and impossible to show a zero-age point. Quantitative comparison of Yorkfit calculations for the two types of concordia diagrams is logical only for Model 1 fits. If you do so (being careful to use the correct errors and error-correlations in both cases), you will find that the ages and age-errors are not exactly the same for the two types of (mathematically equivalent) data. This is not due to roundoff errors in the calculations, but rather to the assumption of a normal distribution for the isotope-ratio errors (only approximately true) and the first-derivative expansion formulae used to obtain the regression-line and concordia-intercept errors. The formulae for transforming errors for conventional Concordia plots to Tera-Wasserburg Concordia plots are:
2 S x = Sy2 2 2 2 S y = S x +S y -2S x S y ρ xy
S z2 = Sy2 +S z2 - 2S y Sz ρ yz 2 2 2 ρx z = S x + Sz Sz
S S y z
ρx y = S 2 S 2 ρxy S y x y ρ y z
(
) (2Sx Sz )
2 = S S ρ S + S S ρ + S S ρ x x y x y x z x z x z xz
where Sx = σ x x and ρxy is the x-y error correlation, et cetera. Note that the corresponding equation for ρxy in Ludwig (1980) is incorrect (sorry).
February 21, 2000
22
Figure 2: Conventional concordia plot.
Figure 3: Tera-Wasserburg concordia plot (same data as Figure 2).
E rro rs o f C o n c o rdi a - I n t e rc e p t A g e s Symmetric The simplest form of concordia-intercept age errors is obtained by propagating the variance/covariance of the regression-line slope and intercept via the usual first-derivative approximations. These age-errors are the first ones given in the results-box (below), and are of necessity symmetric that is, the upper age-error and the lower age-error are identical, and so are given as a simple ± value. For reasonably precisely-determined ages where the uranium decay-constant errors are ignored, these symmetric age-errors are generally quite satisfactory. Age errors are shown both with [in brackets] and without incorporation of the uranium decay-constant errors( see Ludwig, in press, for method and discussion), unless the two types of age errors are almost equivalent. When decay-constant errors are acknowledged, the best possible precision for an upper concordia-intercept age is about 5 Myr (2σ), or worse if the angle of intersection of the discordia line with the concordia curve is shallow. 235 To view or change the errors assigned to the U and 238U decay constants, invoke Options/Consts/Decay-Constant E rrors from Isoplot. Asymmetric For imprecise concordia-intercept ages (because the regression line is either imprecise or intersects the concordia curve at a shallow angle), the true age-errors will be significantly asymmetric that is, with different plus and minus errors (e.g. +32/-17 Ma). Asymmetric age-errors that ignore decay-constant uncertainties are given in the lower part of the Details box (above) that can be invoked from the ConcordiaIntercept Ages results-box.
February 21, 2000
23
Monte Carlo The most reliable errors for concordia-intercept ages are obtained with a Monte Carlo simulation that involves the regression procedure itself (not just the intercepts of a regression line with pre-calculated slopeintercept errors), and so does not rely on the usual first-derivative expansion approximations at any stage. Such Monte-Carlo age-errors are offered only if the regression-line probability-of-fit is greater than 0.05 (so that the assigned data-point errors have a reasonable likelihood of accounting for the observed scatter about the regression line). When the probability-of-fit drops below about 0.3, you will notice that the Monte Carlo errors deviate increasingly from the conventional (first-derivative expansion) errors. This discrepancy evidently arises when the assumption of dispersion from analytical errors alone is tenuous. To take into account the uncertainties in the 235U and 238U decay constants, check Include decayconstant errors. Also, if you are convinced that the lower intercept of the discordia line with the concordia curve must reflect a geologic event, you can constrain the Monte Carlo solutions of the regression to those which have a positive lower concordia-intercept age: check the box labeled Accept Only P ositive Lower-Intercept Ages.
S h o w i n g D e c a y - C o n s t a n t E rro rs i n t h e C o n c o rdi a C u rv e The concordia curve can be constructed to show the effect of decay-constant errors on the position of the concordia curve. Check the Show with decay-const. errors box when it appears, and the concordia curve will be plotted as a band that reflects the 238U and 235U decay-constant errors, with error ellipses for age-ticks. Note that the concordia band and ticks are always plotted at 2σ, even if the data-point errorsymbols have been specified to be 2σ.
T h e C o n c o rdi a A g e In addition to the usual 206Pb/ 238U, 207Pb/ 235U 207Pb/ 206Pb ages, you can use any pair of 206Pb/ 238U Pb/ 235U or 238U/206Pb - 207Pb/ 206Pb ratios to calculate a single Concordia Age (Ludwig, 1998). A Concordia Age is the most-probable age for a data-point (or weighted-mean data-point) on a concordia-diagram, where the true location of the data point is assumed to fall precisely on the concordia curve. Because a Concordia Age makes optimal use of all of the radiogenic Pb/U and Pb/Pb ratios at the same time, it will be slightly to significantly more precise than any single U/Pb or Pb/Pb age. Though the precision advantage for Concordia Ages younger than Late Paleozoic (where most of the chronometric power resides in the 206 Pb/ 238U ratio) is slight, the technique still can be worth using even for analyses of geologically young material, because it yields an objective and quantitative measure of concordance (see below).
