Cetacean Communication [Compatibility Mode]

Cetacean Communication [Compatibility Mode] - 4/26/2010...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–3. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
4/26/2010 1 Cetacean Communication and Social Behavior How can we tell if an animal is intelligent? What constitutes intelligence depends on what the situation demands. Menzel 1986 "Quite possibly we can never know with dead certainty whether or not any given animal is 'really' intelligent, let alone precisely how intelligent it is or to what degree it actually comprehends what it is doing or saying, as opposed to simply fooling us into thinking as much.” Lewontin 1983 "Darwin revolutionized our study of nature by taking the actual variation among actual things as central to the reality, not as an annoying disturbance to be wished away. That revolution is not yet completed Biology remains in many is not yet completed. Biology remains in many ways obdurately Platonic. ... [For example,] Neurobiologists want to know how the brain works, but they don't say whose brain. Presumably when you've seen one brain you have seen them all.” In fact, brain function and intelligence are manifested in many ways within and among animal species An airtight definition of intelligence is elusive- -we get involved in Platonic essentialism. In science, debates about terminology and the definitions of concepts are to be avoided, and insofar as possible one's attention should always be focused instead on natural phenomena and what they signify (Popper 1972). In practice the study of animal intelligence has been approached in at least five different ways: Ecologically, philosophically, psychometrically, anthropocentrically, and technologically (Menzel 1986). – Ecologically speaking, the central question is how particular species (or societies, or individuals) go about making their living in the world at large. – What sorts of problems do they face, what strategies do they use to solve these problems, and how do they cope with novelty and change? Because of the uniqueness of human linguistic communication it is tempting to make a spurious distinction between communication and social behavior in communication and social behavior in general. – It is generally agreed that communication is a matter of social behavior, but it is also clear that there can be no social behavior without communication.
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
4/26/2010 2 – The elaborate development of linguistic communication in man has resulted in non- linguistic forms of human communication being largely overlooked , until rather recently. – If the importance of nonverbal communication by humans and the similarities between man and apes (and other mammals in general) were better understood - there would be no need to distinguish communication and social behavior. Lilly (1967 p.99) .
Background image of page 2
Image of page 3
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Page1 / 4

Cetacean Communication [Compatibility Mode] - 4/26/2010...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 3. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online