Evaluating_Arguments - For each argument#1 and#2 describe whether it is weak or strong In your own words why is the argument weak or strong 1 25 of

# Evaluating_Arguments - For each argument#1 and#2 describe...

This preview shows page 1 - 2 out of 2 pages.

For each argument (#1 and #2), describe whether it is weak or strong . In your own words, why is the argument weak, or strong? 1) 25% of heavy drug users die. 2) Bob is a heavy drug user . ------------------------------------------------------------ 3) Thus, Bob will probably die. Argument 1 is weak because there is little evidence to support the conclusion. 25% is a low score to prove that the conclusion is true. ARGUMENT #2: 1) 75% of heavy drug users die. 2) Bob is a heavy drug user. ------------------------------------------------------------ 3) Thus, Bob will probably die. Argument 2 is strong because the premises provides plenty of evidence to support the conclusion. 75% of data is large enough to show cause for the conclusion. For each argument above (#3 and #4), determine whether it is cogent or not cogent . In your own words, why is the argument cogent or not cogent? ARGUMENT #3: 1) 25% of heavy drug users die. (Suppose this premise is in fact true).