{[ promptMessage ]}

Bookmark it

{[ promptMessage ]}

DDI09-BQ-Healthcare-Neg

DDI09-BQ-Healthcare-Neg - Healthcare Neg BQ Lab Dartmouth...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–4. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Healthcare Neg Dartmouth 2k9 BQ Lab Marissa Wizig and Will Marcal Single Payer System Case Neg Single Payer System Case Neg ............................................................................................................................... 1 Strategy ................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Vagueness ................................................................................................................................................................ 4 T-Increase Not Create .............................................................................................................................................. 5 T-Persons Living in Poverty ................................................................................................................................... 6 Extra Topicality-2NC ............................................................................................................................................. 7 T Cards .................................................................................................................................................................... 8 T Cards .................................................................................................................................................................... 9 LO States Advantage (1/2) .................................................................................................................................... 10 LO States Advantage (2/2) .................................................................................................................................... 11 LO States Advantage- State Budget Crisis ........................................................................................................... 12 LO States Advantage- US/China .......................................................................................................................... 13 LO Competitiveness Advantage (1/2) ................................................................................................................... 14 LO Competitiveness Advantage- Job Loss Alt Causes ........................................................................................ 15 LO Federal Deficits Advantage (1/2) .................................................................................................................... 16 LO Federal Deficits Advantage (2/2) .................................................................................................................... 17 LO Hegemony Impacts Frontline .......................................................................................................................... 18 LO Hegemony Impacts Frontline (2/2) ................................................................................................................. 19 Heg Decline Now ................................................................................................................................................. 20 Hegemony Unsustainable ..................................................................................................................................... 21 Hegemony Unsustainable ..................................................................................................................................... 22 LO Solvency Frontline .......................................................................................................................................... 23 No Spillover 1NC ................................................................................................................................................. 25 CO California Advantage (1/2) ............................................................................................................................. 26 CO California Advantage (2/2) ............................................................................................................................. 27 CO Swine Flu Advantage ...................................................................................................................................... 28 CO Swine Flu- Spending Link .............................................................................................................................. 29 CO Swine Flu- Solvency ....................................................................................................................................... 30 CO Swine Flu- No Impact ..................................................................................................................................... 31 SPS Bad- Patient Waitlists .................................................................................................................................... 32 SPS Bad- Access .................................................................................................................................................... 33 SPS Bad- Quality of Care ..................................................................................................................................... 34 SPS Bad- Administrative costs ............................................................................................................................. 35 SPS Bad- Cost ....................................................................................................................................................... 36 SPS Bad- Cost ....................................................................................................................................................... 37 SPS Bad- Cost ....................................................................................................................................................... 38 SPS Bad- Medicaid Costs ...................................................................................................................................... 39 Free Market Solves ............................................................................................................................................... 40 AT: Health Care is a Right .................................................................................................................................... 41 AT: European Models ........................................................................................................................................... 42 AT: Thousands of People Die without insurance .................................................................................................. 43 Innovation Turn (1/2) ............................................................................................................................................ 44 Innovation Turn (2/2) ............................................................................................................................................ 45 Innovation Cancer Turn (1/2) ................................................................................................................................ 46 Innovation Cancer Turn (2/2) ................................................................................................................................ 47 the new SPS… 1
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Healthcare Neg Dartmouth 2k9 BQ Lab Marissa Wizig and Will Marcal Innovation Links ................................................................................................................................................... 48 Coercion Turn ....................................................................................................................................................... 49 Coercion Extensions ............................................................................................................................................. 50 Private Sector Turn ............................................................................................................................................... 51 Private Sector Turn- Obama Plan .......................................................................................................................... 52 Private Sector Turn -States .................................................................................................................................... 53 Multi Payer CP 1NC .............................................................................................................................................. 54 CP Solves the Advantages ..................................................................................................................................... 55 CP Solvency- Cost ................................................................................................................................................ 56 CP Solvency- Affordability ................................................................................................................................... 57 CP Solvency- Innovation ....................................................................................................................................... 58 CP Solvency- Innovation and Access .................................................................................................................... 59 CP Solvency- Access ............................................................................................................................................. 60 CP Solvency- Starting Point .................................................................................................................................. 61 CP Solvency- Single Payer not Key ..................................................................................................................... 62 CP Solvency- Adminstirative Costs ...................................................................................................................... 63 CP Solvency- Medicaid ......................................................................................................................................... 64 CP Solvency- Doctors ............................................................................................................................................ 65 CP Popular ............................................................................................................................................................ 66 Vouchers solve- administration ............................................................................................................................. 67 Vouchers solve- Funding and Access .................................................................................................................... 68 Vouchers Solve ..................................................................................................................................................... 69 Coercion K Links .................................................................................................................................................. 70 Coercion K Links .................................................................................................................................................. 71 Biopolitics Link .................................................................................................................................................... 72 Politics Links- Political Capital ............................................................................................................................ 73 Politics Links- Plan Unpopular ............................................................................................................................. 74 Politics Links- Plan Unpopular ............................................................................................................................ 75 Politics Links- Plan Unpopular- Congres .............................................................................................................. 76 the new SPS… 2
Background image of page 2
Healthcare Neg Dartmouth 2k9 BQ Lab Marissa Wizig and Will Marcal Strategy TOPICALITY- PERSONS LIVING IN POVERTY is a round winner in this debate. The plan implements a single payer system for all uninsured persons, and our evidence proves that this includes people who aren’t living in poverty. This needs to be in the 1NC. The big argument here is the extra topicality, so you should read the 1NC for the T arg and then read the Extra T 2NC in the block. T-INCREASE NOT CREATE is more of a time skew, but it does apply to the aff so if you can articulate a clear abuse story then you could go for this too.
Background image of page 3

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Image of page 4
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

{[ snackBarMessage ]}