207
February 21, 2000
24
Calculating a Concordia Age To calculate a Concordia Age, select a range comprising one or more data-points for either a Conventional or a Tera-Wasserburg Concordia diagram. If the range contains several data-points, they must be assumed (at least provisionally) to be equivalent, except for scatter induced by their assigned analytical errors. From the main Isoplot dialog-box, check the ConcAge box (above the Normal/Inverse buttons), select U-Pb Concordia as the Isochron or Plot Type, and specify Normal or Inverse for 206Pb/ 238U-207Pb/ 235U or 238U/206Pb207 Pb/ 206Pb data, respectively. If your data-range contained more than one point, the first popup will be the results of the X-Y weighted-mean calculation. This is the 2-dimensional weighted mean of Figure 4: Concordia Age plot, with decay-constant errors. Dark- and medium-gray areas indicate the concorthe data that is, with their X-Y error correladia band and age-ticks. tions as well as their X- and Y-errors taken into account. The MSWD shown in this box refers to the goodness-of-fit of just the X-Y weighted mean that is, how well the data fit the assumptions that the data points are repeated measurements of the same point, and that these data-points scatter only because of the assigned X-Y errors. This MSWD is the MSWD for X-Y equivalence (likewise the weighted residuals, if requested). To have Isoplot plot the error ellipse of the X-Y weighted mean, check the appropriate Show/Plot At button (1σ - 2σ - 95% conf.).
Concordia Age MSWDs There are three MSWD statistics (and associated probabilities) that are relevant to the Concordia Age calculation: the MSWD for X-Y equivalence, the MSWD for concordance, and the MSWD for combined equivalence and concordance. The Concordia Age is meaningful only if the data are both equivalent and concordant, so Isoplot considers the last MSWD to be the most significant. Note that because there is only a single degree of freedom involved, the MSWD for concordance can be as high as 3.8 before the probability of concordance becomes less than 5%.
February 21, 2000
25
Concordia Age Errors Errors for both the X-Y weighted mean and the Concordia Age are given at 3 levels. The 1σ and 2σ errors are a priori errors that is, calculated by propagating only the assigned data-point errors, without consideration of the actual scatter of the data points from one another or from the Concordia curve. As long as the probability for X-Y equivalence and Concordance are not too low (say >.05), these errors are appropriate. The tσ MSWD errors are the 1σ a priori errors multiplied by the square root of the MSWD (to take into account the actual scatter of the data, which for low probabilities must be the result of geologic error rather than analytical error) and again by a Students-t factor (to take into account the fact that the true σ of the data is estimated from only a few points). The tσ MSWD errors are 95%-confidence errors, provided that the true data-point errors are Gaussian and for some reason are reasonably proportional to the assigned errors. In practical use, however, very high MSWD values must reflect a failure of the assumptions of either data-point equivalence or of concordance, in which case the concordia age has no physical significance. Thus if the probability of data-point equivalence is less than 0.001, no further calculations will be attempted. Similarly, if the probability of concordance is less than 0.001, only the word DISCORDANT will be displayed. Effect of Decay-Constant Errors on Concordia Ages and Errors Ages calculated from 206Pb/ 238U, 207Pb/ 235U, and 207Pb/ 206Pb ratios are independent of errors in the uranium decay-constants, and the effects of these errors on the age errors are usually ignored. However, because the position of the Concordia curve is affected by the decay-constant errors (and so the location of the most-probable concordant age), not only is the age error affected by consideration of decay-constant errors, but also the Concordia Age itself. Equally important, the evaluation of concordance (on which the validity of a Concordia Age depends) should only be made with the decay-constant errors taken into account. Isoplot therefore offers two columns of Concordia Ages and errors one ignoring the decay-constant errors, the other acknowledging them. As one would expect, the uncertainty in the difference between two Concordia Ages is best estimated without decay-constant errors.
