This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.
Unformatted text preview: way is the adherence to one's own "opinion." The clash of opinions is in its
noblest aspect the basis of knowledge; the correction of opinion that results when man meets man is the
growth of tolerance and urbanity. Wide reading, travel and experience teach us that our opinions can never be
absolutely right, and we grow to look upon them in a detached sort of way. In fact, the prime result of the
growth of intelligence and of experience is to make one, as it were, objective toward oneself, to view one's
own thoughts, beliefs and emotions with some humor and skepticism. But the uncultured, the narrow, the
inexperienced, the young and the strongly egotistic never detach themselves from their opinions, and their
opinions are themselves. Attack an opinion, contradict or amend it,--and a sort of fighting spirit is aroused.
Argument differs from discussion in that it seeks all means to win--ridicule, sophistry, and personal attack
--and it is by far the more common. There was a time when opinion was entirely enslaved, when only the ruler
might venture on a new belief or its expression; then there came a time when the right to freedom of opinion
and its expression was conceded, and now, with huge forces confronting one another, freedom of opinion is
again threatened. But that is an issue larger than our subject.
 The most profound contribution to the subject of discussion and freedom of opinion in recent years has
been written by Walter Lippman in the Atlantic Monthly, September, 1920. CHAPTER XI. 99 You may judge a man by his type of argument and his reaction to the opinions of others. One should hold to
his own beliefs and opinions, but only if they withstand the assaults of reason. To build ego feeling into
opinions is to make ignorance sacred. For most of us there are certain opinions that we will not tolerate, and
there are others to which we are indifferent. There are those who feel it incumbent on themselves to contradict
any opinion, even if they agree fundamentally with it. The mere fact that some one else gave it utterance
arouses a sort of jealousy. Then there are others who will not permit any opinion of their...
View Full Document
- Spring '11