**preview**has

**blurred**sections. Sign up to view the full version! View Full Document

**Unformatted text preview: **
About AP Statistics
AP® Statistics
Teachers Guide
Michael Legacy Greenhill School Addison, Texas
® connect to college success www.collegeboard.com
The College Board: Connectng Students to College Success
The College Board is a not-for-profit membership association whose mission is to connect students to college success and opportunity. Founded in 1900, the association is composed of more than 5,400 schools, colleges, universities, and other educational organizations. Each year, the College Board serves seven million students and their parents, 23,000 high schools, and 3,500 colleges through major programs and services in college admissions, guidance, assessment, financial aid, enrollment, and teaching and learning. Among its best-known programs are the SAT®, the PSAT/NMSQT®, and the Advanced Placement Program® (AP®). The College Board is committed to the principles of excellence and equity, and that commitment is embodied in all of its programs, services, activities, and concerns. For further information visit www.collegeboard.com.
© 2008 The College Board. All rights reserved. College Board, Advanced Placement Program, AP, AP Central, AP Vertical Teams, connect to college success, Pre-AP, SAT, and the acorn logo are registered trademarks of the College Board. AP Potential is a trademark owned by the College Board. PSAT/NMSQT is a registered trademark of the College Board and National Merit Scholarship Corporation. All other products and services mentioned herein may be trademarks of their respective owners. Permission to use copyrighted College Board materials may be requested online at: www.collegeboard.com/inquiry/cbpermit.html. Visit the College Board on the Web: www.collegeboard.com.
About AP Statistics
Contents
Welcome Letter from the College Board ............................................................ v Equity and Access ...................................................................................................v Participating in the AP® Course Audit...............................................................x Preface ........................................................................................................................x Chapter 1. About AP Statstcs ................................................................................. 1
Overvew: Past, Present, Future ............................................................................................. 1 Course Descrpton Essentals ................................................................................................ 4 Key Concepts and Sklls .......................................................................................................... 6
Chapter 2. Advce for AP Statstcs Teachers ........................................................ 13
Talorng the Course for Your School .................................................................................... 13 Personal Preparaton .............................................................................................................. 19 Models for Statstcal Analyss ............................................................................................. 25
Chapter 3. Course Organzaton .............................................................................. 39
Syllabus Development............................................................................................................ 39 Eght Sample Syllab .............................................................................................................. 43
Chapter 4. The AP Exam n Statstcs.................................................................. 209
Exam Development and Scorng ....................................................................................... 209 Preparng Your Students ...................................................................................................... 214 After the Exam ...................................................................................................................... 224
Chapter 5. Resources for Teachers ........................................................................ 227
Useful Informaton Sources ................................................................................................. 227 How to Address Lmted Resources ................................................................................... 240 Professonal Development ................................................................................................... 243
About AP Statistics
Welcome Letter from the College Board
Dear AP® Teacher: Whether you are a new AP teacher, using this AP Teachers Guide to assist in developing a syllabus for the f irst AP course you will ever teach, or an experienced AP teacher simply wanting to compare the teaching strategies you use with those employed by other expert AP teachers, we are confident you will find this resource valuable. We urge you to make good use of the ideas, advice, classroom strategies, and sample syllabi contained in this Teachers Guide. You deserve tremendous credit for all that you do to fortify students for college success. The nurturing environment in which you help your students master a college-level curriculuma much better atmosphere for ones first exposure to college-level expectations than the often large classes in which many first-year college courses are taughtseems to translate directly into lasting benefits as students head off to college. An array of research studies, from the classic 1999 U.S. Department of Education study Answers in the Tool Box to new research from the University of Texas and the University of California, demonstrate that when students enter high school with equivalent academic abilities and socioeconomic status, those who develop the content knowledge to demonstrate college-level mastery of an AP Exam (a grade of 3 or higher) have much higher rates of college completion and have higher grades in college. The 2005 National Center for Educational Accountability (NCEA) study shows that students who take AP courses have much higher college graduation rates than students with the same academic abilities who do not have that valuable AP experience in high school. Furthermore, a Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS, formerly known as the Third International Mathematics and Science Study) found that even AP Calculus students who score a 1 on the AP Exam are significantly outperforming other advanced mathematics students in the United States, and they compare favorably to students from the top-performing nations in an international assessment of mathematics achievement. (Visit AP Central ® at http://apcentral .collegeboard.com for details about these and other AP-related studies.) For these reasons, the AP teacher plays a significant role in a students academic journey. Your AP classroom may be the only taste of college rigor your students will have before they enter higher education. It is important to note that such benefits cannot be demonstrated among AP courses that are AP courses in name only, rather than in quality of content. For AP courses to meaningfully prepare students for college success, courses must meet standards that enable students to replicate the content of the comparable college class. Using this AP Teachers Guide is one of the keys to ensuring that your AP course is as good as (or even better than) the course the student would otherwise be taking in college. While the AP Program does not mandate the use of any one syllabus or textbook and emphasizes that AP teachers should be granted the creativity and flexibility to develop their own curriculum, it is beneficial for AP teachers to compare their syllabi not just to the course outline in the official AP Course Description and in chapter 3 of this guide, but also to the syllabi presented on AP Central, to ensure that each course labeled AP meets the standards of a college-level course. Visit AP Central at apcentral.collegeboard.com for details about the AP Course Audit, course-specific Curricular Requirements, and how to submit your syllabus for AP Course Audit authorization. As the Advanced Placement Program® continues to experience tremendous growth in the twenty-first century, it is heartening to see that in every U.S. state and the District of Columbia, a growing proportion of high school graduates have earned at least one grade of 3 or higher on an AP Exam. In some states, between 18 and 21 percent of graduating seniors have accomplished this goal. The incredible efforts of
v
Welcome Letter Chapter 1
AP teachers are paying off, producing ever greater numbers of college-bound seniors who are prepared to succeed in college. Please accept my admiration and congratulations for all that you are doing and achieving. Sincerely,
Marcia Wilbur Executive Director, Curriculum and Content Development Advanced Placement Program
v
About AP Statistics
Equty and Access
In the following section, the College Board describes its commitment to achieving equity in the AP Program.
Why are equitable preparation and inclusion important?
Currently, 40 percent of students entering four-year colleges and universities and 63 percent of students at two-year institutions require some remedial education. This is a significant concern because a student is less likely to obtain a bachelors degree if he or she has taken one or more remedial courses.1 Nationwide, secondary school educators are increasingly committed not just to helping students complete high school but also to helping them develop the habits of mind necessary for managing the rigors of college. As Educational Leadership reported in 2004: The dramatic changes taking place in the U.S. economy jeopardize the economic future of students who leave high school without the problem-solving and communication skills essential to success in postsecondary education and in the growing number of high-paying jobs in the economy. To back away from education reforms that help all students master these skills is to give up on the commitment to equal opportunity for all.2 Numerous research studies have shown that engaging a student in a rigorous high school curriculum such as is found in AP courses is one of the best ways that educators can help that student persist and complete a bachelors degree.3 However, while 57 percent of the class of 2004 in U.S. public high schools enrolled in higher education in fall 2004, only 13 percent had been boosted by a successful AP experience in high school.4 Although AP courses are not the only examples of rigorous curricula, there is still a significant gap between students with college aspirations and students with adequate high school preparation to fulfill those aspirations. Strong correlations exist between AP success and college success.5 Educators attest that this is partly because AP enables students to receive a taste of college while still in an environment that provides more support and resources for students than do typical college courses. Effective AP teachers work closely with their students, giving them the opportunity to reason, analyze, and understand for themselves. As a result, AP students frequently find themselves developing new confidence in their academic abilities and discovering their previously unknown capacities for college studies and academic success.
1. Andrea Veneza, Mchael W. Krst, and Anthony L. Antono, Betraying the College Dream: How Disconnected K12 and Postsecondary Education Systems Undermine Student Aspirations (Palo Alto, Calf.: The Brdge Project, 2003): 8. 2. Frank Levy and Rchard J. Murnane, Educaton and the Changng Job Market. Educational Leadership 62(2) (October 2004): 83. 3. In addton to studes from Unversty of CalfornaBerkeley and the Natonal Center for Educatonal Accountablty (2005), see the classc study on the subject of rgor and college persstence: Clfford Adelman, A nswers in the Tool Box: Academic Intensity, Attendance Patterns, and Bachelors Degree Attainment (Washngton, D.C.: U.S. Department of Educaton, 1999). 4. Advanced Placement Report to the Nation (New York: College Board, 2005). 5. Wayne Camara, College Persstence, Graduaton, and Remedaton, College Board Research Notes (RN-19) (New York: College Board, 2003).
v
Equity and Access E hapter 1 Cquity and Access
Which students should be encouraged to register for AP courses?
Any student willing and ready to do the work should be considered for an AP course. The College Board actively endorses the principles set forth in the following Equity Policy Statement and encourages schools to support this policy. The College Board and the Advanced Placement Program encourage teachers, AP Coordinators, and school administrators to make equitable access a guiding principle for their AP programs. The College Board is committed to the principle that all students deserve an opportunity to participate in rigorous and academically challenging courses and programs. All students who are willing to accept the challenge of a rigorous academic curriculum should be considered for admission to AP courses. The Board encourages the elimination of barriers that restrict access to AP courses for students from ethnic, racial, and socioeconomic groups that have been traditionally underrepresented in the AP Program. Schools should make every effort to ensure that their AP classes reflect the diversity of their student population. The fundamental objective that schools should strive to accomplish is to create a stimulating AP program that academically challenges students and has the same ethnic, gender, and socioeconomic demographics as the overall student population in the school. African American and Native American students are severely underrepresented in AP classrooms nationwide; Latino student participation has increased tremendously, but in many AP courses Latino students remain underrepresented. To prevent a willing, motivated student from having the opportunity to engage in AP courses is to deny that student the possibility of a better future. Knowing what we know about the impact a rigorous curriculum can have on a students future, it is not enough for us simply to leave it to motivated students to seek out these courses. Instead, we must reach out to students and encourage them to take on this challenge. With this in mind, there are two factors to consider when counseling a student regarding an AP opportunity.
1. Student motivation
Many potentially successful AP students would never enroll if the decision were left to their own initiative. They may not have peers who value rigorous academics, or they may have had prior academic experiences that damaged their confidence or belief in their college potential. They may simply lack an understanding of the benefits that such courses can offer them. Accordingly, it is essential that we not gauge a students motivation to take AP until that student has had the opportunity to understand the advantagesnot just the challengesof such course work. Educators committed to equity provide all of a schools students with an understanding of the benefits of rigorous curricula. Such educators conduct student assemblies and/or presentations to parents that clearly describe the advantages of taking an AP course and outline the work expected of students. Perhaps most important, they have one-on-one conversations with the students in which advantages and expectations are placed side by side. These educators realize that many students, lacking confidence in their abilities, will be listening for any indication that they should not take an AP course. Accordingly, such educators, while frankly describing the amount of homework to be anticipated, also offer words of encouragement and support, assuring the students that if they are willing to do the work, they are wanted in the course. The College Board has created a free online tool, AP Potential , to help educators reach out to students who previously might not have been considered for participation in an AP course. Drawing
v
About AP Statistics Equity and Access
upon data based on correlations between student performance on specific sections of the PSAT/NMSQT® and performance on specific AP Exams, AP Potential generates rosters of students at your school who have a strong likelihood of success in a particular AP course. Schools nationwide have successfully enrolled many more students in AP than ever before by using these rosters to help students (and their parents) see themselves as having potential to succeed in college-level studies. For more information, visit http://appotential.collegeboard.com. Actively recruiting students for AP and sustaining enrollment can also be enhanced by offering incentives for both students and teachers. While the College Board does not formally endorse any one incentive for boosting AP participation, we encourage school administrators to develop policies that will best serve an overarching goal to expand participation and improve performance in AP courses. When such incentives are implemented, educators should ensure that quality verification measures such as the AP Exam are embedded in the program so that courses are rigorous enough to merit the added benefits. Many schools offer the following incentives for students who enroll in AP:
Extra weighting of AP course grades when determining class rank Full or partial payment of AP Exam fees On-site exam administration
Additionally, some schools offer the following incentives for teachers to reward them for their efforts to include and support traditionally underserved students: Extra preparation periods Reduced class size Reduced duty periods Additional classroom funds Extra salary
2. Student preparation
Because AP courses should be the equivalent of courses taught in colleges and universities, it is important that a student be prepared for such rigor. The types of preparation a student should have before entering an AP course vary from course to course and are described in the official AP Course Description book for each subject (available as a free download at apcentral.collegeboard.com). Unfortunately, many schools have developed a set of gatekeeping or screening requirements that go far beyond what is appropriate to ensure that an individual student has had sufficient preparation to succeed in an AP course. Schools should make every effort to eliminate the gatekeeping process for AP enrollment. Because research has not been able to establish meaningful correlations between gatekeeping devices and actual success on an AP Exam, the College Board strongly discourages the use of the following factors as thresholds or requirements for admission to an AP course:
Grade point average Grade in a required prerequisite course Recommendation from a teacher
x
Equity and Access Chapter 1
AP teachers discretion Standardized test scores Course-specific entrance exam or essay
Additionally, schools should be wary of the following concerns regarding the misuse of AP: Creating Pre-AP courses to establish a limited, exclusive track for access to AP Rushing to install AP courses without simultaneously implementing a plan to prepare students and teachers in lower grades for the rigor of the program
How can I ensure that I am not watering down the quality of my course as I admit more students?
Students in AP courses should take the AP Exam, which provides an external verification of the extent to which college-level mastery of an AP course is taking place. While it is likely that the percentage of students who receive a grade of 3 or higher may dip as more students take the exam, that is not an indication that the quality of a course is being watered down. Instead of looking at percentages, educators should be looking at raw numbers, since each number represents an individual student. If the raw number of students receiving a grade of 3 or higher on the AP Exam is not decreasing as more students take the exam, there is no indication that the quality of learning in your course has decreased as more students have enrolled.
What are schools doing to expand access and improve AP performance?
Districts and schools that successfully improve both participation and performance in AP have implemented a multipronged approach to expanding an AP program. These schools offer AP as capstone courses, providing professional development for AP teachers and additional incentives and support for the teachers and students participating at this top level of the curriculum. The high standards of the AP courses are used as anchors that influence the 612 curriculum from the top down. Simultaneously, these educators are investing in the training of teachers in the pre-AP years and are building a vertically articulated, sequential curriculum from middle school to high school that culminates in AP coursesa broad pipeline that prepares students step by step for the rigors of AP so that they will have a fair shot at success in an AP course once they reach that stage. An effective and demanding AP program necessitates cooperation and communication between high schools and middle schools. Effective teaming among members of all educational levels ensures rigorous standards for students across years and provides them with the skills needed to succeed in AP. For more information about Pre-AP® professional development, including workshops designed to facilitate the creation of AP Vertical Teams® of middle school and high school teachers, visit AP Central. Advanced Placement Program The College Board
x
About AP Statistics
Partcpatng n the AP Course Audt
Overview
The AP Course Audit is a collaborative effort among secondary schools, colleges and universities, and the College Board. For their part, schools deliver college-level instruction to students and complete and return AP Course Audit materials. Colleges and universities work with the College Board to define elements common to college courses in each AP subject, help develop materials to support AP teaching, and receive a roster of schools and their authorized AP courses. The College Board fosters dialogue about the AP Course Audit requirements and recommendations, and reviews syllabi. Schools wishing to label a course AP on student transcripts must complete and return the subjectspecific AP Course Audit form, along with the course syllabus, for all teachers of their AP courses. Approximately two months after submitting AP Course Audit materials, schools will receive a legal agreement authorizing the use of the AP trademark on qualifying courses. Colleges and universities will receive a roster of schools listing the courses authorized to use the AP trademark at each school.
Purpose
College Board member schools at both the secondary and college levels requested an annual AP Course Audit in order to provide teachers and administrators with clear guidelines on curricular and resource requirements that must be in place for AP courses and to help colleges and universities better interpret secondary school courses marked AP on students transcripts. The AP Course Audit form identifies common, essential elements of effective college courses, including subject matter and classroom resources such as college-level textbooks and laboratory equipment. Schools and individual teachers will continue to develop their own curricula for AP courses they offerthe AP Course Audit will simply ask them to indicate inclusion of these elements in their AP syllabi or describe how their courses nonetheless deliver college-level course content. AP Exam performance is not factored into the AP Course Audit. A program that audited only those schools with seemingly unsatisfactory exam performance might cause some schools to limit access to AP courses and exams. In addition, because AP Exams are taken and exam grades reported after college admissions decisions are already made, AP course participation has become a relevant factor in the college admissions process. On the AP Course Audit form, teachers and administrators attest that their course includes elements commonly taught in effective college courses. Colleges and universities reviewing students transcripts can thus be reasonably assured that courses labeled AP provide an appropriate level and range of college-level course content, along with the classroom resources to best deliver that content.
For More Information
You should discuss the AP Course Audit with your department head and principal. For more information, including a timeline, frequently asked questions, and downloadable AP Course Audit forms, visit apcentral .collegeboard.com/courseaudit.
x
Chapter 1
Preface
Welcome! You are about to undertake a truly wonderful adventure. As an AP Statistics teacher, you stand at the beginning of a dynamic and exciting experience. Your students will analyze data using calculators and computers, conduct classroom experiments, and perform individual and group projects, making the AP course much different from the statistics course(s) you and I might have taken during our collegiate career. Your students will be active and engaged learners, and you will be right in the thick of it. It may seem a challenging task at times, but this guide and the broader statistics community are here to help you get your feet on the ground. This course is the equivalent of a one-semester, introductory, noncalculus-based college course in statistics. Most students who take AP Statistics will also take college courses in the physical, biological, and social sciences, and the AP course will provide an excellent foundation for subsequent college work. The purpose of this Teachers Guide is to help new teachers prepare for and teach an AP Statistics course, as well as to offer more experienced instructors some fresh ideas to enliven their courses. I have tried to anticipate and answer many of your questions and to point you to various resources that your colleagues have found helpful. Scattered throughout the guide you will also find advice from other AP Statistics teachers who generously share what they have learned. Chapter 1 begins with an overview by Kenneth Koehler from Iowa State University, chair of the AP Statistics Development Committee. His perspective on the role of AP Statistics and his insights about teaching the subject provide an excellent orientation to the course. Following the overview, you will find a description of what is included in the AP Statistics Course Description and a discussion of key concepts and skills that students should learn. The chapter closes with a free-response problem from the 2005 exam that highlights the connections between the Topic Outline and the AP Exam questions. Chapter 2 contains a plethora of advice about getting started, with topics such as recruiting students, communicating with parents and colleagues, choosing a textbook, connecting with the broader statistics community, and using AP Centrala Web site that contains and links to many essential resources, such as the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group. The chapter concludes with three detailed examples of data analysis that are in the spirit of, but perhaps more extensive than, the investigative-type activities that students might be expected to encounter during the course. Chapter 3 contains advice and guidance for creating your own syllabus. Eight sample syllabi from experienced statistics instructors (six high school teachers and two college statisticians) are included. I encourage you to read all of the syllabi, even those where the primary textbook differs from your own. Each has many gems to offerideas and tips for teaching tough concepts, activities, projects, and favorite AP Exam questions for review. The AP Statistics Exam is the focus of chapter 4. Here you will find more advice from experienced teachers, as well as strategies for preparing your students for the exam. Finally, chapter 5 lists additional resources for teaching AP Statisticsbooks, videos, useful Web sites, suggested reading for the postAP Exam period, statistical software, and references for your professional library.
x
About AP Statistics Preface
Teaching statistics can be a very rewarding and exhilarating experience. It is a class in which you should always expect the unexpected, so you will need to stay on your toes. To understand everything from medicine to politics to sports, a citizen today must be statistically literate. You will never have to ask yourself, Do my students really need to know this? In closing, I would like to offer my heartfelt thanks and recognition to the people who have contributed to this edition of the AP Statistics Teachers Guide. The instructors who shared their syllabi represent an impressive level of expertise and wisdom in teaching this course. The members of the AP Statistics Development Committee, who gave generously of their time and talent, offering comments on my early drafts, have markedly improved the book. Ellen Chien, during the time she worked at Educational Testing Service (ETS), was stellar in helping shepherd this guide to a timely completion. Finally, I must express my gratitude to Jeff Haberstroh of ETS for his guidance and support over the years. The success of AP Statistics is due in no small part to his behind-the-scenes dedication, work, and organization.
Michael Legacy Michael Legacy is a teacher of AP Statistics and the K12 math department chair at Greenhill School in Addison, Texas. He has served the AP community as a member of the AP Statistics Development Committee and as an AP Reader and Table Leader. He is also a frequent presenter at College Board conferences and AP Summer Institutes. Michael was statistics content editor for the Texas series Laying the Foundation®: Connecting to AP Mathematics, funded by the ODonnell Foundation (Dallas), and a 2005 recipient of the Special Recognition Award from the College Board Southwestern Region for contributions to the AP Program.
x
Chapter 1 About AP Statstcs
Overvew: Past, Present, Future
The AP Statistics curriculum provides a modern introduction to working with data and statistical reasoning. It is equivalent to that found in the best college courses, with respect to the development of basic probability concepts for modeling randomness, collection and exploration of data, application of statistical reasoning in decision making, and emphasis on effective communication. Statistics, the science of gathering and interpreting data, is an essential part of most fields of science and many business and government activities. In addition to helping prepare students for advanced study and challenging careers, the ability to critically evaluate information has valuable lifelong benefits for making decisions about important personal issues such as diet, health care, and investments. Recognizing its central importance, many colleges have made statistics a part of their general education requirements. Although some university students take their first statistics course within a statistics or mathematics department, many others receive their introduction to the subject through courses offered by programs in business, engineering, education, or one of the physical, biological, behavioral, environmental, or social sciences. The uses of statistics are quite varied, but they are all based on a fundamental set of concepts and procedures for gathering data, summarizing information, and making decisions in the face of uncertainty. The AP Statistics curriculum was developed from these fundamental concepts and procedures after many years of careful consideration by experienced college and secondary school statistics teachers. AP Statistics emphasizes working with data to investigate questions of interest to students. The course makes use of mathematical concepts taught in algebra and geometry courses to quantify random variability, provide formulas for probabilities, and model relationships between measured quantitiesbut this is only one aspect of the curriculum. The broader emphasis is on clearly defining the questions to be investigated, gathering and organizing data, producing informative graphical and numerical summaries, modeling relationships, making decisions while accounting for uncertainty in the data, and clearly communicating results in the context of a study. Course projects may be developed from data students collect to investigate their own life experiences, data collected for other courses, or articles in the popular press. There are endless possibilities, including environmental issues, effectiveness of nutrition and exercise programs, medical studies, sports, marketing claims, trends in support for education, political opinion polls, and so on. This is what makes the course fun and exciting. Whether it is taught in college or as an AP class, the first course in statistics is generally a very challenging one for both students and teachers. Do not be misled by the lack of a calculus requirement. The combination of talents demanded by this course provides significant challenges. For many students, this may be the first time they are required to integrate skills in communication, mathematics, data organization, computation, graphics, and inductive reasoning. They must also deal with precise use of statistical terminology that is based on words that can have quite different meanings in everyday language. Furthermore, there are often no exactly correct or incorrect solutions. Different approaches to
1
Chapter 1
analyzing the same data may reveal different insights, none of which is completely right or completely wrong, although some approaches may be more informative than others with respect to the objectives of a particular study. Providing students with meaningful learning experiences in making decisions and carefully communicating results, in addition to teaching basic statistical concepts and procedures, is a tall order, and there is no substitute for careful preparation.
Development of the AP Curriculum
In a broad sense, statistics is as old as recorded history, with governments and armies having recorded information on numbers of people, animals, and goods for many years. However, much of what we call modern statistics began to evolve through the work of agricultural and psychological researchers in the f irst part of the twentieth century. In 1925, R. A. Fisher published a landmark book, Statistical Methods for Research Workers, to introduce statistical methods to practicing scientists. George Snedecors book, Statistical Methods, provided a textbook for a college course for prospective scientists in the 1930s. In the 1940s, rapid advances in industrial applications of statistical methodology were spurred by the large-scale needs of the military for reliable products. Much of this work was heavily based on probability models. In the late 1960s and the 1970s, John Tukey and Frederick Mosteller led a revolution that provided a new focus on the exploration of data. These efforts were aided by the development of calculators and computers that could provide the computational and graphical power needed to easily summarize results of data exploration. Application of statistical thinking continued to expand, and in the 1970s and 1980s textbooks introducing the modern introductory course in statistics to the undergraduate college curriculum began to appear. With support from professional organizations, educators continued to explore and assess good practices for teaching introductory college courses in statistics. The development of AP Statistics was heavily influenced by the Quantitative Literacy program sponsored by the American Statistical Association (ASA) in the 1980s. In the early 1990s, George Cobb coordinated an e-mail focus group on statistics education as part of the Curriculum Action Project of the Mathematics Association of America (MAA). The ensuing report, published in the 1992 MAA volume Heeding the Call for Change, recommended greater use of active learning and greater emphasis on data and concepts of statistical thinking, with less theory and fewer recipes. The National Science Foundation funded numerous projects to implement these reforms. Led by Richard Scheaffer, an AP Statistics Task Force established by the College Board in 1992 began to develop a curriculum that would incorporate active learning into a data-orientated approach to teaching statistical thinking. The AP Statistics Development Committee held its first meeting in 1994, and the first AP Statistics Exam was given in 1997. The Development Committee monitors new trends, as educators continue to explore and assess good practices for teaching introductory college courses in statistics. In 2003, the ASA provided support for the Guidelines for Assessment and Instruction in Statistics Education project (GAISE). This project consisted of two groups, one focused on K12 education and one focused on introductory college courses. Building on past developments and a new survey about teaching introductory college courses in statistics, the 2005 GAISE report provided the following six basic recommendations for developing statistically literate students:
2
Emphasize statistical literacy and develop statistical thinking. Use real data. Stress conceptual understanding rather than mere knowledge of procedures. Foster active learning in the classroom.
About AP Statistics
Use technology for developing conceptual understanding and analyzing data. Use assessments to improve and evaluate student learning.
These recommendations are very much in line with the current AP Statistics curriculum.
The AP Curriculum
The Topic Outline in the 2009, 2010 AP Statistics Course Description gathers the components of a modern introduction to statistics into four major categories, the introductory headings of which are reproduced here. The percentages in parentheses for each content area indicate the coverage of that area in the AP Statistics Exam. I. Exploring Data: Describing patterns and departures from patterns (20%30%) Exploratory analysis of data makes use of graphical and numerical techniques to study patterns and departures from patterns. Emphasis should be placed on interpreting information from graphical and numerical displays and summaries. II. Sampling and Experimentation: Planning and conducting a study (10%15%) Data must be collected according to a well-developed plan if valid information on a conjecture is to be obtained. This plan includes clarifying the question and deciding upon a method of data collection and analysis. III. Anticipating Patterns: Exploring random phenomena using probability and simulation (20%30%) Probability is the tool used for anticipating what the distribution of data should look like under a given model. IV. Statistical Inference: Estimating population parameters and testing hypotheses (30%40%) Statistical inference guides the selection of appropriate models.
Challenges and Opportunities
The AP Statistics curriculum emphasizes the use of real data and active learning as keys to the development of conceptual understanding. This approach has been very well received, and the program has experienced remarkable growth. Since the first AP Statistics Exam was given to about 7,500 students in 1997, the number of students taking the exam has steadily increased to more than 100,000 in 2008. As demand for AP Statistics courses continues to strengthen, providing training opportunities and support for teacher professional development remains an important challenge. The impact of the AP Statistics program extends well beyond the course and exam, however. The growing number of high school teachers with experience in teaching statistics provides a valuable resource for the ongoing movement to incorporate more statistical thinking into the K12 mathematics curriculum. Cooperation between high school and college teachers in developing and implementing the AP Statistics curriculum has inspired new active learning approaches to teaching statistical concepts that have been adopted by many colleges and universities. The growing number of students completing AP Statistics has led some colleges to develop a second undergraduate course in statistics to explore more advanced models and methods of data analysis and to help students gain a deeper understanding of concepts of sampling and study design.
3
Chapter 1
We are living in a rapidly changing information age that places great value on the ability to collect, process, and evaluate data and to make decisions in the face of random uncertainty. AP Statistics teachers have an exciting opportunity to help students begin to acquire the essential skills to successfully deal with the challenges this age imposes on higher education and career development and to become informed citizens and effective, lifelong learners. Kenneth J. Koehler Chair, AP Statistics Development Committee Iowa State University, Ames
Course Descrpton Essentals
The first piece of essential reading for any teacher of AP Statistics is the AP Statistics Course Description, which provides a comprehensive view of the course and the exam. It can be purchased as a print publication from the online College Board Store (http://store.collegeboard.com) or downloaded for free from AP Central. A new teacher should read this completely, and all instructors should review it annually. It contains, among much other relevant information, the following important sections:
An overview of the course, including philosophy and objectives The Topic Outline, indicating what is covered in the course An important statement on the use of technology A description of the exam format (different sections and time allocations for each) Sample multiple-choice and free-response questions and answers The formula sheets, charts, and tables that students have access to during the exam
The AP Statistics Development Committee, working with content experts at ETS, sets the direction of the program, updates the Course Description, and develops the examinations. This committee consists of three secondary school AP teachers and three faculty members from colleges and universities in different parts of the United States. Each member typically serves a three-year term. Having both high school and college teachers on the committee is helpful because they provide different perspectives: high school teachers offer valuable advice regarding realistic expectations when matters of content coverage, skills required, and clarity of phrasing are addressed, while college and university faculty ensure that the questions are at the appropriate level of difficulty for an introductory college course in statistics. In addition, the Chief Reader, a college faculty member who coordinates the scoring of the free-response questions at the annual Reading in June, aids in the development process. He or she attends every committee meeting to ensure that the free-response questions can be scored reliably. The Course Description is also the place for communicating changes in the structure of the course. If the Development Committee were to refine the Topic Outline or add a new area, for example, that change would be announced here. However, the new topic would not appear on the examination until two years after the change had appeared in the Course Description. As you read the Course Description, keep in mind the following points:
Do not be tempted to go straight to the Topic Outline. It is important that you not skip over the introduction, the purpose, and the goals of the course. These statements and the content overview provide a structure and perspective that are the heart and soul of the course.
4
About AP Statistics
The list of formulas and tables of values in the Course Description will be furnished to the students taking the exam. You will want to provide copies for students to use throughout the course. It might be helpful to print these out on different colored papers so that students can retrieve them easily from their notebooks. Some teachers also have laminated sets that students use for their tests during the year. Compare the Topic Outline to the table of contents of your textbook. The outline is organized thematically, whereas your textbook may have some other organizational approach. For example, some teachers start the year with sampling and experimental design even though most texts start with data analysis. Students are expected to use technological tools throughout the course. This essentially means graphing calculators with statistical capabilities and computers. Students should have a graphing calculator at all times during the year as well as for the exam itself. Read carefully the statement on technology in the Course Description, especially the final paragraphs on acceptable calculators and unacceptable enhancements to such calculators. For example, adding text to the calculator that gives information about the necessary conditions for inference or steps to execute some statistical process is forbidden. Although computers are fundamental tools of modern data analysis, it may not be possible for your students to gain much experience with them owing to competition for this limited resource in many schools. Recognizing this, it is critical that students have experience reading and interpreting standard computer output that might be provided on the exam. Several examples of this type of output are found among the multiple-choice and free-response questions in the Course Description. In addition, most introductory textbooks written for this course have many examples and exercises that use computer output from standard statistical packages such as Minitab ®, Data Desk ®, JMP®, or their student versions. Students are not necessarily required to understand every single part of the computer output (more output is sometimes given than is needed for the question), but they must be able to pick out, understand, and interpret those components that pertain to the subjects included in the Topic Outline. A salient point here is that most computer output is quite generic. The component parts of the various packages are easily recognizable to knowledgeable readers, and the individual differences are minor. This should be reassuring to students, as they can be confident that they will be able to interpret any computer output presented to them. Using different examples of output will help your students recognize the similarities among the commonly used software packages. The Topic Outline in the Course Description gives the scope of the coverage of the course. Although a good textbook will be your primary source of instruction and information, you will want to look for ways to enrich your course with outside resources, such as online applets and demonstrations, statistical news articles, videos, and data-gathering activities. Many of these supplemental sources are outlined in chapters 2 and 5 of this guide and are mentioned in the sample syllabi in chapter 3. Also, you will want to gather a variety of statistics textbooks to use as resources for additional examples and explanations. As a supplement to the Course Description, read the Statistics Course Perspective by Chris Olsen. This can be found on the AP Statistics Course Home Page (apcentral.collegeboard.com/stats) under AP Statistics Course Information.
The study of statistics blends the rigor, calculations, and deductive thinking of mathematics; the real-world examples and problems of the social sciences; the decision-making needs of business and medicine; and the laboratory method and experimental procedures of the natural sciences. Teaching AP Statisticspreparing motivational lessons with real examples of how statistics are used in practice, directing laboratory-type activities, designing experiments and surveys, helping students with the necessary technology, and, last but not least, thoroughly understanding statistics yourselfmay require more preparation than any other course you have taught. These multidisciplinary aspects and applications of statistics are what eventually should make it the most rewarding of the courses you teach.
5
Chapter 1
Key Concepts and Sklls
The traditional study of mathematics consists of a sequence of lessons in which expressions are manipulated, equations are solved, algorithms are practiced, and a future payoff in problem-solving capability is promised the student. Todays conception of mathematics teaching, as formulated by the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics in its Principles and Standards for School Mathematics, envisions learning to solve real-life problems concurrently with instruction in mathematics, communication of useful mathematical reasoning, and active learning for students. Statistics, more than any of the mathematical courses that you have taught, is ideally suited for teaching and learning with an eye toward solving problems; it develops skills that will benefit students now and in their future roles as productive members of society. The AP Statistics course encourages the use of hands-on activities that students can pursue individually or in small groups. This active orientation both recognizes and insists that statistics is and should be more than calculations, tables, and rote responses to standard questions. Not only should an AP Statistics class act in concert with existing lab-oriented science classes, it should itself function as a laboriented course, with projects, data-gathering activities, and other hands-on experiences. The general goals of the AP Statistics course, which are consistent with the course philosophy, are more about the relations and connections among the topics in the outline than the topics alone. For example, when students are preparing to solve an inference problem with data from two samples, it would be instructive to ask them how the data might have been collected. Do they think the data are from an observational study or from an experiment? This is an opportunity to review sampling and design vocabulary, even though it is a problem from an inference chapter. This is one of the purposes of the investigative task question in the free-response section of the AP Exam. Can students take what they have learned in the course and integrate that knowledge or apply it to a slightly different situation that has not been encountered in class? There is a much more extensive discussion of investigative tasks in chapter 4.
A Conceptual Framework for the Course
Instructional time should encourage students to step back and look at the whole picture. The short-term benefit of such a strategy is that they will be better able to function when confronted with context-rich, open-ended questions. The long-term benefits may be divided into two categories. First, the instructional approach should go beyond topics to be covered and synthesize relations among the topics to provide a solid foundation for further academic study in statistics. The student preparing to study more advanced mathematics in college has a foundation in algebra, geometry, trigonometry, and precalculus constructed throughout his or her high school career. For many students, the analogous foundation in statistics will be provided in the AP Statistics course. Statistics, like mathematics, is a discipline rich in connections between parts that at first blush may not appear related. A solid instruction in statistics will help students see these connections. A second long-term benefit is the preparation of the student to address and solve problems of a statistical nature long after the statistics class has finished. Experience tells us that a relatively disconnected set of topics will be forgotten as time passes. A set of topics cohesively organized into larger schema will be remembered longer and is more likely to be applied in future problem-solving situations. The major components of such a cohesive framework are presented below. (You may notice that the order of presentation for the first two topics is reversed from the way they appear in the Topic Outline. This is because the statistical analysis process begins with thinking about how the data will be collected.)
6
Collection of Data: Sampling and Experimentation
About AP Statistics
For many teachers, this can be one of the most challenging units to teach. It is vocabulary-intensive and involves ideas that most students find difficult to grasp immediately. It also means that you as the teacher must do a lot of advance preparation: this is no place to wing it. The terminology alone may be new for the first-time teacher of the course: treatments, control groups, experimental units, blinding, randomization, bias, placebo, and the concepts of replication, blocking, and confounding, among others. Make sure you understand the terms and their relevance in the scheme of things. This cannot be emphasized enough. If you are unsure, your students will be so as well. Some teachers in their first year or two of teaching this course have become more comfortable with the terminology by practicing lessons out loud before standing in front of the class. One thing you might find helpful is to read the appropriate chapters from several textbooks. Note that the terminology is not completely standardized. Different books may use slightly different terms. This is okay since the focus in the course and on the exam is on understanding the underlying concepts. Also look at the scope of the experimental design questions on the AP Exam. Before you teach this unit, it might be instructive to actually go through all of the sampling and design questions on recent AP Exams (available at AP Central), write up your solution to each, carefully read the model answer given in the scoring guidelines, and then grade your work based on those standards. This exercise will help you review important concepts and vocabulary essential to the topic. Give your students lots of opportunities to write about designs. Draw problems from different sources, such as those listed in the Supplementary Textbooks section in chapter 5 of this Teachers Guide. Students should understand that for valid statistical analyses of data, the method of data collection is critical. The way the data are collected will largely determine the subsequent analysis methodology; hence, careful attention should be given to this aspect of the study. The main issue should be how we can best answer the question at hand. The data collection method is especially important, for example, for survey questions in the social sciences. A survey consisting of vague or poorly worded questions will be difficult to interpret. The introduction of bias, in a myriad of forms, may derail any possible conclusions. Meaningful generalizations from samples to populations can only occur by virtue of an appropriate random sampling plan. Students should be able to describe a good random sampling plan or a randomization method in the case of experimentation. They should also be aware of the differences between observational studies and experiments, specifically with respect to the possibility of tentatively identifying a causal relation between variables and to the scope of any possible inferences that can be drawn from the data. In general, students should be able to plan a study in light of these considerations, as well as analyze and interpret such a study, recognize any limitations on the scope of inference, and offer constructive criticism, such as ways to improve the study.
Representation of Data
Numerical and graphical representations of data are the starting point for both descriptive and inferential statistical analysis. To get information from data, it has to be organized in ways that allow a researcher to ask questions of interest to her or him. Whether data result from observations of individual subjects, from experimentation, or possibly from a simulation, the center, variability, shape of the distribution, and unusual or interesting features of data are of fundamental importance. As well as providing information about the distribution of data values, simple pictures of data can also uncover measurement errors, provide reality checks on assumptions about populations, and suggest possible avenues for future analysis. Students should be able to represent data in a variety of forms, describe data distributions both graphically and numerically, make comparisons among distributions, use the data to check conditions necessary for inference, and draw conclusions.
7
Chapter 1 Probability
Probability, the mathematics of chance and variability, provides foundational ideas such as events, independence, and probability distributions, as well as a mathematical language for communicating these ideas in the AP Statistics course. An understanding of simulations, sampling distributions as probability distributions, and statistics as random variables, together with a basic knowledge of the algebra of random variables, provides a conceptually solid foundation to answer questions such as, Why do we add variances, and why does it matter?, and How often would I get results like this if I used this method many times? An examination of the syllabi presented in chapter 3 will clearly indicate that this is not a probability course. What students do need is a working vocabulary that allows active classroom discussion of statistical ideas based on the underpinning probabilistic principles. Probability calculations are an essential element of statistical inference procedures. Since samples are subject to random variability, probability provides us with a way to quantify that variability and identify meaningful differences. For example, suppose you have two equal groups of surgery patients, with one group receiving the standard postsurgical care and the other group, a new postsurgical regimen. Suppose also that the difference in mean lengths of time it takes the two groups to recover from the surgery is markedly different. What is the probability that, owing simply to the random assignment of the patients, the difference in the mean lengths of recovery time for the two groups could be so large? In other words, what is the probability that, if the two treatments were equally effective, we would see a difference as large, or larger, than this one? This is called the P-value. Students must not only know how to calculate the P-value for an inference test but must also be able to interpret this value in the context of the problem.
Statistical Inference
Statistical inference is the central focus of the course. The successful student should have a firm grasp of the nature and logic of statistical inference as it unfolds in observational studies and experiments, from planning to P-value. Random sampling provides the basis for generalizing ones findings beyond the sample data at hand to the population of interest. Proper experimental design is a tool for controlling extraneous variables and reducing the ambiguities of experimental results. The formal inferential techniques of confidence intervals and hypothesis testing, the main methods for drawing conclusions about a population from sample data, lead to the assessment of the statistical significance of the study or experiment. Students must master the mechanics of choosing an appropriate inference method and computing the numerical values (either by hand or with a calculator), but more importantly, they should be able to communicate and interpret those results to a reader in a coherent conclusion.
Communication of Analysis, Methods, and Results
Even the best experimental design and statistical analysis are compromised if the reporting of methods and results is incomplete, ambiguous, or misleadingand students responses to the AP Statistics Exam openended questions are not exempt from this principle. It may seem paradoxical to expect precision and clarity in a science devoted to the study of uncertainty, but the requirements of the AP Exam are consistent with the communication demands in modern statistical practice. Statistics involves explanation, interpretation, and translation. Students should be prepared to justify their choice of a particular procedure, explain their reasoning, and interpret their results, and they should be able to write an appropriate and complete conclusion. The value of effective communication in this course is emphasized in the Course Description, where the dual importance of statistical knowledge and good communication is cited in the discussion of holistic scoring of the AP Exam free-response questions (page 28 in the 2009, 2010 edition). Note that the scoring guidelines value both of these categories equally.