February 21, 2000
26
T h re e - di m e n s i o n a l R e g re s s i o n s f o r U - P b C o n c o rdi a Planar Regressions Three-dimensional planar regressions of U-Pb concordia data (pioneered by Levchenkov and Shukolyukov, 1970) can be extremely useful for suites of samples whose 206Pb/ 204Pb ratios are relatively low (say <1000), and whose Pb/U systematics conform to either:
Radiogenic Pb/U Component (properly corrected for common Pb) Type I Defines a linear discordia Common Pb Component Isotopically equivalent for all samples Defines a line on the 206 Pb/204 Pb (i.e. a secondary Pb-Pb isochron)
207
Type II Only one, which is concordant
Pb/204 Pb plane
The crucial advantage of the planar regression is that one need not know the isotopic composition of the common Pb, and in fact a crucial parameter of the common Pb the 207Pb/ 204Pb at a given 206Pb/ 238U is part of the regression solution itself (for detailed discussions, see Levchenkov and Shukolyukov, 1970; Neymark and Levchenkov, 1979; Wendt, 1984; and Zheng, 1989b). Another use of planar regressions is for the case when the isotopic composition of the common Pb can be assumed to be invariant, but whose ratios are only approximately known. In this case, the estimated common-Pb isotope ratios should be included as a data-point for the regression, together with its estimated errors and error correlations. Isoplot offers planar concordia-intercept solutions only for Tera-Wasserburg (= Inverse) concordia data, where the third, Z axis is 204Pb/ 206Pb. The data range for Isoplot must consist of 3 columns (X-Y-Z), 6 columns (X, X-error, Y, Y-error, Z, Z-error), or 9 columns (X, X-error, Y, Y-error, Z, Z-error, ρxy, ρxz , ρyz ). And, of course, both the 3-D and Planar option buttons must be on. In many cases, it is reasonable to approximate the X-Y (= 238U/206Pb - 207Pb/ 206Pb) and X-Z (= 238U/206Pb - 204Pb/ 206Pb) error correlations as zero; however, if the 204Pb/ 206Pb errors are not much greater than the 207Pb/ 206Pb errors (e.g. for relatively low 206Pb/ 204Pb measured on a thermal-ionization mass spectrometer), the Y-Z error correlation can be significantly nonzero and negative. The plot (if specified) will be of simply the X-Y plane of the 3-D concordia in other words, just the usual Tera-Wasserburg concordia plot. If you request plotting of the X-Y projection of the data-points, you must also specify whether the points are to be projected parallel to the 204Pb/ 206Pb axis (that is, down the best-fit plane with no change in the X-values), or through some specified 204Pb/ 206Pb. The latter is useful if you have a pretty good idea of the 204Pb/ 206Pb of the common Pb, and will show you where the points would have plotted if their common Pb had each been correctly subtracted. As for a conventional 2-D discordia regression, the popup-box for the concordia-intercept ages of the planar regression will contain the upper and lower concordia-intercept ages. For 3-D planar discordia, however, two other age results are also given: the Pb-Pb isochron age defined by the intersection of the regression plane with the 204Pb/ 206Pb-207Pb/ 206Pb plane, and the intercepts of this isochron with the Stacey-Kramers single-stage Pb-isotope growth curve (Stacey and Kramers, 1975). The latter two types of ages are relevant only for Type II data (concordant radiogenic Pb/U plus common Pb dispersed along a secondary isochron), in which case only one of the concordia-intercept ages will have a geologic meaning. As usual, the errors given in the popups will be the 2σ a priori errors if the probability of obtaining more than the observed amount of scatter of the points (from the best-fit plane) with the assigned errors is more than 15%. For lower probabilities-of-fit, the age errors will be the 1σ a priori errors expanded by Students-t for N-3 degrees of freedom and the square root of the MSWD. In other words, the age errors for low probabilities-of-fit are calculated by expanding the analytical errors until they predict precisely the actual amount of scatter, then converting these 1σ errors to 95% confidence with the appropriate Students-t.
February 21, 2000
27
Note that If the planar regression fails, it may be because the data actually define a line rather than a plane in XYZ space, so try a 3-dimensional linear regression (Total Pb/U Isochron) before giving up (see below). One interesting advantage of planar 3-D regressions of U-Pb data is that such regressions will correctly propagate the errors arising from a large common-Pb correction. For example, consider the case of a suite of, say, sphene analyses that appear to fall along a (common-Pb corrected) discordia line, where there is a reasonable, but not extremely precise idea of the common-Pbs isotopic composition. If one simply propagates the errors assigned to the common-Pb 206Pb/ 204Pb and 207Pb/ 204Pb into the 206Pb */238U and 207Pb */235U ratios required for a conventional, 2-D concordia diagram, the errors for each data-point will be correct, but all of the data-points will tend to be shifted in the same direction on the concordia diagram. The result will be an artificially low MSWD for the regression (because the errors from point-to-point will be correlated, not just the X-Y errors of each point), and the concordia-intercept errors will be correspondingly elevated (this is assuming a constant common-Pb from sample to sample). The correct way to deal with this situation is to use your estimate of the common-Pbs isotopic composition (whether from growth-curve estimates or a feldspar analysis) and errors, and include these ratios as an additional point on a 3-D planar regression. The MSWD of the regression will then correctly reflect the common-Pb uncertainty, yielding not only a more precise age, but also a more accurate one. Linear 3-D Regressions (the Total Pb/U Isochron) Cogenetic samples with an undisturbed U-Pb system that shares the same common-Pb isotopic composition must define a line in 238U/206Pb - 207Pb/ 206Pb - 204Pb/ 206Pb space, whose intersection with the 238 U/206Pb - 207Pb/ 206Pb plane must fall precisely on the U-Pb concordia curve, and whose intersection with the 204Pb/ 206Pb - plane is the isotopic composition of the common Pb. The 3-D linear regression that constrains the X-Y plane intercept to the concordia curve is called the Total Pb/U Isochron (Ludwig, 1998), and has some unique attributes and advantages, including: 1) the MSWD of the regression tests for both closed-system behavior (=concordance) and the assumption of an invariant common Pb; 2) all of the relevant isotope ratios are used at the same time, yielding the smallest justifiable ageerror of any possible U/Pb or Pb/Pb isochron. The Total Pb/U Isochron is the 3-D equivalent of the Concordia Age, in the same way that a planar solution (p. 26) is the 3-D equivalent of the conventional concordia-intercept age, and the data-range requirements are exactly the same as for a planar 3-D regression. The Total Pb/U isochron should be the first step in evaluating a suite of high-204Pb data. If the regression fails, or if its probability of fit is low, the next step should be a Planar regression, followed as a last resort by the classical 206Pb/ 204Pb - 207Pb/ 204Pb, 238 U/204Pb - 206Pb/ 204Pb, or 235U/204Pb - 207Pb/ 204Pb isochrons.
