Issue 9 - Anne Platt McGinn - Yes - Donald R. Robert - NO

Issue 9 - Anne Platt McGinn - Yes - Donald R. Robert - NO -...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–2. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Close ISSUE 8 Should DDT Be Banned Worldwide? YES: Anne Platt McGinn, a senior researcher at the Worldwatch Institute, argues that although DDT is still used to fight malaria, there are other, more effective and less environmentally harmful methods. She maintains that DDT should be banned or reserved for emergency use. World Watch (May/June 2002) NO: Roger Bate, director of Africa Fighting Malaria, asserts that DDT is the cheapest and most effective way to combat malaria and that it should remain available for use. National Review (May 14, 2001) ISSUE SUMMARY DDT is a crucial element in the story of environmentalism. The chemical was first synthesized in 1874. Swiss entomologist Paul Mueller was the first to notice that DDT has insecticidal properties, which, it was quickly realized, implied that the chemical could save human lives. It had long been known that more soldiers died during wars because of disease than because of enemy fire. During World War I, for example, some 5 million lives were lost to typhus, a disease carried by body lice. DDT was first deployed during World War II to halt a typhus epidemic in Naples, Italy. It was a dramatic success, and DDT was soon used routinely as a dust for soldiers and civilians. During and after the war, DDT was also deployed successfully against the mosquitoes that carry malaria and other diseases. In the United States cases of malaria fell from 120,000 in 1934 to 72 in 1960, and cases of yellow fever dropped from 100,000 in 1878 to none. In 1948 Mueller received the Nobel Prize for medicine and physiology because DDT had saved so many civilian lives. DDT was by no means the first pesticide. But its predecessors-arsenic, strychnine, cyanide, copper sulfate, and nicotine-were all markedly toxic to humans. DDT was not only more effective as an insecticide, it was also less hazardous to users. It is therefore not surprising that DDT was seen as a beneficial substance. It was soon applied routinely to agricultural crops and used to control mosquito populations in American suburbs. However, insects quickly became resistant to the insecticide. (In any population of insects, some will be more resistant than others; when the insecticide kills the more vulnerable members of the population, the resistant ones are left to breed and multiply. This is an example of natural selection.) In Silent Spring (Houghton Mifflin, 1962), marine scientist Rachel Carson demonstrated that DDT was concentrated in the food chain and affected the reproduction of predators such as hawks and eagles. In 1972 the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency banned almost all uses of DDT (it could still be used to protect public health). Other developed countries soon banned it as well, but developing nations, especially those in the tropics, saw it as an essential tool for fighting diseases such as malaria. It soon became apparent that DDT is by no means the only pesticide or organic toxin with environmental
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
Image of page 2
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

This note was uploaded on 08/31/2011 for the course STS 302 taught by Professor Nkriesbert during the Summer '08 term at N.C. State.

Page1 / 11

Issue 9 - Anne Platt McGinn - Yes - Donald R. Robert - NO -...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 2. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online