Walzer,+_What+does+it+Mean+to+be+an+Americany_

Walzer,+_What+does+it+Mean+to+be+an+Americany_ - Michael...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–3. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Michael Walzer What Does It Mean to Be an" Arnerican"? THERE IS NO COUNTRY CALLED AMERICA. WE LIVE IN THE UNITED STATES of America, and we have appropriated the adjective "American" even though we can claim no exclusive title to it. Canadians and Mexicans are also Americans, but they have adjectives more obviously their own, and we have none. Words like "unitarian" and 'unionist" won't do; our sense of ourselves is not captured by the mere fact of our union, however important that is. Nor will "statist" or even "united statist" serve our purposes; a good many of the citizens of the United States are antistat- ist. Other countries, wrote the "American" political theorist Horace Kallen, get their names from the people, or from one of the peoples, who inhabit them. "The United States, on the other hand, has a peculiar anonymity" (Kallen, 1924: 51). It is a name that doesn't even pretend to tell us who lives here. Anybody can live here, and just about every- body does-men and women from all the world's peoples. (The Harvard Encyclopedia of American Ethnic Groups begins with Acadians and Afghans and ends with Zoroastrians.) (Thernstrom, 1980) It is peculiarly easy to become an American. The adjective provides no reliable information about the origins, histories, connections, or cultures of those whom it designates. What does it say, then, about their political allegiance? PATRIOTISM AND PLURALISM American politicians engage periodically in a fierce competition to demonstrate their patriotism. This is an odd competition, surely, for in most countries the patriotism of politicians is not an issue. There are ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED IN SOCIAL RESEARCH VOL 57, NO. 3 (FALL 1990) social research Vol 71: No 3: Fall 2004 633
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
other issues, and this question of political identification and commit- ment rarely comes up; loyalty to the pattie, the fatherland (or moth- erland), is simply assumed. Perhaps it isn't assumed here because the United States isn't apatie. Americans have never spoken oftheir country as a fatherland (or motherland). The kind of natural or organic loyalty that we (rightly or wrongly) recognize in families doesn't seem to be a feature of our politics. When American politicians invoke the meta- phor of family they are usually making an argument about our mutual responsibilities and welfarist obligations, and among Americans, that is a controversial argument.' One can be an American patriot without believing in the mutual responsibilities of American citizens-indeed, for some Americans disbelief is a measure of one's patriotism. Similarly, the United States isn't a "homeland" (where a national family might dwell), not, at least, as other countries are, in casual conversation and unreflective feeling. It is a country of immigrants who, however grateful they are for this new place, still remember the old places. And their children know, if only intermittently, that they have roots elsewhere. They, no doubt, are native grown, but some awkward sense of newness here, or of distant oldness, keeps the tongue from
Background image of page 2
Image of page 3
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

This note was uploaded on 12/21/2009 for the course HUMANITIES 128 taught by Professor Barron during the Spring '09 term at Harvey Mudd College.

Page1 / 23

Walzer,+_What+does+it+Mean+to+be+an+Americany_ - Michael...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 3. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online