Homework #5 Solutions
Philosophy 12A
November 24, 2008
Page 158 #6
. ‘If Fermat was a French mathematician, then
he was famous.’ Our domain of discourse (
D
), predicates (
R
,
M
,
F
), and individual constant (
i.e.
, the proper name of the
individual person Fermat) (
f
) are:
M
_ : _ is a mathematician
R
_ : _ is French
F
_ : _ is famous
f
: Fermat
D
: people
In “Loglish,” we have ‘If
Rf
and
Mf
, then
Ff
’. In LMPL, this
becomes: ‘
(Rf
Mf)
→
Ff
’.
Page 158 #16
. ‘If no wealthy economist exists then no fa
mous mathematician exists.’ Our domain of discourse (
D
)
and predicates (
W
,
E
,
F
,
M
) are:
W
_ : _ is wealthy
E
_ : _ is an economist
F
_ : _ is famous
M
_ : _ is a mathematician
D
: people
In “Loglish,” we have ‘If there does not exist an
x
such that
both
Wx
and
Ex
, then there does not exist an
x
such that
both
Fx
and
Mx
’. In LMPL, this becomes the following:
‘
∼
(
∃
x)(Wx
Ex)
→ ∼
(
∃
x)(Fx
Mx)
’.
Page 165 #5
. ‘If it rains, only the killjoys will be happy.’
Our domain of discourse (
D
), predicates (
K
,
H
), and atomic
sentence letter (
R
) are as follows:
K
_ : _ is a killjoy
R
: ‘It rains.’
H
_ : _ is happy
D
: people
In “Loglish,” we have ‘If
This is the end of the preview. Sign up
to
access the rest of the document.
This note was uploaded on 09/23/2009 for the course PHIL 12A taught by Professor Fitelson during the Spring '08 term at Berkeley.
 Spring '08
 FITELSON
 Philosophy

Click to edit the document details