8
About AP Statistics
Relating This Approach to the AP Exam Questions
This philosophy of connecting topics and the building blocks described above guides the Development Committee in creating questions for the AP Statistics Exam. Lets examine a specific example to see how these elements are integrated into the questions. The following is free-response question 1 from the 2005 exam. The goal of a nutritional study was to compare the caloric intake of adolescents living in rural areas of the United States with the caloric intake of adolescents living in urban areas of the United States. A random sample of ninth-grade students from a high school in a rural area was selected. Another random sample of ninth graders from one high school in an urban area was also selected. Each student in each sample kept records of all food he or she consumed in one day. The back-to-back stemplot below displays the number of calories of food consumed per kilogram of body weight for each student on that day. Urban 99998876 44310 97665 20 Rural 2 3 3 4 4 5 2334 56667 02224 56889 1 Stem: tens Leaf: ones (a) Write a few sentences comparing the distribution of the daily caloric intake of ninth-grade students in the rural high school with the distribution of the daily caloric intake of ninth-grade students in the urban high school. (b) Is it reasonable to generalize the findings of this study to all rural and urban ninth-grade students in the United States? Explain. (c) Researchers who want to conduct a similar study are debating which of the following two plans to use. Plan I: Have each student in the study record all of the food he or she consumed in one day. Then researchers would compute the number of calories of food consumed per kilogram of body weight for each student for that day. Plan II: Have each student in the study record all of the food he or she consumed over the same 7-day period (one week). Then researchers would compute the average daily number of calories of food consumed per kilogram of body weight for each student during that 7-day period. Assuming that the students keep accurate records, which plan, I or II, would better meet the goal of the study? Justify your answer.
9
Chapter 1 Commentary
This problem asks students to compare the caloric intake for a random sample of 20 students from one rural high school with a random sample of 20 students from one urban high school. The variable measured was the number of calories per kilogram of body weight consumed in one day by each student. A back-toback stemplot displayed the calories/kg consumed for each student on one day. In part (a), students are asked to compare the distributions from both schools. Referring back to the key concepts above, this is representation of data. The response should include a clear, correct, comparative statement for each of the three characteristics: shape, center (position), and spread. Comparative language must be used: for example, the median daily caloric intake of ninth-grade students in the rural school is higher than the median caloric intake for those in the urban school. Just making a list of the appropriate numbers for each distribution is insufficient to answer the question. In part (b), students are asked whether it is reasonable to generalize the findings of the study to all rural and urban ninth-grade students in the United States. Here the question is getting at elements from collection of data: the design of the study and the generalizability of the results. The response should clearly indicate that generalizing is not appropriate, because only one rural school and one urban school were used. The sampling unit was the school, not the subjects chosen for the study or the area from which the subjects were selected. In part (c), students are presented with two possible sampling plans in consideration of a similar study. Plan I uses only one day; plan II uses a 7-day period with a 7-day average computed for the number of calories consumed by each student. Students are directed to choose the more appropriate plan and justify their choice. The student should indicate that plan II will better meet the goal of the study because it accounts for the effect of day-to-day variability and provides a more precise estimate of the average daily intake. A correct justification would indicate an understanding of what might cause systematic day-today variability in the difference between rural and urban students in the number of calories consumed on different days of the week (different amounts of calories consumed on a weekday versus a weekend day, for example). A student response that simply says that 7 days are better than one day is insufficient for justification. As you look back over this question and response, please note several important details.
The question draws from several parts of the coursedata analysis and sampling design, in particular. This is characteristic of the integrative nature of many AP Statistics Exam questions. One part of a question might be about describing data, and another part might use the same data for conducting an inference procedure. One part may relate to inference and another part to sampling design. A question may start with a straightforward probability calculation that eventually takes the student through the binomial distribution and ends with a part about sampling distributions. There is not much in the way of computation. Students have calculators to help them, so most of the credit they can earn for a problem goes beyond the ability to correctly compute. Brilliant arithmetic will not overcome bad analysis and poor communication, but good analysis and communication can usually overcome errors in arithmetic. Communication is critical (much more about this in chapter 4). Note that the question asks students to explain and justify their choices. It is not sufficient to just write down the choice of plan II. To receive full credit, students must explain or justify in a direct comparison why this is a better choice than plan I.
10
About AP Statistics
The purpose of this chapter has been to explain what the AP Statistics course consists of, how it is reflected in the AP Exam, and the general conceptual skills it is expected to develop in students. This information has been assembled with broad strokes, giving a comprehensive view of where you are headed. The next chapter concentrates on specifics, with detailed advice on resources for new AP teachers, administrative issues, personal preparation for teaching, and data analysis models.
11
Chapter 2 Advce for AP Statstcs Teachers
This chapter is devoted to providing a wide range of practical advice as you prepare to teach AP Statistics. It covers such concerns as the support needed from your school administration; recruitment of students; how to work with colleagues and parents; personal preparation for teaching the course; help provided for the new teacher by the College Board; and some model activities for your classroom. Do not be discouraged by the length of this chapter; it is long because there are many different aspects to consider in managing the course and dozens of ways to craft a successful learning vehicle. There is no single right way to teach this class. Remember also that the acquisition of resources, the improvement of your knowledge base, and your increased comfort level in teaching the course are long-term efforts. Think of this as a journey: you are about to take your first steps down a road that has been, for me, a most enjoyable trip. Statistics, more than any other mathematical discipline, uses data gathered in other fields: the natural, biological, and social sciences; business, health, and politics; and even the humanities. In addition, the concepts and methods of statistics are used in many other disciplines to understand processes and make decisions. This state of affairs is reflected in todays high school curriculum. Teachers of history, psychology, and other social science courses utilize graphic presentations of data, and natural science courses engage students in the techniques and reporting of laboratory experiments, frequently analyzing experimental data. AP Statistics develops a systematic overview of the subject, showing how data exploration, data production, and probability all come together in the weaving of sound inferential arguments. Laboratory scientists may teach that part of statistics that is the most useful in their discipline, whereas social scientists may teach a different subset. No single group of users of statistics is inclined to teach the larger picture of statistical reasoning and how the various techniques used by different disciplines f it into it. Teachers of statistics can provide that conceptual overview.
Talorng the Course for Your School
Administrative Support
Teaching AP Statistics places unique demands on you and requires a supportive environment within your school as a whole and within the mathematics program in particular. You will need extra time to review the subject and develop a new course, and you will need funds for equipment, resources, and possibly computer software. Statistics draws its examples from other disciplines, and coordination with these disciplines will help to make the course a truly broad learning experience for students. Thus, the addition of AP Statistics to the academic program should be thought of as a schoolwide effort.
13
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
The optimal administrative support includes the following: 1. A smaller-than-average class size, especially while the course is being developed. Many schools recognize that some courses require more teacher time. English classes, with their many compositions, and laboratory or equipment-intensive courses frequently have enrollments that are below the norm. To paraphrase an epigram from the world of sports, mathematics is in contact with the real world; statistics collides with the real world. The AP Statistics teacher will have time-consuming duties equal to those classes just mentioned, and this should be supported by the administration. 2. Funding for you to upgrade your skills by taking college courses or attending an AP Summer Institute, and release time and funding for you to attend conferences and workshops during the school year. Many math teachers do not have a background in statistics commensurate with their training in mathematics. Administrators must recognize and support the commitment of math teachers to improve their knowledge of the statistics discipline and its pedagogy. 3. Sufficient equipment, including graphing calculators and computers with statistical software, as well as teaching devices such as tape measures, markers, dice, and cards, to meet the demands of the course. 4. Modern textbooks and accompanying teacher resources that reflect current best practices in statistics. 5. Resource materials, including supplementary textbooks and teaching materials, videos, and at least one journal devoted to statistics. Two excellent journals that should be considered for your library are Chance, an entertaining magazine of contemporary uses of statistics, and STATS, a journal for undergraduates interested in statistics. The American Statistical Association (www.amstat.org) publishes both. A K12 school membership in the ASA is very reasonably priced. 6. Flexibility in scheduling so that students will have sufficient time to gather data and analyze the data using a computer if a lab and software are available. The teacher will have to be flexible and use the class time wisely.
Recruiting Students
In accordance with the College Boards Equity and Access policy (see page vii at the beginning of this guide), students taking AP Statistics should reflect the diversity of the overall school population. The College Board discourages gatekeeping by screening students based on test scores only. AP courses are not just for the smartest and most able students in the school. A highly motivated student who shows a commitment to excellence should be strongly considered for admittance to an AP class. A challenging, engaging, and rigorous class can many times inspire a student to achieve at a high level. The goal of breaking down the barriers to broaden participation in the AP Program is both laudable and achievable. As an AP Statistics instructor, you will need to decide on the criteria for admission to your class. It is not easy for any teacher to make the decision that a student is mature enough, both mathematically and developmentally, for the rigors of college-level work. In the AP Statistics class, students will need to understand some concepts whose presentation is necessarily in a mathematical form and be able to follow and participate in discussions of these concepts. This requires more than just an algorithmic knowledge of the mathematics. The mathematically mature statistics student must be able to let the actual formulas
14
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
recede into the background and have a certain comfort with the ideas and concepts behind the formulas. As a general rule of thumb, students should have been successful in second-year algebra in order to have the mathematical sophistication and disciplined work habits needed for AP Statistics. In addition, students should possess good mathematical reasoning ability and communication skills. How do you encourage students to enroll in AP Statistics? I used to recruit by going to Algebra II classes around the end of January to talk about statistics and its place in many college degree programs, do a little demonstration on sampling or simulations, and encourage students to drop by my desk if they had questions or come visit one of my statistics classes. After a year or two, former students were my best ambassadors, via word-of-mouth. Another valuable resource is AP Potential, a free Web-based tool that allows schools to generate rosters of students who are likely to earn a grade of 3 or better on a given AP Exam. Many statistics teachers have successfully used this source by cross-referencing the mathematics and English lists generated by the system. In fact, some of my strongest statistics students were not necessarily my strongest math students but were among my better writers. For more information, read the overview at appotential.collegeboard.com. In order to use the service to access student lists, you must be registered with an access code from your school. One goal of AP Statistics is to heighten interest in mathematics for those students who might otherwise drop out of mathematical studies at an earlier level. Many students complete three years of college preparatory mathematics by the end of eleventh grade and may not plan to enroll in any math course at all in their senior year. AP Statistics offers an interesting, productive way to keep these students involved with the discipline. Those who are interested in a social science major in college should know that it is statistics rather than calculus that is usually required. The experience of AP Statistics and AP Calculus teachers has been that AP Statistics is a popular option in high schools for a wide variety of students; it does not compete with existing math course offerings. Many students at my school are concurrently enrolled in precalculus and AP Statistics in either their junior or senior year. We also have some who are enrolled simultaneously in AP Statistics and AP Calculus (AB and BC). Students who enroll in your class should do so with the understanding that they are strongly encouraged to take the AP Statistics Exam in May. Some schools make the exam a course requirement. The expectation should be that a substantial majority of students taking the course will master the material and will not then repeat the subject upon entrance to college.
Involving Parents
Our school has a long and successful involvement with AP courses, and students parents and guardians are comfortable with the policies we have set. It is important nonetheless that there be open and ongoing communication with families. Maintaining a strong relationship with parents and guardians is extremely beneficial to the students overall success. At the start of the school year, I post a Topic Outline and course goals on the schools Web site. Additionally, I discuss the course and my expectations at our Meet the Teacher Night in September. During this time, I explain that this is not a typical math course. Students will be expected not only to deal with computations but to evaluate and communicate results in written formnot something they have likely experienced in previous math courses. I include several free-response questions to illustrate the level of analysis that will be required. I have also seen brochures that other statistics teachers have prepared and then used both to recruit students for the class and also to send home at the beginning of the year as an informational flyer.
15
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
Several years ago I went to our college counseling office and selected a dozen course catalogs from schools that our students typically attend. In about an hour, I had a list of a significant number of college majors that required at least one course in statistics as part of the degree program. I have this available for attendees at the Back to School Night, as well as for students who are interested in taking the course. It is also critical that you talk to your school counselors. It is to your advantage to make them allies and help them to better understand your course and what type of students would most benefit from enrolling. A simple way to enlist parental support might be to prepare a brief description of important topics over the next three to five weeks, a summary of upcoming due dates for projects or outside work to be turned in, and a calendar of daily assignments. This could easily be posted on the schools Web site or sent out via regular mail. If you can do this every three weeks, or even every six weeks, it keeps the folks on the homefront in the loop. Parents are encouraged to contact me if they have questions about the program or concerns about their childs progress. At my school, teachers write comments on the students three times a year (the midterm marking period in each twelve-week trimester). This is an arduous task, but it gives me an opportunity to inform parents about how their child is doing, to provide an overview of material that we are studying or will study, and to remind them of important deadlines for projects, unit tests, reviews, and the trimester exams. Although your school may not expect such extensive student commentary and parental communication, I think that staying in touch with families is an essential part of making your program successful. Getting parents and guardians to buy into your program and helping them to understand what is expected of their child in an AP class means that you will have more support at home and there will be fewer surprises if the going gets difficult.
Working with Colleagues
If AP Statistics is being added to a school curriculum that has existing AP courses, it is important that you speak with other AP teachers and the AP Coordinator to learn how the program works, how the course f its into the mathematics curriculum, and how Statistics compares to other AP courses at your school. Working in concert with colleagues in other subject areas engenders a positive and nurturing community spirit, helping to lessen the sense of isolation many statistics teachers sometimes experience. Although our school does not have a math Vertical Team per se, we do have monthly Pre-K12 math department meetings (about 24 people). Usually this one-hour meeting is devoted to a topic that is pertinent to all of usfor example, assessment or writing in the classroom. It is enlightening for upper school teachers to see that even in second grade our students are answering open-ended questions that are scored with a rubric. This is really not about us versus them. It is also beneficial for elementary and middle school teachers to see that the fruits of their labor are reinforced in higher-level courses through the continued use of open-ended questions and assessment rubrics. Many times elementary and middle school teachers think that their job is just to prepare students for high school, where the real math occurs. This is most unfortunate. It is important for those teachers to understand that without their excellent work in laying a foundation, our job in high school becomes that much harder. This year, for instance, our middle school is making a concerted effort to improve writing across all curricular areas. All teachers have access via our Web site to the curriculum map for each grade level (K8) and each upper school course, and can see where a particular concept is introduced, reinforced, and eventually mastered.
16
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
AP teachers at my school are encouraged to visit other AP classes in science, history, and English. Substitutes are provided so that teachers can participate in these worthwhile endeavors, and these visiting days do not count against personal or professional days. AP teachers and those who use Pre-AP strategies are also encouraged to attend the two-day math conferences conducted by the College Board in the Southwestern Region. Teachers are expected to share what they have learned with the rest of the department.
Scheduling an AP Statistics Course
The Topic Outline in the Course Description presents an extensive array of concepts and skills, especially for those students who have not previously been exposed to probability and statistics. In addition to the exploratory techniques of modern data analysis that have recently been included in many secondary school curricula, the course must include introductions to topics in sampling, experimental design, and probability, and the thorough introduction to statistical inference found in most introductory college courses. In most situations, the AP Statistics course will require the equivalent of two semesters in order to teach the recommended subjects adequately. Some instructors have taught the course in one semester or two trimesters but have been hard-pressed to adequately teach the entire curriculum. If your school has an accelerated block schedule, the fact that the AP Statistics Exam is given early in May might be the most important factor in your decision about when to offer the course. If the course is offered only in the spring, you will likely not complete the syllabus before the exam is administered, so the fall is a better betbut in that case, students will need an ongoing review during the spring semester before taking the exam. In contrast, at many other schools the early May exam date leaves a significant amount of time between the exam and the end of the school year. The period after the exam can then be used for project work or to study topics beyond the AP Statistics syllabus.
Textbooks
The single most important decision you will make as you approach the teaching of AP Statistics is your choice of a textbook. The AP Statistics teacher must choose a text that contains appropriate content for the course, fits comfortably with modern technology, and is at a suitable reading and mathematical level. If you are new to the teaching of the subject, you should seek the counsel of experienced AP Statistics instructors, as well as university and college teachers actively involved in statistics education. The AP Statistics community has many experienced high school teachers, as well as a gratifying number of professors of statistics and professional statisticians who have been and will continue to be extremely helpful as you negotiate the shoals of textbook selection. (See chapter 5, Resources for Teachers, for a comprehensive review of the most often cited textbooks.) The AP Statistics Course Home Page (apcentral.collegeboard.com/stats) also contains up-to-date reviews of statistics textbooks, as well as other resources. Further valuable textbook advice may be solicited from experienced teachers of AP Statistics via the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group (EDG). Information about joining the EDG can be found later in this chapter. Although you will rely on your primary textbook, you should also try to build a repository of supplementary materials. I encourage you to maintain a collection of textbooks for reference. The extra examples and different approaches that various authors provide can be valuable as you review course content and plan your lessons. Whereas statistics textbooks are published at particular points in time, the resources for an AP Statistics class are as timely and up-to-date as newspapers, newsmagazines, books, and scientific journals. Increasingly, newspapers are reporting insightfully on health, social concerns, and scientific issues; they are also including references to their sources (for example, in todays issue of the New England Journal of Medicine . . .). Many of these sources have an online presence, and more detailed information than is reported in the newspapers may be found on their Web sites. Chapter 5 lists some of
17
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
the resources that might be used to supplement the textbook. Classroom activities can also be enhanced by a range of contemporary educational materials, including videotapes and DVDs, computer- and Web-based instructional materials, CD-ROMs, and calculator-based measuring devices. Many textbooks targeted for AP Statistics also have extensive teacher-support materials to accompany the text, both in printed form and on the publishers Web sites.
Technological Needs: Calculators and Computers
Modern technology, in the form of calculators and computers, has helped to redefine the nature of mathematics teaching and learning. Although economic issues will always be with us, and each district must struggle in its own way with its policies, calculators and computers should be a standard resource in an AP Statistics class. Calculators and computers each offer unique opportunities to a statistics student. In addition to the routine statistical calculation and graphics that calculators provide, their small size and mobility, combined with laboratory probes that can sample temperature, light, pH, and so forth, bring realistic experimentation and data gathering to the classroom. On the other end of the spectrum, the modern computer can store large data sets, allow interactive data analysis, and provide variety, speed, and visualization to simulations, thereby offering better understanding of the phrase in the long run as it applies to sampling distributions and the central limit theorem. Another important advantage of using computers is that statistical software packages can produce much more effective and informative visual displays of data than most calculators. (No matter the statistical package used, the computer output tends to be largely generic; that is, a scatterplot looks about the same with any package.) There is no balance of the two technologies that is perfect for all teachers and students in an AP Statistics class. This course has been taught successfully in situations with a wide range of calculator and computer availability. It is expected that calculators will be used on the AP Exam; thus, students should have access to them throughout the course, both in class and for homework. While taking the exam, students will be expected to have a calculator with statistical computation and statistical graphics capability. A calculator with a typewriter keyboard will not be allowed. For a list of acceptable calculators, go to the AP Statistics Course Home Page, and click on Calculator Policies for Mathematics and Science. The fact that calculators are available means that an AP Statistics Exam question will not, for example, simply ask students to compute a standard deviation but will also (or instead) assess their understanding of what the standard deviation measures. The use of a computer for statistical computing and statistical graphics is essential in the work of most statisticians. Although the availability of computers will enrich your course, the lack of access to a computer lab will not necessarily hinder students understanding of statistics. However, it would be extremely helpful to have at least one computer in the classroom for demonstrations to help develop student understanding. There is no component of actual computer use on the AP Statistics Exam, but students are required to interpret computer output from standard statistical packages such as Minitab, Data Desk, and JMP, or their student versions. As with textbook selection, the AP Statistics community can help with software selection if you are unfamiliar with existing packages. In many cases, producers of statistics software offer academic versions that are reasonably priced and can easily perform all data analysis tasks that arise in the AP Statistics course. Some statistics teachers have successfully used spreadsheet programs for statistical analyses. Generally, these programs are less satisfactory than programs designed specifically for statistics. There is also the R statistical package, which can be downloaded from the Web for free (www.r-project.org). It is a very powerful package that produces excellent graphs, and it also has a short guide to help students get started with basic data analysis.
18
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
An Applet a Day The graphing calculator is an excellent tool for statistical calculations needed in the AP Statistics course. However, for visualizations and discovery two online applet resources that have become invaluable are Online Statistics (www.onlinestatbook.com) and the Rossman/Chance Applet Collection (www.rossmanchance.com/applets). The first site is totally interactive, with exercises and examples for students. Students not only choose an answer to a question but are expected to explain the answer. Solutions are provided. The simulations are wonderful, and students can truly see the central limit theorem come alive in their own creations. The full range of topics from any introductory statistics book is covered on this site. The second site gives students a variety of ways to sample, using pennies or Reeses Pieces®, to name just two. Students really enjoy watching the candy machine select the colors. The interactivity allows students to change parameters and sample sizes, which truly facilitates the discovery approach to learning. Students can access these sites on their home computers, which is an added benefit when lab time is not available. Robin Levine-Wissing, Glenbrook North High School, Northbrook, Illinois
Personal Preparaton
Generally, effective preparation for teaching AP Statistics consists of a four-part strategy. The first step is to assess your own knowledge of statistics and make a plan to fill in the gaps. The second part is to acquaint yourself with the information available about how to teach introductory statistics, which includes fascinating research on how students think about and learn probability and statistics. The third element is to begin to collect the material that you will use in the classroom. The final component is to find ways to communicate with and stay connected to other teachers of introductory statistics so that you can keep abreast of new developments in statistics education and share what you have learned. The sections below contain suggestions about how to accomplish all this, from me and other teachers who have been there.
Expand Your Knowledge of Statistics
If you want to learn more about statistics, see if you can take a class at your local university, or two- or four-year college, from a knowledgeable statistician who is also a skilled teacher. Before enrolling, however, check on the content of the course. Make sure that it covers the techniques of modern data analysis and planning studies emphasized in the Topic Outline for the AP Statistics course. Alternatively, you could read one or more of the many fine books on elementary statistics now in print. Because there are several different philosophies and ways to approach the study of statistics, it is always a good idea to read a textbook other than the one you are using. Experienced teachers might even consider switching textbooks after a few years to gain a different perspective (budget constraints and local or state textbook adoption policies permitting). In addition to books with statistics content, it is helpful to read about the teaching of statistics. Chapter 5 contains a bibliography of suggested professional readings in statistics and teaching statistics. The American Statistical Association (ASA) offers significant resources relevant to K12 education in general and AP Statistics in particular (visit www.amstat.org). Schools may join the ASA via K12 school membership and receive subscriptions to Chance, STATS, and the Statistics Teacher Network newsletter. The ASA has established an Adopt-a-School program to promote contact between schools and professional statisticians in industry, government, and academia. In addition, the ASA can provide a list of statisticians who would be happy to come to your school to talk with statistics students or to invite you and your students to visit their place of business.
19
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
One of the best ways to learn how to think statistically is to study examples of how great statisticians analyze data. Good examples are readily available and can be found on some of the Web pages already mentioned, as well as in Chatterjee et al., A Casebook for a First Course in Statistics and Data Analysis; Peck et al., Statistics: A Guide to the Unknown; Chance magazine; and the Statistics: Decisions Through Data videotapes developed by the Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications (see chapter 5 for full citations).
Getting Yourself Ready As you prepare to teach this course, you may find, as I did, that some areas are very familiar and others much less so. Concentrate on your weaker points. If you have forgotten certain topics, take a class if necessary. At least work through your textbook before you teach it. Better yet, go to a one-week AP Summer Institute prior to teaching the course. Seek recommendations from colleagues about which ones they have attended and found useful. It is equally important to become part of a network of AP Statistics teachers. You dont want to go it alone. A local group of AP Statistics instructors may already exist; if not, you can create a support group to help each other during the year. Here in North Carolina, we formed the MCSTATS (Mecklenburg County Stats) group, which met once a month and shared information on pacing, activities, tests, and so forth. Experienced teachers can help you get through the first year or two. A local university may also have at least one instructor who is willing to provide some much-appreciated academic insight into content and concepts. Through the work of David Royster, with support from Rich Lambert, we have an AP Statistics evening several times a year at the University of North CarolinaCharlotte. Finally, be sure to join the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group (EDG). Even as a lurker, you will find the messages informative. A searching of the EDG archives will yield many sources of information. There are incredible options for teaching this course in terms of textbooks, technology, projects, and activities. It may feel overwhelming during your first couple of years. Research as much as you can, with the understanding that there is not one perfect choice. If you have taught another AP course (for example, AP Calculus), know that this is a very different experience. Although that might be initially unnerving, it is also exciting. Sheila McGrail, Charlotte Country Day School, Charlotte, North Carolina
Attend Professional Meetings
It is strongly recommended that you attend an AP Summer Institute during the summer prior to teaching the course for the first time. This four-and-a-half-day workshop is usually led by an experienced AP Statistics teacher and is packed with information, handouts, lesson ideas, and teaching tips. It is not meant to teach you all of the statistics you may need to know for the course but rather how to more effectively teach the course and negotiate the toughest concepts that will confront students. In addition, the College Board sponsors one- and two-day workshops that you can attend in your region. These are not only a great way to keep in contact with other teachers of statistics but also to gather new ideas for your classroom. To f ind a professional development opportunity in your area, click on the Institutes and Workshop link on AP Central or contact your College Board Regional Office (you can find the address and telephone number of your regional office by clicking on the Contact Us link at the bottom of any AP Central page). Many high school introductory statistics courses are taught by mathematics teachers, and the major professional associations in mathematics have begun providing resources and workshop opportunities for their members aspiring to teach statistics. The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM), the Mathematical Association of America (MAA), the American Mathematical Association of Two-Year Colleges (AMATYC), and the Consortium for the Advancement of Undergraduate Statistics Education
20
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
(CAUSE) have sessions and workshops on teaching statistics at their local, regional, and national meetings. CAUSE also sponsors the United States Conference on Teaching Statistics (USCOTS), which has sessions of direct interest to AP Statistics teachers. The ASA/NCTM Joint Committee sponsors a Beyond AP Statistics (BAPS) session at its annual joint statistical meetings. This workshop is offered for AP Statistics teachers and consists of enrichment material beyond the basic AP syllabus. BAPS participants are also provided with a complimentary registration to the meetings so that they can visit the exhibit hall or attend statistics education sessions on the day following the workshop.
Gather Materials
Good statistics teaching is as much an attitude as a set of skills. Statistics, more than any other mathematical discipline, transcends its theoretical base to serve other scientific disciplines. As John Tukey, the legendary statistician, remarked, one of the best things about statistics is that one gets to play in everybody elses backyard. A teacher of statistics is constantly alert to how data may be and are collected and used in all the backyards in the neighborhood. You will find that teaching an AP Statistics course changes the way you look at the world. Experienced statistics teachers have file folders containing examples they have gathered from newspapers, magazines, television, and electronic and online sources. Begin your own collection. Opinion polls are routinely reported in newspapers, as well as reports about scientific experiments of public and personal interest. Frequently these reports contain references to their sources, many of which are available online with expanded information. Make one file folder for each of the items listed in the AP Statistics Topic Outline. Each time you come across an example in the newspaper, on television, or in a book, or hear a good idea from a colleague, put it in the appropriate folder. The Mathematics Teacher, familiar to all members of the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, often has articles on teaching statistics. The American Statistician, a publication of the American Statistical Association, frequently contains articles accessible to the teacher of introductory statistics, especially in the Teachers Corner section. STATS and Chance are two other excellent sources of articles. Another very good resource is the Journal of Statistics Education (see chapter 5 for full descriptions of these publications). When you find data that might interest your students, place that article in the appropriate file. You should also have a folder for possible student projects and ideas on how to organize such projects. When constructing lessons or problems of interest to your students, your cache of data, newspaper reports, and journal articles will be priceless! A word of warning: your collection of file folders can easily turn into a complete file cabinet as sources are discovered, located, and revisited. Be sure to cull outdated sources and reverify URLs. Also, make it a habit to record the bibliographic information for articles when you cut them out.
21
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
Data Sources Need data? No problem! Students enjoy collecting information about themselves. Its easy, fun, and readily available. Here are some suggestions: Categorical Data Elementary school attended Eye color Favorite food Favorite music genre Favorite subject or class Greatest fear Worst-tasting food Univariate Data Amount of money in pocket or purse Height in inches Number of letters in name Number of minutes spent talking with parents or guardians in a day Number of people in family Number of phone numbers saved in cell phone Shoe size by gender Time it takes to get ready for school Time spent on last nights homework Time spent on the computer in an average week Time spent watching television in an average week Weight of backpack (use the nurses scale) Bivariate Data Height versus shoe size Height versus wingspan Resting pulse rate versus number of hours spent working out per week Time on quiz versus grade Penny Smeltzer, Westwood High School, Austin, Texas
Mathematics instructors who teach statistics sometimes feel isolated, in that they are frequently the only one in the department teaching this subject. This isolation can be easily alleviated! Although you may be the only teacher of statistics, you are not the only user of statistics in a high school. You will find that your colleagues in the sciences, social sciences, economics, physical education, and health fields use data in their teaching but very often do not analyze it with any sophistication. Ask them to collect data from their laboratory experiments and have them describe the statistics that students need to know in order to analyze those experiments. Ask to borrow a lab manual so you can see the kind of data that are collected. Teaching is easier when it is collaborative!
Get Connected to the AP Statistics Community
AP Central, the Source of All Things AP Statistical
As part of its mission and focus on professional development for AP teachers, the College Board has developed an official online home. AP Central (apcentral.collegeboard.com) is a free Web site for all those involved in or interested in the AP Program, including new and experienced teachers, AP Coordinators, counselors, college faculty, and school and college administrators. The goals of AP Central are to inform, support, and connect the AP community. AP teachers face two significant challenges: first, keeping up-todate in their discipline and with the AP Program; and second, finding appropriate and sufficient resources to enhance and support their teaching. Teachers will have a better sense of involvement in the AP Program through both the information at the site and the opportunities to contribute.
22
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
AP Central offers a unique and growing set of resources. Here you will find the most recent information on the AP Program, including official Course Descriptions, information on the exams, sample syllabi, teaching resources, publications, frequently asked questions (FAQs), and more. You can personalize your online experience in the My AP Central section to access facts about AP Statistics and other courses of your choice, in addition to choosing information specific to your location. The content area of AP Central for this course is the AP Statistics Course Home Page, a site with links to hundreds of print and electronic resources. Here teachers will find tips contributed by colleagues in the AP Statistics community, activities to support teaching AP Statistics, links to useful Web sites (including professional associations), and other relevant information submitted by AP professionals. An important component of the Web site is the Teachers Resources section (click on the link on the AP Statistics Course Home Page), an online application designed to give AP teachers a free, quick, and efficient way to search for resources that they can use to create lessons and activities for their classes or to improve their own understanding of a subject. The inventory of annotated references includes resources of all kindstextbooks, reference books, documents, Web sites, software, calculators, videos, and more with information on their origins, location, content, and quality. All of the resources have been reviewed by college or high school faculty and contain assessments of their value in teaching a successful AP course. Users of this database can add their own comments on each resource and contribute to a discussion of its usefulness. Clicking on the Institutes and Workshops link at the left of the AP Central screen takes you to a searchable database featuring information about training events offered through the College Board and other educational organizations and professional associations. Participating in an AP workshop for professional development is generally one of the first steps to becoming a successful AP teacher. These workshops offer intensive subject-specific training on the content and methods of teaching AP courses and serve as a forum for exchanging ideas, materials, activities, and helpful pedagogical strategies. Other features on AP Central include:
Information on the AP Course Audit and AP Statistics Curricular Requirements. The latest AP Statistics Course Description, which may be downloaded as a free PDF. Course overviews and exam tips written by current AP Statistics teachers. Official policies on calculator use. Feature articles written by both secondary- and college-level professionals, as well as profiles of stellar AP teachers and AP schools. The Teaching Resource Materials and Teaching Resource Reviews sections on the Statistics Course Home Page include articles written by teachers in the field. For example, one outstanding resource in this list is the AP Statistics Web Guide by Ruth Carver and Susan Peters. This excellent compilation is organized by the AP Topic Outline, with linkable interactive Web sites, lesson plans, and activities developed by statistics teachers. A monthly update about important AP developments and events. Information about professional opportunities in AP, including becoming a workshop faculty consultant or a Reader for the AP Exam. Weekly AP news stories.
23
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
Free-response questions and scoring guidelines for past AP Exams, as well as a complete Practice Exam available as a free download to teachers whose syllabi have been approved in the Course Audit process. A link to the College Board Store, which features a variety of print materials, including Released Exams and specialized modules for particular units of study, such as sampling and experimentation.
Electronic Discussion Group (EDG)
Many teachers of AP Statistics are of the opinion that the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group (the EDG, also informally known as the AP Stat listserv) is the best resource available to new (as well as experienced) teachers. The EDG is a lively, friendly, and helpful Web-based discussion group consisting of teachers of AP Statistics and college and university statistics professors who give their time and expertise to the AP Statistics community. Many of the authors of commonly used textbooks are members and frequent contributors. New teachers have expressed their appreciation for such a supportive forum in which to learn about AP Statistics. Besides addressing questions about the course content, it is an excellent resource for teaching tips, activities, and help using technologyboth computer and calculator. The EDG has been a resource for teachers of AP Statistics for years, and the archives of these discussions are available at http://mathforum.org/kb/forum.jspa?forumID=67. You can sign up by clicking on the EDG link on the AP Statistics Course Home Page.
Frequently Asked Questions About Statistical Concepts for New Teachers
A list of frequently asked questions from the EDG is maintained at AP Statistics FAQ (www.mrderksen.com/faq.htm), just one of many sections on Jared Derksens helpful Web site. It is the place to start when you have questions such as: What is the difference between using n versus using n-1? How do I explain confounding and blocking? How do I explain the meaning of r-squared? Are there any good review books? What can I do after the AP Exam is over? Click on Top 10!!!, which includes the most frequently asked questions. This site has cataloged excellent responses from some of the best in our field to these and other vexing questions. You can sometimes save time by checking the available FAQs before posting a question of your own. At this same FAQ site you can find a link for New AP Statistics Teachers. Here you will find general information, a list of recommended textbooks, technology resources, links to experienced teacher Web sites, and much more. (See also Jareds syllabus, later in this Teachers Guide.)
Experienced Teacher Web Sites
One of your greatest resources after AP Central will be the Web sites of experienced teachers such as Jared Derksen. Some of these sites can be accessed through his Web page, as discussed above. These colleagues have assembled lots of links to successful activities, excellent data sets, applets, projects, and other resources, which will save you a substantial amount of searching and trial and error. If you happen to click on one of the links, say projects, and it takes you to the Statistics EDG, simply type projects into the search dialog box, and it will take you to the appropriate responses in the archives. It is possible to be overwhelmed by the avalanche of available resources. You might start with only one or two of the experienced teacher Web sites, choosing, for example, Al Coons, Jared Derksen, Jason Molesky, or Sheila McGrail. Their Web addresses are listed in chapter 5 of this Teachers Guide. As you begin to get the course under your belt, work outward from your initial choices to the remaining very useful sites offered by the rest of the teachers listed in Jareds index. Each has a lot to offer in the way of interesting activities, teaching suggestions, handouts, old tests, and so forth. Many have posted a syllabus online.
24
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
Models for Statstcal Analyss
We have discussed the logistics of the course, your own intellectual preparation, and the support available to youbut as useful as all that information is, you may still be wondering how the AP Statistics curriculum actually plays out in the classroom. To give you some flavor of the course, three data sets are analyzed below:
Stroop effect (an experiment with two independent populations) Size of alligators (regression with nonlinear data) Plantar fasciitis experiment results
These analyses are in the spirit of, but perhaps a bit more extensive than, a type of investigative task that will appear on the AP Statistics Exam. They are included here to give you an idea of what you might expect an able student or group of students to do with a data set if they are given the time to do their best work. Notes and commentary are included along the way to help guide you in areas where students tend to have difficulty or neglect to be as thorough as needed. For these examples a variety of approaches are included to show the kinds of analyses that are appropriate in a variety of settings. The data sets have been chosen so that the analyses illustrate many, but not all, of the methods encompassed in the AP Statistics course. All of the following analyses can easily be done with a graphing calculator, although they might be more easily accomplished with the aid of a computer. In each of the following, a statistician has analyzed a set of data using the exploratory and inferential techniques incorporated in the AP Statistics course. Sometimes there is more than one useful way that a particular set of data can be analyzed, and different statisticians may well have approached the same data with other, perfectly valid, techniques. A data set like this one can be presented early in the course to introduce one idea (study design or comparing data sets) and then used again later to demonstrate other ideas (inference). A good example of this approach can be found at the North Carolina School of Mathematics Web site (http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_Inst/links_to_all_stats_institutes.htm) under the 2007 Statistical Institute. The activity is called Seeing Red.
Analysis 1. Stroop Effect
The original study that led to the interference phenomenon discussed here was first published in 1935 by J. Ridley Stroop.6 C. James Goodwin refers to this study as possibly the most widely replicated study in psychology.7 The phenomenon is widely known among psychologists as the Stroop effect, and variations of the original experiments are still published today in the psychological literature. In the history of experimental psychology related to cognitive processes and learning, the concept of interference has been very important in the literature. Studying the associations and habits that either facilitate or inhibit cognitive behavior helps psychologists understand how learning can be improved. One such study involved the presentation of colors (red, green, brown, blue, and purple) to college psychology students. Students were randomly assigned to two groups and given a name the color of the word test. Subjects in the first group were presented with colors in the form of a written word, and their task was to name the color of the word as quickly as possible. For example, the word red would be printed in red,
6. J. R. Stroop, Studes of Interference n Seral Verbal Reactons, Journal of Experimental Psychology 18 (1935): 643-62. 7. C. James Goodwn, Research in Psychology: Methods and Design, 2nd ed. (New York: Wley, 1998), 212.
25
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
and the correct response was red. The other group was also presented with colors, but the printed words did not match the color of the word. For example, the word red might be printed in blue, the word brown printed in green, and so on. The task of the subjects in this second group was also to name the color of the word, ignoring the word itself. That is, if the word green was printed in blue, the subject should correctly respond with blue. The experiment was designed to investigate the theory that reading is so automatic in adults that the subjects reading would interfere with the correct identification of the color. If this theory of interference is correct, the subjects presented with the colors matching the words should correctly identify the color of the word faster. The data from this experiment are reproduced below. Each student in both of the experimental groups was presented with 100 words. For each word, the student continued to respond until the correct color was identified and then moved on to the next word. The total time in seconds to name the color of all 100 words is recorded for each student. Times have been rounded to the nearest second. Times for the Two Experimental Groups Different color 40 45 90 69 75 59 102 78 21 86 Same color 37 33 45 43 53 37 47 53 40
An initial look at graphical displays of these data suggests that the reading is consistent with the theory of interference with the identification of the colors. Times with Different Colors 1 02 03 50 04 9 05 9 06 85 07 6 08 0 09 2 10 Times with Same Color 377 0357 33
Key: 3|2 represents 32 seconds
The above back-to-back stemplot shows that the time measurements produced from the presentation where the colors matched the words were consistently smaller than when the colors and words did not match. The median time for correctly identifying 100 colors when the color matched the word (43 seconds)
26
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
was lower than the median time for correctly identifying 100 colors when the color was different from the word (72 seconds). It also appears that the response times produced from the dissonant colors and words were much more variable than those produced with the same color, as the range for the same color (20 seconds) was much smaller than the range for the dissonant color or word combinations (81 seconds). Both distributions of times were relatively symmetric. This is also apparent from the parallel dotplots below. Either of the two graphical displays would be an acceptable way to present the data.
These conclusions are supported by the summary statistics. Summary Statistics for Time Measures Same color Different color Mean = 43.1 seconds Mean = 66.5 seconds Median = 72 seconds Median = 43 seconds n=9 n = 10 Std dev = 7.08 seconds Std dev = 25.15 seconds One might be tempted to conclude that the mean times for these groups are significantly different by just examining the previous dotplots or stemplots. The two distributions do indeed look different, but could these differences have occurred by random chance? To determine whether the observed difference between the mean time when the color and the word match and the mean time when the color and word are different is statistically significant, a two-sample t test could be considered. Students tend to throw around the word significant with indiscriminant abandon. Caution them that they must use statistical terms correctly and in context. Because the graphical displays lead us to suspect a difference, another option would be to estimate the magnitude of the difference in the two means via a confidence interval based on the t distribution. We
27
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
must first check the conditions necessary for the confidence interval procedures to be valid. It is important that students check all relevant conditions before conducting any inference procedure. Do the conditions exist that justify our choice of a particular inference procedure? A good discussion of assumptions versus conditions can be found in an article by Dave Bock on the AP Statistics Home Page under Teaching Resource Materials: Is That an Assumption or a Condition? What conditions must be verified to construct a confidence interval to estimate the difference in two means?
Independent samples are randomly drawn from two distinct populations, or the two groups are generated by a random allocation mechanism. Check: Recall that the subjects in the experiment were randomly assigned to the two treatments, creating two independent groups. In general, the underlying populations should be normally distributed. This matters most for small samples. If n is small, say less than 30, the observed data should not show extreme skewness, and there should not be any outliers. Check: The dotplots constructed previously do not suggest asymmetry in either underlying population, and there do not appear to be any outliers present. (One could look at the stemplots as well.) An alternative approach is to construct a normal probability plot for each treatment. This plot graphs each data value against its corresponding z-score in the distribution. These are not easy to do by hand, so it is expected that students will use their calculators to construct the plots. If the distributions of the data are approximately normal, the resulting plot will be roughly linear. We can see in the plots below that this appears to be the case for the Stroop data.
Thus, it appears that the t procedure for two independent samples is appropriate.
