asgn1_sol

# asgn1_sol - CSC 5350 Assignment 1 1. (a). (b). (a1, a2, a3)...

This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: CSC 5350 Assignment 1 1. (a). (b). (a1, a2, a3) (c) i. (a1, a2, a3) ii. Assume that an outcome ω which maximizes the total utilities of all players is not Pareto optimal. Then, there must be another outcome ω ′ , such that at least one player i gets a higher payoff in ω ′ than in ω , while no player gets a lower payoff. Then we have ∑i∈N ui (ω ) < ∑i∈N ui (ω′) which contradict the fact that ω maximizes the total utilities. Consequently, ω is Pareto optimal. 2. (a) N = {Tom, Mary}, A1 = {2, 1, 0}, where 2 means that Tom put 2 dollars in the box. A2 = {accept, reject} The payoff matrix accept reject Tom Mary 2 0,2 0,0 1 1,1 0,0 0 2,0 0,0 (b) The pure strategy Nash equilibriums are (0, reject) and (0, accept). Justification: UT is the utility of Tom, UM is the utility of Mary Since UT(0, accept)> UT(1, accept)> UT(2, accept) UM(0, accept)= UM(0, reject) So (0, accept) is the Nash equilibrium. Since UT(0, reject)= UT(1, reject)= UT(2, reject) UM(0, accept)= UM(0, reject) So (0, reject) is the Nash equilibrium. (c) The completely mixed strategy Nash equilibria is (e(0), (p, 1‐p)) where 0<p<1. Justification: Let (a*, b*) be the mixed strategy Nash equilibrium UT(e(0),b*)=UT(e(1),b*)=UT(e(2),b*) 2b*(accept) +0b*(reject) =1b*(accept) +0b*(reject) =0b*(accept) +0b*(reject) b*(accept) +b*(reject) =1 Then b*(accept)=0 b*(reject)=1 Since UM(a*, e(accept))=UM(a*,e(reject)) 0a*(0) +1a*(1) +2a*(2) = 0a*(0) + 0a*(1) + 0a*(2) a*(0)+ a*(1)+ a*(2)=1 Then a*(0)=1 a*(1)=0 a*(2)=0 Though the result is ((1, 0, 0), (0, 1)), it conflict with the concept of completely mixed strategy, which the probability for each action should be between 0 and 1, and not equal to 0 or 1. However, if Tom chooses the mixed strategy (1, 0, 0), no matter what Mary plays, Mary’s utility is 0. Consider Mary’s strategy as (p, 1‐p) where 0<p<1, since Tom can always get the maximum utility by using the strategy (1, 0, 0), so the completely mixed strategy Nash equilibria is (e(0), (p, 1‐p)) where 0<p<1. (d) Tom should put \$0 in the box. As discussed in (c), no matter what Mary plays, Tom can always gets the maximum utility if he put \$0 in the box. 3. (a). N= {1, 2} A1 = { n1 | x ≤ n1 ≤ y and n1 is an integer}, A2 = { n2 | x ≤ n2 ≤ y and n2 is an integer} ⎧n1 + x, ⎪ u1 = ⎨n1 , ⎪n − x , ⎩2 ⎧ n2 + x , ⎪ u 2 = ⎨ n2 , ⎪n − x, ⎩1 n1 < n2 n1 = n2 n1 > n2 n1 > n2 n1 = n2 n1 < n2 (b) The pure strategy Nash equilibrium is (x, x) Justification: If traveler 1 chooses x, traveler 2 will not change his option from x otherwise his payoff will be 0. If traveler 2 chooses x, traveler 1 will also not change his option otherwise his payoff will be 0. So (x, x) is a Nash equilibrium. In addition, if x<=1, the Nash equilibrium is (n, n), x<=n<=y, and n is an integer because any traveler cannot get better payoff through decreasing or increasing the value he write down since u1(n, n)=n >= u1(n‐1, n)= n‐1+x >= u1(n+1, n)=n‐x u2(n, n)=n >= u2(n, n‐1)= n‐1+x >= u2(n, n+1)=n‐x 4. Model the game as follows: a b If w > y then (a, a) is a strict equilibrium, so that it is an ESS. If z > x then (b, b) is a strict equilibrium, so that it is an ESS. If w < y and z < x then this game has a mixed strategy Nash equilibrium (m*, m*), m*(a)=p and m*(b) = 1‐p, where 0<p<1. Since U(e(a), m*)=U(e(b), m*) pw + (1‐p)x = py + (1‐p)z then p= (x‐z)/(x ‐ z + y ‐ w) 1‐p = (y‐w)/(x – z + y – w) We consider another mixed strategy m(a)=q, m(b)=1‐q. U(m*, m) ‐ U(m, m) a w, w y, x b x, y z, z = pqw + p(1‐q)x + (1‐ p)qy + (1‐p)(1‐q)z ‐qqw ‐ q(1‐q)x ‐ q(1‐q)y ‐ (1‐q)(1‐q)z = (p‐q)(qw + x – qx – qy – z + qz) = (p – q)2(x – z + y ‐ w) >0 (since w < y and z < x) Then (m*, m*) is an ESS In conclusion, there is a mixed strategy that is an evolutionarily stable strategy. ...
View Full Document

## This note was uploaded on 04/23/2010 for the course CSC CSC5350 taught by Professor Leunghofung during the Winter '09 term at CUHK.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online