147 HW3 Solutions
17.6) Let
A
,
B
and
A
α
denote subsets of a space
X
. Prove the following:
(a) If
A
⊂
B
, then
A
⊂
B
.
Solution: Let
C
be some closed subset of
X
. If
B
⊂
C
then
A
⊂
C
so by the deﬁnition of
U
as the
intersection of all closed subsets of
X
containing
U
, we have that
A
⊂
B
.
(b)
A
∪
B
=
A
∪
B
.
Solution:
A
∪
B
⊂
C
if and only if
A
⊂
C
and
B
⊂
C
. Using part (a) we have
A
⊂
A
∪
B
⊃
B
,
and thus
A
∪
B
⊃
A
∪
B
. But
A
∪
B
⊂
A
∪
B
, and the latter set is closed (ﬁnite unions
of closed sets are closed), so
A
∪
B
⊂
A
∪
B
by the deﬁnition of
A
∪
B
.
(c)
S
A
α
⊃
S
A
α
; give an example of where equality fails.
Solution: If
S
A
α
⊂
C
, then for any
α
,
A
α
⊂
C
. Thus
S
A
α
⊃
A
α
for every
α
, giving us that
S
A
α
⊃
S
A
α
. Note: only
ﬁnite
unions of closed sets are guaranteed to be closed.
For an example of equality failing, consider
A
n
= (
1
n
,
1)
⊂
R
.
S
n
∈
Z
+
A
n
=
(0
,
1) = [0
,
1],
but
S
n
∈
Z
+
A
n
=
S
n
∈
Z
+
[
1
n
,
1] = (0
,
1].
17.8) Let
A
,
B
and
A
α
denote subsets of a space
X
. Determine whether the following equations
hold; if an equality fails, determine whether one of the inclusions
This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.
View Full Document
This is the end of the preview. Sign up
to
access the rest of the document.
 Spring '10
 derekwise
 Topology, Closed set, limit point, Hausdorff, disjoint neighborhoods

Click to edit the document details