28
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
Let µS = the population mean time for correctly naming the color in 100 repetitions when the color and the word of the color were the same, and D = the population mean time for correctly naming the color in 100 repetitions when the color and the word of the color were different. Always identify any symbols used in the procedure. The parameter of interest is the difference in mean times for the two populations, that is, D S. A two-sample t interval for independent means will be constructed. The appropriate formula would be: ( xd xs ) t* s1 2 n1 s2 2 n2
The 95 percent confidence interval for estimating the difference in the two population means (different 41.74 with df = 10.56. Most students will likely do their minus same color treatments) is: 5.03 D S work for this type of problem using the statistical test on their calculator and read the above df value from the calculator, whereas others will do their work by hand and use the degrees of freedom based on 1 minus the smaller sample size minus 1 (df = 8). This latter value is a bit conservative in that it tends to produce an interval with slightly higher than desired coverage probability. (Note that the interval was obtained by using the nonpooled option on the calculator, which is valid whether or not the population variances are equal. The pooled option is a special version of the two-sample t statistic that assumes the two populations have the same variance. The best advice for comparing two means is, dont!) We are 95 percent confident that the interval from 5.03 to 41.74 seconds captures the true difference in mean times to correctly identify the color of the word in 100 repetitions. The construction of a confidence interval should always have an accompanying interpretation of the resulting values. Notice that zero lies outside the confidence interval. From this we conclude that the difference in the mean times produced from presenting the colors with the correct verbal description and the mean times produced from presenting the colors with the incorrect verbal description differ significantly. In fact, the 95 percent confidence interval gives us a set of plausible values for those differences. If zero had been in the interval, it is plausible that there is no meaningful difference between the two populations. There would be insufficient evidence to conclude that a difference actually existed. It is important for students to understand that failure to conclude a difference exists is NOT confirmation that the two groups are the same! In summary, it seems that the investigators were correct in their conjecture that the dissonant word/ color treatment produces times that tend to be greater than those produced by the consistent word/color treatment. The subjects were college psychology students, and they were randomly assigned to the two treatments. Thus, it appears that for the psychology students who participated in this experiment, the differences in the times are reliably different. If the college psychology students can be regarded as a random sample from the adult populationa proposition that is by no means obviousit may be that these results would generalize to the adult population.
Class Activity: Conducting the Stroop Experiment
If you do an Internet search for Stroop effect, several useful Web sites appear, some of which allow you to actually gather some data for class. One of the best is at http://faculty.washington.edu/chudler/words.html. By clicking on the timer you can keep track of the length of time it takes to conduct each part of the above experiment. Have students record the times and bring them to class. Variations also exist, such as animals (same name as animal pictured /different name), numbers, and shapes. You can conduct analyses using times for males and females correctly naming the same color, and then males and females correctly naming the different color, or even students comparisons of themselves reading the same and different colors (matched pairing).
29
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
Analysis 2. Size of Alligators
Biologists who take aerial photographs of wildlife habitats often monitor many wildlife populations. Information about the number of animals and their whereabouts is important data for organizations seeking to protect certain species and to ensure the safety of surrounding human populations. This has become more important as housing developments continually encroach on animal habitats, bringing humans and animals in more direct contact. In addition, it is sometimes possible to monitor certain characteristics of the animals. The length of an alligator can be estimated quite accurately from aerial photographs and from visual sightings from air or boat. However, the alligators weight is much more difficult to determine. In the following example, data on the length (in inches) and weight (in pounds) of a sample of alligators captured in central Florida are used to develop a model from which the weight of an alligator can be predicted from its length. (Note: This activity appeared in the 2002 AP Statistics Teachers Guide, but the data have been updated for this publication.) Characteristics of Alligators (Central Florida Sample) Length (inches) Weight (pounds) Length (inches) Weight (pounds) 104 181 110 153 100 115 88 78 140 587 82 68 58 28 74 57 120 311 61 44 94 141 138 496 63 37 89 106 105 119 68 39 69 36 78 71 72 65 114 211 128 310 93 109 98 115 78 57 82 91
30
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
An examination of the scatterplot of weight against length reveals that the relationship between these variables is not a simple linear one but rather curved. A successful model must take into account this nonlinear relationship. We further note that there are two particularly large alligators that in the scatterplot appear to be somewhat separated from the bulk of the data. There does not appear to be any reason to suspect these more extreme observations are the result of a measurement or other type of error, although this should always be considered when there are outliers present.
As a starting point, lets consider a linear model. The Minitab output below represents the fitting of a simple linear model to the data. The regression equation is Weight = -358 + 5.45 Length Predictor Constant Length S = 63.6182 Coef 358.16 5.4549 SE Coef 52.77 0.5552 T 6.79 9.82 R-Sq (adj) = 79.9 percent MS 390653 4047 F 96.52 P 0.000 P 0.000 0.000
R-Sq = 80.8 percent SS 390653 93087 483740
Analysis of Variance Source DF Regression 1 Residual error 23 Total 24
There is more information in the computer output than an AP student is responsible for knowing. It is important for a student to be able to sift through the output and find the relevant numerical values.
31
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
An examination of the residual plot (below) shows that there is a pattern in the residuals. Such a curved pattern indicates that a linear model is not likely to be the best fit for these data.
There are many possible transformations that might improve the model, and most textbooks give strategies for making a good choice. In this example, we will concentrate on the use of logarithms to straighten the data. This is something that is particularly helpful to my students, since straightening data is something they do in physics, when they gather data for motion down an incline. The scope of the AP Statistics course limits itself to the linearization of data. The course does not address fitting quadratic, cubic, quartic, or logistic models to data. You might consider looking at these during any postexam time you have. There are several reasonable methods we might try to straighten the datataking the log of the response variable, taking the log of the explanatory variable, or taking the log of both variables. It sometimes takes a bit of trial and error to come up with a best-fitting model. This process involves taking the log of a variable (we could use either common or natural logs) and examining the resulting scatterplot for linearity and the residual plot for no pattern. After some trial and error, we will take the natural log of the response variable, weight. An examination of the resulting scatterplot for the transformed data indicates a more linear relationship between length and ln(weight).
32
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
The residual plot above indicates that this model is a better fit. There does not appear to be a readily apparent pattern in these residuals, as there was in the residual plot for the original model.
33
Chapter 2 Chapter 1 Important Notes
1. The residual plots in computer output often differ from those that are normally created on the calculator. Computer software is likely to plot the residuals against the fitted (predicted) values from the model, whereas most calculators will plot the residuals against the original or transformed xvalues. The reason for this difference is that the computer software assumes a multivariable analysis is being carried out, whereas the calculator assumes a simple linear regression. In a simple linear regression, calculator plots of the residual versus x and the residual versus y-hat give the student equivalent information; this is not so in a multiple regression. Be sure to point this out to students. 2. On the AP Exam, it is not expected that students will be doing as much calculator-intensive transformation work as this problem implies. A more typical scenario might present a problem situation with one or more possible models to fit the data and accompanying computer output and plots. Students would be expected to work with the given models to answer questions. It would not be unusual if they were asked to decide which model is the most appropriate to use to answer the question and then to justify their choice of model. 3. Most current textbooks include a fair amount of computer output. Students should be able to read and interpret a variety of output from different software packages. Make sure they are exposed to such during the year. After the transformation, the Minitab regression for the alligator problem is given below. The regression equation is ln(weight) = 1.49 + 0.0341 Length Predictor Constant Length S = 0.165087 Coef 1.4854 0.034111 SE Coef 0.1369 0.001441 T 10.85 23.68 P 0.000 0.000
R-Sq = 96.1 percent SS 15.276 0.627 15.903
R-Sq (adj) = 95.9 percent MS 15.276 0.027 F 560.51 P 0.000
Analysis of Variance Source DF Regression 1 Residual Error 23 Total 24
If we choose to adopt this model using ln(weight) and length, we would test hypotheses and construct confidence intervals using the transformed model. However, we are more likely to use the model to predict the weight of an alligator based on its length. It is important to note that students do not need to back-transform the model; however, they will be expected to be able to back-transform any predictions into the original scale. For example, using the transformed model of ln(weight ) an alligator that is 90 inches in length. ln(weight ) ln(weight ) weight weight 1.49 4.559 1.49 0.341(length), predict the weight of
0.0341(90)
e 4.559 95.49 pounds
34
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
The model suggests that we can predict that an alligator measuring 90 inches in length will weigh approximately 95.5 pounds. A word of caution is in order. Once you have a good linear model, it is tempting to apply it to all possible values of x. Although a linear model can often do a reasonable job of summarizing a relationship over a given range of x-values, it should not be applied to values outside the data range used to generate the model, because the model may not hold beyond the given values. Extrapolating too far from the data can lead to errors in predictions.
Analysis 3. Plantar Fasciitis Experiment Results
Plantar fasciitis is caused by the tearing of the plantar fascia, a ropelike band of fibrous tissues that runs from the heel to the toes and supports the arch. The tearing tends to be caused by standing, working, or exercising on hard surfaces (concrete and asphalt, in particular). This condition chronically afflicts teachers, nurses, and athletes of all types. Even mild activity such as walking or jogging can lead to a bout of plantar fasciitis, a nagging injury that may take six to nine months to heal. For about 10 percent of sufferers, recovery may take even longer. In the past, a common exercise for this injury was the Achilles tendon stretch, which involves a series of exercises that stretch the calf muscles. A team of medical researchers was interested in studying whether a new exercise designed to stretch the plantar fascia might be more effective than the currently recommended exercise in speeding recovery from this injury. The new stretch involves holding the toes and curling them backward toward the shin, while flexing the ankle. Researchers recommended that the new procedure be done immediately after the sufferers have gotten out of bed and after other periods of inactivity. A 12-week trial comparing the new plantar fascia stretch to the Achilles stretch is to be performed using 120 randomly selected patients who are suffering from plantar fasciitis but have never tried the Achilles stretch. They would be taught the proper techniques for either the Achilles stretch or the plantar fascia stretch. At the beginning and end of the study, the researchers will measure the patients mobility in the foot afflicted with the plantar fasciitis. The researchers believe that the new treatment will be more effective; that is, that the proportion of plantar fasciitis sufferers in the plantar stretch group who have improved mobility in their foot at the end of the 12-week period will be higher than the proportion for the Achilles stretch group. Lets first focus on the experimental design aspects of this study. How should the subjects be randomized to the treatment groups? There are many methods of accomplishing the random assignment of the patients. For example, randomly select a patient and flip a coin. If the coin is heads, assign the sufferer to the Achilles stretch group. If it is tails, assign the patient to the plantar fascia stretch group. This method will almost surely not yield equal sample sizes. If equal sample sizes are desired, the following method will result in a completely randomized design. Assign each patient a unique random number from 001 to 120, using a random number generator on a calculator, statistical software, or a random number table. The numbers will then be sorted from smallest to largest. The patients with the first 60 numbers in the ordered list will be assigned to the Achilles stretch. The remaining 60 will be assigned to the plantar fascia stretch.
35
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
Students should be able to discuss assigning subjects by various randomization methods: a random number table, drawing numbers or names from a hat, or flipping a number cube or coin, for example. The important feature is that the chance of being assigned to each treatment group is the same for each participant. Why is randomization important in this experiment? Why not just let the subjects choose to which group they will belong? Without random assignment of the plantar fasciitis patients to the two exercises, it is possible that the two treatment groups could differ in some way that affects the outcome of the experiment. For example, suppose the patients in one of the treatment groups knew each other and shared a similar work environment. Their company decides to install carpeting throughout the workplace, replacing the hard surfaces that had previously existed. If all these workers were in the same treatment group, the researchers would not know if the reduction in reported pain is attributable to the treatment or to the carpet installation. Any observed difference in the results for the two exercise groups would be confounded with the effects of installing the carpet. Randomization is insurance against any such pattern, whether we are aware of it or not. The control group for comparison purposes in this experiment is the standard treatment of the Achilles stretch. Should there be an additional do-nothing (placebo) group? The addition of such a placebo group would enable researchers to determine if either type of exercise had more benefit than no exercise. No placebo group is necessary for this experiment. The objective is only to determine whether the new treatment is better than the current one. The burden of proving efficacy is common in medical trials, and to gain approval one must always show that the proposed new treatment is better than the standard one. Is blinding possible in this experiment? It is not possible to blind the participants, as they are being directed to perform one of the stretches. The evaluators of the results should not know which participant was assigned to which treatment group, so that their conclusions are not biased in favor of one of the treatments. To what population might any results be generalized? Suppose we found that the plantar fascia stretch was more effective than the Achilles stretch. If we truly have a random sample of all plantar fasciitis sufferers, then the results of this experiment could be generalized to that group. If, on the other hand, the random sample came from athletes, then the results of this experiment do not directly apply to nurses or teachers, for example, because they were not part of the experiment. What inference procedures can be conducted? Researchers often wish to examine the difference between populations with regard to the proportion falling into a particular response category. Typically, observational studies draw independent random samples from two distinct populations, e.g., males versus females, or smokers versus nonsmokers. On the other hand, if we were to sample husbands versus wives, there is little reason to believe that whatever we might measure about these two populations is unrelated. In experiments, the process of random allocation yields the two groups. In the plantar fasciitis example, the populations are the hypothetical populations of those who could have been given the treatment; they are represented by the two treatment groups generated by the randomized comparative experiment. Can it be concluded that the new stretching procedure was better at increasing mobility in sufferers of plantar fasciitis, or could any difference in the two groups be attributed to the natural variation that exists among sample statistics? This question calls for a hypothesis test. The parameter of interest in our study is the true difference in the proportions of plantar fasciitis patients in the two treatment groups who had increased mobility in the foot.
36
Advice for AP Statistics Teachers About AP Statistics
Let p1 = proportion of plantar fasciitis patients who would experience increased mobility using the plantar fascia stretch procedure. Let p2 = proportion of plantar fasciitis patients who would experience increased mobility using the Achilles stretch procedure. The null hypothesis is a hypothesis of equality: that is, there is no difference in the proportions for the two populations. The alternative hypothesis is that a difference does exist. In this case, a directional hypothesis is needed: we anticipate that the proportion of plantar fasciitis patients who experienced increased mobility is higher for the plantar fascia stretch procedure. H o : p1 H a : p1 p2 p2
Based on researcher measurements of mobility, the data showed that 52 of the 60 subjects assigned to the plantar fascia group experienced an increase in mobility, while 44 of the 60 in the Achilles group experienced an increase in mobility. Because we want to know if a difference exists, we will consider a two-proportion z test. Are the necessary conditions satisfied to conduct this procedure?
Independent samples are randomly drawn from two populations or are generated by a random comparative experiment. Condition check: While we are told that the patients were randomly selected, the key element in an experiment is that some randomization process is used to create the two independent treatment groups. In this case, we are told that subjects were randomly assigned to either the Achilles stretch group or the plantar fascia stretch group. If the data are sampled without replacement, the sample should not exceed 10 percent of the population. Condition check: We do not know the size of the population of plantar fasciitis sufferers from which the sample was drawn. However, our inference would be valid if that population size were to exceed 1,200, which is a reasonable assumption. Both groups are big enough that at least 5 successes and 5 failures are observed in each. Condition check: In the plantar fascia stretch group there were 52 successes and 8 failures, and in the Achilles stretch group there were 44 successes and 16 failures. Different books use slightly different conditionssome use 10 or 15 instead of 5. What is important is that the student checks some value.
ˆ ˆ The sample statistic p1 p2 (the difference between the sample proportions) estimates the parameter p1 p2 (the difference between the population proportions). To find the standard error, we assume that the null hypothesis is true so that p1 p2 pc , the combined estimate of the common population proportion, success1 success2 ˆ and calculate pc . n1 n2
ˆ For this problem, pc
52 60
44 60
96 120
0.80
The test statistic is
z
ˆ ˆ p1 p2 ( p1 p2 ) ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ pc (1 pc ) pc (1 pc ) n1 n2
.867 .733 (0) .8(1 .8) .8(1 .8) 60 60
1.835
37
Chapter 2 Chapter 1
How rare is this value? Could a difference this large have happened by random chance? What is the probability of getting a value at least as extreme as z = 1.835 if there really is no difference between the two treatments (that is, the null hypothesis is true)? This is called the P-value. For this situation, the P-value = p(z > 1.835) = 0.0333. If there really was no difference between the proportion of subjects in the Achilles stretch group and the proportion of subjects in the plantar fascia stretch group who experienced increased mobility, we would have observed a difference at least this large only about 3 percent of the time. If our decision rule were to reject the null hypothesis if the difference could have occurred by random chance less than 5 percent of the time (that is, the Type I error is .05), we would state that there is enough evidence to conclude that the plantar fascia stretch was effective in significantly increasing mobility. If we had set a criterion to reject if the difference could have occurred by chance less than 1 percent of the time, we would have failed to reject the null hypothesis. In this instance we would not conclude that the plantar fascia stretch was effective in significantly increasing mobility. Suppose the question was, How much actual difference is there between the proportions of plantar fasciitis patients in the two treatment groups who experienced increased mobility; that is, what is the gap between the two population proportions? We could estimate that difference with a confidence interval. A 98 percent confidence interval for estimating the difference in the above experiment is given by (0.034, 0.301). Note that while 0 lies within the interval, there are other plausible values for the difference in population proportions in addition to zero. Caution: Failing to reject the null hypothesis does not mean that the two stretch methods are the same. We are just unable to conclude that a difference exists. To many students, this is confusing. Hypothesis procedures are used to assess the evidence against the null hypothesis, not to assess the evidence in support of it. Failure to find evidence against the null hypothesis does not prove the null hypothesis to be true. You will also need to help students understand how to write their conclusions. They seem to have more trouble stating a conclusion when they fail to reject a null hypothesis. In the nonrejection case, students should avoid phrases such as accept the null or retain the null when writing their conclusion. Examine past AP Exam problems and browse several textbooks to see various ways that correct conclusions can be written. Some textbooks have analogized conducting a hypothesis test to a jury trial. Finding a defendant not guilty does not necessarily mean that the defendant is innocent. The evidence just was not strong enough to get a conviction. Using the jury analogy in class can be very beneficial as an introduction to the idea of a significance test. This analogy can also be used to illustrate Type I and Type II errors, the consequences of such errors, power, and even the initial assumption that the null hypothesis is true (presumption of innocence). Now that weve looked at how to start up your AP Statistics course, and how to prepare to teach this challenging subject, lets turn to the question of developing a syllabus. In the next chapter Ill give some tips on course organization, and eight experienced statistics instructors will share their syllabi and offer suggestions for teaching strategies, grading policies, helpful resources, and student activities that you might consider for your own classroom.
38
Chapter 3 Course Organzaton
Syllabus Development
No single AP Statistics course would be appropriate for all students and all learning environments. Some teachers will have well-prepared, engaged, highly motivated students; a new textbook; and lots of resources, including a computer lab. In other years and other schools, the situation may be a bit less rosy. That is why this chapter aims to teach by example. One of the best ways to approach creating your own syllabus is to see what other instructors have done in a wide range of circumstances. That is the purpose of the eight sample syllabi presented in this chapter. In the meantime, some general guidelines to help you in the creation and refinement of your own course syllabus are presented below.
Setting Expectations
This is a college-level course with demanding content. Students should be prepared from the outset to work hard so that there are no surprises down the road. They need to be dedicated and to work conscientiously outside of class. I tell my students to expect a minimum of 30 to 40 minutes of homework each night. In addition to daily class work, they are responsible for the AP problem sets that I have assembled (which consist of two to three previous AP Exam questions to be completed and turned in each week), as well as several long-term projects.
Course Planner
When developing your syllabus, you should read the AP Statistics Course Description carefully. Keep it, as well as your textbook, close at hand while you are planning. Its also important to make sure the syllabus meets the AP Statistics Curricular Requirements: go to apcentral.collegeboard.com/courseaudit for information on submitting your syllabus for audit review. Once you have read the Topic Outline in the Course Description, reviewed the table of contents of your textbook, checked the curricular requirements on AP Central, and read through the various syllabi in this chapter, it is time to tackle the arrangement of your own academic year. Ample review time is necessary prior to the AP Exam in May. You might want to look at your plan in reverse; that is, using your school calendar and the date of the exam, plan backward from that time. For example, because our school is on trimesters, I look at the year in thirds. I make a grid of 12 weeks on a page and map it out by textbook sections, with the last segment ending approximately a week prior to the AP Exam. After accounting for school holidays, trimester exam periods, and the ever-present special school event schedules, I work my way back to the beginning of the year. Included in my grid are lesson days, test days, review days, computer days (it is a struggle to get the lab), and several data-gathering days. You may need to make allowances for the fact that certain sections of your textbook require more time than others. Different items in the Topic Outline take varying amounts of time. In some lessons I may
39
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
be able to check two items off the list in a day, but others may take a week. I may actually spend less time reviewing than other instructors do, because my students have already received a great deal of practice with AP free-response questions throughout the year. If you are a new teacher of this course, I would suggest aiming for two weeks of review, if possible. During this review time I tend to concentrate on sample multiple-choice questions and some of the more challenging investigative tasks. I also give students one of the AP Statistics Released Exams to complete and score (giving them insight into the scoring process as well as putting them in the examtaking environment). It is important for them to see a complete set of multiple-choice questions and realize that this section emphasizes concepts over computation. There is a marked difference between the 1997 and 2002 Released Exams. The advent of calculators with statistical capabilities has changed the nature of many of the questions, and most of the calculator-driven multiple-choice questions on the 1997 exam had been eliminated by 2002. The latter exam is much more representative of what students should expect to see each May. The 2007 exam has now been released, and a complete Statistics Practice Exam is available on AP Central to teachers whose syllabi have been approved in the Course Audit process, providing more problems for you to use. Working with previous AP Exam questions throughout the year and discussing the scoring guidelines communicates the level of preparedness that will be expected on the exam. It also emphasizes that success is not derived from calculations alone. Justifying procedures and interpreting results in a math class will be a new experience for many students. Give them lots of practice. Have them strive for clarity in their writing as well. Reviewing the model solutions in the published scoring commentaries is always instructive for students. It is helpful to give some of these old problems as timed-writing exercises.
First Things First As I designed my syllabus, I knew I wanted to include a minimum of one data-centered activity each week (such as comparing the dexterity of students left and right hands, or determining how many candies must be sampled before finding a green one), so I made that a priority in planning what to teach and when. Inspiration for activities came from statistics books, the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group, and suggestions from experienced teachers. The next task was to convince my district to provide funds to buy supplies for the activities, such as Barbie® dolls from thrift stores, multicolored candy, duct tape, dried beans, dice, cards, ice cream, and inflatable beach balls that looked like the earth. Finally, it was time to map out the course. With the aid of a school calendar and textbook, I blocked out two weeks of review time at the end of the year and allowed for school activities and vacations. The remaining instructional days were budgeted by the amount of emphasis each topic was given in the AP Course Descriptionbut I made sure there was at least one datafocused exercise each week. Flexibility in planning a syllabus is essential, however, so after each years AP Exam I analyze my students strengths and weaknesses and adjust instructional days accordingly. Joyce Smart, Logan High School, Logan, Utah
You will also need to decide how much of a role the calculator will play in your classroom. You will want to include some calculator-based activities, which are useful for data exploration, conducting simulations, and easing the tedium of excessive arithmetic. However, do not let students use the calculator as a shortcut or an excuse for not showing their work! When working with probabilities, z values, and t values, it is a good idea to switch back and forth between using the calculators built-in probability distributions (found with the calculator keystrokes 2nd DISTR) and using the tables available for the AP Exam (tables A, B, and C in the Formulas and Tables section of the Course Description). Students should have facility with both approaches, but some may have a decided preference. The pitfalls of using calculator-speak are discussed in chapter 4.
40
Course Organization About AP Statistics
As you read the sample syllabi in this chapter, search the Web, visit the AP Statistics Course Home Page, and go to workshops, you will undoubtedly come across many interesting and exciting activities that you will want to try, but as a new teacher of the course you may need to exercise some restraint. Your first responsibility is to complete the course in a timely fashion. Some of these activities might be better left to subsequent years when you have the course content under your belt and a better notion of pacing. Rarely do we get the timing exactly right the first year.
Student Projects
Many teachers of introductory statistics say that student projects are an indispensable part of their course. A student project is one in which a student or a group of students define a problem, collect data on that problem, analyze their dataincluding the use of appropriate graphical displaysand write a report on their conclusions or present an oral report to the class. Try to incorporate such projects into your plans. Until students get their hands dirty, many may not appreciate the fine points of doing research that involves the collection and analysis of data. Letting your students wrestle with data they have gathered themselves can be very instructive and makes the course more personal. You might consider doing one simple project each semester during the first year and expanding after that. Remember that you will have to grade projects and still keep up with the current material. To keep from being overwhelmed by the grading, one new teacher who had a very large class assigned a project in which students were required to work with a partner. The students still benefited from collecting and analyzing data, but the teachers grading workload was cut in half. The debates students have with each other when developing a report are also highly effective learning experiences. Projects can be short or can require many weeks to complete. You will find many examples of projects in the Student Activities sections of the sample syllabi presented in this chapter. A number of projects are described in the 2002 AP Statistics Teachers Guide as well. The 2002 guide is something a veteran teacher of the course should have in his or her possession. You might be able to borrow one from a colleague in your area. You can also look at experienced teacher Web sites to find lots of examples. I suggest starting with Al Coonss site (www.bbn-school.org/us/math/ap_stats). One further source is the AP Statistics Course Home Page, where a link to the section After the Exam: Activities and Projects appears under the Teaching Resource Materials heading. A good suggestion is to keep some of the best projects from your previous year(s) to use as examples in the next. This will usually raise the quality of student work.
Learning by Doing Nothing helps students consolidate their knowledge like a project. As much is learned from the iterative process of designing the study and collecting data as from writing the final paper. Full-blown projects might include sections on research questions/variables, sample selection/randomization, data collection methodology, data presentation, statistical test/analysis, a discussion of results, weaknesses/suggested improvements, and conclusion. Projects are time-consuming and should be spread over several weeks. The most instructive ones allow students to find topics related to their own interests while still meeting the teachers detailed expectations. Expect multiple proposals that grow in length. Allowing students to evaluate others proposals is very effective. L arge sample size is less important than the process. Simple random samples are rarely available. Many real questions are first studied with small sample sizes. Surveys or using published data takes less time, but actually measuring (how far golf balls travel when hit with different clubs) or counting (do women drive SUVs more often than men?) can be more satisfying. Check each paper against your list of expectations, but grade holistically as you would for a history paper (see A Guide for Scoring Free-Response Statistics Questions in the AP Statistics Course Description (pp. 2930 in the 2009, 2010 edition). Examples of projects can be found by searching the Web for AP Statistics project or at my class Web site: www.bbn-school.org/us/math/ap_stats. Al Coons, Buckingham Browne & Nichols School, Cambridge, Massachusetts
41
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Build in Time for Student Projects One of my favorite things about teaching AP Statistics is that we have time to spend on projects, hands-on demonstrations, and computer labs. When planning my syllabus for a recent school year, I divided the course into five major units: (1) univariate data, (2) bivariate data, (3) survey and experimental design, (4) probability and sampling distributions, and (5) inference. I referred to the sample syllabi in the 2002 AP Statistics Teachers Guide to help me decide how much time to allot for each segment. I then assigned a project for every unit. Some were completed by students individually, and others were partner or group efforts. I made certain to build into my calendar several days in each unit that gave the students time to work on their projects during class in the computer lab. I also set aside time for students to present their projects to the class. We spent the last two weeks before the AP Exam taking practice tests and reviewing test-taking strategies. It is gratifying to teach a course where there is time for students to explore the topics they are learning and to apply them to issues that are of interest to them. Lina Ellis, The Westminster Schools, Atlanta, Georgia
Evaluation
When you use challenging material such as past AP Exam questions on your own tests and quizzes, make sure that your grading reflects the level of rigor of such questions. If performance on these questions counts as part of a students grade, it is best to score them using the published guidelines and weight them as a percentage of the test. Relatively speaking, in my class the median score on a test tends to fall pretty much in the middle of the B range. If you use AP Exam questions throughout the year and count them as part of the students grades, you should consider a grading policy that does not rely on a strict percentage-based system90 to 100 percent = A, 80 to 89 percent = B, and so on. Students who earn even 80 percent of the points on an AP Statistics Exam could well be on their way to earning an AP grade of 5. Assuming you are scoring a student response with the published rubric, a student who is earning 3 out of 4 points on each freeresponse question is doing well. For example, my AP problem sets (two to three previously used questions due each week) count for 5 percent of the grade in the first trimester, 10 percent in the second, and 30 percent in the third. Students thus have a vested interest in completing them, but their grade is not jeopardized early in the year while they are learning how to write a good response for the question. Even then, the percentage grades (out of 28 points) for the seven AP sets completed in the first trimester can be adjusted so that the median class grade approximately corresponds to a B/B- range. By the third trimester, the AP sets are due every six days or so and in aggregate effectively count as much as one of the tests. Whatever grading policies you use, they should be fair, flexible (so that you can ask challenging questions), and clearly communicated to the students. For example, it is important to think about and establish your expectations when it comes to using published AP Exam questions. Will they serve as review problems only, or will they count as part of the students grade? Remember that students also have access to the scoring guidelines published on the College Board Web site, so giving AP questions as take-home assignments bears some risk. Will students be allowed to use their notes and textbooks in answering these? May they collaborate? In my school, students may ask either of the two statistics teachers for a hint if they are unsure how to proceed, but they may not use each other or any sources outside their notes and textbook.
42
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Eght Sample Syllab
Because there is so much variation among schools and diversity among students, eight sample course outlines that illustrate different ways to approach the course are presented in this chapter. Six syllabi come from high schoolspublic and private, large and small, urban and suburban. Two college syllabi are included as examples of how statistics is taught at the introductory collegiate level. Be sure to read all of the following syllabiwhich cover a wide range of academic environments and calendarseven those that you do not think apply to your situation or textbook. They all contain valuable teaching tips and strategies, resources, projects, and suggestions for student activities that you are certain to find useful in your own classroom. Each syllabus was written by a teacher of a successful statistics course. These instructors have provided information regarding their school environments, teaching strategies, materials, assignments, favorite Web sites and AP questions, resources, postAP Exam projects, and data-gathering activities. Most important, they share their course planners. It is instructive to examine these for pacing guidelines. Some course schedules are organized by the day and others by the week. This will provide you with a good idea of the amount of time to devote to various topics, such as experimental design, probability, inference, and exploratory data analysis. Note carefully the length of class periods and the number of available days to teach the course, and make adjustments to your own course planner accordingly. To open this section, two college professors have contributed syllabi, each of which provides a clear example of the introductory postsecondary classes that high school AP courses are designed to reproduce. Katherine Halvorsen at Smith College in Massachusetts includes two lab activities taught by Allison Crawfordexploring tests and confidence intervals for differences in proportions between cars parked in two parking lots and a Fathom lab for simulating the distribution of the slope in a simple linear regression model. Jackie Miller at Ohio State University teaches in a quarter system, where the courses are only 10 weeks long. She has therefore provided syllabi for two introductory statistics courses that together comprise most of the high school AP curriculum. She has included some nice activities that can be adapted to the high school classroom, and her course planners contain apt teaching advice within each chapter description as well. The high school syllabi follow. Michael Allwood, who teaches at Brunswick School in Greenwich, Connecticut, offers a number of AP tips throughout his course planner, as well as some simulation activities that can be done on a calculator. Anne Carroll teaches in a school in Kennett Square, Pennsylvania, an area with a substantial immigrant worker population. She favors a Socratic method in her teaching and uses a pair-share technique for student learning activities and labs. Dora Daniluk comes from a large suburban high school in Houston and includes quite a few class activities and applets, along with restaurant and helicopter projects that she has done. From Rancho Cucamonga High School, near Los Angeles, Jared Derksen shares one of his crossword puzzles, some of his favorite AP questions that he uses in class, and his end-of-year cumulative project. Jeane Swaynos, from Seminole High School in Sanford, Florida, presents some good ideas for working with diverse classes that include both highly motivated and more challenged students. Josh Tabors syllabus for Glen A. Wilson High School in Hacienda Heights, California, explains his use of partially completed notes to save some class time. He includes an example of this, as well as his daily planner, homework assignments, and favorite AP questions. Since writing this, Josh has changed schools. He is now at Canyon del Oro High School, in Tucson, Arizona, where he is using the same textbook but on a block schedule. He reports that he is basically doing everything the same way, except doubling up lessons on the block schedule days.
43
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Important Note: The AP Course Audit
The syllabi included in this Teachers Guide were developed prior to the initiation of the AP Course Audit and the identification of the current AP Statistics Curricular Requirements. These syllabi contain rich resources and will be useful in generating ideas for your AP course. In addition to providing detailed course planners, the syllabi contain descriptions of classroom activities and assignments, along with helpful teaching strategies. However, they should not be used in their entirety as models that would be authorized under the guidelines of the AP Course Audit. To view the current AP Curricular Requirements and examples of syllabi that have been developed since the launch of the AP Course Audit and therefore meet all of the AP Statistics Curricular Requirements, go to the Course Audit pages on AP Central (apcentral.collegeboard.com/courseaudit).
44
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sample Syllabus 1
Katherine Halvorsen, Instructor of Record Allison Crawford, Laboratory Instructor Smith College Northampton, Massachusetts
College Profile
Location and Environment: Smith College is dedicated to the vision of its founder, Sophia Smith, who wrote in 1871 that her intention in endowing a college for women was to develop as fully as may be the powers of womanhood, and furnish women with the means of usefulness, happiness and honor now withheld from them. Smith is located one hundred miles west of Boston in Northampton, Massachusetts, a vibrant community of 35,000 inhabitants. Most students live on campus in the Smith house system. Smith is a member of Five Colleges, Inc., a consortium of colleges in the Pioneer Valley that also includes Amherst College, Hampshire College, Mount Holyoke College, and the University of Massachusetts Amherst. With permission, students may register for classes at any of these institutions. Some of the most popular majors at Smith are government, psychology, economics, and English. Other majors with large enrollments include art, history, biology, engineering, anthropology, neuroscience, sociology, and Spanish. The study of statistics at Smith is thriving, with about 300 students a year enrolled in introductory courses offered in departments ranging from Mathematics and Statistics to Economics, Government, Psychology, and Sociology. About 5070 students each year take upper-level courses, including Regression Analysis, Research Design, Econometrics, and Mathematical Statistics. Majors in mathematics can concentrate in statistics, and majors in other fields can complete a minor in applied statistics. At least one course in introductory statistics is required for majors in biology, engineering, neuroscience, and psychology. Type: Private liberal-arts college for women Total Enrollment: There are approximately 2,800 students, of which about 300 are away from campus annually, participating in junior-year programs or internships abroad and across the United States. About 20 percent are first-generation college students. The studentfaculty ratio at Smith is 9 to 1. Ethnic Diversity: Approximately 30 percent of students have minority standing (Asian American, 14 percent; African American, 7 percent; Latina, five percent; Native American, 1 percent; multiracial, 1 percent). Six percent are international students coming from 26 countries. AP Policy Smith College participates in the College Boards Advanced Placement Program. AP credit may be used with the approval of the Administrative Board only: (1) to undertake an accelerated course program; (2) to make up a shortage of credit incurred as a result of dropping a course for reasons of health; or (3) to make up a shortage of credits incurred through failure. Credits are recorded for scores of 4 or 5 on most AP Exams. A maximum of one year (32 credits) of AP credit may be counted toward the degree. Students who complete courses that cover substantially the same material as those for which AP credit is recorded may not then apply that AP credit toward the degree requirement. The credits to be recorded for each examination are determined by the individual department.
45
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Personal Philosophy
Students learn statistics by using statistics in contexts that have meaning for them. The subject only has value to the extent that they can see where and how it fits into their personal or working lives. Therefore, they must be able to relate what we are doing in this course to questions they have asked, or discussions they have had, outside of statistics class. To that end, I bring to class a wide range of studies reported in newspapers, magazines, and journals, as well as on the Web, in order to connect with as many students as possible. We discuss the design and analysis of these studies, and for their term project, students pose their own research question, design a study, collect and analyze the data, and present the results at a poster session on the last day of class. Students need to find their own voices in writing about statistical issues, and I emphasize the importance of communicating clearly, in writing, the methods and findings of statistical analyses.
Class Profile
MTH 245, Introduction to Probability and Statistics, provides an introduction to statistics primarily for mathematically mature students who are majoring in the sciences or mathematics. They have already taken at least one semester of college calculus or one year of high school calculus. Students who received a 4 or a 5 on the AP Statistics Exam are encouraged to enroll in the second-level statistics courses, either Research Design or Regression Analysis. A little over half of the 40 students who typically enroll in MTH 245 major in biology, biochemistry, environmental science, or neuroscience. Another 15 percent major in the mathematical sciences; 15 percent come from the social sciences; 15 percent have not yet declared a major; and the remaining 5 percent include students from the other sciences and the arts. Many of these students plan graduate school and careers in biology, neuroscience, medicine, or other sciences. Some of the math majors plan to become high school mathematics teachers. Most students take the course in their first or second year at Smith, and they start using what they are learning almost immediately, in courses such as neuroscience, genetics, ecology, and population biology. Classes meet Monday, Wednesday, and Friday for 70 minutes. Students are expected to attend class, as participation is an important part of the learning process and essential to stimulate discussion. Labs meet for 80 minutes on Tuesday and Wednesday afternoons, and students must sign up for one of these sessions. Lectures are delivered by the instructor of record, and the two lab sections are taught by a lab instructor. Laboratory activities form an integral part of the course and are used to explore statistical concepts in greater depth. This may include collecting and analyzing student-generated data and writing reports that interpret the results of analyses in nontechnical language. The labs have their own homework assignments that usually are due at the next lab period.
Course Overview
The aim of this course is to provide students with a thorough understanding of four central topics in statistics: study design, exploratory data analysis, probability models, and statistical inference. The prerequisite is any of the following: Calculus I, Discrete Mathematics, one year of high school calculus, or permission of the instructor. Students who have not taken calculus or discrete mathematics but have taken four years of high school mathematics should enroll in Statistical Methods for Undergraduate Research (MTH 190). Students with three years of high school mathematics should enroll in Statistical Thinking (MTH 107). MTH 245 satisfies the basis requirements for a statistics course in the Biology and Psychology Departments (basis courses at Smith are the courses all majors have to complete before taking more advanced courses to satisfy the degree requirements in their major).
46
Text
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Text for the course is the fifth edition of Introduction to the Practice of Statistics by David S. Moore and George P. McCabe. Students find the textbook very readable. It is full of outstanding examples of real statistical studies in the sciences and social sciences. We discuss most of the topics covered by the text, but we modify the order and start with chapter 3, Producing Data, because we want the students to start thinking about their course projects right away. The rest of the course is best summarized in the following information that is adapted from material addressed directly to the students and provided on the first day of class.
Learning statistics is like learning a new language. There are new ideas, new vocabulary, and new rules. The pace of this course is moderate but relentless, so it is essential that you do not fall behind. The exams, quizzes, homework, and project assignments are scheduled to encourage steady, consistent application on your part. It is crucially important that you read ahead in the book as well as review the material after we have discussed it in class. There is no better way to learn statistics than to tackle problems in the text, working examples and wrestling with the exercises (many of which have solutions at the back of the book). Class time is spent discussing your questions, looking at other examples, and engaging in activities. We also show you how to use statistical software to do the extensive computations most statistical problems require. The computer is usually faster and more accurate than we are at doing arithmetic and graphs, but we have to know what arithmetic and which graphs will be useful. We recommend that you form study groups of three or four students and get together outside of class to discuss the homework. Each of you should try the problems on your own and then meet to discuss your work. This allows you to develop your own way of thinking about statistics problems before hearing how others think and helps you to gain self-confidence. We also suggest that you create a three-ring binder devoted to this course so that you can collect all of the course notes, lab notes, handouts, project drafts, homework papers, tests, quizzes, and related materials in one place.
Course Web Site
We have a Moodle Web page [an open-source, Web-based course management system] for MTH 245, and course information, including this syllabus, is available there. We regularly update information posted there with class handouts, homework and project assignments, and announcements.
Statistical Software
We use Minitab statistical software that is available in many computer labs on campus. Minitab has an online manual, and we will show you how to use the program and how to use the online help facilities. Additionally, your textbook publisher offers statistical applets and practice quizzes online, which we explore during class. We also use practice quizzes from the ARTIST Web site [see Teachers Resources at the end of this syllabus], and we will let you know when those are available.
Calculator Policy
You must bring a scientific calculator to class and to each test and quiz. You are not allowed to share a calculator with another student during either a test or a quiz. You do not need a graphing calculator, but your calculator should be able to take logs and exponents.
47
Chapter 3 Chapter 1 Homework
Homework is an important way to reinforce concepts learned in class. Problems are assigned each week, and the assignments, with their due dates, are posted on Moodle. We strongly encourage you to complete these and to work other problems if you need more practice. You may discuss the homework problems with your colleagues, but you must write up your own solutions. Homework problems are due at the beginning of class on the due date and must be handed in on time to receive full credit. Homework handed in during class or at the end of class is automatically late, and late homework will not be accepted after the first class following the due date. Absence from class does not permit you to hand in homework after the due date without penalty. If you know you must miss class on the due date, your homework may be handed in early.
Quizzes
Weekly quizzes are given every Wednesday during the first 10 minutes of class. Part of the content of these quizzes is directly related to the reading assignments due that day, and the questions are very easy if you have, in fact, done the reading. This helps ensure that everyone is at the same level when a topic is discussed. The rest of the quiz content is review material and serves to keep your skills honed. In statistics, perhaps even more than in other endeavors, you learn by doing. There will be no makeups, but your lowest quiz score will be dropped. Quizzes count only 10 percent toward your final grade. They are intended to provide just enough extra motivation for you to do your reading on time and to review your notes after every class. If they succeed in doing this, they are likely to reduce your workload, not increase it.
