This preview shows pages 1–3. Sign up to view the full content.
This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.
View Full Document
Unformatted text preview: FROM VOLUME 36, No 1 of The Book Review Column 1 by William Gasarch Department of Computer Science University of Maryland at College Park College Park, MD, 20742 email: [email protected] A review of a book on Combinatorial Identities: Review 2 of Proofs that Really Count: The Art of Combinatorial Proof Author: Arthur T. Benjamin and Jennifer J. Quinn Publisher: MAA, 2003 $43.95, Hardcover Reviewer: William Gasarch Abbott has been teaching Costello combinatorics. Abbott: Costello, how many subsets are there of { 1 ,...,n } ? Costello: Oh. You can either choose 0 elements, or choose 1 element, or choose 2 elements, etc. So the answer is ∑ n i =0 ( n i ) . Abbott: Well ... let me show you a different way to do it. The number 1 is either in the set A or not, so thats 2 choices. Then the number 2 is either in the set A or not, so thats 2 choices, etc. So the final answer is 2 × ··· × 2 = 2 n . So, Costello, you did the problem your way, I did it my way, and we got different answers. What can you conclude? Costello: That one of us is wrong? Abbott: No. We’ve shown. ∑ n i =0 ( n i ) = 2 n . Costello: Really! I don’t believe that! Prove it!! Abbott: We did! Costello: When? Abbott: Just now. Costello: What!? Abbott: Whats on Second. Costello: Who? Abbott: Who’s on first. Costello: (Ignoring reference) Usually when I do a math problem two ways and get two answers I assume one of them is wrong and try to find my error. Its better than what a friend of mine did in elementary algebra— do a problem three times and then take the average. Abbott: In math you can sometimes prove that two things are the same by solving the same problem two different ways. Costello: No way! Abbott: Way! Costello: I’d like to read more about this. Do you have a book to recommend? 1 c William Gasarch, 2005. 2 c William Gasarch, 2005 1 Abbott: Yes. You should read Proofs that Really Count: The Art of Combinatorial Proof by Arthur T. Benjamin and Jennifer J. Quinn....
View
Full
Document
This note was uploaded on 12/04/2011 for the course CMSC 250 taught by Professor Staff during the Spring '08 term at Maryland.
 Spring '08
 staff

Click to edit the document details