February 21, 2000
28
The results of the Total Pb/U Isochron are shown in two boxes one for the Concordia-plane intercept, the other for the common-Pb plane intercept. The upper consists simply of the Total Pb/U Isochron age and error. As usual, the error is the 2σ a priori error if the probability-of-fit calculated from the MSWD is more than 15%; if less, the 1σ a priori error is expanded by the square root of the MSWD and Students-t for 2N-3 degrees of freedom. The lower box consists of the results of the intersection of the isochron with the common-Pb plane, including the 206Pb/ 204Pb and 207Pb/ 204Pb ratios and errors, and the single-stage Stacey-Kramers growth-curve age and Mu (Stacey and Kramers, 1975) for those ratios. Note that, like planar regressions compared to 2-D discordia (and for the same reasons), the Total Pb/U Isochron can have a distinct advantage over a Concordia Age if the common-Pb correction required by the latter is significant.
Pb-Pb Isochrons a n d Growth Curves
Isoplot will determine the Pb-Pb isochron age for 207Pb - 206Pb plots, which include both 206Pb/ 204PbPb/ 204Pb (Normal) and 204Pb/ 206Pb - 207Pb/ 206Pb (Inverse) types. In addition to the isochron age and age error10, the age of the intercepts (if any) of the isochron with the Stacey-Kramers growth curve will be given, as well as the 207Pb/ 204Pb of the isochron at the Stacey-Kramers 206Pb/ 204Pb for the isochron age.
207
For plots of both 206Pb/ 204Pb-207Pb/ 204Pb and 208Pb/ 204Pb-207Pb/ 204Pb data, you can request construction of a single-stage Pb-isotope growth-curve by checking the Pb Growth box. The default parameters of the growth curve will be the Stacey-Kramers (1975) values, but you can specify any curve when the growthCurve dialog box (below right) appears.
10
Isoplot will calculate the 207 Pb/206 Pb age-error both with and without decay-constant errors. If there is a significant difference between the with and without age-errors, both errors will be given.
February 21, 2000
29
Figure 5: Pb-Pb isochron with growth curve.
The
230
230
Th/U System
U / 2 3 8U
T h / U I s o c h ro n s w i t h V a ri a b l e
234
A variety of isochrons have been used to obtain 230Th/U ages. For systems with variable 234U/238U, perhaps the most common (Rosholt, 1976) are a coupled pair of isochrons, the first being 230Th/232Th versus 234U/232Th, and the second being 234U/232Th versus 238U/232Th. The slopes of the isochrons are then used to infer the 232Th-free 230Th/234U and 234U/238U, from which a 230Th/U age can be calculated. But this representation is one of the worst possible, because 1) The most desirable samples will have relatively little 232Th, yielding large errors for both X and Y parameters (at least when measured alpha-spectrometrically), and high X-Y error correlations for both isochrons; 2) Any spread in 238U/232Th will disperse the points along the X-axis, yielding a visually rather welldefined trend (and r2 statistic) even in the absence of geochronologically meaningful systematics; 3) Because 232Th and 234U each appear in both of the isochrons, the results of the regressions are necessarily correlated in a complex way but these correlations are never taken into account when calculating the ages or age-errors. The first and second problems are addressed by using 230Th/238U versus 232Th/238U and 234U/238U versus Th/238U isochrons (Osmond et al., 1970, modified by Ludwig and Titterington, 1994), where the intercepts of the isochrons are used to calculate the age; however, the third problem requires a simultaneous solution using all three of the ratios for the modified Osmond ratios, resulting in a regression for an isochron line in three dimensions. Using X = 230Th/238U, Y = 234U/238U, Z = 232Th/238U, the X-Y plane intercepts of this linear 3-D isochron define the ratios used to calculate a 230Th/U age and initial 234U/238U (Ludwig and Titterington, 1994).
232
You can assign any combination of the 232Th/238U - 230Th/238U - 234U/238U to be X, Y, Z for plotting purposes (see below) so any of the three possible X-Y projections of the isochron can be viewed.
February 21, 2000
30
If you specify X = 230Th/238U, Y = 234 U/238U, you can also request that one or more 230Th-234U evolution curves be placed on the plot, with ages indicated either by isochron lines or age-ticks (see right, and resulting plot in Fig. 6). Isochron ageindicators will be labeled by age, parallel to the isochron line and along the top or right, inside or outside (you specify) of the plot-box. The plot below shows the results of the above dialog-box settings, with multiple evolution curves later specified for initial 234U/238U of 3.0, 2.5, 2.0, and 1.5.