Tests
The two midterm examinations will be held on February 23 and March 30. You are allowed to bring some personal notes to these tests. We will give explicit instructions before each test. The final examination will be self-scheduled during the final examination period in May. If you have special needs concerning test-taking, please discuss them with Professor Halvorsen. Recall that Smith College has had an academic honor code since 1944, and all students are bound by it. Cases of dishonesty or plagiarism will be sent to the Academic Honor Board. Makeup exams may be given to students who notify Ms. Halvorsen, in advance, that they cannot take a scheduled midterm and who have an appropriate explanation for their absence. Makeup exams may be oral or written at the discretion of the instructor.
Term Projects
You are expected to complete a research project of your own choosing during the term and to present your results in a poster on the last day of class. These projects consist of collecting and analyzing data and writing about your results. You should start thinking right away about research questions you want to explore. Students work in teams of two or three on the projects. We will give you detailed project instructions and also make these instructions available on Moodle.
Grading
In grading your written work, we look for problem solutions that are technically correct and reasoning that is clearly explained. Numerically correct answers alone are not sufficient on homework, tests, or quizzes. We value neatness and brief, clear answers that explain your thinking. If the grader cannot read or follow your work, she cannot give you credit for it.
48
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Course Planner
Spring 2007
The following outline lists each class date and gives the topic that was discussed in that class. The reading assignment from the textbook is also given for each class date. IPS = Introduction to the Practice of Statistics; HW = homework. Date M/Jan. 29 W/Jan. 31 F/Feb. 2 M/Feb. 5 W/Feb. 7 F/Feb. 9 M/Feb. 12 W/Feb. 14 F/Feb. 16 M/Feb. 19 W/Feb. 21 F/Feb. 23 M/Feb. 26 W/Feb. 28 F/Mar. 2 M/Mar. 5 W/Mar. 7 F/Mar. 9 M/Mar. 12 W/Mar. 14 F/Mar. 16 Mar. 1724 M/Mar. 26 W/Mar. 28 F/Mar. 30 M/Apr. 2 W/Apr. 4 F/Apr. 6 M/Apr. 9 W/Apr. 11 F/Apr. 13 M/Apr. 16 Topic Introduction, Collecting Data, Types of Studies Planning and Conducting Experiments Planning and Conducting Surveys Displaying Distributions: Numeric Summaries and Graphs Normal Distributions, z-Scores Assessing Normality, Q-Q Plots, N-scores Scatterplots, Median Trace, Correlation Simple Linear Regression (SLR) Residuals, Outliers, Influence Points, and Causation Exponential Growth, Log Transformations RALLY DAY (NO CLASSES) FIRST MIDTERM EXAM Probability and Randomness Probability Models Random Variables Means and Variances of Discrete Random Variables General Probability Rules Generalizing from Study Results Binomial Model for Counts for Small Sample Sizes Approximating the Sampling Distributions for Counts Approximating the Sampling Distributions for Proportions SPRING BREAK Sampling Distribution of the Sample Mean and CLT Confidence Intervals for Means SECOND MIDTERM EXAM Tests of Significance Uses and Abuses of Tests Power of a Test, Inference as a Decision Inference for the Mean, One Sample Inference for Means, Two Samples Inference for a Proportion, One Sample Inference for Proportions, Two Samples Reading IPS 3.1 IPS 3.2 IPS 3.3 IPS 1.1, 2 IPS 1.3 IPS 1.3 IPS 2.1, 2 IPS 2.3 IPS 2.4, 5 IPS 2.6 Assignment Due Quiz 1 HW 1 Quiz 2 HW 2 Quiz 3 HW 3
Exam 1 IPS 4.1 IPS 4.2 IPS 4.3 IPS 4.4 IPS 4.5 IPS 3.4 IPS 5.1 IPS 5.1 IPS 5.1 IPS 5.2 IPS 6.1 IPS 6.2 IPS 6.3 IPS 6.4 IPS 7.1 IPS 7.2 IPS 8.1 IPS 8.2 Quiz 4 HW 4 Quiz 5 HW 5
HW 6
HW 7 Exam 2 Quiz 6 HW 8 Quiz 7 HW 9
49
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Date W/Apr. 18 F/Apr. 20 M/Apr. 23 W/Apr. 25 F/Apr. 27 M/Apr. 30 W/May 2 F/May 4 May 811
Topic Data Analysis for Two-Way Tables Inference for Two-Way Tables, Chi-Square Tests Confidence Intervals and Tests for Regression Parameters ANOVA Table and F Test in Regression One-Way Analysis of Variance: Intuition and Test One-Way Analysis of Variance: Multiple Comparisons General Review Project Poster Session FINAL EXAMS
Reading IPS 9.1 IPS 9.2 IPS 10.1 IPS 10.2 IPS 12.1 IPS 12.1
Assignment Due Quiz 8 HW 10 Quiz 9 HW 11
Project Poster Due
Teaching Strategies
Students must keep up with the pace of the course to absorb new ideas presented both in their reading and in class; to that end, we have weekly homework sets and weekly quizzes on the most recent reading and homework questions. Weekly laboratory sessions provide opportunities for hands-on work with problems related to the previous weeks reading and class discussions, as well as for practice using computer software to carry out simulations or analyses of data. Students spend class time discussing the material in the reading and working examples. Statistical thinking is emphasized, and we use statistical applets on the Web and hands-on activities to develop concepts. Learning difficult material is challenging and often frustrating to students. Immediate feedback and easily available help are both important to help keep such frustration within reasonable bounds. I try to return quizzes in the class period following the quiz. Tests, lab assignments, and homework are returned within a week, usually within one or two class periods. Although I have regular office hours each week and make myself available by appointment at other times, my main means of communication with students outside of class is through e-mail and through our Moodle Web site. I post most of the course handouts on the Web. Students can meet with teaching assistants between 7 p.m. and 9 p.m. on Sunday through Thursday evenings to get help, and they can meet with the laboratory instructor during her office hours. I strongly encourage students to form study groups that meet outside of class to discuss class work and homework and to bring questions to class that they cannot solve in their study groups.
Lab Component
Students meet in the statistics laboratory once a week for an 80-minute class. The lab is a required part of the course, and students must attend and do the lab homework weekly. Each lab section contains between 15 and 20 students. Lab work may require computers or lab equipment (e.g., balances, calipers) for weighing or measuring as students gather data from an experiment. Students typically work in pairs or larger groups for most lab activities. There is no lab manual; instead, we hand out plans for each lab during the section in which the plan will be used. Below are two examples of the detailed lesson plans given to students. Each lab plan contains some objectives and an activity for that days lab and, usually, a homework assignment.
50
Course Organization About AP Statistics
LAB 10: Exploring Tests and Confidence Intervals for Proportions Through Data Collection and Analysis
Objectives
To learn methods for constructing tests and confidence intervals for proportions To acquire experience applying the methods for testing a hypothesis and for constructing a confidence interval for the difference in proportions from two populations
Description of the Activity
We want you to develop a research hypothesis about a difference in proportions between the cars that park in two Smith College parking lots. Consider the following possibilities, but you are not limited to these comparisons. Discuss other options you may wish to pursue with your lab instructor before you start to take measurements. Proportion of SUVs in each lot Proportion of vehicles sitting on the white line that defines the parking place Proportion of vehicles with one or more bumper stickers Proportion of vehicles with something dangling from the rearview mirror Write here what you plan to compare:
Explain why you think your data will meet the criteria needed to ensure the validity of a confidence interval or a test of two proportions (that is, what the assumptions are and why you think your data will satisfy them).
51
Chapter 3 Chapter 1 Methods
How are you going to decide whether a vehicle has the characteristic you are going to count? For instance, how much of a vehicles tire must be on the line before it counts as sitting on the white line? Give an operational definition of the variable you plan to count below. Provide as much detail in your description as you would need to instruct someone else to collect these data for you.
Data Collection
Decide how you are going to collect and record your data (including mechanisms to ensure that your group does not count the same car twice). Attach your data collection record to your lab report.
Inference Procedure
1. Report your summary statistics (for example, the total number of vehicles in each lot, the number of vehicles in each lot that had your characteristic of interest, the sample proportion in each lot, and the standard deviation of the sample proportion in each lot). 2. Describe your research question. a. What is your null hypothesis? What is the alternate hypothesis? b. What α level will you use for this test? c. Under what condition will you reject the null hypothesis? 3. Conduct the test you described above. 4. Construct a 95 percent confidence interval for the difference between the two proportions. 5. Report your conclusion in context.
52
Course Organization About AP Statistics
LAB 11: Simulation of the Distribution of the Slope in a Simple Linear Regression Model
(The original idea for this lab came from Robin H. Lock, the Jack and Sylvia Burry Chair in Statistics at St. Lawrence University. It is designed for use with Fathom 2.)
Objectives
To gain an understanding of the simple linear regression model To observe the sampling distribution of the slope of a regression line To be able to use Fathom to generate data, take samples, and plot graphs
Description of the Activity
We have seen the least squares regression line ŷ = a + bx as a description of a linear relationship between a response variable y and an explanatory variable x. Now we have learned that the least squares line computed from a sample is an estimate of a true regression line for the population, just as x-bar is an estimate of the true population mean μ. The notation for population regression line is β0 + β1 x, and for sample data, it is b0 + b1x. The intercept b0 of the fitted line estimates the intercept β0 of the population line, and the slope b1 estimates the slope β1. The statistical model for simple linear regression assumes that for each value of xi, the possible values of the observed response variables yi are normally distributed about the mean E [yi | xi]. Moreover, b0 and b1 are approximately normally distributed with means β0 and β1 respectively. This result depends on the assumption that the error terms εi in the model yi = β0 + β1 xi + εi are independent and normally distributed with mean 0 and standard deviation σ. In this lab, we will use Fathom to simulate the sampling distribution of a slope b1. We draw random samples from a bivariate population, (xi , yi ), compute the fitted regression line for each sample, and show that b1 are normally distributed with mean β1. Generating the Population Regression Line 1. Open Fathom. 2. Pull the New Collection box off the tool shelf. Double-click on the default name Collection 1 to rename the collection box as Population. 3. Generate 1,000 observations for the Population. You will see golden balls filling the collection box.
Collection New Cases 1,000
4. Right-click on the Population box to open the Inspect Collection dialog box. Click on the Cases pane. a) Fill in a variable name under the heading Attribute, for example, X. b) Fill in the formula by double-clicking in the blank box below the heading Formula. Enter prev ( X ) + 1 in the formula box. Click OK. You should see the formula below the Formula heading, and 1 (the value for the first observation) appears below the Value heading. We have created a sequence of values from 1 to 1,000 in ascending order.
53
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
c) Fill in the next variable name, Y. d) Enter 10 + 3 X in the formula box. Click OK, and you will see 13 in the Value box for the f irst observation. e) Fill in the third variable name, YRand. That is the y value when a random error εi is included. f) Enter Y + RandomNormal (0, 10) in the YRand formula box. We are adding the random error εi, which has mean 0 and standard deviation 10 to Y. RandomNormal instructions can a lso be found by choosing Functions Random numbers randomNormal. Taking Random Samples from the Population 5. Highlight the Population box, and go to Collection Sample Cases. A new box named Sample of Population will appear. 6. Right-click on the Sample of Population box, and open the Inspector Collection dialog box. 7. On the Sample pane
Turn off animation (uncheck the box in front of Animation on). Keep With replacement and Replace existing cases on. Collect 25 cases by entering 25, and click on Sample More Cases. That is the size of our sample.
8. On the Cases pane, you should see all three variables. 9. On the Measures pane, enter Slope under Measure and enter linRegrSlope (X, YRand) in the formula box. The formula can also be found by choosing Functions Statistical Two Attributes linRegrSlope. Collecting Measures from Samples 10. Highlight the Sample of Population box, and go to Collection Collect Measures. A third box named Measures from Sample of Populations will be there. 11. Open the Inspector Collection box by right-clicking the Measures from Sample of Populations box. 12. On the Collect Measures pane
Turn off animation. Keep Replace existing cases on. Collect 500 measures. Click on the icon Collect More Measures.
54
Making Graphs for Values of Slope 13. When it is done, open the Cases pane.
Course Organization About AP Statistics
14. Pull a Graph off the tool shelf. Make a histogram for values of Slope by grasping the variable Slope from the Cases pane and dropping them on the horizontal axis. Choose Histogram. 15. Right-click on the graph, and choose Plot Function. Key in the formula: normalDensity (slope, mean( ), s( ) ), and click OK. You should be able to see a normal curve being fitted to the histogram.8 16. Take a New Graph off the tool shelf and make a Normal Quantile Plot for the values of Slope. Showing the Classical Summary and the Five-Number Summary 17. Pull the Summary icon from the tool shelf. 18. Grasp Slope from the Cases pane, and drop it onto the Summary table. 19. The mean will be immediately displayed as default. 20. Right-click on the Summary table box, and choose Add Formula. 21. The standard deviation of the distribution can be found by choosing Functions Statistical One Attribute stdDev. 22. Produce the five-number summary in the summary table by using Functions Statistical One Attribute 23. Use the information from your graphs and summary statistics to comment on how well the normal distribution approximates the observed distribution of slope. Use a text box to insert your answer on the screen page. To insert a text box, go to the text icon on the tool shelf A, and pull the box off the shelf. Type your answer inside the box. You may resize the box by dragging on a corner. Finding the 95 Percent Confidence Interval for the Mean of the Distribution of Slope 24. Theoretical estimation
Pull the Estimate icon off the shelf. Choose Estimate Mean under Empty Estimate. Grasp and drop Slope onto the first line that contains Attribute (numeric): <unassigned>. You should see all the analysis about the confidence interval you need.
8. Note that by movng the cursor over the hstogram, you can see a hand, a double-headed horzontal arrow, or a sngle-headed arrow. The hand symbol, held over a bar n the hstogram, causes the program to report both the upper and lower values on the horzontal scale for the bar, and the number of observatons n ths nterval. These numbers are shown n the lower left-hand corner of the screen, just above the Start button. For example, 2 .987 <= Slope <= 2.989: 25 cases means that there are 25 values of the varable Slope between 2.987 and 2.989. The double-headed horzontal arrow, held over a vertcal lne, causes the program to report the X-value of the vertcal lne. The sngle-headed arrow causes the program to report the (x, y) coordnates of the pont at the tp of the arrow.
55
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Finding the 95 Percent Prediction Interval for a New Observation by Theoretical Estimation and by Empirical Estimation 25. Theoretical estimation
The 95 percent prediction interval for a new observation is: ŷ ± t* SE ŷ, where t* is the value for the (n2) density curve with area 95 percent between t* and t*. t value for 498 degree of freedom at 97.25 percent is 1.9647. Insert your answer in a text box.
26. Empirical estimation Highlight the collection box, Measures from Sample of Population. Pull the Table icon from the tool shelf. You should be able to see all 500 estimates of the slope in the table. Click on Slope in the table, and all the values will be highlighted. R ight-click, and choose Sort Ascending. The 500 values will be arranged in ascending order. Take the average of the twelfth and thirteenth values and also the average of the four hundred eighty-seventh and four hundred eighty-eighth values. These two numbers estimate the range of the middle 95 percent of the distribution. Create a text box, and record your empirical prediction interval in the text box.
27. Compare the two prediction intervals, and give an explanation for any discrepancy you may find. Use another text box for this discussion.
Assignment
Produce a lab report that includes the histogram, normal quantile plot, numerical summary, point estimate, 95 percent confidence interval for the mean slope, the two prediction intervals for new observations, and your comments.
Student Evaluation
The semester grade for this course is a weighted average of several components, as indicated below. In borderline situations, class participation and attendance are given greater emphasis. Participation Quizzes Homework Lab work First midterm Second midterm Final exam Projects 5 percent 10 percent 10 percent 15 percent 15 percent 15 percent 15 percent 15 percent
56
Course Organization About AP Statistics
The lab instructor grades the lab homework and provides the course instructor with an overall lab grade for the semester. This grade is then averaged into the course grade as shown above. Homework is marked by a grader using an answer key provided by the instructor. Each homework assignment is graded from 1 to 5 points, based on a combination of accuracy and effort. Below are rough guidelines for grading: 5all problems completed with detailed solutions; 75 percent or more correct 4all problems completed with detailed solutions; 5075 percent correct; OR close to all problems completed; 75100 percent correct 3close to all problems completed; less than 75 percent correct 1more than half but fewer than all problems completed; 75 percent correct 0no work submitted; no work also means submitting very few of the problems and showing no detail/work to the solutions Both midterm exams and the final exam follow the format of the AP Statistics Exam. The midterms have 8 to 10 multiple-choice/fill-in-the-blank questions and 4 free-response questions. Students have an hour and 10 minutes to complete the exam. They may bring one 8½ by 11 inch sheet of handwritten notes to each midterm and to the final exam. These can be any notes they want to bring. I see the preparation of these notes as a way for students to review and summarize the course material. They have to decide what was important and what they need to bring to the exam to help them remember the details correctly. Students must hand in the notes so that I can look at them when I am grading the exams. I sometimes check to see what a student has written in her notes when she gets a question wrong. Final exams at Smith are self-scheduled over a four-day period. A student may pick up her exam from a central location staffed by the registrars office, take it to a designated classroom, complete it within 2 hours and 20 minutes, and return it to the table where she picked it up. Students can take their exams in any order and at any of the scheduled times within those four days. There is no standard grading scale at Smith. I average the grades at the end of the term and give As to students with averages between 90 and 100, Bs to students with averages between 80 and 89, and so forth.
Teacher Resources
Textbook
Moore, David S., and George P. McCabe. Introduction to the Practice of Statistics. 5th ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2005.
Other
ARTIST (Assessment Resource Tools for Improving Statistical Thinking). https://app.gen.umn.edu/artist/index.html. Provides a variety of assessment resources for teaching first courses in statistics. Fathom Dynamic Data Software. Version 2. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press. w ww.keypress.com.
57
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Student Activities
Class Projects
The following student handout explains in detail all the requirements of the semester-long research studies that the students develop and implement, either individually or with a partner.
For your class project you will select a research question that interests you and write a proposal describing how you plan to conduct your research. We encourage you to work with another student on your project. You will review other students proposals, and you will receive reviews of your proposal from your peers, from the instructors, and, for some of you, from Smith Colleges Institutional Review Board. After your research proposal has been approved, you will carry out your data collection and analysis. Finally, you will create a poster describing your study and your results. Posters will be displayed in the style of a professional conference on our last day of class. Each of you will be assigned to review three of the final posters. The following steps lead to a completed class project:
Project outline, due Monday 2-5 Project proposal, due Friday 2-16 (please hand in three copies) Peer review of proposals, due Monday 2-19 Revisions (if needed) to project proposal, due Monday 2-26 Progress report, due Monday 3-12 Copy of project data and descriptive statistics, due Monday 4-2 Preliminary data analysis, graphs, and tables, due Monday 4-16 Poster draft, due Monday 4-23 Project poster, due Friday 5-4 One-page abstract of project, due Friday 5-4 Peer reviews of three posters, due in class Friday 5-4
The project may be either of the following types: 1. An original experiment or observational study: You might conduct an experiment (for example, collect data on which type of nail polish lasts longest), or you might survey a sample of students on some topic that interests you. Your project will involve developing an observational or experimental protocol or a survey, selecting a sample or assigning available units to treatments, collecting and analyzing the data, and drawing conclusions. 2. An analysis of an existing data set: You may be able to apply the techniques we learn in this course to a data set that already exists. The Internet has a vast array of data sets on a wide variety of subjects, such as demographics, disease, economics, geography, entertainment, science, and womens issues. You may also obtain data sets from local businesses or government organizations. Alternatively, a professor you know or are working with may have a data set you could analyze.
58
Course Organization About AP Statistics
General Rules The work (analysis and write-up) must be your own. You may consult other sources for information about the nonstatistical, substantive issues in your project, but be sure to credit these sources in your poster. Consult the instructors about statistical questions. Projects that involve using human subjects (interviewing, measuring, etc.) or live animals must be reviewed by the Institutional Review Board, and you need to allow time for this in planning your project. Institutional review ensures that the subjects will be treated properly, their privacy protected, and their consent obtained. If you need to use human subjects, we will show you how to prepare a proposal for institutional review. Project Outline The project outline consists of a one-page form on which you very briefly describe your proposed project. One copy of the blank form is attached to these instructions, and the form is also available on Moodle at our class site. We will use this information to work with you to develop your full project proposal. Project Proposal The proposal for your poster is a paper, 5001,000 words in length, that describes in detail the research you plan to conduct and the methods you will use to both collect and analyze your data. The fundamental goal of any proposal is to convince the reviewer that your objectives are worthy of the research effort and that you have a plan of action that will result in successful achievement of these objectives. You must hand in three copies of your proposal. Please be aware that the instructors or the Institutional Review Board may require changes in your proposal before you receive permission to conduct your study. We will work with you to ensure that your proposal will be approved. Be sure to use the format given below for your proposal and to address each item in the outline. The proposal must be typed, double-spaced, on 8½ by 11 inch white paper. Include a cover sheet with the following information: the names and contact information for the authors, the course number and name, the date, and the course instructors names. On the cover sheet state clearly: This proposal [requires/does not require] institutional review. Use the following section headings in the body of your proposal. I. Introduction What is your topic? What do you already know about your topic? Why is your topic worthy of study? What is the objective of your project? State your research question as one that can be answered through the collection and analysis of data. II. Methods A. Sampling Issues 1. What are the units in your study (observations, objects, people, studies)? 2. What is the population from which the units are drawn? 3. How many units do you plan to measure? 4. How will you avoid sampling bias? (You should provide enough detail about your sampling methods so that someone else could collect the data for you.)
59
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
B. Data Collection Issues 1. What variables will you measure on each unit in your sample, and how will you measure each variable? (You should measure a minimum of two variables on each unit.) Give operational definitions of your variables and of your methods of measurement. What is the proposed response variable? What are your proposed explanatory or associated variables? 2. How will you collect measurements from the units (for example, will you use a questionnaire to ask questions, or will you directly measure something like height or observe something like price)? 3. Address each of the issues of randomization, replication, and control in your study. C. Statistical Analyses 1. Are you going to be looking for an association between your two variables or a cause-and-effect relationship? Give your best guess about the relationships between the response and explanatory variable. 2. Note that analysis of your data must include at least one of the following tools:
Confidence interval for the difference in two means Confidence interval for the difference in two proportions Test for a difference between two (or more) means Test for a difference between two (or more) proportions Chi-square test for the independence of two categorical variables Test for the significance of the slope of a regression line
3. Describe what graphs and tables you expect to use to display your results. Describe what results you expect to see. D. Data Collection Form Provide a copy of the form you plan to use to collect the data. If you plan a survey, then provide a copy of the actual questionnaire you plan to use. E. Consent Form If you plan to use human subjects for your study, you must provide them with a statement telling them about your study and asking them for their consent to participate. The consent form must contain all of the following information: 1. Your name, the purpose of the study, and a description of the study. You may not deceive participants or put them at risk in any way.
60
Course Organization About AP Statistics
2. A statement that responses are confidential or anonymous, as appropriate. If the information you are requesting is at all sensitive, you must provide some explanation regarding the steps you are taking to assure confidentiality or anonymity. 3. A request that the subjects voluntarily participate in the study. You should have them sign a consent form if your study is not a survey. F. Third-Party Information If you require resources from a third party (for example, using data belonging to someone else), include a copy of your written request to that party for the information. Do not send the request before you obtain written approval from the instructors. Peer Review of a Project Proposal You will be asked to read and assess someone elses project proposal. Your job is to assess the feasibility and rationale of the project you review. Are the variables the researchers plan to collect appropriate for their research question? Are the data collection methods appropriate? Do lurking variables exist? Is the sample size sufficient? How else could the project be done? Can the objectives be met given the available resources? We will provide a form for your peer reviews. Progress Report Midway through the project you need to assess your work to date by completing a progress report. We will give you a set of questions to answer. Project Data and Descriptive Statistics By Monday April 2 you should have all of your data collected so that you can begin to focus on the data analysis and on producing a well-organized and attractive poster. At this time you must submit a copy of your data and a report containing descriptive statistics for each variable you collected. Preliminary Data Analysis By Monday April 16 a preliminary draft of your complete data analysis is due. This assures that you will have time to complete your analysis and create the poster on time for our poster session on May 4. Poster Draft On Monday April 23 please hand in a copy of the text and graphs you plan to put on your poster. Abstract and Poster Presentation Bring your poster and a separate abstract for your project to class. The content of your poster should be roughly equivalent to that of a 10-page paper (you do not need to hand in a paper). Your poster should include the following items:
Title: Invent a catchy or interesting title that captures the spirit of your project. Byline: List the authors of the project and their institutional addresses. Rationale: Provide a statement of the question or purpose of the project. What problems are addressed, what key issues are important to the project, and what was known about the topic before you started?
61
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Methods: Explain what you did and how you did it. How did you choose your sample? What variables did you measure? How did you measure each variable? What statistical techniques did you use? Results: Present a summary of your data both in figures (graphs or tables) and in a textual description. Emphasize trends as well as specific values. Give the results of confidence intervals or statistical tests. Discussion: Explain what you learned about the problem or question you set out to investigate. Discuss your findings in terms of what else is known. Critique: What did you learn about the process of carrying out your project? What went wrong, and how could you avoid that pitfall in the future? What advice would you give to future students? References: List any sources you used in the poster. Acknowledgments: Thank those who helped you with the project.
Creativity, innovation, and humor are all encouraged! Poster Reviews On the day of the poster presentation, we will provide forms on which you may write your poster review. It will contain specific questions to address and space for you to provide more extensive comments. We will ask you to consider the following issues:
Presentation: Is the poster attractive and well organized? Are all components present? Is it easy to follow? Is the text well written? Are the graphs and tables easy to understand? Statistical content: Did the investigators use appropriate statistical techniques? Are the techniques used correctly? Are the figures appropriate to the data? Subject matter content: Did you learn something about the subject of the poster? Is the content interesting, fun, provocative, compelling, educational, or fascinating?
Students complete a short questionnaire at the end of term after the project is complete. Here are a couple of responses I particularly liked: Question: What have you learned from the process of conducting your research? In conducting my research for the statistics project, I learned that it is very different from conducting a science experiment. Through filling out the IRB form [Institutional Review Board forms required for projects using human subjects], I learned about all of the ethics and meticulous details that must be thought about even when conducting the simplest experiment. I also learned that it really pays off to be organized and get everything done by the helpful deadlines. I also learned how to communicate efficiently with a research partner and how to compromise. Planning and consistent effort matters a lot. Working consistently over the entire assignment period makes the project go a lot smoother. [There is] [m]ore time to make decisions and corrections.
62
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sample Syllabus 2
Jackie Miller Ohio State University, Columbus
University Profile
Location and Environment: In terms of enrollment, Ohio State is the largest university in the United States. It is located in an urban environment about two miles from downtown Columbus, the state capital, in the center of the state. Columbus is the fifteenth-largest U.S. city and the thirty-second-largest metropolitan area. In addition to the university, it boasts many arts and cultural institutions and professional sports teams in soccer, hockey, arena football, and minor league baseball. It is also a major business center. Ohio State is ranked nineteenth in U.S. News and World Report s 2007 Americas Best Colleges survey. Its First Year Experience (FYE) and Living-Learning Programs are listed as stellar examples of programs that lead to student success. Kiplinger Personal Finance in 2007 ranked the school sixty-second among its top 100 best values in public colleges. Ohio State was also selected in 2003 and 2004 as one of the countrys 50 best colleges for African Americans by Black Enterprise magazine. More than half (53 percent) of the entering first-year students in fall 2007 ranked in the top 10 percent of their graduating high school class, and 89 percent ranked in the top 25 percent. There are more than 170 majors at Ohio State. Students can also opt to custom-design their own major through the Personalized Study Program. Undecided students can participate in the Ohio State Exploration Program. The university sponsors nine preprofessional programs (predentistry, pre-education, prelaw, premedicine, pre-occupational therapy, preoptometry, prepharmacy, pre-physical therapy, and pre-veterinary medicine), as well as 28 Agricultural Technical Institute (ATI) programs leading to an Associate of Applied Science or Associate of Science degree. Type: Coeducational, public research university Total Enrollment: On the Columbus campus, as of fall 2007, there were 52,568 students (39,209 undergraduates, 10,097 graduate students, and 3,262 professional students). The undergraduate student-tofaculty ratio is 13:1. Ethnic Diversity: As of fall 2007, the minority student population was as follows: African American, 6.5 percent; Asian American, 5.2 percent; Hispanic/Latino, 2.5 percent; Native American, 0.4 percent. International students from 113 countries accounted for 7 percent of the total enrollment.
Personal Philosophy
I love teaching statisticsdespite the fact that I often describe it as selling a product that my students do not want to buy. (This aphorism has also become part of several of my graduate assistants teaching philosophies.) For many students, statistics is a required course, but regardless of why they choose to take it, most of them really do not know what the subject entails. At Ohio State, for each quarters course, I have 10 weeks to open up the world of statistics to my students; it is an opportunity to help them consciously realize how statistics influence their daily lives. It is important to me that my students not only learn the process of collecting and analyzing data but that they think critically about the statistics that are presented to them from all quarters: scientific, financial, and political. It is the combination of these abilities that leads my students to be better consumers of statistics. This is why selling a product that students do not want to buy is challenging, rewarding, and never dullthe point being proved when some of my students f ind the course interesting enough to pursue further opportunities in the discipline.
63
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Class Profile
Ohio State operates on the quarter system, and because our courses are only 10 weeks long and could not possibly include all the material included in a yearlong AP Statistics high school class, this syllabus presents Course Planners for two separately taught, one-quarter, introductory statistics courses that together comprise most of the skills included in the AP Statistics curriculum: Statistics 145 (Introduction to the Practice of Statistics) and Statistics 245 (Introduction to Statistical Analysis). The latter is a higher-level course, although it is still introductory in nature. It is not a continuation of Stat 145. For that reason, AP students who earn a grade of 3 on the AP Statistics Exam get credit for Stat 145 and receive five hours of college credit, whereas those who earn a 4 or 5 get credit for Stat 245 and also receive five hours of college credit.
Statistics 145
Students at Ohio State tend to put off this course until later in their college careers. This means that more of my students are juniors and seniors than sophomores and first-year students. Typically, more than half are women. The students come from preprofessional majors in the medical professions, from the social and behavioral sciences, and from the honors program in the arts and sciences. During the academic year, three lecture sections of Stat 145 are offered every quartertwo during the day and one in the evening, with a different instructor for each. I am the coordinator for the course and always teach one of the daytime lectures. Another faculty or staff member teaches the second daytime lecture, and a senior graduate teaching associate teaches the smaller evening class. We have a total of approximately 400 students in each of the autumn and spring quarters, and about 350 students total in the winter quarter. (During the summer quarter, we offer one daytime lecture that typically serves approximately 100 students.) The evening lecture usually has about 50 students, and the rest of the students are divided equally between the two daytime lectures. The average number of students per recitation ranges between 26 and 28, depending on enrollment for the quarter. There are typically six recitation sections for each daytime lecture and two recitation sections for the night lecture. This is a five-credit course. The daytime sections (and the summer course) have three 48-minute lectures and two 48-minute recitations per week. The evening class is structured slightly differently, with two 72-minute lectures and two 48-minute recitations per week. The recitations include computer lab work, but there is no separately scheduled lab for the course.
Statistics 245
Statistics 245 has a prerequisite of Calculus II. Even though calculus is not really used in this course, we prefer that the students have the mathematical sophistication that Calculus II provides. Furthermore, I am not aware of any calculus-based introductory statistics books that fit our course. In the autumn 2007 quarter, the vast majority of the students were juniors and seniors (nearly 80 percent), and three-quarters of them were men. Nearly a third were honors students. In general, the students come from majors in biology, biomedical sciences, engineering, geography, and social and behavioral sciences (economics and psychology students seeking the B.S.). During the academic year, only one daytime lecture is offered (autumn quarter). There are approximately 150 students in the course, and this class meets for three 48-minute lectures and two 48-minute recitations per week. Graduate teaching assistants (GTAs) teach the six recitation sections, which have about 25 students in each. There is no lab component to the course.
64
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Course Overviews
According to our course bulletin, Stat 145 topics include probability, descriptive statistics, correlation, regression, design of experiments, sampling, estimation, and testing; emphasis on applications, statistical reasoning, and data analysis using statistical software. Stat 245 is described as a calculus-based introduction to data analysis, experimental design, sampling, probability, and inference. For both courses, the Web-based statistical software we use is StatCrunch, because it has the benefits of Minitab and allows us to conduct recitations in both the Mac and PC computer rooms. Ohio State has purchased a license for StatCrunch, and our students can access it from within our course management system. We cannot require students to purchase a particular calculator, so this is the closest we can get to students using the same technology in recitations and on homework. My broad goals for both courses are similar. The objectives are for students to learn the following:
Essential techniques for producing data (surveys, experiments, observational studies); analyzing data (graphical and numerical summaries); modeling data (basic probability, sampling distributions); and drawing conclusions from data (inference proceduresconfidence intervals and significance tests) When and how to use technology to aid in solving statistical problems How to produce convincing oral and written statistical arguments, using appropriate terminology How to become critical consumers of published statistical results by heightening their awareness of ways in which statistics can be improperly used to mislead, confuse, or distort the truth
Textbooks
For Statistics 145, we use the second edition of Intro Stats by De Veaux, Velleman, and Bock. For Statistics 245, the text is the third edition of Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis by Peck, Olsen, and Devore. See the Teacher Resources section of this syllabus for full citations.
Course Planners
Statistics 145: Introduction to the Practice of Statistics
In the past two years, we have lost time during the winter quarter, and I have had to drop confidence intervals and hypothesis testing of the population mean from the course during that term. Because of this, I will use the sequencing from autumn 2006 for the three-lecture-a-week section. Chapter 1: Stats Starts Here (0 days) Students are encouraged to read this introduction on their own. Chapter 2: Data (1.5 days) This chapter introduces the how and the Ws of data (who, what, when, where, why). Because students f ind the Ws difficult to grasp at first, it is important to emphasize the importance of context in statistics: k nowing the answers to the Ws makes a study or analysis more meaningful. This chapter also introduces students to the basic differences between categorical, quantitative, ordinal, and identifier variables.
65
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Chapter 3: Displaying Categorical Data (0.51 day) In this chapter, students learn about bar charts and pie charts. These are graphical displays that they should be familiar with from past mathematics (or statistics) classes or from the media. It is important to underscore the pitfalls of each type of display so that students know when they are seeing data portrayed correctly (for example, pictograms typically violate the area principle). Chapter 4: Displaying Quantitative Data (1.5 days) The chapter talks about dotplots, stemplots, and histograms (boxplots appear in chapter 5). Because of the limited time in the quarter system, we have chosen to concentrate on histograms. The text asks students to describe the distribution of a data set by shape, center, and spread. The authors include unusual features (outliers, gaps, etc.) in shape. To emphasize the importance of the unusual features, I separate this category out as a fourth aspect that should be considered when describing distributions. Recently I heard one of my graduate teaching associates split shape up even further, telling her students to address modality and symmetry. Chapter 5: Describing Distributions Numerically (2 days) This chapter talks about the mean, median, interquartile range, and standard deviation. It also introduces boxplots as another option for graphically displaying quantitative data. Students learn when it is most appropriate to use the mean and standard deviation or the median and IQR to describe, respectively, the center and spread of the distribution. QUIZ IN RECITATION ON CHAPTERS 25 Chapter 12: Sample Surveys (1.5 days) The important thing for students to understand about sample surveys is when they should question methodology and how different types of bias act on surveys. An interesting question that arises here at Ohio State in association with that issue is why some of us trust electronic Student Evaluations of Instruction (eSEIs), given the fact that Internet surveys are often useless and students must fill out the eSEIs through their own OSU account. We know that no student can evaluate the same course twice, so that problem is eliminated, but it is good to discuss what types of bias may filter into the eSEIs. Chapter 13: Experiments (1.5 days) In this chapter, the authors use David Moores diagram of an experiment to show random assignment, groups, treatments, and comparison of the response variable. The chapter addresses blocking and matched pairs designs as well. I have used two past AP Statistics Exam questions in connection with this chapter the yoga/tai chi (2003, no. 4) and old/new shampoo (2004, no. 2) experimental design questions. Chapter 14: From Randomness to Probability (LLN) (1 day) The idea of from randomness in the chapter title is lost a bit in Stat 145 because we do not have time to study chapter 11 (Simulation) with any justice; simulation is a key element in understanding how we get from randomness to long-run probabilities. To show the law of large numbers during lecture, I use the coin-toss applet linked to the fifth edition of Introduction to the Practice of Statistics that can be accessed at http://bcs.whfreeman.com/ips5e by clicking on Student Applets and then Probability.
66
Course Organization About AP Statistics
One thing in this chapter that I caution students about is that the addition and multiplication rules are specific to disjoint and independent events, respectively. However, the general probability rules in chapter 15 can be used in the special situations encountered in chapter 14. Chapter 15: Probability Rules! (1 day) When we get to this point in the course, I remind students that I had foreshadowed the general probability rules of this chapter when we talked about the specific rules for disjoint and independent events. Conditional probabilities are always difficult for students to grasp, but I remind them that we are now formalizing the techniques that we used back in chapter 3 when we looked at marginal and conditional distributions of categorical variables. Another stumbling block for students is the temptation to multiply the probability of events A and B when finding the probability of the union of those two P A P B P A B to events. In other words, students tend to make the jump from P A B PA B P A P B P A P B without thinking about the implications. Be aware that they may make this misstep and then, in a later exercise, show that the events are not independent. They routinely do not see the contradiction, despite warnings in both lecture and recitation against this common mistake. Review for midterm exam (1 day) COMMON EVENING MIDTERM ON CHAPTERS 25 AND 1215 Chapter 6: The Standard Deviation as a Ruler and the Normal Model (1.5 days) I teach chapter 6 out of order because it makes more sense to me to have students learn about z-scores and the normal distribution right before they need it (the just in time approach). This has worked in the class so far, but I understand why the authors have placed chapter 6 where it is in the book and why others would teach the chapters in order. Chapter 18: Sampling Distribution Models (CLT) (1.5 days) This chapter deals with sampling distribution models for both proportions and means. It spends a bit more time on proportions than on means: I think this is because the authors move directly into inference for proportions. The sampling distribution is motivated by simulation of data. This can be done and understood without having studied the simulation chapter. QUIZ IN RECITATION ON CHAPTERS 6 AND 18 (sometimes delayed to include chapter 19) Chapter 19: Confidence Intervals for Proportions (1.5 days) The authors introduce confidence intervals in a way that I think makes sense for the class, although students continue to find the process of constructing confidence intervals difficult to understand. One thing that helps is asking them what the probability is that a 95 percent confidence interval contains the true population proportion. Talking about this emphasizes the process of constructing confidence intervals. I use the applet linked to the fifth edition of Introduction to the Practice of Statistics that can be accessed at http://bcs.whfreeman.com/ips5e by clicking on Student Applets and then Confidence Intervals to demonstrate the effect of confidence level on the width of the interval. During recitation, students do an activity with M&Ms®, one that we feel we have improved over the typical version (see Student Activities section at the end of this syllabus). This exercise also carries over to chapter 20, on hypothesis testing.
67
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Chapter 20: Testing Hypotheses About Proportions (2 days) This is a chapter that students find challenging. No matter how you explain the steps to hypothesis testing, they have a difficult time setting up the hypotheses, making a decision using the P-value, and drawing a conclusion in context. Actually calculating the test statistic and the P-value are not the stumbling points for these students. However, I think that AP Statistics students have had more time to be exposed to the process of doing and thinking about statistics and may catch on to these steps more easily than other students. It is important to stress that we use the sample proportion when finding the standard error (and margin of error) for the confidence interval, but we use the hypothesized population proportion when f inding the standard deviation for the hypothesis test. Chapter 21: More About Tests (1.5 days) This chapter ties confidence intervals and hypothesis tests together, explaining how to use a confidence interval to test a hypothesis. It also talks about errors and power, both of which are eliminated from our coverage in the interest of time. We have discussed having the students read this chapter on their own and getting them involved with an activity that would address the same issues. Chapter 23: Inference About Means (2 days) This is a chapter in which I emphasize that we are studying variations on a theme, the theme being inference. The processes of constructing confidence intervals and conducting hypothesis tests are the same as we have already seen, with slight variations in the distribution and formulas used and the conditions checked. Students do not seem to have a difficult time understanding the t distribution, especially when we compare/contrast it with the standard normal distribution. Chapter 7: Scatterplots, Association, and Correlation (1.5 days) Again, as can be seen by the chapter numbers, I have chosen an unconventional order for the topics in the introductory statistics course. Because 10-week quarters are so intense, I like to end on an easier note and let the ideas from inference settle in with the students over the remaining time in the course. Students have no trouble understanding scatterplots and association. The biggest difficulty with correlation actually comes in chapter 8 when they might see some partial StatCrunch output and be asked to state the correlation. It seems that no matter how many times students tell you in class that the correlation is negative when there is a negative association, they still do not pick this out in the final exam question that tests this. Chapter 8: Linear Regression (1.5 days) The actual process of doing linear regression and making predictions does not seem difficult for students. They understand that extrapolation is not something they should do (I like to say Friends dont let friends extrapolate, a slogan that can also be found on an ASA T-shirt!). One concept that is difficult for them to explain on the final exam (which is the only time this is tested) is what a residual plot tells you about the regression.
