# hws07 - Economics 241B Answers to Exercise 7 1. (Final...

This preview shows pages 1–4. Sign up to view the full content.

Economics 241B Answers to Exercise 7 1. (Final Examination, Economics 241B, Winter 2004) a. 1 follows from mulitiplying both sides of the regression by X t : X t Y t = 2 t + X t U t : if E ( X t U t ) = 0 (because we have sample analogs for E ( X t Y t ) and E ( X 2 t ) . With measurement error, the resultant equation is X t Y t = 2 t + X t ( U t t ) : Because E ( X t V t ) 6 = 0 , = E ( X t Y t ) E ( X 2 t ) E ( X t V t ) . Because there is no sample analog for E ( X t V t ) , b. For Z t to be a valid instrument, it must be the case that n 1 n X t =1 Z t Y t P ! ZX ; where Q ZX = lim n !1 n 1 P n t =1 Z t X t . To check n 1 n X t =1 Z t Y t = n 1 n X t =1 Z t ( t + U t t ) : Because Z t is a function of X t and X t is independent of U t : n 1 n X t =1 Z t U t P ! 0 : Next n 1 n X t =1 Z t V t = n 1 n X t =1 V t 1 ( X t ± med ( X )) n 1 n X t =1 V t 1 ( X t < med ( X )) ; which converges in probability to E ( V j X ± m ) P ( X ± m ) E ( V j X < m ) P ( X < m ) ;

This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document
where m is the population median of X . Clearly P ( X m ) = P ( X < m ) = 1 2 . Thus Z is a valid instrument if E ( V j X m ) = E ( V j X < m ) : Such a result would hold if V and X were independent, but they are clearly dependent. Because V and X are dependent, the two conditional expecta- tions are not generally equal, and Z is not a valid instrument. In fact, if X is also symmetrically distributed around its mean (then mean=median) and E ( V j X m ) = ± E ( V j X < m ) , so that n 1 P n t =1 Z t V t P ! E ( V j X m ) 6 = 0 . c. The assumption that V t is symmetrically distributed yields additional mo- ment information. To exploit this, we set up the moment conditions. Because The second moments yield EX 2 t = E ( X ± t ) 2 + 2 V EY 2 t = ± 2 E ( X ± t ) 2 + 2 U E ( X t Y t ) = ±E ( X ± t ) 2 ; which is a system of 3 equations in 4 unknowns. For this system ± To estimate the parameters, we need further moment conditions. Because the distributions of U t and V t are symmetric, the third moments are zero, which yields EX 3 t = E ( X ± t ) 3 EY 3 t = ± 3 E ( X ± t ) 3 : We now have a system of 5 equations in 5 unknowns, so ± via the method of moments. In particular B MM = n t =1 Y 3 t P n t =1 X 3 t ± 1 3 : 2. (Fall 1990 Final Examination) a) To correct for heteroskedasticity we transform the model to obtain an error that is homoskedastic. In the case at hand, we know V ( U t ) = 2 Z 2 t with Z t known, V ² U t Z t ³ = 2 , and so U t Z t is a homoskedastic error. The transformation is Y t Z t = ² + ± X t Z t + U t Z t :
Why the presence of an intercept? Because P n t =1 U t = 0 does not imply P n t =1 U t

This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

## This note was uploaded on 09/04/2011 for the course ECON 140a taught by Professor Staff during the Fall '08 term at UCSB.

### Page1 / 9

hws07 - Economics 241B Answers to Exercise 7 1. (Final...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 4. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document
Ask a homework question - tutors are online