if then primary substance in the metaphysics

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: not an ontologically basic item in the world—a scholar is just a human with a liberal education.”) If then primary substance (in the Metaphysics conception of primary substance) cannot be a form-matter compound, what is primary substance? The possibilities seem to be: matter and form. (Aristotle actually discusses more possibilities—this is a simplification.) Metaphysics Z.3: the subject criterion In Z.3, Aristotle considers the claim of matter to be substance, and rejects it. Substance must be separable and a this something (usually translated, perhaps misleadingly, as “an individual”). • Separable: to be separable is to be nonparasitic. Qualities, and other nonsubstances of the Categories, are not separable. They only exist in substances. Separability, then, amounts to independent existence. • This something: [there is much dispute over what Aristotle means by this odd locution] “Individual” comes close, except for the suggestion that only a primary substance of the Categories could count as a “this something”. Perhaps an individual plant or animal counts as a this something, but perhaps other things do, too. For Aristotle seems to count form as, in some way, a this something (e.g., H.1, 1042a28). But, as a rough gloss, individuality seems to be what is at issue. Now it may seem puzzling that matter should be thought to fail the “separability/individuality” test. For: Copyright © 2004, S. Marc Cohen 3 Last modified 12/4/2004 10:49 PM • Separability: It seems that the matter of a compound is capable of existing separately from it. (The wood of which a tree is composed can continue to exist after the tree has ceased to exist.) • Individuality: We can certainly pick out a...
View Full Document

This note was uploaded on 01/31/2011 for the course PHYSICS 110 taught by Professor Staff during the Spring '09 term at UC Davis.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online