68
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Chapter 9: Regression Wisdom (1 day) This chapter is to chapters 7 and 8 what chapter 21 is to chapters 19 and 20. There are important concepts in chapter 9, but I find it a little repetitive, so we are trying to develop a lecture activity that would get at all of the ideas without taking class time to go through the chapter itself (students would be responsible for reading the chapter on their own). Review for final exam (2 days) COMMON FINAL EXAM DURING FINALS WEEK (COMPREHENSIVE)
Statistics 245: Introduction to Statistical Analysis
Autumn 2007 was the first quarter that I taught from this text. The notes that I planned for each chapter took longer than I thought. Thus, the following is a reflection of the content coverage for the syllabus as planned in future offerings of the course. Review for the exams takes place in the recitations. Chapter 1: The Role of Statistics and the Data Analysis Process (2 days) In chapter 1, we discuss some basic terminology (e.g., observational units, variables, and categorical and quantitative data). We also examine simple graphical displays (bar graphs for categorical data and dotplots for quantitative data). The idea of central tendency is introduced as a prelude to material to come in chapter 4. Chapter 2: Collecting Data Sensibly (2.5 days) In this chapter, we discuss drawing conclusions from studies (including when it is appropriate to do so). We also consider ways to get a proper random sample, along with other methods of sampling (e.g., convenience sample, stratified sample) and their benefits or detriments. Finally, we outline how to properly design an experiment. Chapter 3: Graphical Methods for Describing Data (1 day) This chapter is a brief look at dotplots, stem-and-leaf diagrams, and histograms. We also discuss what is needed to describe a distribution (shape, center, spread, and unusual features). Chapter 4: Numerical Methods for Describing Data (2.5 days) This chapter examines center (mean, median), spread (range, standard deviation), and z-scores. In addition, the five-number summary, the IQR, and boxplots are addressed. Chapter 6: Probability (2 days) Here we encounter the basic and general probability rules, along with conditional probabilities. EXAM 1 IN CLASS ON CHAPTERS 14 AND 6
69
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Chapter 7: Random Variables and Probability Distributions (3 days) In this chapter, we talk about random variableswhat they are, what a distribution is, and how to find the expected value, variance, and standard deviation. The specific distributions that we study are the binomial and the normal (including the standard normal distribution and how to read a normal table). Chapter 8: Sampling Variability and Sampling Distributions (2 days) This chapter deals with the sampling distribution of the sample proportion and the sample mean. It is important to stress the differences between and among the population distribution, the distribution of a sample, and the sampling distribution. Chapter 9: Estimation Using a Single Sample (2.5 days) This chapter introduces confidence intervals for the population proportion and the population mean. The critical issue to emphasize with students is that conditions must be checked to make sure that they can actually go ahead with calculating the interval. Another thing that should be pointed out is that confidence intervals are not complete at the end of the calculationthey need to be interpreted in the context of the problem. This chapter also addresses the calculation of sample sizes. Chapter 10: Hypothesis Testing Using a Single Sample (3 days) This chapter introduces hypothesis tests for the population proportion and the population mean. Again, it is important to stress that conditions need to be checked to ensure that students can actually go ahead with calculating the interval and that the conclusions made need to be interpreted in the context of the problem. The link between confidence intervals and hypothesis tests is also discussed. EXAM 2 IN CLASS ON CHAPTERS 710 Chapter 11: Comparing Two Populations or Treatments (3 days) Here we look at confidence intervals and hypothesis tests for two populations, including the two-sample difference in proportions, the two-sample difference in means, and the dependent sample mean difference. As in chapters 9 and 10, the process of confidence intervals and hypothesis tests are highlighted (including condition checks and interpreting results in context). Chapter 5: Summarizing Bivariate Data (2.5 days) This chapter deals with scatterplots, correlation, and simple linear regression. The reason for its placement near the end of the quarter is practicalthese are nice concepts to study when the students are tired from a long quarter. This is an introduction to the relationship between two quantitative variables, and bivariate data analysis for categorical variables is discussed in chapter 12. Chapter 12: The Analysis of Categorical Data and Goodness-of-Fit Tests (2 days) It is important for students to see bivariate data analysis for categorical variables. Although they worked with categorical variables in the chapters on inference for proportions, which was a special case
70
Course Organization About AP Statistics
(the normal approximation to the binomial), they have not worked with categorical variables that have more than two categories since the beginning of the quarter. I feel that they need to be exposed to these procedures so that they remember that quantitative variables are not the only type of variables in the world. FINAL EXAM DURING FINALS WEEK (COMPREHENSIVE)
Teaching Strategies
During lectures, students use course note packets that I created, based on the PowerPoint® slides from the texts but with examples added that are of interest to students. The packets use a fill-in-the-blank format, with room for us to work the examples that I have included for that quarter. Many students like the note packets because they can listen in class instead of furiously writing down notes. This is exactly why I developed them, having learned in my education courses (and from personal experience) that it is very difficult to truly listen to the teacher and copy notes from the board at the same time. One novel thing that I do in these classes is to use a tablet PC. This allows me to write on PowerPoint slides that duplicate the note packet, so I can actually do the work with the students and/or incorporate their suggestions. It is very handy to be able to write down notes on a specific question that students might ask as well. During the Stat 145 lectures, we work through at least one example of each concept; extra examples are saved for recitation. I have been trying to find ways to get students in a large lecture to be more talkative and to participate more. To this end, I question students as much as I can during lecture and ask that they offer solutions to examples or hints on how to approach examples. Occasionally, I set them the task of trying something in their notes and then walk around the lecture hall to help individual students before bringing them back together to discuss their solutions. I also have the class do a lot of voting (for example, which answer is correct?) and hope to include clickers (student response systems) and podcasts within the next year or two. Basically, the teaching strategies for the two courses are very similar, but for Stat 245 the notes are more interactive than those I use in Stat 145. It is up to the students to read the book and to grasp the essentials of the concepts. In class, we work through examples, do simulations, use applets, and engage in an interactive lecture. In Stat 145, one lecture period is allotted for review for the midterm exam and two periods for the f inal exam. Quiz review is handled in recitation. For the midterm and final exams, I supply review sheets containing problems similar to those that will be on the exams but that focus on all of the concepts. I always tell my students that if they understand the concepts, they can answer any question, but if they concentrate only on certain types of questions, they might struggle with the concepts. Because of this, I do not provide practice exams. Students have both the midterm review and the final exam review in their note packets, so they can start working on those problems at any time. On the days of review, I ask them which concepts they found most difficult, and we concentrate on those questions first before moving on to others (time allowing). Because there is never enough time to finish all of the review questions, I release solutions to the reviews prior to the exams so that students can compare their solutions with mine.
Lab Component
Recitation is the place where students get to ask questions about homework, work on activities, do student presentations, and so forth. The recitations are held in computer labs, so students can actively work with StatCrunch in the lab. Each recitation room also has an instructor podium, which allows the graduate teaching associates (GTAs) to project what they are demonstrating for the entire class. In the PC rooms, we have NetSupport School classroom management software, which allows the instructor to project her or his screen onto the students computer screens and project one students screen onto the screen at the front of the class. The instructor can also shut down the computers when they are not being used in recitation so that students cannot surf the Web or send e-mail during class.
71
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Recitations take many different forms, depending on the GTA in charge. As part of a functional and productive instructional team, the GTAs share ideas with each othersuch as which activities to include (see my Student Activities section for a few examples), prep questions that students work on before coming to recitation, knowledge checks (mini-quizzes), and how to approach difficult concepts. I like to give the associates room to teach in a style that works best for them (and their students) but to also provide some framework, with extra exercises from the book that they might choose to work on if they cannot think of something else to doflexibility within a structure is how we all look at it. All GTAs have their students work in groups for at least some of the time during recitation. Last quarter we tried having students work in groups on smaller, more frequent homework assignments (compared with our control group, which had fewer, longer, individual homework assignments). This quarter we had the students do the more frequent homework individually. We have not yet done a final analysis, but preliminary results indicate that the more frequent group work was not as effective as the longer individual homework.
Student Evaluation
Statistics 145
Students grades for the course are based on the following components: Homework (20 percent) Recitation participation (10 percent) Quizzes (20 percent) Midterm exam (20 percent) Final exam (30 percent) There are 78 homework assignments every quarter, each consisting of 611 exercises from the textbook. Each assignment is worth 20 points. Ten points are earned for completion of the homework, and the other 10 are awarded, as appropriate, for accuracy of the solutions. Each GTA grades from a rubric that I provide at the beginning of the quarter. Regardless of the number of assignments, homework counts as 20 percent of the students grade. For example, if there are 8 homework assignments during a quarter, each is worth 2.5 percent of the students total grade. Recitation participation is loosely based on attendance and performance on specified activities. Each GTA has the latitude to determine how recitation participation will be graded, but the students are aware of this structure from the GTAs syllabus. Here are examples of recitation participation guidelines from two different associates: Your recitation participation grade will be determined in the following manner: Each recitation is worth 10 points. You will receive 4 points just for attending recitation (only 1 point if you are tardy or leave early) and 6 points for participating in the activity (this includes actively listening, making comments, doing board work, and turning in any worksheets done in class). There are 19 classes this quarter, making the total number of points you can earn 190. I will take the total number of points you earn out of 170 to calculate your participation percentage. (You cannot get more than 100 percent for participationeven if you attend and participate in all 19 classes.)
72
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Your recitation attendance and participation grade will be determined in the following manner: 5 percent knowledge checks 2.5 percent attendance 2.5 percent participation Knowledge checks are very short closed-book, closed-notes assessments and are designed to help you stay up-to-date with your readings and studying for the course. They are given at the beginning of designated recitations and last about five minutes. You will not be given extra time for the knowledge check if you are late or miss recitation that day. For this reason, I will drop your lowest knowledge-check score. Also note that I will give you about 10 to 20 questions to study for each knowledge check and then choose only a handful of them for the in-class assessment. Each of the two quizzes given in recitation is worth 10 percent of a students grade. Each GTA reviews for the quiz for about 25 minutes, and then students are given 20 to 25 minutes to take the quiz. Quizzes are typically made up of 3 or 4 multiple-choice questions and 2 free-response questions. Students are allowed to use one 3 by 5 inch notecard (both sides) with whatever facts, formulas, and examples they want for each quiz. Statistical tables are provided as necessary. The midterm is given in the evening so that students from both daytime lectures and from the evening lecture can take the exam at the same time. It usually consists of 10 multiple-choice questions and 3 or 4 free-response questions. Students are allowed to use one 8½ by 11 inch sheet of paper (both sides) with whatever facts, formulas, and examples they want for the midterm. Statistical tables are provided as necessary. The final exam is also given at a single time on the first evening of finals week. Typically, it has 15 multiple-choice questions and 5 or 6 free-response questions. Students are allowed to use two 8½ by 11 inch sheets of paper (both sides) with whatever facts, formulas, and examples they want for the final. Statistical tables are provided as necessary.
Statistics 245
Students grades are determined based on the following components: Homework (20 percent) Two in-quarter exams (25 percent each) Final exam (30 percent) There are approximately 10 homework assignments, each of which consists of 611 exercises from the textbook. Every homework assignment is worth 20 points. Ten of these points are for completion of the homework, and 10 points are awarded for accuracy. Each GTA grades from a rubric that I provide at the beginning of the quarter. Regardless of the number of homework assignments, homework counts as 20 percent of the students grade. For example, if there are 10 homework assignments during a quarter, each is worth 2 percent of the students total grade. The two in-quarter exams are given during a lecture period. A typical exam consists of 1015 true/false questions and 3 or 4 free-response questions. Students are allowed to use one 8½ by 11 inch sheet of paper (both sides) with whatever facts, formulas, and examples they want to use. Statistical tables are provided as necessary.
73
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
The final exam is given during the time allotted for our course during finals week. It contains 2025 true/false questions and 56 free-response questions. Students are allowed to use two 8½ by 11 inch sheets of paper (both sides) with whatever facts, formulas, and examples they want to have available. Statistical tables are provided as necessary. For both courses, I use the following grading scale: B+ 8789 percent B 8386 percent B 8082 percent C+ 7779 percent C 7376 percent C 7072 percent D 6069 percent F below 60 percent
A 93100 percent A 9092 percent
There is no standard scale dictated by Ohio State.
Teacher Resources
Primary Textbooks and Related Resources
Statistics 145 De Veaux, Richard D., Paul F. Velleman, and David E. Bock. Intro Stats. 2nd ed. Boston: Pearson/AddisonWesley, 2006. De Veaux, Richard D., Paul F. Velleman, and David E. Bock. TestGen. CD-ROM. 2nd ed. Boston: Pearson/Addison-Wesley, 2006. Computerized test bank. Must be used in conjunction with Pearsons TestGen application: http://wpslive.pearsoncmg.com/wps/media/access/Pearson_Default/720/737317/testgen_login.html. De Veaux, Richard D., Paul F. Velleman, David E. Bock, and William B. Craine III. Instructors Solutions Manual for Intro Stats. 2nd ed. Boston: Pearson/Addison-Wesley, 2006. Miller, Jackie, Richard D. De Veaux, Paul F. Velleman, and David E. Bock. Printed Test Bank and Resource Guide. 2nd ed. Boston: Pearson/Addison-Wesley, 2006. Statistics 245 Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. 3rd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2008.
Supplementary Textbooks for Reference
Agresti, Alan, and Christine Franklin. Statistics: The Art and Science of Learning from Data. Upper Saddle R iver, N.J.: Prentice Hall, 2007. Utts, Jessica M., and Robert F. Heckard. Mind on Statistics. 3rd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2007.
Internet Resources
ARTIST (Assessment Resource Tools for Improving Statistical Thinking). https://app.gen.umn.edu/artist/index.html. Provides a variety of assessment resources for teaching first courses in statistics.
74
Course Organization About AP Statistics
CAUSEweb. w ww.causeweb.org. Web site for the Consortium for the Advancement of Undergraduate Statistics Education, a national organization whose mission is to support and advance undergraduate statistics education in four target areas: resources, professional development, outreach, and research. Moore, David S. Statistical Applets for The Practice of Statistics, 5th ed. http://bcs.whfreeman.com/ips5e. Scroll down to Student Tools and click on Statistical Applets. (You can also go to www.whfreeman.com, click on Statistics, and search for Moore to find other texts that may have linked applets.) StatCrunch: Data Analysis on the Web. w ww.statcrunch.com.
Student Activities
The following pages contain two activities that have been developed for Stat 145 and structured with instructions for the teacher. These activities (and others) have been submitted to CAUSEweb (www. causeweb.org) for inclusion in the peer-reviewed activities there. Although these activities and their overviews have not been copyrighted, please give credit to Beau Corkins, Marian Frazier, and Jackie Miller, all of Ohio State University, when using them.
Categorical Data (Chapter 3)
Overview Objective We want the students to familiarize themselves with the technology and its use in calculating marginal, conditional, and joint distributions. In addition, students are asked to make conclusions from these tabular and graphical displays. Finally, they are required to come up with their own way (tables, graphs, and so forth) to answer content questions. The Activity Prior to the assignment of this activity, students should have received an introduction to graphical displays of quantitative data, contingency (two-way) tables, and joint/marginal/conditional distributions. The data include information on 198 pizza deliveries by various pizza shops in the Ohio State University area. To familiarize them with the technological package they are using, students are first asked to make some simple graphs (bar charts, pie charts) and summarize what they see on these graphs. They are then asked to use multiple graphs to guess which store has the worst on-time record; they use contingency tables to f ind the conditional distribution and support this guess. Finally, they are asked several questions and not given any clear instructions about how to answer them. In this section, the hope is that students will use what they learned from the first several questions to answer in whatever way (tabular, graphical) makes the most sense to them. Assessment The activity is not structured to include any formal assessment. However, assessment can certainly occur through discussion, both classwide and one-on-one. Many of the students questions will focus on the technology: how to construct different graphs or tables. But if this is the first time students have seen these types of displays, they will also ask more substantive questions about how to interpret the results. Especially with the latter, more open-ended questions, you may need to guide students and remind them of what they were supposed to have learned in the earlier questions. As these questions can be answered in several ways, this may lead to a discussion of the best way to approach them.
75
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
More formal assessment will generally occur later, in quiz or exam questions. Sample questions include the following:
Present a graphical display (bar chart, pie chart), and ask students to report some result in context. Ask them to calculate the conditional or marginal distribution. Given the conditional distribution, are two variables independent?
Teaching Notes This activity can be done in class or assigned as out-of-class work. If this is the first time that students are using the technology, we suggest that it be done in class so they can ask questions and collaborate. The activity works extremely well with pairs or groups of three.
This activity is not dependent on any particular choice of technology. However, students cannot perform the necessary work on their calculators, so they must have access to some statistical computer package. The activity takes approximately 40 to 50 minutes, not including a classwide discussion or debriefing session. As mentioned above, many of the students questions will focus on how to use the technology. We recommend letting the students work together to explore the computer package: encourage them to play around and find the answer themselves. Of course, the instructor should be available and k nowledgeable about the package and how to create every display in the activity.
Student Worksheet with Instructors Solutions
Introduction How long did you have to wait the last time you ordered pizza? We all know that there is nothing worse than waiting for a hot, cheesy pizza when you are hungry and trying to get through halftime. So if you want your pizza on time, from whomand whenshould you order? In this activity, we will be using categorical data analysis (including contingency tables, bar charts, and pie charts) to explore which stores have the worst on-time record and which days and times are most closely associated with late deliveries. The Study The file PIZZA contains data on 198 pizza deliveries collected by students taking an introductory statistics class at Ohio State University in February 2001. The Variables Store = name of pizza store Day of week = day of the week of the order Distance = distance (miles) from pizza shop to delivery point Estimate = number of minutes estimated by pizza shop for delivery, or midrange (for example, if 4560 was quoted, then used 53) Time ordered = hour:minutes Time blocks: Daytime = pizza ordered noon to 6 p.m. Dinnertime = pizza ordered 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. Evening = pizza ordered 8 p.m. to 10 p.m. Nighttime = pizza ordered 10 p.m. to 3 a.m.
76
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Time arrived = hour:minutes Delivery time = time arrived minus time ordered (in minutes) Pizzas = number of pizzas ordered Other items = indicates if something besides pizza was also ordered (yes/no) Actual - Estimate = delivery time minus estimate (that is, positive values mean the pizza was late) ±(a-e) = 1 if the pizza was late, 1 if the pizza was early, 0 if the pizza was exactly on time Questions [The solutions appear in boldface throughout.] 1. On StatCrunch, load the file pizza. 2. Create a bar chart of store. What store has the largest proportion of orders on this list? Papa Johns 3. Create a pie chart of the marginal distribution of late status (whether the pizza was early, on time, or late). Are most pizzas early, late, or on time? The majority of pizzas are early. 4. Open the bar chart (no. 2) and pie chart (no. 3) side-by-side. Notice that by clicking on a section of the pie chart, StatCrunch highlights those stores that make up that section. Which two stores appear to have the highest percentages of late pizzas? Store 1: Adriaticos Store 2: Pizza Hut 5. Create a contingency table of store versus late status (whether the pizza was early, on time, or late). Include in this contingency table the values row percent, column percent, and percent of total. Contingency Table Results Rows: store Columns: sign(ae) Cell format Count (Row percent) (Column percent) (Percent of total)
77
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
1 Adriatico\s 7 (35%) (6.25%) (3.535%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 10 (71.43%) (8.929%) (5.051%) 7 (58.33%) (6.25%) (3.535%) 15 (53.57%) (13.39%) (7.576%) 5 (55.56%) (4.464%) (2.525%) 1 (100%) (0.8929%) (0.5051%) 1 (100%) (0.8929%) (0.5051%) 9 (69.23%) (8.036%) (4.545%) 5 (83.33%) (4.464%) (2.525%)
0 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 2 (100%) (11.76%) (1.01%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 2 (16.67%) (11.76%) (1.01%) 4 (14.29%) (23.53%) (2.02%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 2 (15.38%) (11.76%) (1.01%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%)
1 13 (65%) (18.84%) (6.566%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 4 (28.57%) (5.797%) (2.02%) 3 (25%) (4.348%) (1.515%) 9 (32.14%) (13.04%) (4.545%) 4 (44.44%) (5.797%) (2.02%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 2 (15.38%) (2.899%) (1.01%) 1 (16.67%) (1.449%) (0.5051%)
Total 20 (100.00%) (10.1%) (10.1%) 2 (100.00%) (1.01%) (1.01%) 14 (100.00%) (7.071%) (7.071%) 12 (100.00%) (6.061%) (6.061%) 28 (100.00%) (14.14%) (14.14%) 9 (100.00%) (4.545%) (4.545%) 1 (100.00%) (0.5051%) (0.5051%) 1 (100.00%) (0.5051%) (0.5051%) 13 (100.00%) (6.566%) (6.566%) 6 (100.00%) (3.03%) (3.03%)
Ange\s
Catfish Biffs
Domino\s
Donatos
East of Chicago
Eddy\s
Grandad\s
Gumby\s
HoundDog\s
78
Course Organization About AP Statistics
1 Kings 3 (50%) (2.679%) (1.515%) 4 (66.67%) (3.571%) (2.02%) 2 (100%) (1.786%) (1.01%) 33 (60%) (29.46%) (16.67%) 1 (100%) (0.8929%) (0.5051%) 8 (38.1%) (7.143%) (4.04%) 1 (100%) (0.8929%) (0.5051%) 112 (56.57%) (100.00%) (56.57%)
0 1 (16.67%) (5.882%) (0.5051%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 3 (5.455%) (17.65%) (1.515%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 3 (14.29%) (17.65%) (1.515%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 17 (8.586%) (100.00%) (8.586%)
1 2 (33.33%) (2.899%) (1.01%) 2 (33.33%) (2.899%) (1.01%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 19 (34.55%) (27.54%) (9.596%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 10 (47.62%) (14.49%) (5.051%) 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 69 (34.85%) (100.00%) (34.85%)
Total 6 (100.00%) (3.03%) (3.03%) 6 (100.00%) (3.03%) (3.03%) 2 (100.00%) (1.01%) (1.01%) 55 (100.00%) (27.78%) (27.78%) 1 (100.00%) (0.5051%) (0.5051%) 21 (100.00%) (10.61%) (10.61%) 1 (100.00%) (0.5051%) (0.5051%) 198 (100.00%) (100.00%) (100.00%)
Monkey
Ohio State
Papa John\s
Peppercini\s
Pizza Hut
Rotolo\s
Total
6. Prove your assertion in question 4 by finding the conditional distribution of late status given Store 1 and the conditional distribution of late status given Store 2. Adriaticos Late On time Early % 65% 0% 35% Pizza Hut Late On time Early % 47.6% 14.3% 38.1%
79
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
7. If an ordered pizza is randomly selected, find the probability that it was from Dominos and that it was early. 3.535% 8. Do time of day and late status appear to be independent? Justify your answer. For this, we made a contingency table of time of day versus late status (see below). Although daytime and nighttime have very similar conditional distributions, and dinnertime and evening are similar, the two groups (day/night and dinner/evening) are very different from each other. Based on this, we conclude that time of day and late status are not independent variables. Contingency Table Results Rows: time blocks Columns: sign(ae) Cell format Count (Row percent) (Column percent) (Percent of total) Early Daytime 15 (45.45%) (13.39%) (7.576%) 43 (59.72%) (38.39%) (21.72%) 36 (63.16%) (32.14%) (18.18%) 18 (50%) (16.07%) (9.091%) 112 (56.57%) (100.00%) (56.57%) On Time 1 (3.03%) (5.882%) (0.5051%) 6 (8.333%) (35.29%) (3.03%) 9 (15.79%) (52.94%) (4.545%) 1 (2.778%) (5.882%) (0.5051%) 17 (8.586%) (100.00%) (8.586%) Late 17 (51.52%) (24.64%) (8.586%) 23 (31.94%) (33.33%) (11.62%) 12 (21.05%) (17.39%) (6.061%) 17 (47.22%) (24.64%) (8.586%) 69 (34.85%) (100.00%) (34.85%) Total 33 (100.00%) (16.67%) (16.67%) 72 (100.00%) (36.36%) (36.36%) 57 (100.00%) (28.79%) (28.79%) 36 (100.00%) (18.18%) (18.18%) 198 (100.00%) (100.00%) (100.00%)
Dinnertime
Evening
Nighttime
Total
80
Course Organization About AP Statistics
9. Are pizzas more likely to be late during the week (MTh) or on the weekend (FSun)? Why do you think this is? For this, we made a contingency table of day of week versus late status (see below). Looking at row percent, a higher percentage of pizzas are late during the week. Specifically, Tuesday has the highest percentage of late pizzas versus early/on-time ones. Looking at column percent, the highest percentage of late pizzas throughout the week come from weekdays. A possible reason for this is that the pizza places are better staffed on the weekends. They know demand will be high then, so they have a lower percentage of late deliveries. Contingency Table Results Rows: day Columns: sign(ae) Cell format Count (Row percent) (Column percent) (Percent of total)
81
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Early Friday 9 (64.29%) (8.036%) (4.545%) 20 (55.56%) (17.86%) (10.1%) 24 (66.67%) (21.43%) (12.12%) 18 (66.67%) (16.07%) (9.091%) 15 (51.72%) (13.39%) (7.576%) 8 (30.77%) (7.143%) (4.04%) 18 (60%) (16.07%) (9.091%) 112 (56.57%) (100.00%) (56.57%)
On Time 0 (0%) (0%) (0%) 4 (11.11%) (23.53%) (2.02%) 2 (5.556%) (11.76%) (1.01%) 3 (11.11%) (17.65%) (1.515%) 2 (6.897%) (11.76%) (1.01%) 5 (19.23%) (29.41%) (2.525%) 1 (3.333%) (5.882%) (0.5051%) 17 (8.586%) (100.00%) (8.586%)
Late 5 (35.71%) (7.246%) (2.525%) 12 (33.33%) (17.39%) (6.061%) 10 (27.78%) (14.49%) (5.051%) 6 (22.22%) (8.696%) (3.03%) 12 (41.38%) (17.39%) (6.061%) 13 (50%) (18.84%) (6.566%) 11 (36.67%) (15.94%) (5.556%) 69 (34.85%) (100.00%) (34.85%)
Total 14 (100.00%) (7.071%) (7.071%) 36 (100.00%) (18.18%) (18.18%) 36 (100.00%) (18.18%) (18.18%) 27 (100.00%) (13.64%) (13.64%) 29 (100.00%) (14.65%) (14.65%) 26 (100.00%) (13.13%) (13.13%) 30 (100.00%) (15.15%) (15.15%) 198 (100.00%) (100.00%) (100.00%)
Monday
Saturday
Sunday
Thursday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Total
Inference for Proportions (Chapters 19 and 20)
Overview Objective We want students to practice constructing confidence intervals and performing hypothesis tests. In addition, this activity stresses interpretation of confidence intervals and comparison and application of results in context. The Activity Prior to the assignment of this activity, students should have received instruction in sampling distributions and an introduction to constructing confidence intervals for proportions. They should understand the ˆ difference between p and p, although this activity may help them grasp the difference. For the second part
82
Course Organization About AP Statistics
of the activity, students should have received an introduction to hypothesis testing. The activity discusses the connection between confidence intervals and hypothesis testing, but it is not necessary that the students see this beforehand. In this activity, students try to determine whether Mars, Inc., is accurate in its claim that 20 percent of plain M&Ms are orange. The data for this activity are collected by students in small groups. Each group takes a sample of M&Ms (how many is determined by the class) and counts what percentage are orange. Each group then constructs and interprets its own confidence interval based on that groups sample data. Then they are asked to compare their results (and those of the entire class) to what we expect given Marss claim. The second part of the activity explores this question through hypothesis testing. Because this is probably the first activity that students have done with testing, they are taken step-by-step through the process. Again, they interpret their results and compare them to those of the entire class, Mars, and their own results from part 1. Assessment The activity is not structured to include any formal assessment. However, assessment can certainly occur through discussion, both classwide and one-on-one. Several parts of this activity lend themselves to discussion. The first section (on checking conditions) is meant as a whole-class discussion and decisionmaking process. The interpretation of confidence intervals and conclusions from testing will probably lead to spirited exchanges among group members, as will question 5b in part 1. Questions 6 and 7 (part 1) and question 5 (part 2) require the whole class to report and discuss their results and what conclusion they can make about those results. More formal assessment will generally occur later, in quiz or exam questions. Questions will most likely give students a sample statistic and require them to construct a confidence interval or perform a hypothesis test at some confidence level. Another type of question might identify a confidence level and the results of a hypothesis test and ask students to compare the results or explain how the two are related. Teaching Notes This activity is designed for in-class, group work. It would not be as helpful in an individual, out-ofclass situation. The activity works extremely well with several pairs or groups of three.
This activity is not dependent on any particular choice of technology. In fact, it requires no higher statistical packageall work can be done on a basic calculator, with access to a standard normal table. Each part of the activity takes approximately 40 to 50 minutes. Several parts of this activity are designed to foster (in fact, require) whole-class discussion. The instructor should encourage (and be prepared for) differences in ideas and opinions. For this reason, time constraints may be an issue; instructors should budget time wisely so that this discussion time does not suffer.
Student Worksheet and Instructors Solutions
Mars, Inc., claims that its plain M&Ms are made up of a certain percentage of orange, blue, green, yellow, red, and brown candies. In this activity, we will explore whether this claim is true. Part 1: Confidence Intervals 1. How will we sample the M&Ms to make sure that all our assumptions/conditions are met? a. Plausible independence condition
83
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Because the population of M&Ms is so vast, we can assume that our sampling is not imposing any dependence. Our M&Ms are from the same bag, however, and that may be a concern with respect to independence. b. Randomization condition We must sample in a way that is random: pouring the candies from a bag or using a random dispenser are possibilities. c. 10 percent conditionis the sample size no more than 10 percent of the population? Check. d. Success/failure conditiondo we have at least 10 successes and 10 failures? We must sample enough M&Ms to insure that np > 10. Because p = .20, this means that at least 50 M&Ms are necessary. Thus, you might want to put the students in pairs or small groups, in the interest of saving time and money. Decide, based on these conditions, how we will sample, including how many M&Ms per person. 2. Count the number of orange M&Ms in your sample: x If we are interested in the proportion of all M&Ms that are orange, what are the parameter, p, and ˆ ˆ the statistic, p ? What is your value of p ? p = proportion of all M&Ms that are orange
ˆ p = proportion of M&Ms in my sample of size n that are orange = x/n
ˆ Different groups will get different values for p . ˆ ˆ 3. Estimate the standard error for your p. (Hint: Remember the sampling distribution of p from chapter 18.) ˆ ˆ p(1 p) ˆ SE( p) n
4. Construct an approximate 68 percent confidence interval and an approximate 95 percent confidence interval for p, the true percentage of M&Ms that are orange. Remember to interpret these intervals in context! ˆ ˆ p(1 p) ˆ 68 percent confidence interval: p 0.994 n ˆ ˆ p(1 p) ˆ 95 percent confidence interval: p 1.96 n Interpretation: We are 68 percent confident that the true proportion of orange M&Ms is between Or: If this study was repeated many times, and if each time we randomly drew x M&Ms, found the proportion of those that were orange, and constructed a 68 percent confidence interval, we would expect approximately 68 percent of those intervals to contain p, the true proportion of orange M&Ms. The interpretation for the 95 percent confidence interval should be analogous to that of the 68 percent confidence interval. and .
84
Course Organization About AP Statistics
5. Mars claims that 20 percent of plain M&Ms are orange (http://us.mms.com/us/about/products/milkchocolate/). Did your 68 percent confidence interval contain the p 0.2 f igure advertised by the company? Did your 95 percent confidence interval contain this figure? a. Based on your intervals, does p 0.2 seem reasonable?
If their interval contains 0.2, students will certainly say it is reasonable. If the interval does not, they may say that it is reasonable (it almost contains 0.2; this is only one sample) or unreasonable (0.2 is not anywhere near the interval). b. How big would your confidence interval have to be so that p 0.2 is within the limits? That is, what is the confidence level of the narrowest interval that still contains 0.2?
ˆ For a given p : Recall that the general form of a confidence interval is ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ p(1 p) ˆ p(1 p) ˆ . ,p z * p z* n n ˆ We want 0.2 to be on the edge of this interval. If 0.2 p , students should set ˆ ˆ ˆ (1 p) ˆ p(1 p) p ˆ ˆ ˆ 0.2 p z* 0.2 and solve for z*. (If 0.2 p, set p z * n n
and solve for z*.) This will give the z* for the narrowest interval that contains 0.2. Then use the standard normal table to find the corresponding confidence level. 6. We will now look at everyones intervals: Talk about why we do this. How many (and what percentage) of the classes intervals include p with what we expect? 0.2 ? How does this compare
Of course, we expect 68 percent (95 percent) of the confidence intervals to contain p. Of the intervals that do not include 0.2, how many are too high (above 0.2)? How many are too low? We ask this because it may be that your class has values that are systematically too high or too low, leading to the conclusion (below) that there are more (or less) than 20 percent orange M&Ms. 7. Discuss: Do you think that there are, in fact, 20 percent orange M&Ms? Obviously, this will depend on your classes results. Things to point out include how many high/ low intervals there are (see above), issues with sampling variability, and so forth. Part 2: Hypothesis Testing In part 1, we constructed confidence intervals to assess whether we thought Mars was telling the truth about the proportion of orange M&Ms. Now we will attempt to answer this same question in another way. 1. How will we check if the facts are consistent with what Mars claims? What parameter are we testing? Hypotheses: H0 : p Ha : p 0. 2 0. 2 0.2 or p 0.2 specifically, so test the general
We have no a priori reason to believe that p two-sided alternative.
85
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
2. Model: What kind of test will we do here? Two-sided one-sample proportion. Are the appropriate conditions satisfied? Plausible independence: As mentioned above, there might be issues with this. Proceed with caution. Randomization: We tried to achieve this through our sampling method. Success/failure: It is hoped that all students had (at least) 10 orange M&Ms in their samples (assuming samples of size 50). 10%: n is certainly less than the entire population of M&Ms. What is our null model?
ˆ The sampling distribution of p is Normal with mean = p
0.2 and st.dev. =
p(1
n
p)
0.02(0.98) . Remember to stress that in a hypothesis test, we assume H is true. 0 n
3. Mechanics: You want to compare your data to what we would expect if the null model were true. Thus, your z value is . . . ˆ p 0.2 z 0.02(0.98) n . . . and your P-value is . . . P-value = 2P (Z | z |) 4. . . . which leads you to conclude . . . Talk about what α level they compared this to. Do not institute a mindless µ = 0.05.rule with no justification! 5. Discuss: Does this agree with what you decided in part 1 about Marss claim? What about everyone else? How many of your classmates rejected the null hypothesis? Here, have them look at whether they reached the same conclusion as in part 1. This should lead to a discussion of the relationship between confidence intervals and hypothesis testing. The number who rejected here should be (almost) the same as those who had intervals not containing 0.2.
86
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sample Syllabus 3
Michael Allwood Brunswick School Greenwich, Connecticut
School Profile
Location and Environment: Brunswick is a pre-K12 boys private day school in Greenwich, a town at the southwestern tip of Connecticut. Brunswicks Upper School (grades 912) has a coordinated arrangement with Greenwich Academy, the girls private school located close by, and the boys and girls take academic courses on both campuses. Thus, the high school boys interact with the girls in academic, artistic, and social contexts, with the rest of their school life (student governments, athletics, publications) being a single-sex experience. The schools mathematics departments, however, have opted to work separately, based on research that has shown that girls learn mathematics more effectively in a single-sex environment. Brunswick parents take a strong interest in their sons education, so we are lucky to have students who are willing to work very hard for academic success. Consequently, the schools college record is impressive, with all of our students attending college and nearly 90 percent of our graduates going on to schools designated by Barrons Educational Series as highly competitive or most competitive. Grades: Prekindergarten12 Type: College-preparatory boys day school Total Enrollment: 884 Ethnic Diversity: African American, 4.7 percent; Hispanic/Latino, 3.4 percent; Asian American, 3.3 percent; Middle Eastern American, 0.7 percent; Native American, 0.1 percent; multiracial, 3.0 percent. College Record: All of our graduates go on to four-year colleges.
Personal Philosophy
Most of the students who take AP Statistics at Brunswick do so because they like math, and teaching the course gives me the opportunity to show how mathematics and mathematical thinking can be applied to important real-life situations. The AP Statistics Exam requires of the student a true understanding of the material included in the course, and 75 percent of its content is descriptive and/or interpretative. In recognition of this, I encourage in-depth discussion of the concepts underlying statistical thinking and of the process of applying these ideas to the everyday issues that are raised in class. Some of the more complex principles are clarified by means of classroom activities, and throughout the course I emphasize the need for written explanations that employ correct use of terminology and that are clear, precise, and concise.
Class Profile
Each year the school offers either one or two sections of AP Statistics, depending on the number of students choosing the course. When we have had two sections, the two teachers have followed the same curriculum and given the same tests. Currently, we have one section of 15 students. Generally, we prefer that students take AP Statistics only as a second math course, and those who enroll in this class must have previously taken, or concurrently be taking, Precalculus. All students in the course take the AP Exam.
87
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Brunswicks Upper School operates on a seven-day rotating schedule, in which each class meets for an hour on five school days in every seven. The schools academic year runs from September to June and is 33 weeks long, exclusive of breaks and holidays. It is divided into four quarters, with a midyear exam at the end of the first semester. AP math classes do not meet after the AP Exams.
Course Overview
The topics are largely organized in the order in which they are presented in the textbook, with the main exceptions being that the data collection unit is left until after bivariate data, and errors in hypothesis testing and regression are left until the end of the course. Each student owns a TI-83 Plus or TI-84 calculator. A TI viewscreen with overhead projector is used in class (usually operated by a student). Students are given a copy of the formula sheet used in the AP Exam at the start of the course. Copies of this sheet are also provided during the tests.
Course Objectives
My aim is that students finishing the course should have attained the following competencies:
Know the facts and have the skills required by the AP Statistics Course Description Have an intuitive understanding of the background of these facts and skills Be able to explain and interpret statistical concepts with clear and refined use of language Have gained experience in the application of statistical ideas to real-life situations Have developed an appreciation for the relevance and significance of statistics in the real world
Texts
Our primary text is the second edition of Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis by Peck, Olsen, and Devore. We also use the second edition of The Practice of Statistics by Yates, Moore, and Starnes. (See the Teacher Resources section in this syllabus for full citations.)
Course Planner
Please note the following:
The timetable below represents the plan for a typical year. In any given year, it must always be adapted according to the needs of the students, interruptions to the schedule, and so forth. Possible examples and exercises from the textbook that might be used in each class or homework assignment are listed in brackets at the end of each entry. Ex. refers to a worked example from the textbook, in which the authors have provided a solution to the problem. Made-up exs. refers to times when data from students are used, when data from a previous example are used to demonstrate a new concept, or when numbers are generated on the spot. Items that are not preceded by any abbreviation indicate an exercise from one of the textbooks problem sets. The following abbreviations are used to indicate source material: POD = Peck, Olsen, Devore, Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis; YMS = Yates, Moore, and Starnes, The Practice of Statistics.
88
Semester One
UNIT I: DATA SUMMARY AND DISPLAY
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Class 1 (Some of Unit I is included in the previous years math course, so these items can be covered quickly.) Stem-and-leaf displays; shapes of distributions; relationship of shape of stem-and-leaf display to pattern in dotplot; mention of splitting stems in stem-and-leaf display; median and quartiles, interquartile range (percentiles); middle 50 percent [Ex. 3.10, Ex. 3.15 (draw stemplot), 3.18 (adapted), made-up exs.] Class 2 Use of calculator to find five-number summary; boxplots; parallel boxplots; comparing distributions [3.22 (adapted), 3.62, 4.34 (adapted), made-up exs.; and the main exercise from Matching Plots to Variables, in Scheaffer et al., Activity-Based Statistics, p. 15] AP tip: Comparing distributions is very important for the AP Exam: see the exam scoring guidelines for detailse.g., 2005, free-response question no. 1(a). Class 3 Outliers; outliers on calculator (modified boxplot); mean, variance, standard deviation; mean, variance, standard deviation of frequency distribution; mean, variance, and standard deviation (including frequency distributions) on calculator [3.28 (adapted), 3.32 (adapted), 4.37 (adapted), made-up exs.] Class 4 Mean versus median and implication of skewness; sensitivity of mean and standard deviation to extreme values; criteria for appropriateness of use of mean and standard deviation; discrete versus continuous data; histograms; z-scores [3.28, 3.26, Ex. 4.19, 4.43, made-up exs.] UNIT II: BIVARIATE DATA Class 5 Scatterplots and correlation in general; drawing scatterplot on calculator and commenting; calculation of correlation using calculator; range of values of correlation; correlation formula [5.6 (adapted), 5.12, 5.16, made-up exs.] Class 6 Test on Unit I Class 7 Correlation: explanation of invariance under addition of a constant to all x- (or y-) values and under multiplication of all x- (or y-) values by a constant; correlation versus causation; interpretation of correlation value; introduction to regression; use of the calculator to find the equation of the regression line and draw on graph [5.9, 5.12, 5.17, made-up exs.] AP tip: The interpretation of the value of the correlation is very important for the AP Exam: see the exam scoring guidelines for detailse.g., 2002, free-response question no. 4. Class 8 Definition of regression line in terms of least squares; least-squares activity (see the Student Activities section in this syllabus for details); formulas for slope and y-intercept; how to state the equation of the regression line [5.19, 5.21] AP tip: When stating the equation of the regression line, AP Exam questions require definition of any variables used, along with the word predicted applied to the y-variable.