February 21, 2000
31
If youve already corrected your 230Th/238U 234 U/238U data for detrital Th and U (or if the correction is negligible), you can specify a range of 2-dimensional data, with X = 230Th/238U, Y = 234 U/238U, and simply plot these data on the resulting 230 Th-234U evolution diagram. If your data range contains only one row of data for a 2D 230 Th/238U - 234U/238U plot, the 230Th/U age and initial 234 U/238U will be calculated and displayed for that datapoint. If the probabilityof-fit of the isochron is greater than 0.05, you will have the option (see below) Figure 6: U-series evolution diagram with optional labeled evolution curves and isochrons. of calculating the 230Th/U age error from either the usual first-derivative expansion (e.g. Ludwig and Titterington, 1994, p. 5033, eqn. 6-8) or by a Monte Carlo simulation. The choice is offered because age errors by usual first-derivative expansion are significantly inaccurate in cases where the age is close to the limit of the technique (say >250 ka for alpha-spectrometric analyses, >350 ka for TIMS) or the isotope-ratio errors are large. You can include the 230Th and U decay-constant errors in the ageerror calculation. To do this correctly, you must know how the activity ratios of 230Th/238U and 234U/238U were calculated: by normalizing the measured ratios (whether alpha-spectrometric activity or mass-spectrometric atomic) to a secular-equilibrium standard, or by multiplying measured atomic ratios by the ratio of the relevant decay constants.
234
As usual, for isochron ages the 1σ internal error is the 1σ error propagated from the assigned data-point errors and error-correlations only (the scatter from the regression line is ignored), so this error is only relevant if the probability of fit value shown is reasonably high, in which case the 95%-confidence errors shown are simply 1.96 times the 1σ internal errors. If the probability of fit is low, the 95%-confidence errors are the 1σ internal errors multiplied by the square root of the MSWD (to take into account the fact that the data points scatter by more than can be expected from the analytical errors alone) and by Students-t for 2N-4 degrees of freedom (to take into account that the true scatter of the points from the isochron line is estimated from a small number of data-points).
February 21, 2000
32
It is important that the data-point error correlations be reasonably accurate. Entering arbitrary errorcorrelations can result in ages and, especially, age-errors that are significantly invalid. This point, and methods for the calculation of the error correlations, are discussed in detail in Ludwig and Titterington (1994).
230
T h / U I s o c h ro n s w i t h S e c u l a r E qu i l i b ri u m
234
U / 2 3 8U
For volcanic rocks and minerals, one can generally assume that the 234U/238U is now, and has always been, in secular equilibrium. The 3D isochron approach is then not required, and one can simply regress either 230Th/238U against 232Th/238U or 230Th/232Th against 238U/232Th to obtain the 232Th-free 230Th/238U from which a 230Th/U age can be calculated. The regression algorithm is the usual X-Y error-weighted algorithm of York (1969), with errors calculated from the maximum-likelihood approach of Titterington and Halliday (1979). As always, unless the regression has a reasonably high probability-of-fit (say >0.05), the 1-sigma a priori errors have no geologic significance. X-Y error correlations for mass-spectrometric input-data of 230Th/238U - 232Th/238U o r 230Th/232Th U/ Th isochrons will generally be negligible (because the 230Th measurement error is typically much larger than for 238U or 232Th). For alpha-spectrometric input-data, however, these error correlations will typically be in the range of +0.2 to +0.4, which will have a noticeable effect on the isochrons MSWD and errors.
238 232
S i n g l e - A n al y s i s
230
Th/ U A g es
If the range passed to Isoplot is a single row containing only 230Th/238U [error] 234U/238U [error] [errcorrel], Isoplot will calculate a single age without correction for detrital Th and U. Generally, though, its probably more convenient to do this directly in the worksheet with the Th230Age or Th230AgeAnd Initial functions (p. 40), using the CorrThU function as necessary (p. 40).
February 21, 2000
33
Weighted Averages o f a Single Variable
To plot and calculate the classical one-parameter, error-weighted average, select a 2-column range (values and errors) and the Weighted Average plot type. The results-popup (below) will show first the errorweighted (actually, inverse-variance weighted) mean and 2σ error propagated from the assigned errors only (=2σ internal error), then the 95% conf. error. The 95% conf. error will be 1.96 times the 1σ internal error if the probability-of-fit is more than 15%, or Students-t times the square root of the MSWD if the probability is less. If the probability of fit is more than 5%, you can choose either the 2σ internal, or 95% conf. error to be shown on the plot. Outlier rejection (via a modified 2-sigma set of criteria) can be enabled or disabled from a checkbox in the Other section of the main Isoplot dialog-box.
Figure 7: Weighted average plot
As an alternative to explicit, error-weighting plus outlier rejection, Isoplot also offers a robust (Tukeys Biweight) mean shown in the results popup (left) is calculated using the algorithm discussed in Hoaglin, Mosteller, and Tukey (1983), which yields a very robust (insensitive to outliers or distributions with heavy tails) estimate of the average for most data sets. Outlier rejection is neither Results popup for weighted averages necessary nor desirable with this approach, and the assigned errors are ignored. The plus-or-minus values calculated for both the median value and the Biweight value are valid only if a dominant component of the data conforms to a normal distribution. That is, you should pay attention to the calculated uncertainties only if the data set can be regarded as from dominantly normal distribution, perhaps contaminated by one or more values that do not belong to the dominant distribution. The algorithm to determine the 95%-confidence limit errors of the Biweight Mean is derived from Monte Carlo simulations, and is strictly valid only for a dominant normal distribution that is only slightly contaminated (by a distribution with a different mean or variance). You can also place the Weighted Average calculation formula and results directly under the selected range of values and errors using Isoplots toolbar-button (see p. 47).
