hws07 - Economics 241B Answers to Exercise 7 1. (Final...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–4. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Economics 241B Answers to Exercise 7 1. (Final Examination, Economics 241B, Winter 2004) a. 1 follows from mulitiplying both sides of the regression by X t : X t Y t = 2 t + X t U t : if E ( X t U t ) = 0 (because we have sample analogs for E ( X t Y t ) and E ( X 2 t ) . With measurement error, the resultant equation is X t Y t = 2 t + X t ( U t t ) : Because E ( X t V t ) 6 = 0 , = E ( X t Y t ) E ( X 2 t ) E ( X t V t ) . Because there is no sample analog for E ( X t V t ) , b. For Z t to be a valid instrument, it must be the case that n 1 n X t =1 Z t Y t P ! ZX ; where Q ZX = lim n !1 n 1 P n t =1 Z t X t . To check n 1 n X t =1 Z t Y t = n 1 n X t =1 Z t ( t + U t t ) : Because Z t is a function of X t and X t is independent of U t : n 1 n X t =1 Z t U t P ! 0 : Next n 1 n X t =1 Z t V t = n 1 n X t =1 V t 1 ( X t ± med ( X )) n 1 n X t =1 V t 1 ( X t < med ( X )) ; which converges in probability to E ( V j X ± m ) P ( X ± m ) E ( V j X < m ) P ( X < m ) ;
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
where m is the population median of X . Clearly P ( X m ) = P ( X < m ) = 1 2 . Thus Z is a valid instrument if E ( V j X m ) = E ( V j X < m ) : Such a result would hold if V and X were independent, but they are clearly dependent. Because V and X are dependent, the two conditional expecta- tions are not generally equal, and Z is not a valid instrument. In fact, if X is also symmetrically distributed around its mean (then mean=median) and E ( V j X m ) = ± E ( V j X < m ) , so that n 1 P n t =1 Z t V t P ! E ( V j X m ) 6 = 0 . c. The assumption that V t is symmetrically distributed yields additional mo- ment information. To exploit this, we set up the moment conditions. Because The second moments yield EX 2 t = E ( X ± t ) 2 + 2 V EY 2 t = ± 2 E ( X ± t ) 2 + 2 U E ( X t Y t ) = ±E ( X ± t ) 2 ; which is a system of 3 equations in 4 unknowns. For this system ± To estimate the parameters, we need further moment conditions. Because the distributions of U t and V t are symmetric, the third moments are zero, which yields EX 3 t = E ( X ± t ) 3 EY 3 t = ± 3 E ( X ± t ) 3 : We now have a system of 5 equations in 5 unknowns, so ± via the method of moments. In particular B MM = n t =1 Y 3 t P n t =1 X 3 t ± 1 3 : 2. (Fall 1990 Final Examination) a) To correct for heteroskedasticity we transform the model to obtain an error that is homoskedastic. In the case at hand, we know V ( U t ) = 2 Z 2 t with Z t known, V ² U t Z t ³ = 2 , and so U t Z t is a homoskedastic error. The transformation is Y t Z t = ² + ± X t Z t + U t Z t :
Background image of page 2
Why the presence of an intercept? Because P n t =1 U t = 0 does not imply P n t =1 U t
Background image of page 3

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
Image of page 4
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

This note was uploaded on 09/04/2011 for the course ECON 140a taught by Professor Staff during the Fall '08 term at UCSB.

Page1 / 9

hws07 - Economics 241B Answers to Exercise 7 1. (Final...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 4. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online