89
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Class 9 Interpretation of slope and y-intercept of the regression line; extrapolation; outliers in bivariate context; influential points; calculator demonstration for influential points (see Calculator Demonstrations in my Student Activities section for details) [5.34, 5.36, Ex. 5.10 (adapted)] AP tip: Correct interpretation of the slope and y-intercept of the regression line are important for the AP Exam: see exam scoring guidelines for detailse.g., 1999, free-response question no. 1. Class 10 Use of residual plot to show if a straight line is the best model; sum of squares of residuals and its relevance; calculator demonstration for residual plots (see Calculator Demonstrations in my Student Activities section for details); introduction to coefficient of determination [5.32, 5.33, made-up exs.] Class 11 Coefficient of determination, r2; reading computer displays in bivariate context; calculation of b, a, and r without statistical features of the calculator; equation on formula sheet relating b and r [5.41, 5.42, made-up exs.] The coefficient of determination: This is one of the trickiest concepts in the course. I have found it best to explain the idea in the following way: When all the points lie on a straight line, there is some variability in the y-values but it is all explained by the x variable (if I know the x value, I know the y value exactly); one y value is higher than another because the associated x value is higher (positive association). When the points are moved off the line, there is unexplained variability in the y-values. In this second situation, some of the variability in the y-values can be attributed to variation of y with x according to the line (as in the first situation), and the remainder can be attributed to the fact that the points are not on the line. The proportion of the y-variability that is explained by the variation of y with x according to the line is r2. When points are close to the line, the unexplained variability is low. When points are far from the line, the line has low predictive ability. UNIT III: COLLECTING DATA (1) Class 12 Difference between observational study and experiment; limitation of observational study; confounding variables [2.27, 2.28, 2.35, 2.36, 2.37] Class 13 Test on Unit II Class 14 Simple experimental concepts: population; use of volunteers; randomization (and why); control group and its purpose; generalization; replication; direct control [2.28, 2.30, 2.44, 2.48ae] Class 15 Placebo effect; use of placebo; blinding (single and double); how to randomize [2.54, 2.57 (adapted)] AP tip: In AP Exam free-response questions on experimental design, students are required to include a description of how the treatments are randomizede.g., 2006, question no. 5(b). Class 16 Blocking; summary of experimental design [2.40, 2.43, 2.45] Blocking: This should be explained in terms of reduction of variability in order to more easily discern the effect of the explanatory variable. For further explanation, see YMS, p. 303.
90
Class 17 PBS video: The Wonder Pill (about the placebo effect) UNIT IV: COLLECTING DATA (2) / PROBABILITY (1)
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Class 18 Census; simple random sample (SRS); stratified sample; cluster sample; systematic sample; convenience sample [2.6, 2.8, 2.11ad] Class 19 Test on Unit III Class 20 Bias in general; selection bias; response bias; measurement bias; nonresponse bias (note that small sample size is not a source of bias) [2.16, 2.17, 2.25] Class 21 Probability using Venn diagrams; probability notation involving unions, intersections, complements; addition rule [sheet of problems] Probability: This topic is covered in considerable detail in the textbook, but in order to allow time for the remainder of the course, I have found it necessary to condense my approach. The order of subtopics given here is the one I have found to be most efficient. Class 22 Mutually exclusive events; conditional probability [sheet continued] Class 23 Review and extension of conditional probability; definition and explanation of independent events [6.39c, 6.49, made-up exs.] Class 24 Problems involving independent events; probability of at least one [6.47, 6.48 (adapted), 6.50] UNIT V: PROBABILITY (2) / RANDOM VARIABLES Class 25 Tree diagrams [made-up exs.] Class 26 Test on Unit IV [End of First Quarter] Class 27 Tree diagrams continued; Bayes rule [6.71, 6.72, 6.73] Bayes rule: For this I follow the method essentially as given on p. 323. I omit the formula given on p. 324. Class 28 Random variables; discrete versus continuous; probability distributions; graphical representation [7.11, 7.12, 7.14, 7.16, 7.18]
91
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Class 29 Continuous random variables; probability density functions [7.23, 7.24, 7.26] Class 30 Mean, variance, and standard deviation of discrete random variable; formulas for expected value and variance of aX + b [7.29, 7.33, 7.40] UNIT VI: BINOMIAL AND GEOMETRIC DISTRIBUTIONS Class 31 Binomial distribution [made-up exs.] Class 32 Test on Unit V Class 33 Binomial distribution continued; use of binompdf and binomcdf on calculator [7.46, 7.49, 7.55ab] Binomial probabilities: In order to familiarize students with the basic binomial probability formula, I assign problems in which use of binompdf or binomcdf is not allowed. Class 34 Mean and standard deviation of binomial distribution; geometric distribution; introduction to normal distribution (intuitive only) [7.54, 7.55cd, 7.62, made-up exs.] Distinguishing distributions: The Unit VI test includes a question that requires students to differentiate between random variables that are binomially distributed, geometrically distributed, normally distributed, or none of these. Class 35 Test on Unit VI UNIT VII: NORMAL DISTRIBUTION / MEAN AND VARIANCE FORMULAS Class 36 Normal distribution problems: finding probabilities and the inverse normal function [7.73ad, 7.77, 7.78] Class 37 Normal distribution problems: finding mean and/or standard deviation [sheet of problems] Class 38 Review of mean, variance, and standard deviation of aX + b; mean, variance, and standard deviation of X + Y; mean, variance, and standard deviation of aX + bY [made-up exs.] Class 39 Sums and differences of independent normally distributed random variables; conditional probability problems involving normal distribution [sheet of problems] UNIT VIII: SAMPLING DISTRIBUTIONS / DISTRIBUTION OF SAMPLE MEAN Class 40 Overview of population parameters, sample statistics, and the use of a statistic to estimate a parameter Class 41 Test on Unit VII
92
Class 42 German tanks activity (see my Student Activities section for details)
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Class 43 Sampling distributions; unbiased statistics; use of standard deviation to compare statistics [8.4, 8.6, 8.9] Class 44 Distribution of sample mean; central limit theorem [8.20, 8.21, 8.24] Class 45 Central limit theorem activity (see my Student Activities section for details) Class 46 Test on Unit VIII Classes 4752 Review for midyear exam, which is administered outside of class (see the Teaching Strategies section that follows this Course Planner for details) [End of Second Quarter]
Semester Two
UNIT IX: SIMULATION / INFERENCE (1) Class 53 Simulation activity (see my Student Activities section for details) Class 54 Simulation [sheet of problems] Class 55 Normal approximation to binomial distribution; calculator demonstration (see Calculator Demonstrations in my Student Activities section); distribution of a sample proportion [8.32, 8.34, 8.35] Class 56 Confidence interval for a population proportion; margin of error; interpretation of confidence interval and of confidence level [9.15, 9.23, 9.25] Confidence intervals: The idea of a confidence interval is tricky for students. They need to understand that it is the set of fixed parameter values that make feasible the sample results obtained. AP tip: When a confidence interval is asked for in an AP Exam free-response question, students are required to: (a) test the conditions for the process; (b) find the confidence limits using the appropriate formula; and (c) interpret the interval in the context of the problem. While it is not always required, students should also be able to write a coherent interpretation of the confidence level. UNIT X: INFERENCE (2) Class 57 Confidence interval for population mean; normal and t distributions [9.35ab, 9.38, 9.43] Class 58 Test on Unit IX
93
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Class 59 Hypothesis test for population proportion; one-tail and two-tail [10.27, 10.28, 10.29] AP tip: In any hypothesis test in an AP Exam free-response question, students are required to: (a) state the hypotheses, defining any symbols used for the population parameters; (b) test the conditions for the procedure to be used; (c) evaluate a test statistic using the correct formula and find the P-value; and (d) reach a conclusion in the context of the problem, linking this conclusion with the P-value. (Procedures involving critical values of the test statistic rather than P-values are also acceptable.) Class 60 Hypothesis test for population mean: z and t tests [10.48, 10.49 (adapted), 10.57, 10.58] AP tip: When the question does not state that the population(s) is/are normally distributed, where the sample size(s) is/are not large, and where data values are given (as opposed to summary values such as sample mean and standard deviation), it is necessary for students to check that the sample values make reasonable the assumption that the population(s) is/are normally distributed. This involves drawing, for example, a dotplot or boxplot and observing that the sample values show a distribution that is roughly symmetric and includes no outliers. Class 61 z and t tests for difference of population means (t test: only unpooled version) [11.24, 11.25, 11.26] Class 62 Confidence interval for difference of two population means; review of confidence interval ideas in general [11.12a, 11.18c] UNIT XI: INFERENCE (3) Class 63 Introduction to distribution of difference of two sample proportions Class 64 Test on Unit X Class 65 Hypothesis test for difference of two proportions; confidence interval for difference of two proportions; relevance of confidence interval containing zero [11.54, 11.55, 11.56] Class 66 Paired t test [11.32, 11.36, 11.39] Class 67 Distinguishing between paired and two-sample t tests; paired and two-sample t confidence intervals [11.38a, 11.72, 11.80] UNIT XII: INFERENCE (4) Class 68 Confidence intervals: required sample size for given margin of error [9.27, 9.46, 9.47] Class 69 Test on Unit XI
94
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Class 70 Chi-square test for goodness of fit [12.7, 12.8, 12.9] Calculator tip: The calculators lists can be used in an ingenious way to find the value of the test statistic and the P-value: see YMS, p. 734, or POD, p. 670. Class 71 Chi-square test for independence [12.20, 12.21] Calculator tip: The chi-square test on the Stat, Tests menu evaluates the expected frequencies: see POD, p. 673, or YMS, p. 754. Class 72 Chi-square test for homogeneity; distinguishing between three types of chi-square test; inference activity (see my Student Activities section for details) [12.16, 12.28, 12.36, 12.40, 12.42] Classes 73 and 74 Inference activity continued UNIT XIII: ERRORS IN HYPOTHESIS TESTING Class 75 Introduction to Type I and II errors Class 76 Test on Unit XII [End of Third Quarter] Class 77 Errors: problems involving description of Type I and II errors and their consequences [10.14, 10.17, 10.19] Class 78 Discussion of effect on probability of Type I and II errors (and power) by changes in significance level and sample size (and true value of parameter) [10.16, 10.20, 10.21] Class 79 Quiz on Unit XIII UNIT XIV: INFERENCE FOR REGRESSION / NONLINEAR REGRESSION Class 80 t test for closeness to linear relationship (done on calculator) [13.21ab, 13.25] Class 81 Confidence interval for slope of the regression line (and hypothesis test) by use of computer read-out and by use of formula for sb given on the formula sheet [13.18a, 13.20 (adapted), 13.21 (adapted), 13.24b] Class 82 Nonlinear regression: finding the best transformation by trial and error; prediction [sheet of problems] Class 83 Nonlinear regression: use of residual plot; logarithmic transformations; implication of straight-line logarithmic relationship in terms of original relationship [sheet continued]
95
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Class 84 Exponential and power relationships; prediction [sheet continued] Class 85 Review and consolidation of Unit XIV Class 86 Test on Unit XIV Class 87 Cumulative relative frequency graphs; other minor topics missed during the year [Ex. 3.16, handout] Classes 8894 Review for the AP Exam (see the Teaching Strategies section below for details) [End of Fourth Quarter]
Teaching Strategies
A typical class begins with a quick verbal check to make sure that everyone has completed the previous nights homework. I then run through the answers to that assignment, very often choosing students randomly to read out their written explanations. (This method serves as excellent preparation for the AP Exam, because students have an opportunity, on a daily basis, to think critically about their own and their peers wording of statistical concepts.) Next, I introduce the main item of work to be explored in that class, using data collected from the class or by means of an example from the textbook. I always encourage discussion so that a real appreciation for the relevance and the essence of the topic is established. If mathematical derivation of a formula is required, that work is also done at this stage. I then give the students a further example to solve in class by themselves, or, if time is short, we discuss an example as a class, talking about how each part of the problem should be tackled. Finally, I assign the next days homework. Most of the time, I either stand at the front of the room, using the whiteboard and/or leading class discussion, or the students work on brief (ungraded) practice assignments, discussing their findings with their neighbors as necessary. In the first of these two modalities, there is extensive questioningby me, in order to encourage constructive and critical thought, and by the students, when clarification is needed. Occasionally, in the context of project work, students use class time for data collection and later present the results of their work to the rest of the class. The TI-83 (or -84) calculator is used extensively throughout the course for calculation, graphical representation of data sets, and demonstration of concepts. Throughout the course, test questions and review examples are designed to mimic the style of AP Exam free-response questions, and the questions are graded according to criteria similar to those used for the AP Exam. In order to encourage familiarity with the definitions and formulas involved, I often ask students to do calculations without using the statistical features of the calculator. Prior to each test, I hand out a set of review questions (usually the test questions from the previous year), and the students are required to complete this for the class before the class on which the test is scheduled. When we then go over this assignment in detail, they gain a good understanding of the test requirements and have the opportunity to ask questions about items that may still confuse them. The remainder of that class is used to begin the next unit of material.
96
Course Organization About AP Statistics
For approaches to teaching specific topics, see the AP tips and other underlined suggestions and recommendations throughout the Course Planner above. Much of the learning that goes on in my classroom is based on the students working through designated problems and examples during the class period, as noted in the daily schedule. Detailed descriptions of many of these exercises can be found in the Student Activities section that begins on page 99.
Review for the Midyear Exam
The material studied in the first semester is condensed into six major topic areas, and one of these is covered in each of the six review classes and the associated homework by means of multiple-choice questions from Barrons AP Statistics. Additionally, the first homework assignment in the review process is to read the Planning a Study section in that book in order to reinforce understanding of the topic, introduce students to further terminology, and provide a more detailed look at matched pairs design.
Review for the AP Exam
This process consists of the following:
AP Exam free-response questions are assigned as graded homework. AP Exam multiple-choice questions from the Released Exams are assigned as graded homework or done in class. AP Exam free-response questions are done in class and graded by peers according to published scoring guidelines. A summary of inference and a sheet of mixed inference questions are distributed. A summary of computer readouts encountered during the year is distributed. A sheet of AP Statistics Exam tips for students (from AP Central) is distributed.
A word of advice to new teachers of AP Statistics: work through a variety of past AP Exam free-response questions yourself, and grade your own answers according to the official scoring guidelines. Through this experience, you will often find that you have neglected to mention certain critical detailsand when it comes to the exam, students benefit hugely from a teacher who is familiar at this level with the specifics of what is required.
Student Evaluation
In the first three quarters, grades are based entirely on the students test scores. This is possibly unusual and therefore deserves some explanation. First, all the students almost invariably do their nightly homework assignments without the incentive of grades, and I further encourage full completion of this work by the random selection of students to read out their written explanations. Second, I have found over the years that projects and activities turn out to be more effective if they are not graded. The difference has, in fact, been marked, with graded projects provoking a great deal of worry about the grading requirements, whereas ungraded projects have been done thoughtfully and with enthusiasm. Third, owing to their academic, athletic, and artistic commitments, our students tend to be under considerable time pressure. Therefore, while retaining the aim for very high levels of achievement in the subject, I look for every opportunity to reduce the demands put on the students by this, their second math course.
97
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Students take approximately four tests in each of the first three quarters. In the fourth quarter, I give one test and one quiz, followed by several graded homework assignments consisting of past AP Exam questions. In the fourth quarter, the graded homework assignments count for 60 percent of students grades, with the remaining 40 percent coming from the test and the quiz. Each of the first two quarters counts as 36 percent of the first semester grade. The midyear exam accounts for the remaining 28 percent. In the second semester, the grade is formed by an average of the third- and fourth-quarter grades. The course grade is the average of the first and second semesters. Brunswick Schools grading scale is as follows: A+ A A B+ B B C+ C C D+ D D 98100 percent 9397 percent 9092 percent 8789 percent 8386 percent 8082 percent 7779 percent 7376 percent 7072 percent 6769 percent 6366 percent 062 percent
Teacher Resources
Primary Textbook
Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. 2nd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2005.
Other Books and Articles
Allwood, T. Michael M. A Statistical Supplement: The Formulas Explained. In Teachers Resource Binder for Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis, 2nd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2005. Bock, David E., Paul F. Velleman, and Richard D. De Veaux. Stats: Modeling the World. Boston: Pearson/ Addison-Wesley, 2004. College Board. 2002 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 2002. (Note: The 2007 Released Exam has become available since this syllabus was submitted.) Dinkheller, Ann L., and David C. Flaspohler. German Tanks: A Problem in Estimation. Mathematics Teacher 92 (November 1999): 724-28. Hugill, Michael. Advanced Statistics. London: Bell and Hyman, 1985. Mann, Prem S. Introductory Statistics. 3rd ed. New York: Wiley, 1998.
98
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sternstein, Martin. Barrons AP Statistics: How to Prepare for the Advanced Placement Exam. 3rd ed. Hauppauge, N.Y.: Barrons Educational Series, 2004. Yates, Daniel S., David S. Moore, and Daren S. Starnes. The Practice of Statistics: TI-83/89 Graphing Calculator Enhanced. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003.
Web/Video
AP Central. apcentral.collegeboard.com. I use this Web site for AP Exam free-response questions, scoring guidelines, and advice for students. Scientific American Frontiers: The Wonder Pill. 2003. Hosted by Alan Alda. Distributed by PBS Home Video. VHS. 60 minutes. w ww.shoppbs.org.
Student Activities
Least Squares (Class 8)
Students are given graph paper and a set of about six points. Each student plots the points and then draws a line in an attempt to minimize the sum of the squares of the vertical distances of the points from the line. The sums of squares are collected and compared with the result for the true regression line produced by a calculator. This last calculation is done by sum(lRESID2). You can also ask students to draw a good line and ask how they will compare the lines to motivate the least-squares criteria.
German Tanks (Class 42)
This is an introduction to parameters, statistics, estimation, and sampling distributions and simulates a situation that occurred in World War II, in which Allied statisticians estimated the total number of German tanks by using the serial numbers of captured tanks. A bag contains cards that are numbered consecutively 1 to N (N can be about 300). Each group of students takes a random sample of seven cards and formulates and evaluates a statistic to estimate N. The relative merits of the statistics are discussed. The statistic used in World War II is then given: (M1)(n+1)/n, where M is the maximum serial number in the sample and n is the sample size (here n = 7). The most-favored student statistic and this statistic are evaluated for each of the samples and compared. Finally, the true value of N is given. (The idea for this activity was discussed in the National Council of Teachers of Mathematicss Mathematics Teacher in November 1999. The activity is also included in Activity-Based Statistics. My version is significantly different.)
Central Limit Theorem (Class 45)
Each student seeds the random number generator on his calculator by storing his own chosen number to rand, clears all lists in the STAT editor, then proceeds through the following steps, guided by me: 1. Make a population of size 100 by 1/1000seq(X 2, X,1,100)L1. 2. Use a histogram to show the shape of this highly skewed population distribution. 3. 0N.
99
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
4. N+1N:L1(randInt(1,100))L2(N):N ENTER, ENTER, This repeatedly samples numbers randomly from the population and enters them in L2, displaying the value of the counter, N, after each sampling. Stop when N = 40. 5. Use 1-Var Stats L2 to find the sample mean. Type this sample mean into L3. 6. Repeat from step 3, recording as many sample means in L3 as time permits. 7. Link cords are then used to gather all the sample means as a list on the overhead calculator. A histogram of the sample means is displayed and compared with the appropriate normal distribution.
Simulation (Class 53)
I have used various different activities for this topic. Here is one example: 1. The teacher writes four simple negative emotions on the board (e.g., anger, guilt, loneliness, disappointment). 2. A student volunteer is chosen. 3. For each emotion, the volunteer thinks of an occasion when he has felt that emotion. 4. The volunteer numbers the emotions 14 and (privately) uses RandInt(1,4) on his calculator to choose one of the emotions. He then sits in front of the class thinking intently of the occasion on which he felt that emotion (not acting the emotion). 5. The rest of the students in the class try to pick up which emotion is being felt by the volunteer, and they write down their decisions. 6. The number of correct decisions is counted. A simulation is then carried out in order to discover whether the result achieved is significant or, if not, what results could be considered significant. This is done as follows: 7. Suppose there are 14 members of the class, excluding the volunteer. The teacher demonstrates the simulation of one set of 14 random guesses by using RandInt(1,4,14) and counting the number of correct responses. 8. Each student seeds the random number generator on his calculator by storing his own chosen number to rand. 9. The students repeat the process in step 7 as many times as possible. 10. A frequency distribution for the numbers of correct responses over all the runs of the simulation is established on the board at the front of the class. 11. Using the frequency distribution, the significance of the result achieved (in step 6) and/or a critical region for the number of correct responses can be established.
100
Course Organization About AP Statistics
12. If there is time, a comparison can be made between the frequencies achieved in the runs of the simulation and the frequencies predicted by the binomial distribution.
Inference Activity (Classes 7274)
In class 72, the class is divided into groups of three or four. Each group decides on a hypothesis to be tested and what data will be collected to test the hypothesis. (Data are to be collected by means of a survey or an experiment, not by means of published information. Poor sampling methods are tolerated as long as the limitations are realized by the students.) For homework after class 72 and during class 73, the data are collected. For homework after class 73, the data are analyzed by means of the appropriate hypothesis test. In class 74, each group presents its results to the rest of the class, and discussion of, for example, the appropriateness of the sampling methods and the applicability of the hypothesis test is encouraged.
Calculator Demonstrations
Influential Points (Class 9) This is to show that influential points tend to have extreme x values. Create a cluster of points with negative correlation by seq(X,X,0,5,0.1)L1, 50.5L1+randNorm(0,0.5,51)L2. With a [0,20] by [0,20] window, make a scatterplot with xlist=L1 and ylist=L2. Draw the regression line for this set. Show that adding the point (2.5,15) has little effect on the regression line, whereas adding (12,5) has a large effect. Residual Plots (Class 10) This shows how the residual plot can reveal a curved pattern in what initially seems to be a linear relationship. First enter seq(X,X,20,30,1)L1 and (10+L12)+randNorm(0,.002,11)L2. A scatterplot of L1 against L2 shows what appears to be a straight line, but a residual plot shows that a curve would provide a better fit. Point out that the r value for the original set is close to 1, but this does not mean that a straight line is the best fit. Normal Approximation to Binomial Distribution (Class 55) This is to demonstrate that the binomial distribution B(40, 0.6) is closely approximated by the normal distribution N(40·0.6, (40·0.6·0.4)). Follow these steps: 1. seq(X,X,0,40)L1. (This stores the integers 0,1,,40 in L1.) 2. binompdf(40,.6) L2. (This stores the probabilities for B(40, 0.6) in L2.) 3. Using STAT PLOT, switch Plot 1 on as a histogram with Llist: L1 and Freq: L2. 4. Set up a window of [14.5, 34.5] by [0.5, 1.5] with Xscl = 1. 5. Using the Y= key, delete any functions that have been entered and make sure that only Plot 1 is on. 6. By pressing the GRAPH key, the histogram of B(40, 0.6) is displayed. 7. For the function Y1, enter normalpdf(X,40*.6,(40*.6*.4)). 8. Move the cursor to the left of Y1 and select the path graph style (the fifth option). 9. Again press GRAPH and watch the normal distribution curve being superimposed on the histogram.
101
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Sample Syllabus 4
Anne M. Carroll Kennett High School Kennett Square, Pennsylvania
School Profile
Location and Environment: Kennett High School serves a diverse rural and suburban populace in southern Chester County in the southeastern corner of Pennsylvania, close to the borders of Delaware and Maryland. The cornerstone of our school was laid during the Great Depression in the 1930s. Located in the historic borough of Kennett Square, a small town with a population of about 5,300, this recently renovated school was the original single building of the Kennett Consolidated School District. In addition to the high school, the district now consists of three elementary schools and one middle school spread over several townships. The area is a bedroom community for Wilmington, Delaware, with many parents employed by DuPont and other chemical and pharmaceutical giants. Moreover, the greater Kennett area continues to provide a large base of agricultural workers for the mushroom industry: Kennett Square is known as the mushroom capital of the world. Large numbers of immigrants from Mexico provide the workforce for the agricultural trade, and the transience of this population is a challenge to the educational system. Many households are monolingual, and older students often come to the high school after not being in classes for many years. Approximately 28 percent of the district population is eligible for free or reduced-fee lunches. Grades: 912 Type: Public high school Total Enrollment: 1,212 Ethnic Diversity: Hispanic/Latino, 32 percent; African American, 5 percent; Asian American, 1 percent. College Record: Of our graduates, 69 percent go on to four-year colleges; 17 percent choose junior colleges, community colleges, or technical schools; and 2 percent join the military.
Personal Philosophy
An understanding of statistics is necessary for anyone to be a savvy consumer, an informed citizen of a democracy, and a successful student of many other disciplines. The AP Statistics course gives students an opportunity to build a deep conceptual understanding of graphical analysis and statistical inference and their roles in decision making. This course is the one that I wish that I had taken before the calculus-based statistics I had at both the undergraduate and graduate mathematics levels. Students who take this course are able to read information critically and to pursue further statistical studies, and I am gratified to be a part of helping them to achieve these skills.
102
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Class Profile
Traditionally, Kennett High School has offered one section of AP Statistics with an enrollment of between 5 and 20 students, according to demand. We also offer a less demanding course called Applications of Algebra/Statistics that includes one semester of statistics (the other semester is a review of Algebra 2 topics and forms with emphasis on problem solving), as well as a stand-alone semester statistics course. The AP course meets on a traditional schedule, five days a week for one period in an eight-period day. Classes are 42 minutes long. The year is divided into two semesters, each having two marking periods. The first semester concludes with a required midterm examination. All AP students are required to take the AP Exam. Having done so, they are exempt from the second-semester examination. The course is available to any student who has successfully completed Algebra 2 and who has either completed or is concurrently enrolled in Analysis (Precalculus). Generally, students taking AP Statistics are juniors or seniors (although sophomores have taken the course).
Course Overview
The basic textbook used for this class is The Practice of Statistics (second edition) by Yates, Moore, and Starnes, hereafter referred to as YMS. (See the Teacher Resources section of this syllabus for a full citation.) The major features of the course can be summarized as follows: Expectations This is a college-level class that moves at a fast pace. There is time for fun but no time for nonsense. It is assumed that all students will show respect for themselves, for their peers, for the teacher, and for any guests. Attendance Class attendance is essential to a students success in this course, where each day builds on the previous days learning. Work missed because of class absence owing to illness or other excused reason must be made up within the number of days missed. Any unexcused class absence results in no credit for the days work. Participation Each student must participate in class. Participation includes bringing the necessary materials; preparation (having homework, both written and study, complete); asking questions for clarification or exploration; offering answers and insights; putting work on the board; working with partners or pair-sharing, as appropriate to the assignment; tutoring other students; and supporting other students and a good classroom environment. Students who participate in class are more alert and therefore get more out of classroom instruction, experience better retention of information, and complete homework sessions in a shorter time. Materials All students must have the following in class on a daily basis:
Three-ring loose-leaf binder for notes and homework Blue or black ballpoint pen Two no. 2 pencils One colored pen or pencil
103
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
One straightedge Covered textbook Graphing calculator (TI-83 Plus or TI-84 preferred if purchasing new)
Any student with financial need or for whom buying any of these supplies or paying for the AP Exam is a hardship may make arrangements for funding through the school. Binders Each days notes must be kept in pen, with a topic and date. Homework that supports the notes is to be done in pencil, with date and corresponding textbook page number. These exercises must be corrected from the answers in the back of the book, as well as during pair-sharing sessions in class. All returned quizzes, tests, labs, and special projects are to be corrected and integrated with the classroom notes. Homework It is expected that every student will spend at least one-half hour each night on written and study homework, with perhaps more time on weekends or as labs/projects come due. Once a week, students should review their notes for the entire course to keep all skills and concepts fresh. If this is done consistently, an hour of study on the night before a test should be sufficient. Preparation time increases in the weeks preceding the AP Exam. Grading Grades are computed on a cumulative-point basis (see the Student Evaluation section of my syllabus for a complete explanation). Graded items include quizzes, tests, labs, projects, class participation, notebook completeness and organization, and homework. Tutorials Tutoring is available to every student through a variety of means. I assist students by phone in the evening or personally in the morning before homeroom period, during study halls when our schedules mesh, or after school. E-mail questions are welcome from those who do not expect an immediate answer; often this is a good way for students with a long-term absence to clarify their independent study efforts.
Course Objectives
By the end of this AP Statistics course, students should be able to do the following:
104
Appreciate the role of statistics in understanding our world Examine data (univariate and bivariate) both graphically and numerically to determine patterns, make comparisons, and draw inferences Understand density curves in general and the normal distribution in particular Use the standard normal distribution for analysis or comparison Examine methods of producing data and understand the elements of good experimental design Understand the language and laws of probability Explore sampling and probability distributions Use simulation to replicate experimental conditions Conduct significance tests using z-, p-, t-, and chi-square and regression statistics
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Construct confidence intervals with z-, p-, t-, and regression statistics Use calculator and computer technology and software to enhance understanding of statistics Apply statistical methods to a research question
Course Planner
The following abbreviations and short titles are used to indicate source material: AP Test Prep = Preparing for the Statistics AP Exam with Stats: Modeling the World, Second Edition (Carroll et al.); COMAP video = For All Practical Purposes; GRB = Golden Resource Binder (instructors supplement to the textbook); Precalculus = Demana et al., Precalculus; RVSL = Rice Virtual Lab in Statistics Web site; Sevin = Discovering Statistics lab manual; Statistics video = The High-Stakes World of Statistics (Witzel et al.). See the Teacher Resources section later in this syllabus for full citations. Assessments appear in brackets in the Other column. All tests are chapter tests. Assignments (odd-numbered Topic Time Frame Text Other problems required) ***SEMESTER 1*** Introduction to statistics 1 day pp. viixvii Preview text; COMAP video, prog. 6; install Minitab GRB, special problem 0 Exploring Data (chapter 1) Variables 1 day pp. 17 Exer. 1.11.4 Examining distributions 35 days Section 1.1 Exer. 1.51.30 RVSL: Histograms, graphically Bin Width, and Cross Validation (Web simulation); histogram lab (Sevin) [quiz 1.1] Examining distributions 24 days Section 1.2 Exer. 1.311.50 RVSL: Mean and Median numerically (Web simulation); numerical summary lab (Sevin) [quiz 1.2] Review 2 days Chapter Exer. 1.511.73 Statistics video, pt. 1 summary [test] Normal Distributions (chapter 2) Density curves and 24 days Section 2.1 Exer. 2.12.18 Minitab lab (GRB): special normal distributions problem 2A; assessing normality lab (Sevin) [quiz 2.1] Standard normal 23 days Section 2.2 Exer. 2.192.37 [quiz 2.2] distribution Review 2 days Chapter Exer. 2.382.54 [test] summary
105
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Topic
Time Frame
Text
Assignments (odd-numbered problems required) Exer. 3.13.5 Exer. 3.63.23 Exer. 3.243.37
Other
Examining Relationships (chapters 3 and 4) Variables 1 day pp. 118-23 Scatterplots 12 days Section 3.1 Correlation 12 days Section 3.2
Least-squares regression
34 days
Section 3.3
Exer. 3.383.61
Review Transforming data
2 days 24 days
Chapter 3 summary Section 4.1
Exer. 3.623.77 Exer. 4.14.26
COMAP video, prog. 8 [quiz 3.1] University of Illinois, Correlation Game (Web site); RVSL: Correlation (Web simulation) [quiz 3.2] RVSL: Regression by Eye (Web simulation); leastsquares regression line lab (GRB): special problem 3A [quiz 3.3] [test] RVSL: Transformations (Web simulation); nonlinear data lab (GRB): special problem 4C [quiz 4.1]
Cautions: Lurking Confounding Extrapolation Causation Categorical data Review
23 days
Section 4.2
Exer. 4.274.49
12 days 2 days
Section 4.3 Exer. 4.504.71 Chapter 4 Exer. 4.724.83 summary End Marking Period 1 pp. 266-70 Section 5.1
[quiz 4.24.3] [test]
Producing Data (chapter 5) Studies and experiments 1 day Sampling designs 23 days
Exer. 5.15.30
Experimental design
34 days
Section 5.2
Exer. 5.315.58
Simulation
34 days
Section 5.3
Exer. 5.595.72
COMAP video, prog. 7 Easton and McColl, Statistics Glossary (Web site) [quiz 5.1] Experimental design lab (see the Student Activities section of my syllabus) [quiz 5.2] Simulation lab (GRB): special problem 5A [quiz 5.3]
106
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Topic Review Probability (chapter 6) Randomness
Time Frame 2 days
Text Chapter summary pp. 326-30
Assignments (odd-numbered problems required) Exer. 5.745.88
Other [test]
12 days
Probability concepts Counting methods: multiplication principle, permutations, combinations Probability models
12 days 23 days
Section 6.1
Exer. 6.16.10
COMAP video, prog. 9; Precalculus, chap. 9; Annis et al., What Are the Odds? (Web site); Poker Project (see my Student Activities section) Precalculus, sec. 9.1 Precalculus, sec. 9.2
34 days
Section 6.2 Section 6.3 (pp. 359-65) Section 6.3 (pp. 366-82) Chapter summary
Exer. 6.116.44 Exer. 6.456.53 Exer. 6.546.77 Exer. 6.786.87
General probability rules 23 days Conditional probability Review 23 days 2 days
Statistics video, pt. 2; Precalculus, sec. 9.2 [quiz 6.16.2] Precalculus, sec. 9.3 Precalculus, sec. 9.4 [quiz 6.3] [test]
Random Variables (chapter 7) Discrete vs. continuous 1 day Means and variances 23 days Review 1 day
Section 7.1 Section 7.2 Chapter summary Distributions of Discrete Random Variables (chapter 8) Binomial 12 days Section 8.1
Exer. 7.17.20 Exer. 7.217.53 Exer. 7.547.68
[quiz 7.1] [quiz 7.2] [take-home test]
Exer. 8.18.36
Geometric Review
12 days 1 day
Review for examination
2 days
Section 8.2 Exer. 8.378.54 Chapter Exer. 8.558.64 summary End Marking Period 2 Chapters 18
Precalculus, sec. 9.4; RVSL: Normal Approximation to the Binomial Distribution (Web simulation) [quiz 8.18.2] [take-home test]
[midterm examination]
107
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Assignments (odd-numbered Topic Time Frame Text Other problems required) ***SEMESTER 2*** Sampling Distributions (chapter 9) Statistical inference 1 day pp. 484-88 COMAP video, prog. 10 Parameters and statistics 12 days Section 9.1 Exer. 9.19.18 [quiz 9.1] Sample proportions 23 days Section 9.2 Exer. 9.199.30 Sample proportions lab (Sevin) [quiz 9.2] Sample means 1 day Section 9.3 Exer. 9.319.35 (pp. 514-19) Central limit theorem 12 days Section 9.3 Exer. 9.369.42 RVSL: Sampling (pp. 520-26) Distributions (Web simulation); Minitab lab (GRB): special problem 9A [quiz 9.3] Review 2 days Chapter Exer. 9.439.53 [test] summary Inference (chapter 10) Confidence intervals 23 days Section 10.1 Exer. 10.110.26 Confidence interval lab (Sevin) [quiz 10.1] Significance tests 34 days Sections 10.2 Exer. 10.27 [quiz 10.210.3] 10.3 10.65 Error and power 23 days Section 10.4 Exer. 10.66 Intuitor.com, Type I and 10.77 Type II Errors (Web simulation); AndersonCook, Hypothesis Testing (Web simulation) [quiz 10.4] Review 12 days Chapter Exer. 10.78 [test] summary 10.89 Inference for Distributions (chapter 11) One-sample t procedures 23 days Section 11.1 Exer. 11.111.21, [quiz 11.1] 11.23c, 11.24 11.34, 11.36 Two-sample t procedures 23 days Section 11.2 Exer. 11.37 [quiz 11.2] 11.61 Review 1 day Chapter Exer. 11.62 [test] summary 11.73
108
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Topic
Time Frame
Text
Assignments (odd-numbered problems required)
Other
Inference for Proportions (chapter 12) One-sample 12 days Two-sample 23 days
Section 12.1 Section 12.2
Review
12 days
Chapter summary Section 13.1
Exer. 12.112.21 [take-home quiz 12.1] Exer. 12.22 Simulations and inference 12.34 lab (GRB): special problem 12A [take-home quiz 12.2] Exer. 12.35 [test] 12.45 Exer. 13.113.13 [quiz 13.1]
Inference for Tables (chapter 13) Chi-square test for 12 days goodness of fit Chi-square test for 12 days homogeneity Chi-square test for 12 days independence Review 1 day
Section 13.2 Exer. 13.14 (pp. 750-57) 13.18 Section 13.2 Exer. 13.19 (pp. 757-69) 13.30 Chapter Exer. 13.31 summary 13.40 End Marking Period 3 Section 14.1 Section 14.2 Chapter summary Exer. 14.114.11 Exer. 14.12 14.17 Exer. 14.18 14.27
[quiz 13.2] [test]
Inference for Regression (chapter 14) Inference for slope 12 days Predictions Review Intensive cumulative review for AP Exam Intensive cumulative review for AP Exam 12 days 1 day 510 days 5 days
AP Test Prep, intro and topics 12 [quiz 14.1] AP Test Prep, topic 7 [take-home quiz 14.2] [test] AP Test Prep, topics 36; released AP Exam questions (AP Central) AP Test Prep, practice exams; released AP Exam questions (AP Central)
AP EXAM PostAP Exam project 1015 days End Marking Period 4 Independent research
109
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Teaching Strategies
I introduce the major conceptual components of the course by using individual programs from the video series For All Practical Purposes. These informal and conversational episodes are an effective way to familiarize students with the basic vocabulary and common applications for the skills they are about to learn. I use PowerPoint for most of my classroom presentations, so I can thereby incorporate Web sites of interest, charts, and graphs into the lecture. Students take their own notes, and sample problems and discussion are woven into the presentation; problem sets are done outside of class. Students then discuss these problems with their pair-share partners in order to identify and work out difficulties. Any problems that remain unsolved are presented to the class for resolution by the rest of the group (and me). The pair-share technique works well. A pair forms a cooperative learning unit and can join another pair to form a lab group. My classroom presentations are often Socratic: I ask questions to stimulate thinking. Students are frequently reluctant to take the risk of answering such questions, but they become bolder after a discussion with a partner. The partners take academic responsibility for one another and push each other toward better performance in homework, labs, quizzes, and tests. The partner is the first source of information for students who miss class. In the first marking period, students are often paired with a partner from another grade to build familiarity. In the second marking period, I pair students based on their first-marking-period performance (strong with weak) and by observed personalities. In the third marking period, I pair them based on their midterm examination grades. Because that examination mimics the AP Exam and uses questions from AP Released Exams as its base, students who have demonstrated facility with these kinds of questions can help those who are less agile in an exam situation. In the fourth marking period, students may choose their own seats in the classroom, and that seating determines the partners or groups. Most chapters are explored on the front end or reinforced on the back end with a lab, often in the form of one of the special problems in the Golden Resource Binder that accompanies our textbook. I refer to any class-long group activity or individual investigation as a lab, and students follow the guidelines in the Binders special problem 0 to report their results; or, in the case of the labs developed by Anne Sevin, they complete these together with their partner(s) and report them on the form provided. Many of the special problems require the use of Minitab or similar spreadsheet and graphing software. Students are provided with a copy of Minitab at the beginning of the year, and one of the first labs (special problem 2A) is an exploration of its capabilities. The directions are included with the lab. Students who have other software at home are permitted to substitute it (after checking with me.) There are three computer stations, plus the teachers laptop, available in my classroom. When an applet is useful (e.g., Correlation Game Web site), students form teams and utilize these four stations to inform or compete. Simulation labs are done with the calculator or computer. Minitab labs are done with the software loaded on the classroom, math lab, or home computers of the students. (The classroom computer or math lab computers may be used only by students who do not have a computer at home.) Minitab labs are most frequently done independently (without partners). Students always read the requirements for a lab or project and ask questions in the classroom before beginning the work. I allot a one- to two-week time frame in which I expect them to complete the assignment independently, but we determine the actual due date collaboratively. (I ask, Having read the requirements, what do you think is a reasonable amount of time to complete this lab?) Some labs are completed during class time with partners. These are often ones that require experimentation rather than simulationdice rolling, penny spinning, and the like. The experimental design activity (described in the Student Activities section at the end of my syllabus) and many of Anne Sevins labs are best done in the classroom. They are handwritten reports.
110
Course Organization About AP Statistics
For assessments, I use the test and quiz resources in the textbook because I find that they closely model the AP Exam question types. I give take-home quizzes or tests for short chapters, for chapters at the close of the semester, or just before the AP Exam purely as a timesaver. With juniors in the course, teaching time in the third marking period is seriously impacted by our mandatory state assessments, which eat up nearly a week of instructional time. I sometimes ask students to do the assessment at home without the aid of text or notes, but on other occasions I use a take-home quiz or test as a teaching aid. To prepare students for the AP Exam, I facilitate the purchase of a review book. In the past I have used the AMSCO book by Jim Bohan, but most recently I have been using the Pearson/Prentice Hall book that is ancillary to David Bock et al.s Stats: Modeling the World. (Disclaimer: I am one of the authors of this test prep book, a fact I also disclose to my students.) All students purchase their own copies; I place a group order, accept shipment, and usually pay shipping and handling. They use the book to prepare independently for midterms. In the two to three weeks prior to the AP Exam, I specify chapters from the textbook and test prep book for review and then give in-class quizzes on the review topics. These quizzes consist of short-answer questions from the Released Exams that address the particular concept or skill, and students are placed under time restrictions similar to those of the AP Exam. I grade the quizzes based on my experience with the AP Exam Scoring Guidelines and return the papers for discussion the next day. We often review the scoring procedures as a group and look at sample answers. Weekend assignments are the practice exams from the test prep book. After the AP Exam, students are generally free of homework. All work is completed during class. We explore opportunities for research and analysis that will assist the school community. Some project themes are proposed by the administration, and other research ideas come from students. Prior years themes have addressed the following questions:
Does the day or the grade level or a combination of these factors influence absence rates at Kennett High School? How does the evacuation alarm compare with the ambient noise levels at Kennett High School? Are students satisfied with the cafeteria offerings in the Kennett Consolidated School District? Does extracurricular activity impact grade point average?