February 21, 2000
34
If an even more robust average is desired, with the fewest possible assumptions about the reason for dispersion from a single value, use the median function and binomial-distribution errors (Rock and others, 1987, p. 167), available from the relevant button in Isoplots toolbar (see p. 47).
A r g o n - A r g o n Step-Heating Plots and Plateau Ages
To create an Argon-Argon stepheating plot (age versus percent 39Ar or 39 Ar gas-fraction), select Ar-Ar StepHeating as the plot type. The data range must comprise 3 columns, the first being either 39Ar gas-fraction or percent gas, the second the calculated Ar-Ar age for that fraction, and the third the error in the Ar-Ar age. As usual, the age error can be 1σ or 2σ, percent or absolute but must not include the propagated uncertainty in J. Isoplot will also try to pick the best statistically-justifiable plateau and plateau-age from the data, using an algorithm that selects the plateau with the largest amount of gas that meets the following criteria:
Figure 8: Argon-Argon step-heating plot.
1) Has three or more contiguous steps comprising more than 60% of the 39Ar (default can be set to anywhere between 30% and 99% by the user from Options/Consts). 2) The probability-of-fit of the weighted-mean age of the steps is greater than 5%; 3) The slope of the error-weighted line through the plateau ages is not different from zero at 5% confidence; 4) The ages of the outermost 2 steps for either side of the plateau must not be significantly different (at 1.8σ) than the weighted-mean plateau age (6 or more steps only); 5) The outermost 2 steps for either side of the plateau must not have nonzero slopes (at 1.8σ) with the same sign (9 or more steps only).
February 21, 2000
35
The first three criteria are simply statistical common sense, while criteria 4 and 5 are arbitrary, and intended to reproduce ones visual sense of a plateau. While conforming to criteria 1 - 3 seem a reasonable minimum requirement, the plateau selection of Isoplot is not intended to be rigorous, but rather a tool for evaluation of the data; it should not be used without contemplation and, in many cases, modification. U s e r- S p e c i f i e d P l a t e a u S t e p s You can override Isoplots concept of the best plateau-steps by putting any other sequence of contiguous steps in a bolded font. Isoplot will calculate the weighted-mean age of your selection, and indicate that the plateau criteria are user-defined. If the probability-of-fit of the weighted mean is less than 5%, Isoplot will expand the a priori 1σ error by tσ MSWD to obtain the 95%-confidence age-error.
Cumulative Probability Plots a n d Histograms
Figure 9: Cumulative probability plot with histogram.
February 21, 2000
36
This plot-type shows the cumulative probability distribution obtained by summing the probability distributions of a suite of data with normally-distributed errors. The input range must comprise 2 columns the values and their errors. You can also have a histogram of the data included in the plot by checking the Include Histogram box. You can then define the bin-width for the histogram either by checking the A uto bins box and specifying the number of bins to use (typically 20-50), or by specifying the bin width and the Bin start, which is interpreted as the lower-limit of any particular bin. In the example at left, specifying the Bin start as any number evenly divisible by 0.2 would give the same plot.
Utility Functions f o r Isotopic D a t a
Many of the numeric routines used by Isoplot are made available to the user as a set of additional spreadsheet functions, which can be used like any other Excel function. For example, to insert the 207 Pb/ 206Pb age of the 207Pb/ 206Pb ratio in cell G3 into cell H3, just enter = AgePb76(G3) into cell H3, where AgePb76 is one of the Isoplot user-defined functions (in this case, user is me, not you). Note that for functions that return errors, where the level of the input errors can be specified as either 1σ or 2σ, the default input errors are always 2σ and the default output errors are always 2σ/95%-conf. A c c e s s i ng Is o pl o t s U s e r F unc t i o ns Press the Function button on the Standard Toolbar (the button containing the f x symbol). Select User Defined from the Function Wizards Function Category. The list at the right will show the Isoplot functions available, with a brief description of each function at the bottom (as the cursor is moved). Select the desired function, click NEXT. A dialog box with more-detailed explanation will appear, in which you can enter the required arguments as either numeric values (e.g. 1.234), calculated values (e.g. 123.4/100) or ranges (e.g. D5). As soon as you have entered the required arguments, the result of the function will appear at the upper-right of the Function Wizard. When you click Finish, your entries will appear on the Formula line of Excel. Once you already know how the function works and the arguments it requires, you can use it like any other Excel function for example, entering =AgePb76(0.123) will calculate the Pb/ Pb age for the ratio 0.123. When a function requires the use of geochemical constants such as decay constants, Isoplot will use the constants defined in the Options/Consts screen. Because you wont be able to remember the syntax of all of Isoplots functions, one of the best ways to invoke a function is to first type in its name in the relevant cell, e.g. =AgeErPb76 then press the f x symbol in either the formula bar or one of the toolbars. If you typed the function name in correctly, Excel will present a dialog box in which you can enter the functions arguments, e.g.
