Indeed he tells us 1028b3 the old questionalways

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: d that if we are to study being we must study substance. Indeed, he tells us (1028b3): … the old question—always pursued from long ago till now, and always raising puzzles— ‘What is being?’ is just the question ‘What is substance?’ But Aristotle can no longer take it for granted that the old Categories examples of substances—a man, a horse, a tree—are going to be acceptable as basic items. Why? Because of the hylomorphic analysis that was introduced in the Physics. How hylomorphic analysis threatens Categories substances Matter underlies and persists through substantial changes. A substance is generated (destroyed) by having matter take on (lose) form. Examples: 1. A house is created when bricks, boards, etc., are put together according to a certain plan and arranged in a certain form. It is destroyed when the bricks, boards, etc., lose that form. 2. An animal is generated when matter (contributed by the mother) combines with form (contributed by the father). This suggests that the primary substances of the Categories, the individual plants and animals, are, when analyzed, actually compounds of form and matter. And in the Metaphysics, Aristotle suggests that a compound cannot be a substance (Z.3, 1029a30). Copyright © 2004, S. Marc Cohen 2 Last modified 12/4/2004 10:49 PM This may seem a strange move for Aristotle to be making. But the idea may be this: a compound cannot be a basic ontological ingredient. Cf. these compounds: • a brown horse • a scholar Each of these is a compound of substance + attribute: • a brown horse = a horse + brownness • a scholar = a human + education In these cases, the compound is a compound of entities that are more basic. (“A scholar is...
View Full Document

This note was uploaded on 01/31/2011 for the course PHYSICS 110 taught by Professor Staff during the Spring '09 term at UC Davis.

Ask a homework question - tutors are online