This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.View Full Document
Unformatted text preview: • preparation for death? Dworkin used the standard shape of human life to develop a “metric” to measure the amount of loss connected with a death But we each use the standard shape to structure our search for meaning in life - pursing meaning in an age-inappropriate way can be a m-harm: • the 11 year old father • the 90 year old who aspires to be an Olympic volleyball player • the 90 year old who marries a 25-year old? (case 5) Consider cases (1), (2), (4), (6) from first death lecture. Death is not a m-harm when: (1) it ends great and irremediable suffering; OR all of the following are true: (2) It ends a complete life; (3) The one dying is ready for death; (4) She thinks she has had a meaningful life; (5) Her self-assessment is correct . Does a death satisfying (1) or (2)-(5) count as an m-benefit ? Case (7): Immortality Nagel: We should welcome it. Bernard Williams: The “tedium of immortality”...
View Full Document
- Fall '10
- Dworkin, standard shape