207 206
February 21, 2000
37
Some of the Isoplot functions are array functions, which are a bit tricky to use. The output of an array function occupies a range of cells rather than a single cell, so you need to know in advance how large a range to select before invoking the array function. For example, the worksheet output for the WtdAv function looks like:
25.159 0.029 0.051 1.873 1 0.059 Wtd Mean (using ext. err) 95%-conf. err. of mean Required external 2-sigma MSWD #rejected Probability of fit
with the numeric output in the left column of the 6-row by 2-column range and the explanation (which is part of the function output) in the right. You could select a smaller range for example 6 rows by 1 column in which case the explanation column would not be shown. To enter an array function, select the output range as discussed above, type in the equals sign followed by the function name and arguments (or use the function wizard), then press Ctrl-Shift-Return instead of simply Return. U ra n i u m - L e a d F u n c t i o n s Age7corr (TotPb6U8, TotPb76, Comm76) Returns the 207-corrected age often-used by SHRIMPsters. Variables are the total (that is, uncorrected for common Pb) 238U/206Pb and 207Pb/ 206Pb, and the assumed common 207Pb/ 206Pb. The age returned is calculated by assuming that the true radiogenic 238U/206Pb and 207Pb/ 206Pb ages are precisely concordant. Age8Corr (TotPb6U8, TotPb8Th2, Th2U8, CommPb68)
February 21, 2000
38
Returns the 208-corrected age, also mainly used by SHRIMPkins. Variables are the total (that is, uncorrected for common Pb) 238U/206Pb and 208Pb/ 232Th, and the assumed common 206Pb/ 208Pb. The age returned is calculated by assuming that the true radiogenic 238U/206Pb and 208Pb/ 232Th ages are precisely concordant. AgeEr7Corr (Age, CommPb76err) TotPb6U8, TotPb6U8err, TotPb76, TotPb76err, CommPb76,
Returns the error in the 207-corrected age calculated by Age7corr . Variables are the 207-corrected age, total 238U/206Pb, error, total 207Pb/ 206Pb, error, common-Pb 207Pb/ 206Pb, error. Because the sigmalevel of input errors is unspecified, the output error is at same sigma-level as the input error. AgeEr8Corr (T, TotPb6U8, TotPb6U8err, TotPb8Th2, TotPb8Th2err, Th2U8, Th2U8err, CommPb68, CommPb68err) Returns the error in the 208-corrected age calculated by Age8corr . Variables are the 208-corrected age, total 238U/206Pb, error, total 208Pb/ 232Th, error, common-Pb 208Pb/ 206Pb, error. Because sigma-level of input errors is unspecified, output error is at same sigma-level as input error. AgeErPb76 (Pb76rad, Pb76er, Optional t2, Optional withLambdaErrs, Optional SigmaLevel, Optional PercentErrsIn) Returns the error in the 207Pb/ 206Pb age calculated by AgePb76 (also available via Isoplots toolbar button: see p. 47) Required variables are the radiogenic 207Pb/ 206Pb and error (absolute or percent); optional variables are:
t2 withLambdaErrs SigmaLevel PercentErrsIn
The time at which Pb-isotope evolution ceased, zero if unspecified; TRUE if the 238U and 235U decay-constant errors are to be propagated in the ageerror calculation, FALSE if unspecified; Relevant only if withLambdaErrs=TRUE; 2 if unspecified; must be either 1 or 2; If Pb76er is in percent, must be TRUE.
Output errors are always 2σ (even if input is 1σ), absolute. A g e P b 6 U 8 (Pb6U8) Returns the
206
Pb/ 238U age. Input is the radiogenic
206
Pb/ 238U.
A g e P b 7 6 (Pb76rad, Optional t2) Returns the classical 207Pb/206Pb age (also available via Isoplots toolbar button: see p, 47). Variables are the radiogenic 207Pb/ 206Pb and the time at which the system ceases to evolve (zero if not specified). A g e P b 7 U 5 (Pb7U5) Returns the
207
Pb/ 235U age. Input is the radiogenic
207
Pb/ 235U.
A g e P b 8 T h 2 (Pb208Th232) Returns the
208
Pb/ 232Th age. Input is the radiogenic
208
Pb/ 232Th.
