Unformatted text preview: Use only flow paper for rebuttal, not brief Methods of Refutation 1. Minimization : To Deny significance of an argument that your opponent may be winning 2. Maximization : To emphasize the importance of an argument that you may be winning 3. Turning the tables : Using an argument that the opponent made to your advantage 4. Assessing Probabilities : Comparing the likelihood of the ills to the likelihood of the disadvantage and claim one to be greater than the other --- If affirmative, the ills outweigh the disadvantage--- If negative, the disadvantage outweighs the ills--- Minimization and Maximization should always be used together...
View Full Document
- Winter '11
- Logic, Argument map, witness, step refutation model