ANNEX TCASILAN vs. TOMASSIG.R. No. L-4294 January 31, 1952.EN BANC, Paras, C.J.FACTS: The plaintiffs, Alipio N. Casilan and Purita Galagnara, filed in the Court the First Instance ofSamar a complaint against defendants, Raymundo Tomassi and Santiago Gangcayco, for the recovery ofthe sum of P3,000 as damages, plus the legal interest. In due time the defendants filed a motion fordismissal on the ground of improper venue, and, acting upon said motion, the Court of First Instance ofSamar issued on August 12, 1950, an order dismissing the case with costs. From this order the presentappeal was taken by the plaintiffs.The complaints alleges that plaintiff Alipio N. Casilan resides in the municipality of Tacloban, Leyteplaintiff Purita Galagnara resides at No. 7l3 Legarda, Sampaloc, Manila; the defendant SantiagoGangayco resides at No. 521 Pennsylvania, Malate, Manila, (oftentimes found in Guiuan, Samar); and thedefendant Raymundo Tomassi resides in Tacloban, Leyte (oftentimes found in Guiuan, Samar).