77_HWKTTE 4004c - Table 6-10. Summary of Results for...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–2. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Table 6-10. Summary of Results for Fitting the ASD to the LRFD Prediction Method ASD LRFD Equiv. ASD Design (EOD) ASD Design (BOR) FS φφ / λ R β P f (%) φ/λ R β P f (%) CAPWAP 2.5 0.578 0.362 3.089 0.100 0.458 2.515 0.596 PDA 2.5 0.578 0.430 2.786 0.267 0.557 2.210 1.357 Paikowsky Energy 2.5 0.578 0.520 2.267 1.171 0.691 1.449 7.374 Sakai et al Energy 2.5 0.578 0.384 1.293 9.810 0.396 1.976 2.411 FDOT (overall) 1.0 1.444 0.606 1.146 12.600 0.561 1.445 7.430 FDOT (<1779 kN) 1.0 1.444 0.969 0.369 35.630 1.065 0.536 29.620 FDOT (>1779 kN) 1.0 1.444 0.457 2.274 1.150 0.525 1.688 4.575 ENR (overall) 6.0 0.241 0.805 0.700 24.210 1.024 0.115 45.440 ENR (<1779 kN) 6.0 0.241 0.963 0.395 34.660 1.293 -0.032 51.300 ENR (>1779 kN) 6.0 0.241 0.713 0.976 16.470 0.994 0.146 44.220 Modified ENR (overall) 6.0 0.241 0.540 1.263 10.340 0.662 0.788 21.550 Modified ENR (<1779 kN) 6.0 0.241 0.741 0.605 27.280 0.868 1.306 9.586 Modified ENR (>1779 kN) 6.0 0.241 0.454 1.534 6.258 0.640 0.815 20.770 Gates (overall) 3.0 0.481 0.276 3.067 0.108 0.255 3.718 0.010 Gates (<1779 kN) 3.0 0.481 0.450 2.676 0.363 0.451 3.703 0.010 Gates (>1779 kN) 3.0 0.481 0.214 4.694 0.0001 0.240 4.177 0.0015
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
68 ASD Design Evaluation Because Equation 5-9 relates LRFD to ASD in terms only of the bridge span length, and load factors, all methods that use the same safety factor will have the same
Background image of page 2
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Page1 / 2

77_HWKTTE 4004c - Table 6-10. Summary of Results for...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 2. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online