Competitive Strategy—Week 2
Industry Analysis
Chad Syverson

Distribution of Average Industry Profits
Source: Ghemawat and
Rivkin

Average Annual ROC by Major Sector, 1998-
2018
Sector
ROC (%)
Sector
ROC (%)
Construction
19.1
Information
3.1
Wholesale trade
16.5
Arts, entertainment, and
recreation
2.6
Finance and insurance
12.5
Other services, except
government
2.0
Professional, scientific, and
technical services
9.3
Transportation and warehousing
2.0
Administrative and waste
management services
8.6
Mining
1.5
Retail trade
8.5
Utilities
1.2
Manufacturing
5.9
Educational services
1.1
Health care and social assistance
4.9
Agriculture, forestry, fishing, and
hunting
0.9
Accommodation and food
services
3.5

Top and Bottom Average Annual ROC by
Industry, 1998-2016
Top Industries
ROC (%)
Bottom Industries
ROC (%)
Legal services
32.9
Accommodation services
0.8
Construction
18.1
Farms
0.6
Wholesale trade
16.5
Pipeline transportation
0.4
Petroleum and coal products mfg.
15.5
Air transportation
0.4
Social assistance services
14.1
Motor vehicles and parts mfg.
-0.7
Ambulatory health care services
12.6
Information and data processing
-1.9
Insurance carriers and related
12.2
Securities and investments
-2.9

I. Introduction to Industry Analysis
Accounting profits reflect rents to scarce, valuable assets not
reflected in balance sheet
Industry analysis is about:
What factors affect the scarcity of assets owned by
industry players
What factors affect the value of those assets
If we know this, we can:
Predict accounting profits
Understand key dimensions of industry competition

A Framework for Competitive Strategy
Analysis (I.E., CompStrat in a Nutshell)
Economic
Profitability
Competitive
Advantage
or Disadvantage
Market
Attractiveness
Market Economics
and Opportunities
Firm’s Assets
The market
The firm and
its position
in the market
Explanations for profitability
Measurable indicators
or causes
Entry threats
Competition from rivals
and substitutes
Buyer and supplier
power
Complements
Regulatory pressures
Benefit Position in
Served Market
Cost Position in
Served Market
Firm’s strategy for
creating value
Root
conditions
Firm’s strategic
interactions in market

A Framework for Competitive Strategy
Analysis (I.E., CompStrat in a Nutshell)
Demand for the
Industry’s Good
(Benefit)
Opportunity Cost of
Industry’s
Resources
Quantity Produced by the
Industry
$
PIE

I. Introduction to Industry Analysis
Our analytical framework: the Five Forces

I. Introduction to Industry Analysis
Today we go through the broad outline and hit key points
We will revisit these forces jointly and individually in more
detail later in quarter

Force 1: Entry and Threatened Entry
Classic case 1: Special assets


You've reached the end of your free preview.
Want to read all 36 pages?
- Spring '17
- Economics, Monopoly, Supply And Demand, Average cost