POSC Midterm

POSC Midterm - The Logic of the Triad Identify o All types...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–3. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: The Logic of the Triad Identify o All types of societies have people who bicker and cant work it out o Natural for people to turn to a third party o Used a method of solving problems as opposed to self-help Some cases cant be solved by self-help o Parties must consent o Distinguish judges and people of the law as separate parties o Judges not supposed to succumb to bias o The law and the rule of law are essential to upholding the logic of the triad Significance o Better than self-helpallows for neutral 3 rd party to come in o More stable by ruling on precedent o Way to look at the law making and issuing process o Shapiro argues that his relationship is largely unstable: has to be propped up After ruling, goes from a triad to two against one o Sets precedents o Unbiased and consistent Laws and the rule of law apply equally to all members of society o US v Nixon 3 rd party (court) interprets precedent and constitutiontapes relevant to case Self-help Identify o A method of settling disputes without consulting the law o No third party o Present to some degree everywhere o Both sides make concessions in pursuit of resolution o Go-it-alone: Litigant acts unilaterally o The Godfather: Litigant goes to a third party to act unilaterally Steps in to deliver justice o Mutual Accommodation: Litigants work it out without help Significance o Pros Tailored/Particularized Efficient Can engender mutual accommodation Parties in control Free from precedent o Cons No procedural checks against mistakes or arbitrary action Limited access Escalation (Eye for and eye) The Rule of Law Identify o Is the norm or expectation that legal disputes will be resolved according to pre-existing rules and procedures, regardless of the status of individual litigants o Basic characteristics of rules Generality, Equality, Certainty Freedom to decide what rules are necessary and what decisions need to be made Legal liberty Significance o Reinforces logic of the triad o Strengthens judicial system Eliminates bias since it follows precedent o Plays an important role as a neutral party o NY v Sullivan Rule of law is a powerful norm even though the Courts must rely on the power of the pen rather than the sword of the purse to initiate change o US v Nixon President of US not given special treatment o Watergate Nixon couldnt invoke presidential privilege Power of court triumphed, making Nixon resign US v Nixon Identify o Watergate: Democratic campaign headquarters o Began small, evidence against president grew o Deep-throat tapes in President Office o Nixon: presidents absolute privilege o Supreme Court ruled that in a criminal investigation Nixon had no presidential privilege and must handover the tapes Significance o Rule of law not given special treatment o Promise of law: orderly dispute resolution o Triad used discretion...
View Full Document

Page1 / 18

POSC Midterm - The Logic of the Triad Identify o All types...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 3. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online