Student Evaluation
Students are graded on a point system, with each quiz contributing 1025 points; each test, 5090 points; each lab, approximately 50 points; homework for the marking period, approximately 50 points; notebook binder, approximately 50 points; and classroom participation, approximately 50 points. Roughly, tests account for 35 percent of the grade; quizzes, 20 percent; labs, 30 percent; homework, 5 percent; binder, 5 percent; and class participation, 5 percent. It varies according to the number of activities I can accomplish with any given group. Tests (taken from the Golden Resource Binder) are point balanced between the multiple-choice and the free-response questions, to anticipate AP Exam scoring. All AP courses at Kennett High School are weighted at 5.0 on a 4.0 scale. Each of the four marking periods is graded separately, and the cumulative points create a percentage that corresponds to a letter grade. That letter grade contributes a certain number of points to the students GPA. The GPA points are accumulated over the four marking periods, then doubled in value, added to the midterm letter grade GPA value, and averaged to arrive at the final year-end letter grade. The schools grading scale is as follows:
111
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Marking Period and Examination Letter Regular Courses Grades GPA A+ 97100 4.33 A 9396 4.00 A 9092 3.67 B+ 8789 3.33 B 8386 3.00 B 8082 2.67 C+ 7779 2.33 C 7376 2.00 C 7072 1.67 D+ 6769 1.33 D 6066 1.00 X 5059 0.00 Y Below 50 1.00
Honor Courses GPA 4.83 4.50 4.17 3.83 3.50 3.17 2.83 2.50 2.17 1.83 1.50 0.00 1.00
AP Courses GPA 5.33 5.00 4.67 4.33 4.00 3.67 3.33 3.00 2.67 2.33 2.00 0.00 1.00
Teacher Resources
Primary Text
Yates, Daniel S., David S. Moore, and Daren S. Starnes. The Practice of Statistics: TI-83/89 Graphing Calculator Enhanced. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003. Related Print Resources Barat, Christopher. The Practice of Statistics Instructors Solution Manual. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003. Fligner, Michael A., and William I. Notz. The Practice of Statistics Printed Test Bank. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003. Yates, Daniel S., and Daren S. Starnes. The Practice of Statistics Golden Resource Binder. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003.
Supplementary Materials
Books Bohan, James. AP Statistics: Preparing for the Advanced Placement Examination. New York: AMSCO, 2000. Carroll, Anne M., Ruth E. Carver, Susan A. Peters, and Janice D. Ricks. Preparing for the Statistics AP Exam with Stats: Modeling the World, 2nd ed. AP Test Prep series. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson/ Prentice Hall, 2007.
112
College Board. 1997 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 1997.
Course Organization About AP Statistics
College Board. 2002 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 2002. (Note: The 2007 Released Exam has become available since this syllabus was submitted.) Demana, Franklin, Bert K. Waits, Gregory D. Foley, and Daniel Kennedy. Precalculus: Graphical, Numerical, Algebraic. 6th ed. Boston: Pearson/Addison-Wesley, 2004. Lovell, Robert. Probability Activities: For Problem Solving and Skills Reinforcement. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press, 1993. Scheaffer, Richard L., Mrudulla Gnanadesikan, Ann Watkins, and Jeffrey A. Witmer. Activity-Based Statistics: Instructor Resources. New York: Springer, 1996. Sevin, Anne D. Discovering Statistics: An Interactive Approach. Workshop presentation, 1995. From an unpublished laboratory manual, Laboratory Manual for Introductory Statistics, Framingham State College, Framingham, Massachusetts, spring 1993. Software and Other Technology Minitab. Student Version. Release 12. 1998. w ww.minitab.com. Texas Instruments. TI-84 Plus Graphing Calculator and ViewScreen. http://education.ti.com/educationportal/sites/US/homePage/index.html. Video For All Practical Purposes: An Introduction to Contemporary Mathematics, episodes 610. 1987. Produced by the Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications (COMAP). An Annenberg/CPB Project. VHS/ DVD. Distributed by Intellimation, Santa Barbara, Calif. 30 minutes per episode. The High-Stakes World of Statistics (Parts 1, 2, and 3). 1998. Directed by Jonathan Reich. Performed by the Standard Deviants. Academic consultants: Ronald Witzel and Barry Skolnik. VHS. Distributed by Cerebellum Corporation, Falls Church, Va. Three videocassettes, 261 minutes.
Web Sites
Anderson-Cook, C. M., and S. Dorai-Raj. Hypothesis Testing. w ww.amstat.org/publications/jse/v11n3/java/Hypothesis. Web site to accompany Making the Concepts of Power and Sample Size Relevant and Accessible to Students in Introductory Statistics Courses Using Applets. Journal of Statistics Education 11, no. 3 (2003). Annis, Rebekah et al. What Are the Odds? The Ins and Outs of Probability. http://teacherlink.org/content/math/interactive/probability/home.html. Consortium for the Advancement of Undergraduate Statistics Education (CAUSE). w ww.causeweb.org/resources. Easton, Valerie J., and John H. McColl. Statistics Glossary. w ww.cas.lancs.ac.uk/glossary_v1.1/samp.html.
113
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Intuitor.com. Type I and Type II ErrorsMaking Mistakes in the Justice System. w ww.intuitor.com/statistics/T1T2Errors.html. Rice Virtual Lab in Statistics. http://onlinestatbook.com/rvls.html. University of Illinois at UrbanaChampaign. Department of Statistics. The Correlation Game. w ww.stat.uiuc.edu/courses/stat100/java/GCApplet/GCAppletFrame.html. W. H. Freeman Co. The Practice of Statistics. 2nd ed. Companion Web site. http://bcs.whfreeman.com/yates2e.
Student Activities
The Poker Project
(Topic: Probability) Goal Students use a basic understanding of probability, the fundamental counting principle (multiplication principle), and the combinations rule to count the number of possible hands and their probabilities for winning at five-card poker. The Problem On an initial deal of five cards to any one player, list the 10 possible hands in poker, and count the number of ways to acquire each of those hands. Students may use books or the Internet to assist them but are encouraged to do their computations independently and check that they have accounted for the entire sample space before using other resources. If sources are used (and students are encouraged to check), they must be cited in proper form as part of the paper. The Product Each student must hand in a typed paper, which may be as creative in design as desired. The paper must include not only the probability of each hand but the explanation, with proper notation, of how the probability was derived. (This part is unique to each student: although students may get answers and techniques from another source, the explanations must be their own.) Evaluation This project is graded on the correctness of each hand and the quality of the explanation (4 points for each hand), as well as the presentation and proper citation (10 points).
Experimental Design Activity
(Topic: Experimental Design) Goal The students demonstrate an understanding of design in both paragraph and diagram formats. In intent, this activity is similar to question 2 about waterproofing boots that appeared on the 2002 AP Exam.
114
Course Organization About AP Statistics
The Problem An antidepression drug on the market has an effective period of 8 to 10 hours for each dosage. A number of patients have complained that they have experienced dryness as a side effect and are therefore increasing their water consumption. The pharmaceutical company has decided to investigate this side effect. You are asked to design an experiment to determine the significance of this claim. You have been given eight days to complete this experiment, and the subjects are 20 single-housed, healthy, young adult male Sprague Dawley rats. (Previous animal experiments have shown that dryness is an indication that can be determined by using rats as subjects, and we have determined the proper dosing range for rats.) Describe and diagram your design. Be prepared to discuss. The Product Each group submits a handwritten report at the end of the class period. Evaluation Students generally work on this problem in groups of two to four. One design is submitted and graded on a 20-point scale. A class discussion of the various designs follows.
PostAP Exam Project
(Topic: A combination of AP Statistics topicsstudent/teacher/school-driven) Goal Students use the statistical methods they have studied to analyze and report on a topic of interest to the Kennett High School community. This topic is chosen collaboratively. The Product Each team of students works on a different aspect of the analysis (e.g., collecting data, graphical displays, inference). The teams then unify their work into a single report. A sample report follows. The objective of this particular project was to determine whether the ambient noise at Kennett High School exceeded safe levels. Students were provided with devices to record the ambient noise (courtesy of a local codes official). We took 11 separate ambient noise level readings from different areas at the high school. The mean of these 11 noise levels was 93.45 decibels. Using statistical methods we also constructed three confidence intervals in which we are x percent confident that the true mean actually lies, x being either 90 percent, 95 percent, or 99 percent, depending on the confidence level. These confidence intervals are centered around the sample mean. The 90 percent confidence interval is 87.53 decibels to 99.37 decibels. The 95 percent confidence interval is 86.17 decibels to 100.73 decibels. The 99 percent confidence interval is 83.10 decibels to 103.80 decibels. Taking the 99 percent confidence interval, for example, we are 99 percent confident that the true mean of the ambient sound level in those certain areas lies between 83.10 decibels and 103.80 decibels. Evaluation The project is graded as class participation for the individuals as they work in their teams. This constitutes most of a students class participation grade for the fourth marking period.
115
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Sample Syllabus 5
Dora Daniluk Mayde Creek High School Houston, Texas
School Profile
Location and Environment: Mayde Creek High School, one of six high schools in the Katy Independent School District, is located 25 miles west of downtown Houston. The district, encompassing 181 square miles in eastern Texas, has seen student enrollment steadily grow to more than 50,000 in the 2006-07 school year, with just under 3,000 of these pupils at Mayde Creek High. Our school is academically grounded, technologically advanced, student-centered, communitysupported, and respectful of individuals. The curriculum is broad-based and includes a strong AP program, dual credit for courses with the local community college, a special program for gifted and talented students, and international business and career/technology offerings. Grades: 912 Type: Public, four-year secondary school Total Enrollment: Approximately 2,600 Ethnic Diversity: Hispanics/Latinos constitute 38 percent of the population; African Americans, 14 percent; Asian Americans, 6 percent; and others, 1 percent. College Record: Of the class of 2006, 63 percent went on to attend a four-year college, 29 percent enrolled in a two-year college, 3 percent received further vocational training, and 4 percent entered the military.
Personal Philosophy
Students who enroll in my classes vary greatly in their mathematical backgrounds and abilities. For many, this class provides their first or only AP experience, whereas others have a schedule filled with AP courses. I do believe that this is one course where all students can feel a measure of accomplishment. Statistics is the real world around us, and relating activities and learning to what students see and know can stimulate interest and success. I believe that activity-based lessons are essential to present concepts, and as a result, each chapter in our textbook involves at least one activity that will help students discover, learn, and/or recall the needed material. The classroom involves cooperative learninga chance to share ideas, discuss problems, and explore possible answers. This team atmosphere is a major reason that 90 percent of our students consistently earn grades of 3 or better on the AP Exam.
Class Profile
Mayde Creek High School usually has two sections of AP Statistics, with approximately 25 to 30 students in each; I teach both classes. We are on a traditional schedule, and the class meets daily for 45 minutes. The course prerequisite is Algebra 2, and as a result the students vary in ability from those who have only Algebra 2 in their math background to those who are currently taking AP Calculus. Our district has an open-door policy for AP courses, and all students are encouraged to enroll in these classes. All AP courses
116
Course Organization About AP Statistics
provide an extra bonus point toward calculating a students grade point average on our 4-point scale. Although our school does not require AP students to take AP Exams, students in this course are strongly encouraged to do so, and on average, more than 80 percent take the exam.
Course Overview
The aim of this AP course is to provide students with a learning experience equivalent to that obtained in most college introductory statistics courses, which have become a requirement for many college majors. Students are expected to complete college-level assignments and be sufficiently motivated and selfdisciplined to perform at a postsecondary level. The course involves four major topics: exploring data, planning a study, anticipating patterns, and statistical inference. The skills and concepts listed in the Topic Outline of the AP Statistics Course Description are all covered. In addition to mastering skills and understanding concepts, I hope each student will develop an awareness of the importance of this subject in the real world, improve communication skills to convey decisions and ideas, and apply this knowledge in the future. TI-83 or -84 calculators are essential for success, and the mathematics department permits rental of calculators for students who are unable to make such a purchase. There is no formal lab component in this course. The computer lab is used only for Internet activities found at the textbook publishers Web site or at various other sites listed in the Teacher Resources section of this syllabus. In past years this has involved one or two days in the lab, as well as having students research specific sites from home. The primary statistics text for the district is The Practice of Statistics: TI-83 Graphing Calculator Enhanced by Yates, Moore, and McCabe.
Course Planner
Our academic year consists of two semesters, with school beginning in late August and running through the end of May. In the timetable below, the number of days in the Time Frame column indicate the actual number of classroom instruction daysthat is, 15 days equals three weeks, exclusive of school breaks, holidays, and test days. There is a test at the end of each instructional unit and a semester exam at the end of each semester. Textbook problem numbers are not always listed in numerical order because the problems sometimes piggyback one another, and the sequence listed allows students to continue the same line of thought. The following abbreviations are used to indicate book titles: ABS = Activity-Based Statistics (Scheaffer et al.); PS (course textbook) = The Practice of Statistics (Yates et al.); SIA = Statistics in Action (Watkins et al.); SMW = Stats: Modeling the World (Bock et al.); WS = Workshop Statistics (Rossman and von Oehsen). See my Teacher Resources section for full citations.
117
Chapter 3 Chapter 1 SEMESTER 1
Time Frame ~15 days Unit Title, Topics, and Assignments Exploring Univariate Data Topics Displaying distributions with graphs Describing distributions with numbers Assignments PS, chapter 1, problems 5, 7, 8, 14, 16, 18, 35, 41, 43, 54, 55 SIA, p. 93 Resources, Activities, and Strategies Activities Distribution activity Features of a Distribution, WS, pp. 2934 Matching graphs to variables and matching statistics to graphs, ABS, pp. 3140
~7 days
Strategies A student survey from the first day of class that collects nonsensitive information (favorite fast-food restaurant, number of DVDs owned, etc.) can be used for graphical displays and discussion of types of data, as well as future topics. TI graphing features are used extensively. (Beware, however, of teaching too many calculator functions, such as renaming lists; weaker students may be overwhelmed by this additional information.) Assign several past AP Exam free-response questions to make students more aware of expectations and methods of scoring these questionse.g., 2001, no. 1. Introduce transformation of data and the resulting effects on measures of center and spreadlater referenced in chapter 7. Counting Techniques and Probability Activities Students select lottery numbers on the day Topics we begin this chapter, and drawings are Randomness done on a daily basis. (The Texas Lottery Probability models consists of selecting six numbers from 1 to 54.) A calculator is used to randomly select six numbers at the beginning of class, and Assignments prizes are given for matching four, five, or Worksheets to review basic counting six numbers. And yes, very few prizes are techniques, including combinations and given. permutations Probability review worksheets PS, chapter 6, problems 8, 9, 12, 13, 19, 21, 22, 23, 3133, 39, 40 Strategies Provide as much practice as possible in this section. A review of basic probability at this point has proved to be beneficial before addressing probabilities found using different density curves.
118
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Time Frame ~9 days
Unit Title, Topics, and Assignments The Normal Distribution Topics Density curves Normal distributions Standard normal calculations Assessing normality
Resources, Activities, and Strategies Activities Group problems from SMW, pp. 9395
~10 days
Strategies A calculator is used to find the probability on the standard normal curve. I do not teach too many shortcuts at this time. Draw connections with chapter 1, such as Assignments graphing data and finding the quartiles for PS, chapter 2, problems 2, 3, 4, 7, 9, 13, the normal curve. 17, 26, 27, 30, 31, 33, 39, 40, 43 Past AP Exam free-response question practice: 2003, no. 3. Examining Relationships Activities Activities to demonstrate the meaning of Topics LSRL and the coefficient of determination: Scatterplots Using the data from example 3.12, we Correlation calculate the sum of the squares of the Least-squares regression residuals for the line y = 4 + .5x. Students then try to find a better line with a smaller sum of squares. A calculator is Assignments then used to show the LSRL, and the PS, chapter 3, problems 1, 2, 5, 7, 11, 42, minimal sum is calculated. 43, 10, 26, 30, 36, 38, 50 PS computer lab activity from the textbook Web site Web sites related to these concepts (GC Applet and Regression Applet in the Teacher Resources section of this syllabus) Matching descriptions to scatterplots activity, ABS, pp. 8385 Strategies Go slowly and show as many examples as possible. Emphasize all steps needed to analyze the data. Recipes for slope and coefficient of determination are helpful for students to learn, but be sure these concepts are understood.
119
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Time Frame ~10 days
Unit Title, Topics, and Assignments More on Regression Analysis and TwoVariable Data Topics Modeling nonlinear relationshipslog and power transformations, piecewise functions Interpreting correlation and regression Relations in categorical data Assignments Review worksheet on logs and exponentials PS, chapter 4, problems 51, 52, 54, 7, 9, 10, 12, 61, 1924, 38, 39, 65, 40, 41, 43, 64 Samples and Experiments Topic Designing samples Designing experiments Simulating experiments
Resources, Activities, and Strategies Activities Have students collect data in a variety of ways and find the best model to fit their datae.g., the Cheerios® exploration available on Jared Derksens Web site (www.mrderksen.com/Downloads /cheerios.pdf). Strategies Most of my students need a one-day review of logs and exponentials. Group activities work well in this unit. Now is a good time to practice past AP Exam free-response questions (such as no. 1 from 2005). Activities Random Rectangles, ABS, pp. 154-55. Systematic, cluster, and stratified sampling is also demonstrated.
~15 days
~9 days
Strategies Students find examples of recent Assignments experiments or studies and then analyze PS, chapter 5, problems 1, 4, 5, 7, 912, according to principles learned in this 1425, 27, 31, 33, 29, 40, 45, 47 chapter. Group experiment based on the Vocabulary for this chapter needs to be Helicopter Project (see the Student stressed. Activities section of this syllabus) Past AP Exam free-response question practice: 2002, no. 2; 2004 (Form B), no. 2. Probability Revisited Activities Play the Game of Greed (URL is in my Topic Teacher Resources section) to introduce Probability tables and trees (section 6.3) simulations. Rules of the game: Students Law of large numbers stand. Single die is rolled twice and total Simulating probability (section 5.3) is counted. Students may sit and retain this total or stand for additional rolls. Any roll of 6 erases the accumulated total, and Assignments winner(s) are those students who most PS, chapter 6, problems 50, 53, 54, 45, recently sat down. On average, how many 47, 49, 51, 60 points would you expect to earn? Worksheets using problems from a Textbook Web site simulation of the law of variety of texts to supplement table and large numbers. tree problems
120
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Time Frame ~6 days
Unit Title, Topics, and Assignments Random Variables Topics Discrete and continuous random variables Means and variances of random variables Assignments PS, chapter 7, problems 3, 7, 8, 9, 11, 10, 17, 27, 18, 19, 25, 26, 29, 24, 30, 31, 32
Resources, Activities, and Strategies Activities Random Behavior, ABS, pp. 9395 Spinner activity to demonstrate transformations and combinations of random variables Dice activity to demonstrate that 2x is different from x + x Strategies Keep in mind that rules about means and variances for linear combinations of random variables are not on the formula chart for the AP Exam. These topics need to be included with problems in future chapters.
SEMESTER 2
Time Frame ~6 days Unit Title, Topics, and Assignments The Binomial and Geometric Distributions Topics Binomial distributions Normal approximation to the binomial Geometric distributions Assignments PS, chapter 8, problems 1923, 24, 29, 41 Additional worksheets Resources, Activities, and Strategies Activities Binomial Rabbits demo from NetLogo (see my Teacher Resources section) Normal approximation to the binomial demo (see the Teacher Resources section) M&Ms to demonstrate binomial and geometric distributions Student pairs graph binomial distributions on classroom boardfrom p = .1 to p = .9. Compare the graphs; calculate the mean and standard deviation for each using formulas from chapter 7; then compare these results to formulas for binomial distributions. Strategies Students need to see a variety of examples to emphasize the difference between binomial and geometric distributions.
121
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Time Frame ~10 days
Unit Title, Topics, and Assignments Sampling Distributions Topics Sampling distributions Sample means Introduction to confidence intervals Assignments PS, sections 9.1, 9.3, 10.1; chapter 9, problems 1, 4, 10, 33, 37, 39, 43, 45; chapter 10, problems 13, 5, 14, 6, 11, 16, 24
Resources, Activities, and Strategies Activities PS activity 9A (alternate) to demonstrate the central limit theorem (CLT). I have a dozen sets of these numbers, as well as four sets of a uniform distribution. Use one-inch graph paper to record data. I select sample sizes of 3, 5, and 10 from the normal distribution and sample size of 10 from the uniform. Displaying these graphs for the remainder of the year proves beneficial to remind students that sample size (not population size) is important in determining the variation of the sampling distribution. Strategies Using the sets of numbers for the normal distribution (described above), students graph a confidence interval and note if it captures the true mean of the population. There are some really nice software models demonstrating the central limit theorem (see Sampling Distribution and CLT Model in my Teacher Resources section). Understanding of the CLT is very important; time here is well spent. Strategies Students need to memorize much of the vocabulary in this chapter. Students begin a portfolio of all types of inference tests and intervals. Although calculating power and probability of Type II errors is not required material, both are valuable in demonstrating the relationships between Type I, Type II, power, sample size, and effect size.
~9 days
Introduction to Significance Tests and Inferences Topics z tests and intervals Type I and II errors Power Assignments PS, various problems are selected, but format involves parameter of interest, conditions, hypotheses, graph, test statistic, P-value, and conclusion PS, chapter 10, problems 61, 62, 63, 64 SMW, problems from pp. 418-19
122
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Time Frame ~9 days
~7 days
Unit Title, Topics, Resources, Activities, and Assignments and Strategies Inferences for One-Sample Distributions Activities Activities to gather data and to reinforce Topics experimental design and sampling Sampling proportions concepts from chapter 5 Inference for the mean of a population (sigma unknown) Strategies Inference for a population proportion Students need to analyze computer data for this section (and the ones to come). Assignments Output from different computer programs PS, sections 9.2, 11.1, 12.1; chapter 9, should be utilized. problems 15, 19, 21, 23, 25; chapter 11, Examples of each type of test and interval problems 1, 5, 6, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14; chapter are added to the students portfolios. 12, problems 111 (odd) Worksheet with mixed practice Inferences for Two-Sample Distributions Activities Activities to gather data for analysis and Topics reinforcement of experimental design and Comparing two means sampling concepts Comparing two proportions Ongoing portfolio project Assignments PS, chapter 11, problems 3133, 37, 39, 43, 44; chapter 12, problems 2124 Strategies Past AP Exam free-response questions covering inferences Activities Test of homogeneity: For a quiz grade, each student receives a cup of multi-fruitcolored cereal and determines if the colors are equally distributed. After the quiz, they check the bottom of their cups to determine which kind of Froot Loops® they have (three different brands of cereal are used in the class). Strategies Test after this unit on chapters 913 combined: This exam (the only one in the course that covers multiple units) combines all of the different types of intervals and tests. I feel that tying all of these topics together is important to success in this area.
~8 days
Chi-Square Procedures Topics Goodness of fit Homogeneity of proportions Independence Assignments PS, chapter 13, problems 1, 3, 4, 12, 21, 30 Worksheets with mixed types of inference studied to this point
123
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Time Frame ~7 days
Unit Title, Topics, and Assignments Inference for Regression Topics Hypothesis test for slope Confidence interval for slope Computer output Assignments Review worksheets on linear regression and transformations to achieve linearity Computer data printouts AP Exam questions Review for AP Exam Assignments Multiple-choice and free-response questions from AP Central and Released Exams PostAP Exam Period Topics Games of chance Apply principles of probability in developing a game of chance
Resources, Activities, and Strategies Activities Cooperative assignments and review worksheets Strategies Review chapters 3 and 4 for AP Exam. Students need to be able to analyze data from different types of computer software.
~ 10 days
~ 10 days
Activities Game of Chance project (see my Student Activities section)
Teaching Strategies
I have integrated my specific teaching strategies for each segment of the syllabus into the Course Planner above. Here I describe some of the broader instructional methods that I employ. I start most class periods with a short warm-up question that reviews recently presented material. These problems are graded as correct or incorrect, and the points earned are recorded for each student. Individual accumulated points become a quiz grade at the end of the grading periodbased on five-eighths of the total points possible. As the year progresses, I begin class once a week with 12-minute timed warm-ups, using free-response questions similar to those that appear on the AP Exam. Group points are earned in cooperative activities. For example, I often distribute challenging multiplechoice questions (at a higher level of difficulty than most of my test questions) to groups of students in order to review for a test. These encourage discussion in the group and give the students good practice. At the end of each six weeks, group points are converted into a quiz grade, based on the average number of points earned by the class groups. Such a quiz is usually a benefit to student averages. New groups are determined randomly (of course) every six weeks. I am a strong believer in learning by doing, so a great deal of my instruction is based on classroom activities that reinforce the material being taught. Students learn abstract concepts best from practical applications, and they also enjoy engaging in hands-on projects. For instance, because it has a second-story balcony, my school offers the perfect place to stage the Helicopter Project described on the North Carolina
124
Course Organization About AP Statistics
School of Science and Mathematics (NCSSM) Web site. (For a complete description of this and several other such undertakings, see the Student Activities section at the end of this syllabus.) I have found the amount and quality of learning that students derive from group activities to be well worth the additional time required. Once we begin to study inference, I have the students develop a portfolio that contains examples of each type of hypothesis test and confidence interval (see the Student Activities section). The total points earned are counted as a test grade, but most important, students claim that this collection of their work provides the best study material for the AP Exam. I use released AP Exam questions for many of these problems, but I vary them from year to year, because the portfolios tend to be saved by former students.
Student Evaluation
Students transcripts show two semester grades, both of equal value. Each semester has three six-week grading periods and a semester exam, each worth 25 percent of the semester grade. District guidelines require that each six-weeks grade be determined as follows: Tests: 70 percent Quizzes: 20 percent Daily class work and homework: 10 percent There is a test at the end of each instructional unit. All unit tests are half multiple-choice and half free-response questions. Semester exams are 70 percent multiple-choice and 30 percent free-response. The second-semester exam is a comprehensive final. Quizzes are given periodicallyeither announced or unannouncedin order to assess students knowledge of the material on a day-to-day basis. The schools grading scale is as follows: 90100 8089 7579 7074 A B C D
Teacher Resources
Primary Textbook
Yates, Daniel S., David S. Moore, and George P. McCabe. The Practice of Statistics: TI-83 Graphing Calculator Enhanced. New York: W. H. Freeman, 1999.
Supplementary Books
Bock, David E., Paul F. Velleman, and Richard D. De Veaux. Stats: Modeling the World. Boston: Pearson/ Addison-Wesley, 2004. Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. 2nd ed. Pacific Grove, Calif.: Brooks/Cole, 2005. Rossman, Allan J., and J. Barr von Oehsen. Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data and the Graphing Calculator. New York: Springer, 1997.
125
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Scheaffer, Richard L., Mrudulla Gnanadesikan, Ann Watkins, and Jeffrey A. Witmer. Activity-Based Statistics: Instructor Resources. New York: Springer, 1996. Utts, Jessica M., and Robert F. Heckard. Mind on Statistics. 2nd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2004. Watkins, Ann E., Richard L. Scheaffer, and George W. Cobb. Statistics in Action: Understanding a World of Data. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press, 2004. Yates, Daniel S., and Daren S. Starnes. The Practice of Statistics Golden Resource Binder. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003.
Web Sites
Boggs, Rex. The Game of Greed. w ww.lhs.logan.k12.ut.us/~jsmart/greed.htm. NCSSM Statistics Leadership Institute Notes. The Helicopter Experiment: A Factorial Design. http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_Inst/PDFS/FacDesgn.pdf. Rice Virtual Lab in Statistics. Normal Approximation to the Binomial Distribution. http://onlinestatbook.com/stat_sim/normal_approx/index.html. Rice Virtual Lab in Statistics. Sampling Distribution. http://onlinestatbook.com/stat_sim/sampling_dist/index.html. University of Illinois at UrbanaChampaign, Department of Statistics. GC Applet. w ww.Stat.uiuc.edu/~stat100/java/GCApplet/GCAppletFrame.html. West, R. Webster, University of South Carolina. Regression Applet. w ww.stat.sc.edu/~west/javahtml/Regression.html. W. H. Freeman Co. The Practice of Statistics. 2nd ed. Companion Web site. http://bcs.whfreeman.com/yates2e. For my purposes, the Web site for the second edition works fine with the first edition of the textbook. Wilensky, Uri, Center for Connected Learning and Computer-Based Modeling, Northwestern University. NetLogo Binomial Rabbits Model. http://ccl.northwestern.edu/netlogo/models/BinomialRabbits. Wilensky, Uri, Center for Connected Learning and Computer-Based Modeling, Northwestern University. Central Limit Theorem Model. http://ccl.northwestern.edu/netlogo/models/CentralLimitTheorem.
126
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Student Activities
Graphical Methods for Describing Univariate Data
(Adapted from a project attributed to Susan Mead, in Christopher R. Olsen, AP Statistics Teachers Guide [New York: College Board, 2002], 154.) You are a dietician who has been asked to make a presentation to a high school class. You would like to discuss the nutritional value of fast food, using the concepts learned in The Practice of Statistics, chapter 1. Please do the following: 1. Pick one of the restaurants from the following list and look at one nutritional value (e.g., calories, sodium content, fat content, cholesterol) across all food products (entrees, salads, and sides). If there is more than one size for that product, use the middle size. Using the data shown in the tables, prepare a graphical representation of the nutritional value of the data set with at least 15 values. Then analyze the distribution, including measures of center and spread, the shape, clusters, gaps, and outliers. Write a brief summary of the nutritional value of the fast food from your restaurant. 2. Pick two restaurants. Choose a nutritional value different from the one you chose in problem no. 1. Do a comparison of this value for both restaurants, including graphical and numerical analysis. Are there any differences or similarities between the two types of establishments with regard to the chosen nutritional value? Please include separate lists of data for each part of this project. Web sites for the restaurants are given below. If you would like to analyze a fast-food restaurant that is missing from this list, just ask if you may include it. Burger King Chick-fil-A Churchs Chicken Jack in the Box Kentucky Fried Chicken McDonalds Wendys Whataburger www.bk.com www.chickfila.com www.churchs.com www.jackinthebox.com www.kfc.com www.mcdonalds.com www.wendys.com www.whataburger.com
Grading This is a 50-point project, equivalent to half a test. All work is due at the beginning of the period on 15 percent per day deduction for late work. , even if you are absent. There will be a
Each project should begin with a cover sheet that includes the title of your project, your name, and the date. Do not put it in a binder. Just staple or paper clip the pages together.
Summaries should be typed, double-spaced, and in paragraph form. Graphs may be on separate pages from your summaries.
127
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Projects should be grammatically correct and without spelling errors. I will deduct points for offensive errors. You may turn in a rough draft before for me to evaluate.
Point breakdown for grading: List of data for part 1 Appropriate display of data for part 1 Summary for part 1 Lists of data for part 2 Appropriate comparative display of data sets for part 2 Summary for part 2 2 points 9 points 9 points 4 points 13 points 13 points
The Helicopter Project
(Adapted from the NCSSM Web site: http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_Inst/PDFS/FacDesgn.pdf) Group members: (names and contact information):
For this project, we will investigate the flight of helicopters (made from cardstock) launched from the second floor of Mayde Creek High School. We want to see if there is a difference between launching helicopters with a longer or shorter blade. We will also look to see if there is a difference between using one or two weights (paper clips). Once agreement is reached by the entire class as to what will constitute the best flight, each group will develop and perform its own experiment to determine the best combination of rotor length and added weight. The first trial is a rough draft day so that individual group members can compare their conclusions and develop one report for each group. You will have 20 helicopters to use for the experiment, plus 4 for the trial run. Tape measures and stopwatches will be available, if needed. First-Day Worksheet Answer/define the following questions/terms for your group: 1. The explanatory variable(s) 2. The response variablehow will you measure this? 3. The experimental units 4. The factor(s) and level(s) 5. How many treatments?
128
6. What type of design will be used? 7. Draw the design: 8. What controls do you need? Be specific:
Course Organization About AP Statistics
9. State the procedure your group will use to do the experiment. BE PRECISE!! Assign group members to do the different jobs. 10. Assign the helicopters to treatments. Explain how your group did this. 11. Perform trial runs. Make corrections or improvements to your answers for the questions above. Second-Day Worksheet As a group, answer these questions when you finish your experiment. You will finalize your comments/ thoughts in your group report. 1. What are the results for each helicopter? 2. What are the mean and standard deviation for each treatment? 3. What conclusions can be drawn from your data? 4. Did anything go wrong? If so, what? 5. What would you and your group do differently? 6. Draw a double line graph (one line for the longer rotor, one for the shorter) of the means of each treatment, putting the measurement of flights on the vertical axis. Grading The report that each group submits should consist of the following parts and must include this sheet for each group member. Your grade is based on the following (maximum possible points are in parentheses): Points Abstract of experiment (10) Randomization method and list of helicopters assigned to treatments (5) Controls (10) Procedures (10) Raw data and exploratory analysis (10) (does not need to be typed) Double line graph (10) Interpretation of results (10) What would you do differently? (5)
129
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
First-day worksheet from each group member (10) Cooperative work (group/teacher evaluation) (20) Project grade (100)
Confidence Intervals and Significance Tests Portfolio
Each year, I provide students with a set of problems that examines, in addition to the tests and intervals, all of the important concepts, including conditions that are violated, questions regarding Type I and II errors, sample size needed for a particular size interval, references to cause and effect, and so forth. Each student creates an individual portfolio and receives credit for each submission (graded on a 5-point scale). Students are given the opportunity to correct or improve these examples before the final submission. When all of the items have been completed, the portfolio is used to answer several in-class problems. Two of the original problems are also randomly selected to determine if they have been corrected or improved to perfect 10s.
There are 10 examples to complete. All work must be neatly shown, with a full summary and explanation. The portfolio should include this cover page and be in a three-ring folder/notebook. The portfolio counts as the equivalent of one test grade, and problems are graded according to the following criteria:
Completion/correctness on specified due dates Correctness at the conclusion of the project (5) (5) (5) (5) (5) (5) (5) (5) (5) (5)
1. One-sample z (completed) 2. One-sample t (completed) 3. Matched pairs t (completed) 4. One-sample proportion z (completed) 5. Two-sample t (completed) 6. Two-sample proportion (completed) 7. Chi-square goodness of fit (completed) 8. Chi-square homogeneity (completed) 9. Chi-square independence (completed) 10. Lin-reg slope (completed)
--------------------------------------------11. Notebook, cover sheet, and neatness 12. Random problem (corrected) (10) (10)
130
13. Random problem (corrected) 14. In-class problem(s) Total: (10) (20) (100)
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Game of Chance
After the AP Exam, we usually have two weeks of class before final exams start, and because some of my students are taking other AP Exams, I do not want to burden them with additional homework or makeup work. The Casino Lab activity from the Golden Resource Binder (2nd ed.) for chapter 7 of our text is used to introduce games of chance. Additional history for each game is also discussed. After completing the lab, students must create their own game of chance. Partners may be used if desired. Students must create a sheet for documentation of game results when played by their classmates. Often additional texts must be referenced to determine the theoretical probability of the new game. This has proved to be an entertaining way to finish the year! Instructions After having looking at several popular games of chance, it is now your turn to develop your own game using probability. You may work alone or with one partner. The following requirements must be met: Step One: 1. Decide on a game that you would like to develop. 2. Test your ideas through simulations of your game. 3. Are you able to answer all of the questions in step two for your game? 4. Adjust/change the rules and guidelines for your game. 5. Share your thoughts with Mrs. Daniluk before proceeding. Proposal acceptance date: Step Two (prepare your written project, including each of the following): 1. Name your game. (5 points) 2. Describe the rules of your game. (10 points) 3. Play your game, recording the results, and determine the experimental probability of winning. Playing of your game may be done with the actual materials or simulated with the calculator. Play a realistic number of times in order to feel somewhat confident about your experimental probability. (5 points) 4. Determine the theoretical probability of winning your game. This may be much more difficult than it sounds, so think about this aspect of your game as ideas grow. Of course, your work must be shown! (10 points) 5. If it costs $2 to play your game, what must the payoff be in order to make this a fair game? (5 points)
131
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
6. Find two other individuals from our class to play your game. Provide them with the proper forms or worksheets to record their results. (5 points) 7. How do these results (in item 6) compare with the experimental and theoretical probabilities that you found in items 3 and 4 above? (5 points) Is there a substantial difference? (5 points) 8. Are there any improvements or alterations that you think should be made to your game? Grading This assignment counts as a 50-point quiz, or you may double the points to make it equivalent to a 100point testwhichever you prefer. Note: This will not be decided randomly J. Have fun!
132
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sample Syllabus 6
Jared Derksen Rancho Cucamonga High School Rancho Cucamonga, California
School Profile
Location and Environment: Rancho Cucamonga High School (RCHS) is located in a suburban area 40 miles east of Los Angeles. The school has experienced six years of improvement on state tests. There are two student leadership groupsone follows a traditional model by organizing rallies, dances, lunchtime activities, and community projects, whereas the other group, our Renaissance Program, is solely dedicated to promoting and recognizing student achievement. Renaissance works with local businesses and school funds to provide special T-shirts to students on the Honor Roll and recognizes students who show marked scholastic improvement, as well as our academic Top 10. The Renaissance Rally held every spring is viewed by many students as one of the highlights of the school year. RCHS also sponsors more than thirty student clubs, ranging from guitar and chess to various ethnic dancing groups and anime. Our awardwinning music program has many different ensembles and performing groups, and the athletic program is competitive in the Southern California League. In short, RCHS has a strong sense of school pride and accomplishment and fosters an environment where being involved while learning is highly valued. Grades: 912 Type: Public high school Total Enrollment: 2,800 Ethnic Diversity: The student body is 34 percent Hispanic/Latino, 16 percent African American, and 7 percent Asian American. College Record: Although 70 percent of the graduating students go to college, only 30 percent attend a four-year university.
Personal Philosophy
I am enthusiastic about teaching AP Statisticsthis is a dynamic class that significantly influences my students thinking and the way they view the world. I jokingly tell them, Be forewarned! If you do not want to think about statistics at the most inopportune moments for at least the next five years, dont take this class! The applications and implications of statistics can be found everywhere in our culture: election polls, medical studies, financial analysisand even bags of M&Ms. For that reason, I always make sure that assignments are tied to real-world data, and class time often includes interactive experiments and activities. My goal is to show students how to think carefully about the collection and analysis of data, thereby helping them to make discerning and rational decisions about many important issues that rely on statistical claims and improving their critical thinking skills in general.
Class Profile
RCHS offers three sections of AP Statistics annually, all taught by me. It is a one-year, two-semester course that meets five days a week. The class is 55 minutes long, except on Fridays, when it meets for 45 minutes. Class size ranges from 25 to 35 pupils per section. Students enter the class with a wide range of
133
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
backgrounds. Some have the minimum prerequisite (passing Algebra 2 with a C), whereas others come from the honors program. It is not uncommon for honors students to take AP Statistics concurrently with Precalculus or Calculus.
Course Overview
The course includes the topics listed in the AP Statistics Course Description, primarily through the use of three resources: Bock et al., Stats: Modeling the World, second edition (the main textbook); Levine-Wissing and Thiel, AP Statistics, third edition; and the past AP Exam questions available on AP Central, as well as in the AP Statistics Released Exams (1997 and 2002 [Note: The 2007 Released Exam has become available since this syllabus was submitted.]). (For complete citations, see the Teacher Resources section of this syllabus.) My objectives for the course are that the students learn:
The material in the Topic Outline of the Course Description How to read and analyze surveys and experiments as reported in the media How to use technology, both handheld and computers, to analyze data sets, large and small How to clearly communicate the results of a study to a small group
The handout below, which I give to the students at the beginning of the year, explains the overall organization of the course.
Expectations I look forward to teaching every day. I hope that you will come to class ready to learn and with a positive attitude. Statistics is an inherently interesting subject: it surrounds us everywhere we go. Investigating such a fascinating topic will involve lots of participation on your part. So turn off your cell phone, and come to class ready to think and be stretched! Participation You are expected to participate in class regularly. Finishing the Do-Now problems and completing problems that we work on during class time is essential for your learning. You will turn in participation cards during class to demonstrate how involved you are. Materials All students must have the following in class on a daily basis:
A three-ring binder or spiral notebook Your formula sheet in a sheet protector Graphing calculator (TI-83 Plus or TI-84 preferred, if purchasing new)
Please talk to me if you need to check out a calculator. Homework Homework will be assigned three or four times a week. You are allowed one late assignment for every 10 we complete. Other late assignments may be completed for half credit.
134
Course Organization About AP Statistics
After-School Tutoring and Study Groups I will be available after school for tutoring one or two days a week. On Mondays, the schedule for the week will be announced. I strongly recommend that you form a study group. Working with your classmates to learn the material is an excellent way to improve your understanding of statistics.
Course Planner
The numbered weeks below indicate actual instruction time, exclusive of school breaks and holidays. Full citations for all sources mentioned here can be found in the Teacher Resources section of this syllabus.