Concordia (Pb7U5, Pb7U5err, Pb6U8, Pb6U8err, ErrCorrel, withLambdaErrs, Optional PercentErrs, Optional SigmaLevel) An array function that returns the Concordia age for the conventional-Concordia ratios, errors, & error-correlation (see Ludwig, 1998). Input values are 206Pb */238U, error, 207Pb */235U, error, error-correlation, withLambdaErrs (TRUE to propagate the 235U and 238U decay-constant errors), and two optional Boolean variables (PercentErrs and SigmaLevel specifying the type of error input (default is absolute, 2σ). Output is a 2-row x 4-col range containing the Concordia Age, 2σ a priori age error, MSWD, and probability-of-concordance. The second row of cells contains captions for the values in the first
February 21, 2000
39
row. Remember that the a priori error propagates only the assigned 206Pb/ 238U and 207Pb/ 206Pb errors, and so is invalid/irrelevant for low probabilities. For Tera-Wasserburg Concordia data, use ConcordiaTW. ConcordiaTW (U8Pb6, U8Pb6 err, Pb76, Pb76 err, ErrCorrel, withLambdaErrs,. Optional PercentErrs, Optional SigmaLevel) Same as the Concordia function, but with Tera-Wasserburg Concordia ratios. ConvertConc (InputRange, TeraWassIn, Optional PercentErrs) An array function that converts Tera-Wasserburg concordia ratios, errors, and error correlations to Conventional concordia ratios, errors, and error correlations or vice-versa. The input ratios can be either 2-dimensional (X=238U/206Pb, Y=207Pb/ 206Pb to/from X=207Pb/ 235U, Y=206Pb/ 238U) or 3-dimensional (X=238U/206Pb, Y= 207Pb/ 206Pb, Z= 204Pb/ 206Pb to/from X= 207Pb/ 235U, Y=206Pb/ 238U, Z=204Pb/ 238U). For converting Tera-Wasserburg ratios to Conventional ratios (TeraWassIn = TRUE), the input range must be structured as: X, X-error, Y, Y-error [, ρxy] X, X-error, Y, Y-error, Z, Z-error X, X-error, Y, Y-error, ρxy, Z, Z-error [, ρxz, ρyz ] for 3-dimensional data, where ρxy is the X-Y error correlation, and the brackets indicate an optional parameter. For converting Conventional ratios to Tera-Wasserburg ratios (TeraWassIn = FALSE), the input-range must be X, X-error, Y, Y-error, ρxy for 2-dimensional data, or as X, X-error, Y, Y-error, ρxy, Z, Z-error, ρxz , ρyz for 3-dimensional data. The output range is always X, X-error, Y, Y-error, ρxy [, Z, Z-error, ρxz , ρyz ] The errors can be input either as absolute (default) or percent (add TRUE as a third parameter). Output errors are the same form as input errors. P b 7 6 (AgeMa) Returns the radiogenic 207Pb/ 206Pb ratio for the specified age, assuming initial secular equilibrium of the radioactive uranium daughters. SingleStagePbMu (Pb206Pb204, Pb207Pb204) Returns the Mu-value defined by the specified 206Pb/ 204Pb and 207Pb/ 204Pb, assuming single-stage Pbisotope evolution using the Stacey and Kramers (1975) parameters. SingleStagePbR (Age, WhichRatio) Returns the 206Pb/ 204Pb, 207Pb/ 204Pb, or 208Pb/ 204Pb ratio ( WhichRatio = 0 , 1 , 2 , respectively) for the specified age, assuming single-stage Pb-isotope evolution using the Stacey and Kramers (1975) parameters. SingleStagePbT (Pb206Pb204, Pb207Pb04) Returns the age defined by the specified 206Pb/ 204Pb and 207Pb/ 204Pb, assuming single-stage Pb-isotope evolution using the Stacey and Kramers (1975) parameters. for 2-dimensional data, or as or as
February 21, 2000
40
U ra n i u m S e ri e s F u n c t i o n s AlphaMS (Ratios, Optional PercentErrs) An array function that converts Osmond-type U-series isochron ratios (X=238U/232Th, Y= 230Th/232Th, Z=234U/232Th) to Rosholt-type ratios (X= 232Th/238U, Y= 230Th/238U, Z=234U/238U). Ratios is a 6- or 9cell range of X, x-error, Y, y-error, Z, Z-error [, ρxy, ρxz , ρyz ]. The error correlations ® are optional, but should always be included when converting from Rosholt to Osmond ratios. Errors are assumed to be in percent, unless the optional PercentErrs parameter is FALSE. Output is a 9-cell range containing the converted X, x-error, Y, y-error, Z, Z-error, ρxy, ρxz , ρyz , with the errors in the same form as the input errors. CorrThU (Detritus, Sample, Optional PercentIn, Optional PercentOut) An array function that corrects measured 230Th-232Th-234U - 238U ratios for a detrital component, using 232 Th as an index isotope. Detritus is a 6- or 9-cell range containing 232Th/238U, err, 230Th/238U, err, 234 U/238U, err (all as activity ratios) and, optionally, the error correlations for 230Th/238U-232Th/238U, 234 U/238U-230Th/238U, and 234U/238U-230Th/238U (assumed to be zero if not specified). Sample is another 6or 9-cell range with the same ratios, but for a measured, detritally-contaminated sample. The two optional Boolean variables specify the form of the input and output errors (default is FALSE for both). Output is a 5-cell row containing the detritus-corrected 230Th/238U, error, 234U/238U, error, error-correlation. I n i t U 2 3 4 U 2 3 8 (AgeKyr, U234U238ar) Returns the initial 234U/238U activity ratio for the specified age (in kiloyears) and present-day activity ratio. T h 2 3 0 2 3 8 a r (AgeKyr, InitialU234U238ar) Returns the 230Th/238U activity ratio for a closed system of AgeKy r kiloyears with an initial activity-ratio of InitialU234U238ar. T h 2 3 0 A g e (Th230U238ar, U234U238ar) Returns the a...