100%(1)1 out of 1 people found this document helpful
This preview shows page 1 out of 1 page.
CASE: Dillard Dept Stores, Inc v. SilvaCourt: Supreme Court of Texas148 S.W.3d 370 (tex. 2004)Factsa. Plaintiff/DillardsDefendant/Silvab. Silva went to Dillards to exchange three shirts he received as a gift. Before exchanging them he boughtthree other shirts. A store clerk saw him and reported him for possible shoplifting. Silva was put inhandcuffs, detained , and turned over to the Houston police.c. (1) C/A: false imprisonment(2) relief requested:(3) defenses raised:Procedural History:a. Lower court’s ruling(s): in favor of Silva, court of appeals affirmedb. Damages awarded: 13,124.01 mental anguis and court costs, 50,000 for exemplaryc. Appellant: DillardsIssues:a. substantive issue(i) was Silva detained in a reasonable manor?