This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.View Full Document
Unformatted text preview: large segments of population C : Everyone who owned realty benefitted Conclusions Beard: minority benefitted (original argument) Brown (responding to Beard): majority benefitted Sources Sources P1: Not primary, original BUT secondary writings P2: Beard’s sources are not impartial C : Beard’s argument cannot be impartial Example 3: Brown’s counterargument Example 4: Brown’s criticism of Beard Correlations Correlations Example 5: Beard E1 : People who made substantial financial investments are motivated by protecting/expanding investments E2 : Government policies favor affluent business groups C1 : People with significant financial investments affect policies of the Government OR? Possible rebuttal C2 : The absence of well-organized trade unions allows the affluent business groups to affect policies of the Government Correlations may be explained in multiple ways...
View Full Document
- Spring '10
- Government, AirTrain Newark