This preview shows pages 1–3. Sign up to view the full content.
This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.
View Full Document
Unformatted text preview: Physics 341: Problem Set #4 Solutions 1. We showed in class that we can derive the total mass from a visual binary orbit, M = m 1 + m 2 = 4 π 2 d 3 ˜ α 3 GP 2 where M is the total mass, ˜ α is the angular semimajor axis in radians ( ˜ α = ˜ α 1 + ˜ α 2 ), P is the orbital period, and d is the distance to the system. Often for visual orbits of stars, we know ˜ α and P very precisely, but the distance d is much more uncertain. Let’s call the fractional uncertainty on the distance f d , meaning that we think the true distance is within d = d ± f d d (where d is our best guess and f d 1 ). For example, if d = 100 ± 3 pc , the fractional uncertainty would be f d = 3 / 100 = 0 . 03 (or in other words, a 3% uncertainty). (a) If f d is the fractional uncertainty on the distance, what is the fractional uncertainty on the total mass f M ? Hint: All you need to know is M ∝ d 3 and then use our favorite Taylor expansion approximation that (1 ± x ) α ≈ 1 ± αx when x 1 . The fractional uncertainty in the mass f M will be related to f d in a simple way. We can substitute d = d ± f d d = d (1 ± f d ) into our formula for the total mass: M = 4 π 2 ˜ α 3 GP 2 d 3 = 4 π 2 ˜ α 3 GP 2 d 3 (1 ± f d ) 3 = 4 π 2 ˜ α 3 d 3 GP 2 (1 ± f d ) 3 = M (1 ± f d ) 3 where M is our best estimate of the mass (corresponding to the distance d ), M = 4 π 2 ˜ α 3 d 3 /GP 2 . Now, because the fractional uncertainty is assumed to be small, f d 1, we can use our favorite Taylor expansion approximation, that (1 ± x ) α ≈ 1 ± αx when x 1. So in our case we have M = M (1 ± f d ) 3 ≈ M (1 ± 3 f d ) We define the fractional uncertainty in the mass f M just like we did for f d : M = M ± f M M = M (1 ± f M ) Comparing our results above, we see that the fractional uncertainty in the mass is just f M = 3 f d , three times the fractional uncertainty in the distance. (b) Our best estimate for the distance to the center of the Galaxy is d = 8 . 1 ± . 5 kpc . What is the fractional uncertainty in the distance, f d ? Using your result from part (a), what is the fractional uncertainty f M in our mass estimate for Sgr A*? 1 The fractional uncertainty in the distance is just f d = . 5 kpc 8 . 1 kpc = 0 . 062 = 6 . 2% As we showed above, because the mass scales as d 3 , the fractional uncertainty in the mass is about three times as large, f M = 0 . 186 or 18.6%. If you would like to check this, try calculating the mass for Sgr A*, using distances of 7.6 kpc, 8.1 kpc, and 8.6 kpc (i.e., covering the quoted uncertainty range). (c) Sirius is a visual binary with an orbital period P = 49 . 94 yr . Sirius A (the bright star) has an angular semimajor axis of ˜ α A = 2 . 419 00 , while Sirius B (the fainter star) has ˜ α B = 5 . 191 00 . The distance to the Sirius system is 2 . 64 ± . 01 pc . What are the masses of Sirius A and B? What are the uncertainties in the masses?...
View
Full
Document
This note was uploaded on 10/18/2011 for the course PHYSICS 341 taught by Professor Keeton during the Fall '08 term at Rutgers.
 Fall '08
 Keeton
 Mass

Click to edit the document details