Morality and Law 4

Morality and Law 4 - Hart denies that there is a necessary...

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ch 8 Thursday, February 03, 2011 12:06 PM Main ideas Hart begins his response to natural law theory Distinction: specific concept of justice vs general sphere of morality Explains intuitive connection between justice and law Distinction: moral rules vs other social rules Harts target natural law theory There is a necessary connection btwn law and morality There are principle of morality discoverable by human reason These principle are objective, universal and may or may not have a divine origin Human laws that conflict with these principles are not valid Nazi law is not law Pros and cons of NLT? Pro: intuitive connection btw law and justice (fairness and equality) Con: disagreements about what morality is Con: there are times when we don’t want law enforcing morality (avoid moralistic laws) Con: sometimes practicality requires deviating from strict morality (common good) Con: law ofern benefits only one class (ie progressive tax) Given the NLT is harts punching bag, then, can we reconstruct what hart is doin in this chapter
Background image of page 1
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: Hart denies that there is a necessary connection btwn law and 'natural' morality or justice Determining what the law is has nothing to do with whether it is good/bad, just/unjust For hart validity is determined by secondary rules Its purely a procedural/formal matter Nazi laws are valid But the principle "treat like cases alike" means nothing until we know what the relevant featres are Complex structure of justice 2parts (160) Constant: 'treat like cases alike' Varying: determine when cases are alike Concept 'justice' is analogous to the concep 'tall' A tall child could b ethe same height as a short man So 'justice' is open-textured in the same way that. . Distinguishing moral rulse from other social rules Importnace Immunity form deliberate change Volunatry character of moral offenses Form of social pressure...
View Full Document

This note was uploaded on 05/23/2011 for the course PHIL 280 taught by Professor Hubbs during the Spring '08 term at UNC.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online