Chapter2Slides - Chapter 2 Chapter Constitutional Law U.S....

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: Chapter 2 Chapter Constitutional Law U.S. Constitution U.S. • • • • Over 200 years old General in nature Federalism Enumerated powers – In Tenth Amendment • Separation of powers • Checks and balances General Approach to constitutional cases constitutional • Is it the government who is engaging in Is the conduct? the • If so, does the conduct’s If accomplishment justify the infringement? infringement? • A balancing of the conduct’s goals and balancing the infringement the Commerce Clause Commerce • Federal government regulates Federal commerce only if it crosses state lines commerce • Situation in 1787? • Situation in 2009? • Same rule, different result • Feds can regulate most commerce Feds Commerce Today Commerce • Feds can regulate any commerce Feds affecting interstate commerce affecting • States can pass laws that don’t: – Conflict with federal laws – Put a burden on interstate commerce Commerce Clause Cases Commerce • 1824 Gibbons v. Ogden: Fed can regulate if 1824 Gibbons Fed “Substantially affects” Interstate commerce “Substantially • 1942Filburn: Home wheat consumption? • Iowa truck length case • Laws favoring local business • New York auto defroster requirement • California auto emissions standards • Interstate online wine sales-2005 Freedom of Speech Freedom • Political—fully protected (includes Political—fully corporations) corporations) • Commercial—limited protection – Commercial = advertising – Regulated, but not prohibited – No cigarette ads on TV: OK? – Lawyer advertising bans? • Obscene v. Offensive speech Due Process Due • Procedural-Deals with right to a trial; hearing Procedural-Deals before property is taken, etc. before • Substantive: Law must be clear enough for a Substantive: reasonable person to determine its meaning reasonable – Some vagueness is OK – Examples • • • Vagrancy statutes Montana Speed Limit Illinois town anti-gang law Equal Protection Clause Equal • Government must treat similarly situated Government persons similarly….. persons …..unless there are legitimate grounds ..unless not to. not • Law or action’s purpose is balanced Law against the distinction against Equal protection clause Equal • 3 Levels of scrutiny – Strict: Race distinctions – Intermediate: Age or gender – Rational Basis: all other distintions • Level of scrutiny: How hard is it to Level justify the law’s distinction? justify Race distinctions Race • Strict scrutiny applied • Only rarely is a race distinction in the Only law ok law • Affirmative action programs sometimes Affirmative ok ok Age distinctions Age • • • Intermediate Scrutiny Easier to justify Age – Drinking age – Social security – Age discrimination act – Draft eligibility Gender distinctions (and legitimacy) legitimacy) • • • Intermediate Scrutiny Easier to justify Gender – Mandated Insurance Rates – Mandated Health Insurance Benefits – Draft Registration All other distinctions All • • • Rational Basis Very easy to justify Examples – Out of state tuition – Liquor store closings – Car dealership closings – Other industry-specific laws Privacy Rights Privacy • Only recently recognized in Constitution • Statutory rights to privacy re the Statutory government government • Invasion of privacy by individuals? ...
View Full Document

This note was uploaded on 12/06/2010 for the course BCOR 3000 at Colorado.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online