SEMESTER 1
Unit I: Exploring and Understanding Data Stats, chapters 16 Time frame: five weeks Week 1 Introduction to stats (chapter 1)
What is data? (chapter 2) Describing and displaying categorical data (chapter 3) Introductory discussion of independence (chapter 3)
Workshop Statistics (Rossman et al.), activities 1-1 through 1-6 Activity: M&M dotplots with description Week 2 Describing and displaying quantitative data (chapter 4) Quiz on chapter 4 Week 3 Summary statistics for quantitative data (chapter 5)
Outliers (chapter 5)
Workshop Statistics, activity 3-1 Quiz on outlier rule and describing/comparing quantitative data Favorite released AP Exam free-response questions to use:
° ° ° °
1997, no. 1 2000, no. 3 2001, no. 1 2002 Form B, no. 5
135
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Week 4 The normal distribution (chapter 6)
The effect of linear transformations to data sets on summary statistics (chapter 6)
Week 5 Review and assessment of Unit I Unit I vocabulary crossword Project 1: Exploring datacollect data, graph it, and describe it (see the Student Activities section of this syllabus) Unit I Exam A major test is given at the end of this unit. It includes at least one AP Exam free-response question (see list in week 3) and is given on one-and-a-half school days. The test has multiple-choice problems as well. Unit II: Regression Stats, chapters 710 Time frame: four weeks Week 6 Displaying and describing scatterplots (chapter 6)
Analyzing two-variable quantitative data
Workshop Statistics, activities 8-1 and 8-2 Quiz on describing scatterplots Week 7 Analyzing two-variable quantitative data
°
Correlation and the coefficient of determination (chapter 7)
° °
Least-squares regression (chapter 8) Slope and y-intercept (chapter 8)
Week 8 Analyzing two-variable quantitative data
Unit II vocabulary crossword (see the Student Activities section) Analysis of the Anscombe data set Megaquiz on regression (after chapter 8) Stats wandering point worksheet (from Printed Test Bank and Resource Guide) Favorite released AP Exam free-response questions to use:
° °
Residuals and residual plots (chapter 8) Outliers and influential points (chapter 9)
136
° ° ° °
1999, no. 1 2002, no. 4 2002 Form B, no. 1 2003 Form B, no. 1
Week 9 Transformations to achieve linearity (chapter 10) Favorite released AP Exam free-response questions to use:
Course Organization About AP Statistics
° °
1997, no. 6 2004 Form B, no. 1
Unit II Exam This major exam includes regression (again) and the topics in chapters 9 and 10. Unit III: Collecting Data Stats, chapters 1213 Time frame: three weeks Week 10 Designing surveys via various methods (chapter 12)
Bias in surveys (chapter 12) Randomization and representative samples (chapter 12)
Workshop Statistics, activities 12-1 and 12-2 Project 2: Bias in surveys (see the Student Activities section) Weeks 11 and 12 Observational studies (chapter 13)
Experimental design (chapter 13)
Workshop Statistics, activities 13-1 and 13-2 Unit III vocabulary crossword (see the Student Activities section) Stratification activity (North Carolina School of Science and Math [NCSSM] Web site) Favorite released AP Exam free-response questions to use:
° ° ° ° ° ° °
Control Random assignment of treatment Replication Placebo and blinding Blocking and matched pairs Confounding and lurking variables Statistically significant difference (introduction)
° ° ° ° ° °
1997, no. 2 1999, no. 3 2001, no. 4 2002, no. 2 2002 Form B, no. 3 2003, no. 4
137
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Unit III Exam In addition to 10 multiple-choice questions, the test contains 3 free-response questions that are similar to those found on the AP Exam. Unit IV: Probability Stats, chapters 11, 1418 Time frame: eight weeks (the last six weeks of the first semester and the first two weeks of the second semester) Week 13 Basic probability principles, including complementary, independent, and mutually exclusive events (chapter 14) Examination of homemade dice data: law of large numbers Week 14 Addition, multiplication, and conditional probability rules (chapter 15) Scramble worksheets assigned (worksheets that consist of a mixture of different probability chapters) Probability quiz Favorite released AP Exam free-response question to use:
°
2003 Form B, no. 2
Week 15 Random variables (chapter 16)
More scramble worksheets Unit IV vocabulary crossword Favorite released AP Exam free-response questions to use:
° °
Expected value and standard deviation Rules for transforming and combining random variables
Probability test: chapters 1416 Week 16 Simulating probability scenarios (chapter 11) Favorite released AP Exam free-response question to use:
° ° °
2001, no. 2 2002 Form B, no. 2 2004, no. 4
°
2001, no. 3 (or a variation that examines whether iPods® really shuffle randomly!)
Week 17 Review for final exam Week 18 Finals week: cumulative semester exam
138
SEMESTER 2
Unit IV: Probability (continued) Week 1 Binomial and geometric distributions for means and proportions (chapter 17) Continue to use simulations from chapter 11 to examine this topic Quiz Week 2 Sampling distributions (chapter 18) Sampling distributions activity using beads of two different colors Sampling distribution applet used for demonstration Test: chapters 17 and 18 Unit V: Inference for Proportions Stats, chapters 1922 Time frame: four weeks Week 3 Confidence intervals for one proportion (chapter 19) Use beads of two different colors to estimate proportions Quiz on confidence intervals Week 4 Hypothesis testing for one proportion (chapter 20) Short test on tests and intervals Week 5 Type I and II errors and power (chapter 21)
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Colored bead activity from mystery bags (analysis of errors and power) Unit V vocabulary crossword Unit V exam (chapters 1921, including review of sampling distributions for proportions) Week 6 Intervals and tests for two proportions (chapter 22) Cumulative Unit V Exam (Chapters 1922) Unit VI: Inference for Means Stats, chapters 2325 Time frame: three weeks Week 7 Confidence intervals and hypothesis tests for one mean (chapter 23) Examination of homemade dice (mean = 3.5?) Students will not know whether their die, because it is homemade, will have a mean of 3.5 or not. A fair die should. Quiz on t procedures
139
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Week 8 Confidence intervals and hypothesis testing for two means (chapter 24) Unit VI vocabulary crossword Exam on one- and two-sample t procedures Week 9 Confidence intervals and hypothesis testing for matched pairs means (chapter 25) Cumulative Unit VI Exam Unit VII: Inference for Counts and Slope Stats, chapters 2627 Time frame: two weeks Week 10 Chi-square goodness of fit (chapter 26)
Chi-square for homogeneity and for independence (chapter 26)
Test homemade dice for fairness Week 11 Confidence interval for slope (chapter 27)
Hypothesis testing for slope (chapter 27)
Unit VII vocabulary crossword Unit VII Exam This includes regression review questions. Review for the AP Exam Time frame: four weeks
Various book exercises Practice free-response problems Practice work from AP Statistics (Levine-Wissing and Thiel)
Assessment As we review the course, free-response questions are given as quizzes. These free-response scores are accumulated to generate a practice test score. I also give a practice multiple-choice exam. Cumulative Project Time frame: four weeks
Cumulative year-end project (see the Student Activities section at the end of this syllabus)
Assessment The final project receives a grade.
140
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Teaching Strategies
I firmly believe that it is important for students to take an active role in their own learning process, not just to be passive sponges soaking up isolated pieces of information. Their immersion in the subject by working both independently and together in class on a variety of problems and projects helps them to consolidate what they have gleaned from the textbook and from listening to me. Moreover, it spurs them to think for themselves, to make critical judgments about statistical claims they encounter every day, and to consider novel applications for the methods they have learned. In order to engage them in this sort of challenge, I use a number of different approachesamong them, the following:
Data is frequently collected from the class. On the first day, students fill out a short questionnaire, and these data are used throughout the first unit. Many topics are introduced by asking students to provide simple information about themselves, and the resulting data are used to open the days lesson. I use participation cards in class to encourage active learning. Whenever a student participates in any class activity (answering questions, offering solutions, doing work on the board, and so forth) that person (along with any other student who helped with the answer) hands me a card with his or her name on it. These cards are then tabulated as a part of each students grade. Every other week students read current news articles that contain statistics and/or statistical issues and summarize them. These articles are then discussed in class. Sources are available everywhere on the Internetthe AP newswire, online newspapers, and popular Web sites. Two good examples are stories about a survey of the survivors of the 2004 tsunami in the Washington Post (www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A10689-2005Jan14.html) and about smart baby DVDs at WebMD (http://children.webmd.com/news/20070807/smart-baby-dvds-no-help-may-harm). A classroom set of Workshop Statistics is used for occasional cooperative group work. When studying inference, students do confidence intervals and hypothesis tests on a template sheet that walks them through the necessary steps: name, hypotheses (tests only), check of conditions, formulas and math work, and conclusion. They use this template throughout the inference units and even on many of the assessments. During review time for the AP Exam, they are weaned from the template, but by then the steps for inference have become automatic. When we finish the course with a final project after the AP Exam, students learn the use of Data Desk ® computer software. I have designed a series of four lessons that guide them through the basics of using the program:
° ° ° °
Lesson 1Descriptive Statistics (graphs and summary reports) Lesson 2Regression (using scatterplots and regression tools) Lesson 3Inference (performing hypothesis tests and confidence intervals) Lesson 4Large Data Sets (students are given large data sets and asked to analyze them)
Students are then encouraged (as technology at school and home permits) to use Data Desk to analyze their final project.
141
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Student Evaluation
Students receive two separate grades for each semester of the course. In order to help students and the instructor remain focused on the thorough learning of each component of the course, all assessments are sorted by unit. A typical grade breakdown is as follows: First Semester Homework Participation Unit I Unit II Unit III Unit IV (beginning) Second Semester Homework Participation Unit IV (end) Unit V Unit VI Unit VII Review for AP Exam Final project
10 percent 10 percent 25 percent 20 percent 15 percent 20 percent
10 percent 10 percent 10 percent 20 percent 15 percent 10 percent 15 percent 10 percent
I do not put tests and quizzes in a separate category. Any assessment the student takes goes into the unit to which the material pertains. The first-semester final exam grade is broken into four partsone part for the questions on each unit. This grading system has the advantage of making it easier to recognize and reward progress over time. For example, if a student earns high marks on the regression questions on the f irst-semester final exam, these scores can be compared with the grade in the Unit II category and a more appropriate grade for the students level of comprehension can be assigned. Students are highly encouraged to take the AP Exam. They are reminded that high-stakes exams are common in college, so taking an AP Exam is a good way to practice for these upcoming assessments.
Teacher Resources
Basic and Supplementary Textbooks
Bock, David E., Paul F. Velleman, and Richard D. De Veaux. Stats: Modeling the World. Boston: Pearson/ Addison-Wesley, 2004. (This is the primary text used for the course.) Levine-Wissing, Robin, and David Thiel. AP Statistics. 3rd ed. Piscataway, N.J.: Research and Education Association, 2006.
Resource Books
Bock, David E., and William B. Craine III. Printed Test Bank and Resource Guide for Stats: Modeling the World. 2nd ed. Boston: Pearson/Prentice Hall, 2007. College Board. 1997 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 1997. College Board. 2002 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 2002. (Note: The 2007 Released Exam has become available since this syllabus was submitted.) Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. 2nd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2005. Rossman, Allan J., Beth L. Chance, and J. Barr von Oehsen. Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data and the Graphing Calculator. 2nd ed. Emeryville, Calif.: Key College Publishing, 2002.
142
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Scheaffer, Richard L., Mrudulla Gnanadesikan, Ann Watkins, and Jeffrey A. Witmer. Activity-Based Statistics. New York: Springer, 1996. Yates, Daniel S., David S. Moore, and Daren S. Starnes. The Practice of Statistics: TI-83/89 Graphing Calculator Enhanced. 2nd. ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003.
Software/Multimedia
ActivStats. CD-ROM ed. 20002001 release. By Paul Velleman. N.p.: Addison-Wesley, 2000. Data Desk is the analysis software that is built into ActivStats.
Web Sites
AP Central. apcentral.collegeboard.com. I use this site regularly as a source of free-response questions other than those published in the Released Exams. Claremont Graduate University, WISE Projects Statistical Power Applet. Type I and II and power applet. http://wise.cgu.edu/power/power_applet.html. Eclipse Crossword. w ww.eclipsecrossword.com. Generates crossword puzzles from a list of words and clues. Geometers Sketchpad Resource Center. w ww.dynamicgeometry.com/javasketchpad/gallery/pages/least_squares.php. Least-squares regression demonstration. NCSSM Statistics Leadership Institute. An Exercise in Sampling: Rolling Down the River. http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_inst01/PDFS/river.pdf. Stratification activity Stanton, Charles. California State University, San Bernadino. w ww.math.csusb.edu/faculty/stanton/m262/regress/regress.html. Linear regression influential point applet. University of Illinois at UrbanaChampaign, Department of Statistics. Guess my correlation applet. w ww.stat.uiuc.edu/courses/stat100//java/GCApplet/GCAppletFrame.html.
Student Activities
Project 1: Exploring Data
Purpose To practice describing data and graphs and to begin to think about data collection and sources of bias.
143
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Page 1 (must be typed) First paragraph: Second paragraph: Describe how and where you collected your data (collect at least 25 data points; data must be quantitative). Do you think your data represent the population you were studying? Why or why not? What sources of bias do you think may have been present in your data collection? By studying graphs of the data, what relationships can be observed? What do the graphs show? What conclusions can be drawn?
Third paragraph: Page 2 and following Graph your data.
By hand, neatly, is fine. Make two different types of graphs for the quantitative datahistogram, boxplot, stemplot, and/or dotplot.
Note: Excel makes great pie graphs and lousy histogramsproceed at your own peril.
Project 2: Bias in Surveys
Purpose To investigate how much different forms of bias can affect the results of a survey. The Project The project must be done in groups of one to four. Submit one poster per group.
A brief oral presentation is also required for each group. No written report is necessary.
Topic You will design a survey on an interesting topic of your choice, but you must design it so you can address one of the following questions:
Is it possible to word a question in two different ways that are logically equivalent but that produce much different responses? Do the characteristics of the interviewer affect responses? Does anonymity change the responses to sensitive questions? Does providing extra information affect the responses?
Note: You may choose another form of bias if you get special approval from me. You should compare at least two different groups. Usually this consists of a control group that is normal and unbiased and a second group that is biased in a certain direction. Depending on your idea, you may choose to have two different biasesone that will tilt in one direction and one that will tilt in another. You will not be penalized if you do not succeed in creating a large bias.
144
Proposal Each groups project proposal should include the following:
Course Organization About AP Statistics
A definition of the population A copy of the survey questions A short description of how you will create bias and what direction you think the bias will swing Where and how you will collect your data
Note: Your sampling procedure should not be biased. Survey 50 people per question (50 for the unbiased question, 50 for each biased question). Poster The poster should completely summarize your project yet be simple enough to be understood by someone unfamiliar with statistics. Remember the purpose of the project! It should be pleasing to the eye. It should include a one-page typed summary describing what you did. The colors on your graphs are crucial to communicating the bias being examined: use a consistent color key so the change can be easily spotted. Points: 30 points (10 for appearance, 10 for clear communication on graphs, 10 for the summary) Oral Presentation All group members must participate equally in this five-minute talk, and your poster should be used only as a visual aid. To receive full credit for the presentation, your group must speak clearly and with confidence, and you must do something to engage the audience. I leave it open-ended as to exactly what you tell us about what you did, but I absolutely insist that your presentation be clear, interesting, and articulate. Your task is to be verbally engagingwe do not have time for elaborate props/media setup. Points: 20 points (10 for being stimulating, 10 points for clear communication) Due Dates
Proposal: Tuesday, November 14 Poster: On your presentation date, between December 4 and December 15 Your group will be randomly assigned a presentation date. If your group is not ready and/or does not have 100 percent attendance on that day, you will be moved to a different date and receive a 20 percent penalty on your presentation grade.
Cumulative Year-End Project
Report Proposal Due: Friday, May 12
The question of investigation/curiosity: Population of interest: A brief description of how and where you are going to collect your data: (to be completed by me)
Difficulty/Interest Rating:
145
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
I. Data Report (20 points) Due: Wednesday, May 25 This section should be a thorough explanation of how you collected your data and be a beautiful example of how much you have learned this year about the difficulties of getting a representative sample. Examples of what you should include follow:
How you collected your data Why you are confident your sample matches your population Biases avoided and not avoided A copy of any survey that was filled out Your data, either in Excel format or in a table/matrix summary. You need at least 75 people/subjects for each group you want to compare. Your data should be broken up by any category you want to compare.
II. Exploring the Data (25 points) Due: Friday, June 2 This section should be an outstanding example of exploratory data analysis (the first unit in our text). Graphs should show comparisons between all relevant groups. You should state any preliminary conclusions that can be drawn from visually obvious patterns. Be sure to include the following:
Graphs of your data Statistics from your data Descriptions of the graphs and statistics
Extra credit will be earned for using Data Desk. III. Analyzing the Data (25 points) Due: Wednesday, June 7 Analyze your data, using whatever method(s) are appropriate. Your conclusion should be clearly written, using all appropriate statistical support. Remember that confidence intervals can be a powerful method for comparing different groups. This analysis should include the following elements:
Hypothesis test (with conditions checked) and/or Confidence intervals (with conditions checked) and/or Regression Your grand conclusion!
Extra credit will be earned for using Data Desk.
146
IV. Presentation (20 points) Due: Friday, June 9 The requirements for the groups oral reports are given below:
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Clearly communicate your question and how you collected your data (5 points). Visually display graphs of your dataPowerPoint (if you must), overhead, poster, or video (5 points). I do not want a pretty poster that summarizes the whole project. I want you to make a visual aid that shows the class how your data came out. There should be only minimal text on your visual aid titles and big numbersnot any explanations. Clearly communicate your conclusion (5 points). Be interesting to listen to and give us some sort of hook to inspire us to listen (5 points). Do not read from your visual aiduse note cards or your report. Be careful how you communicate numbers to the classtoo many numbers at once are confusing, as is giving too many decimal places.
V. Success!? (15 points) I will evaluate the overall success and difficulty of your project. More challenging data collection issues add to your score. Small sample sizes or an overly simple question will lower your score. General Requirements
Make your own copies of the data, graphs, and so forth. Once you turn in each part of your report, I need to keep it. Do not get lazythis is to be the summation of what you have learned all year. Please type your paper. Handwritten work is acceptable for some graphs and the like, if it is done very neatly. Your work should be thorough and competently written. Bullet points may be used to delineate a list of observations. Clear communication and thorough analysis is necessary for full credit.
Vocabulary Crosswords
On the following pages is a crossword puzzle that I created with Eclipse Crossword (www.eclipsecrossword.com).
147
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
1
2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 16 17 18 19 14 15
20 21
22 23 24
25 26
27
28
29
EclipseCrossword.com
148
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Across
1. REPRESENTATIVEIf the sample looks like the population, then it is 3. RANDOMLYWe assign the treatments to the subjects . . 5. STRATIFIEDWhen I divide the population into homogenous groups and choose randomly from each, this is a random sample. 8. BLOCKSWe divide subjects into groups that will respond similiarly to the treatments called 10. COMPAREAt the end of the experiment, we 14. SAMPLEThe small group from which we get data 19. PLACEBOA sugar pill 20. VOLUNTARY RESPONSEWhen those surveyed get to choose if they want to respond 21. BIASTo systematically favor certain outcomes 22. CONTROLThe group that does the status quo for purposes of comparison is the 24. STATISTICA value that I get from my sample/data 25. CONFOUNDINGWhen two variables are intertwined so I cannot determine their effects, they are variables. 26. SUBJECTSWe assign treatments to the . bias. (Interviewers 27. RESPONSEAnything that biases the responses of those surveyed is a appearance, wording . . .) group. the treatment groups. 12. NONRESPONSEBias created because some people refuse to participate in the survey .
29. STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANTIf the difference between two statistics is more than chance variation would explain, the difference is . . .
Down
2. PARAMETERThe value of the population I am trying to estimate 4. CENSUSI try to survey the entire population. 6. FACTORThe variable the experimenter controls is the . sample. . 7. SAMPLING VARIABILITYThe natural variability that occurs from sample to sample 9. SYSTEMATICI survey every 10th person who walks by. This is a 11. MATCHED PAIRSAn experimental design where every subject does both treatments. 13. RANDOMWe know all the values, but cannot predict what will happen next. This is 15. MULTISTAGEA combination of various sampling methods is a sample. 16. POPULATIONThe entire group of individuals we want to learn about 17. UNDERCOVERAGEBias created because there are people whom I never survey 18. TREATMENTIn an experiment, we apply a . sample. 21. BLINDINGKeeping someone unaware of what treatment they are using and/or administering 23. CLUSTERWhen I sample by surveying entire, convenient, heterogeneous groups, it is a 28. SRSI randomly choose from the population to take my survey.
149
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
1
REPRESENTATI A
3
2
VE
R R ANDOML Y M E
4 5 6
C ED N S U
13 10 7
STRATI
9
FI A C T R
8
S M
T R
15 11
BLOCKS Y T E M A I C
C OMP AR E P I N G V A R I A B L I ECTS Y
21
12
M A T H E D P A I R S
NONRESPONSE
16
P O P L A T I N
17
R A N D M
14
S AMP L E
18
M U T I
U N D R C O V E R A
T R A T M E N
19
PLACEBO
20
VOLUNTARYRESPONSE
BI L I N D
AS T A G E
22
CONTROL
23
C L U
24
STATI
STI N G
C
25
CONFOUNDI
NG E
26
SUBJ T E
27
RESPONSE
29
28
R STATI STI CALLYSI GNI FI CANT
EclipseCrossword.com
150
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sample Syllabus 7
Jeane Swaynos Seminole High School Sanford, Florida
School Profile
Location and Environment: Seminole High School, a suburban school rich in tradition, is located in central Florida, about 60 miles north of Walt Disney World. Sanford is a long-established community that prides itself on its history and family values. This 100-year-old school is the oldest of the eight county high schools, and a large percentage of the faculty are also Seminole High alumni. Seminole High is the only magnet high school in the county with an International Baccalaureate Program as well as an Academy of Health Careers. As a result, more than 700 students come from other areas of the county to be a part of these programs. We also have approximately 1,100 students who are below grade level and therefore in remedial reading and/or math courses. English is the second language in about 13 percent of the homes; approximately 38 percent of the student body qualifies for free or reduced-fee lunches; and our students have close to a 30 percent mobility rate. Grades: 912 Type: Public high school Total Enrollment: 3,100 Ethnic Diversity: Our student body is 23 percent African American, 17 percent Hispanic/Latino, 7 percent Asian American, and 5 percent multiracial College Record: About 30 percent of the graduates go on to college.
Personal Philosophy
I believe that every student can learn and apply some parts of the AP Statistics objectives. It is important that students see the relevance of this course in their daily lives. My primary goal is to give them the tools necessary to read critically when making decisions and to make those decisions based on sound statistics. Another significant aim of this class is to show students the wide variety of practical applications of noncalculus-based mathematics. Often students see themselves as poor mathematicians because they struggle with precalculus and calculus. Statistics shows them another branch of mathematics and opens them up to the possibility that there are many other avenues to take when furthering their mathematical k nowledge.
Class Profile
AP Statistics has been taught at Seminole High since 1999, with two or three sections offered each year, all taught by me. Each class typically has between 20 and 25 students. We operate on a seven-period day, with all classes meeting five days a week for 49 minutes, except for Wednesday, which is a shorter day with only 40 minutes per class.
151
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
AP Statistics classes are composed of a mixture of students, equally divided between two types. In the f irst group are highly motivated students who are enrolled in Pre-IB courses and take AP Statistics as an elective. Others are sophomores who are enrolled in Precalculus as well. We also have a number of seniors who have completed AP Calculus BC and are taking this subject as another elective. The second group is made up mainly of seniors, some of whom have never taken an AP course before and who have completed no math course beyond Algebra 2. Some have a weak reading level or poor study skills, and enrolling in an AP class exposes them to the work necessary to be successful in college. The Health Academy students often sign up for AP Statistics because they see a need for this subject in their field. A majority of students have part-time jobs, working on average 20 hours a week. Keeping everyone engaged in the learning process has been a challenge.
Course Overview
The AP Statistics course at Seminole High incorporates the curriculum set forth in the Topic Outline of the AP Statistics Course Description in the order presented by the textbook that I use: The Practice of Statistics (second edition) by Yates, Moore, and Starnes. There are four quarterly grading periods, each nine weeks long. The first semester runs from August through January, and the second, from February through June. All AP Statistics students are required to take the AP Exam. This exam is funded by the state of Florida, and students taking an AP course get a weighted grade of 1.0 for the class. Students must maintain a C for the weighted grade and are required to take the end-of-year state assessment. There are computer labs on campus, but reading students and low-level classes are given first priority for these facilities. The statistics class has access to the lab about once every nine-week period. All students have a TI-83 or equivalent calculator that they use at home and in school. Students are loaned calculators for the year if they are not able to afford one. This service is free of charge and available to all students in Algebra 2 or above. One of our schools goals is to increase enrollment in AP courses. The administration is more concerned with enrollment in the classes than with the students grades on the AP Exam. The faculty and administration want to expose students to higher-level courses and therefore will accept a wide range of student abilities in AP courses. Studies show that students who take AP courses are more successful in college than those who have not had this opportunity. There are no prerequisites listed for the courses only suggested recommendations. For AP Statistics, that is completion of Algebra 2. There are, however, some advanced IB students who take Algebra 2 concurrently with AP Statistics, and if they work hard, they are successful. My specific objectives for this course are that the students acquire the following skills:
152
They know the basic concepts presented in the Course Description. When explaining statistical concepts, they understand the importance of using clearly defined terms that show an intuitive understanding of these concepts. They are able to apply statistical concepts when collecting information and make informed decisions using statistics accurately. They develop an appreciation for the depth of understanding that statistics add to real-life situations and understand how statistics could be used to help visualize and add mathematical facts to subjective situations.
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Course Planner
The following abbreviations and short titles are used to indicate source material: ABS = Activity-Based Statistics (Scheaffer et al.); APS = AP Statistics (Bohan); DTD = Statistics: Decisions Through Data video (COMAP); FF = Fifty Fathoms (Erickson); FRQ = AP Exam free-response question from past exams (AP Central and the printed Released Exams); ISDA = Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis (Peck et al.); PS (the main textbook) = The Practice of Statistics, 2nd ed. (Yates et al.); SFE = Statistics for Experimenters (Box et al.); SMW = Stats: Modeling the World (Bock et al.); and VS = Visual Statistics (Doane et al.). See the Teacher Resources section in this syllabus for full citations. Practice free-response questions are usually graded very generously, and students are allowed to work on them in groups. The questions that are not designated practice are done individually and graded more stringently.
Quarter 1 (PS Chapters 14)
Day Topic 1 Broad definition of statistics Grading system, structure of the class, and syllabus What to look for when reading an article that uses statistics Activities and Resources Review class syllabus. Hand out books. Homework PS, read sec. 1.1 and complete the first part of the guided notes. Project: Find an article involving statistics, and write a short summary. Due the day before test 1. Complete the data sheet. (This asks students to provide general information about their schedules, themselves, and their families for survey purposes.) PS, chap. 1, problem nos. 48
2
Resources DTD, unit 1: What Is Statistics? ISDA, Published Data, pp. 86 and 136 SMW, read pp. 24 Graphical displays of various Sec. 1.1: Displaying distributions Distributions with Graphs Define the various shapes of Stem-and-leaf plots graphs. Define categorical and quantitative variables. Describe the center, shape, and spread of a distribution. Stem-and-leaf plots. Resources DTD, unit 2: Stem-and-Leaf Plots FF, demo 2: Mean and Median, p. 24 SMW, p. 52, nos. 15, 16; p. 54, no. 30 SMW, read pp. 3639 ISDA, p. 64, no. 3.20
153
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic 3 Distribution of univariate data (center, shape, spread) Skewed distributions Time plots
Activities and Resources Activity Using the data collected, construct class histograms using Post-It® notes. Resources VS, chap. 3: Shapes of Distributions SMW, read pp. 1617 ISDA, p. 83, no. 3.38 Work in groups on making cumulative distributions. PS, nos. 2023: begin in class. Resources DTD, unit 4: Measures of the Center Activity Make a human boxplot using birthdays. Take pictures of the five-number summary students.
Homework PS, chap. 1, nos. 9, 10, 1214, 16, 18, 19
4
Tools to create a histogram and a cumulative histogram Statistical language to describe a distribution
PS, chap. 1, nos. 15, 1723 SMW, p. 33, no. 26
5
Boxplots Five-number summary and data sets Side-by-side boxplots
PS, read sec. 1.2 with guided notes; chap. 1, nos. 2427. SMW, pp. 7678, nos. 20, 28; p. 82, nos. 43, 44
6
Mean and median of a distribution Technology to create distributions IQR and rules for justifying an outlier
Resources ABS, Matching Graphs to Variables, p. 12 DTD, unit 5: Boxplots SMW, read pp. 6162 and 6869 Define IQR median and mean PS, chap. 1, nos. 2932, 3436 of a distribution using student-generated data. Find SMW, p. 107, no. 11 the IQR and determine if there are outliers. Activity On the board have student groups display and describe the data collected from day 2 homework. Resources VS, chap. 1, p. 19
154
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic 7 Split stemplot Effects of changing units on summary measures
Activities and Resources Board problems Review any technology problems when making histograms and boxplots.
Homework PS, chap. 1, nos. 4143 Practice FRQs, 2001 nos. 1 and 6A
8
Resources FRQ, 2001 no. 1 VS, chap. 3, p. 55; chap. 4, p. 74 Various ways of describing Review guided notes for chap. 1. PS, chap. 1, nos. 4951 data: advantages and Using five simple data entries, disadvantages f ind the standard deviation, Practice FRQs, 2004 no. 1, working through each part of 2002 no. 1 Finding the standard deviation without technology the formula Resources SMW, read pp. 8384 ABS, Capture/Recapture, pp. 126-29 Technology to find the mean Students work with partners to and standard deviation f ind the mean and standard deviation of class-generated data. Resources FF, demo 4: Transforming the Mean and Standard Deviation, p. 28 WS, activities 4.12 and 4.13, p. 66; 6.8, p. 98 TEST 1 (chap. 1) Density curves in relation to a histogram
9
PS, chap. 1, nos. 5355, 58 Articles are due. FRQ, 1997 no. 1
10 11
12 13
Normal density curve 68-95-99.7 rule Standardized normal distribution Finding the z-score for normal distributions
Review of test 1 Sec. 2.1: Density Curves and the Normal Distribution Practice FRQs, 2005B no. 1, 2006B no. 1 PS, outside activity 2A: Finegrained Distribution Board problems to determine if PS, read sec. 2.2; chap. 2, data are normal nos. 1214, 18 Sec. 2.2: Standard Normal Calculations Resources DTD, unit 7: Normal Curve ISDA, p. 134, no. 4.40 PS, chap. 2, nos. 1924
PS, read sec. 2.1; chap. 2, nos. 14 PS, chap. 2, nos. 69
155
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic 14 Finding the area given the z-score Finding the z-score given the area
Activities and Resources Homework Use the chart to find the area PS, chap. 2, nos. 2629 when given the z-score. Use the chart to find the z-score FRQ, 2002 no. 3A when given the area. Resources DTD, unit 8: Normal Calculations Board problems: finding z-score PS, chap. 2, nos. 3133, 35, and area 38, 39 Assessing normality FRQ, 2003 nos. 3A and 3B Resources FF, demo 3: What Do Normal Data Look Like? SMW, read p. 97 Review guided notes for chap. 2. PS, chap. 2, nos. 40, 41, 4648 Use calculator to find the z-score and area and to create FRQ, 1999 no. 4 a normality plot. Review chap. 1 with ABS Read Is It Normal? activity. Resources Flanagan-Hyde, Is It Normal? (AP Central) TEST 2 (chaps. 1 and 2)
15
Normality plots
16
17
Technology to create a normality plot Technology to find the z-score and/or area Methods for assessing normality
18 19 Scatterplots: definition, interpretation, and analysis of patterns
Review of test 2 Sec. 3.1: Scatterplots Response and explanatory variables Activity Plant project (see the Student Activities section of this syllabus ) Resources DTD, unit 11: Scatterplots SMW, read pp. 116-17
PS, read sec. 3.1; chap. 3, nos. 14, 6 PS, chap. 3, nos. 9, 10, 12
156
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic 20 Linear regression (plant project) Bivariate data: finding the correlation and linearity of the relation
Activities and Resources Activity Work in groups to organize the plants and complete the project. Write reports following a rubric.
Homework PS, chap. 3, nos. 1518
21
Least-squares regression line using a graphing calculator Correlation and coefficient of determination using a graphing calculator Residual of a data point r2 and the correlation coefficient in relation to the LSRL
22
Resources SMW, read pp. 127-29 Resources PS, chap. 3, nos. 2123, 25, 28, 29, 32 FF, demo 6: Least Squares Linear Regression, p. 34 FF, demo 8: Devising the Correlation Coefficient, p. 38 VS, chap. 18: Visualizing Regression Models, p. 353 Define r2 and read a computer PS, chap. 3, nos. 3437; read printout. sec. 3.3 Resources DTD, unit 13: Correlation ISDA, read p. 157 Activity As a group, work through f inding the SSM and SSE of four data points. Calculate r2. Review guided notes. Board problems Resources SMW, read Butterfly Ballot, pp. 167-68 Board problems Resources ISDA, Correlation, p. 175, nos. 5.30, 5.31; p. 189, nos. 5.42, 5.43 SMW, read pp. 147-52 SMW, p. 133, nos. 11, 12; p. 135, no. 23 PS, chap. 3, nos. 3841
23
Finding the SSM and SSE when looking at a linear regression Influential points and outliers in relation to the LSRL
24
PS, chap. 3, nos. 42, 43, 45 FRQs, 1998 nos. 2 and 4
25
Residual plots using the graphing calculator Slope, correlation, and coefficient of determination using correct statistical language
PS, chap. 3, nos. 4648, 5052
157
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic Activities and Resources 26 Linear regression concepts Board problems applied to problems for Answer questions about the which students have plant project. generated their own data Reading a computer printout Resources SMW, read pp. 152-53 VS, chap. 15, p. 287 27 Review for test 3 Problem no. 65 in class Work in groups at the board to complete review problems. 28 TEST 3 (chaps. 1, 2, and 3) 29 Exponential and power Sec. 4.1: Transforming functions in relation to Relationships statistics Review log properties. Importance of linear relationship in statistics 30 Transformations of Sec. 4.2: Cautions About exponential functions Correlations and Regressions Transformations in relation Making transformations of to the residual plot exponential functions Resources DTD, unit 16: Questions of Causation ISDA, p. 206, no. 5.52; p. 210, no. 5.61 ABS, Matching Graph to Scatterplot, pp. 5055 Making transformations of power functions
Homework PS, chap. 3, nos. 57, 60, 61 Practice FRQs 1999 no. 1, 2000 no. 1
PS, chap. 3, nos. 62, 64, 68, 73 FRQ, 2005 no. 3 PS, read sec. 4.1 PS, chap. 4, nos. 1416, 25
PS, chap. 4, nos. 3337
31
Transformations of power functions and their relation to residual plots Using the graphing calculator to make and interpret residual plots Confounding and lurking variables Distribution tables and conditional probabilities Marginal distributions
Complete the plant project. FRQs, 1997 no. 6, 2005B nos. 5A and 5B PS, chap. 4, nos. 38, 39, 4143
32
33
Residual plots Making residual plots using the calculator Sec. 4.3: Relations to Categorical PS, chap. 4, nos. 5054 Data Confounding variables Lurking variables
158
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic 34 Using distribution tables to determine conditional probabilities Simpsons Paradox 35 36 Review: describing data with graphs and numerical values 37 38 39 Review: bivariate data
Activities and Resources Conditional distribution Simpsons Paradox TEST 4 (chaps. 3 and 4) Review for nine-week exam. Homework test (30 minutes) Review chaps. 3 and 4. Review NINE-WEEK EXAM
Homework PS, chap. 4, nos. 5962
FRQ, 2004B no. 1
Quarter 2 (PS Chapters 58)
Day Topic 1 Parts of a survey Population of interest Retrospective and prospective studies Activities and Resources Sec. 5.1: Designing Samples Homework PS, read sec. 5.1; chap. 5, problem nos. 16, 10, 11, 13, 15, 16
Activity Explain the survey project. With a partner, students design two Complete the survey project. ways to ask the same question to gather information about a SMW, p. 13, nos. 114 particular topic. Resources DTD, unit 18: Survey DTD, unit 15: Designing Experiments SMW, read pp. 68, 246-55, and 263, nos. 15 ABS, Random Rectangles, pp. 99102 Describe the various types of sampling techniques. Resources SFE, Random Sampling, pp. 28, 64; Experimental Error, p. 24 SMW, read pp. 229-34 ISDA, p. 27, no. 2.17; p. 55, no. 2.23
2
Sampling techniques
PS, chap. 5, nos. 2123, 25, 28
159
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic 3 Random digit table for choosing subjects in an experimental design
Activities and Resources Explain how to use the random digit table to choose sample. Scheme, stopping rule, repeat digits Activity PS, class problem no. 21 Principles of experimental design Plant experiment revisited
Homework PS, read sec. 5.2 FRQ, 1999 no. 6
4
Three principles of experimental design
PS, chap. 5, nos. 3133
5
6
Resources ISDA, read pp. 29; 37, no. 32 Randomization in relation to Randomization and why it is PS, chap. 5, nos. 3436 statistical inference important Biased samples Resources SMW, p. 243, nos. 46, 12, 13 Diagrams to explain Principles of experimental PS, chap. 5, nos. 3739, 41, 42 experimental design design Randomization of treatment Drawing an experimental design R AT (random allocation of Confounding variables treatment) Blocking Confounded variables Resources SFE, Blocking, pp. 102-5 SMW, p. 244, nos. 15, 16 ISDA, p. 36, no. 28 Activity Writing the alphabet backward with/without practice
7
Block design and matched pair design
PS, chap. 5, nos. 4346, 50, 51, 53; read sec. 5.3
8
Using a graphing calculator to simulate experiments when the digits are repeated
Resources SMW, p. 263, nos. 3, 5 Sec. 5.3: Simulating Experiments PS, chap. 5, nos. 56, 58 Chance behavior FRQs, 1997 no. 2, 1998 no. 3 Assigning digits Activity Problem no. 70 (birthday)
160
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic 9 Experimental design and the plant project 10 Comparison of the plant projectsthe first one after chapter 3 and this one after chapter 5
11 12
Law of large numbers Random phenomena as they apply to probability
Activities and Resources Homework Discuss the plant project and the PS, chap. 5, nos. 6163, 69, 70 guidelines for the report. FRQ, 2000 no. 5 Allow students time to work in PS, chap. 5, nos. 7476, 79 groups to complete the project and summarize their data. FRQs, 2001 no. 4, 2003 no. 4, Answer questions and discuss 2006 no. 5 the concepts of lurking and confounded variables. TEST 1 (chap. 5) PS, read sec. 6.1 Sec. 6.1: The Idea of Probability PS, read secs. 6.1 and 6.2; chap. 6, nos. 4, 11 Activity Class applies the law of large numbers. Resources ABS, The Law of Averages, p. 68 Sec. 6.2: Probability Models Tree diagrams Sample space Venn diagrams Complements of events Activity ABS, Streaky Behavior: Runs in Binomial Trials, p. 65 Resources Problem 6.3, p. 334: class activity Computer lab activity with Venn PS, chap. 6, nos. 1921, 23, diagrams 2426 Basic probability simulations Independence and the PS, chap. 6, nos. 2729, 31, multiplication rule 3235 FRQ, 1997 no. 3
13
Methods to display sample space Determining the probabilities of each event Multiplication principle Disjointed events
PS, chap. 6, nos. 11, 14, 15, 17, 18 FRQ, 1997 no. 3
14
Web sites related to probability Independent events in relation to disjointed events
15
161
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic 16 Applying probability concepts to application problems Rule for justifying independence of events 17 Conditional probability How to prove events are independent
Activities and Resources Homework Sec. 6.3: General Probability PS, chap. 6, nos. 3740, 43, 46, Rules 47; read sec. 6.3 General addition rule for disjointed and nondisjointed FRQs, 1999 no. 5, 2006 no. 3B events Rule for independence Conditional probability and how PS, chap. 6, nos. 4850, 52, 53, this applies to independence 56, 57 Resources FRQs, 2002B no. 2, 2003B no. 2 ISDA, p. 259, no. 6.31 Review guided notes for chap. 6. PS, chap. 6, nos. 5864 Activity Problem no. 87 in class Resources ABS, Randomized Response Sampling: How to Ask Sensitive Questions, pp. 131-33 Resources ISDA, p. 268, nos. 6.41, 6.42, 6.44 Review for test 2. Board problems Resources ISDA, p. 269, no. 6.47; p. 297, no. 6.91 TEST 2 (chaps. 5 and 6) Sec. 7.1: Random Variables Define discrete and continuous random variables. Resources SMW, Law of Large Numbers, pp. 275-77 PS, chap. 6, nos. 6770, 71, 73
18 19
Applying the rules of probability to all types of problems Gathering data on sensitive issues
20
Review for test 2
PS, chap. 6, nos. 7477
21
Review for test 2
PS, chap. 6, nos. 7880, 83, 86
22 23
Random variables Applying probability to random events
PS, chap. 7, nos. 25
162
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic 24 Normal distribution in relation to a histogram Applying a probability distribution to a histogram
Activities and Resources Homework Activity PS, chap. 7, nos. 6, 7, 10, 11 Using dice, create a probability distribution table, and convert this to a histogram. Show how a discrete random variable can approximate a normal distribution.
25
Resources ISDA, p. 315, nos. 1214, 19 Types of density curves Sec. 7.2: Mean and Variance of Random Variables Density curve for continuous random variables in relation Law of large and small numbers to a probability distribution Activity The king of large numbers The imaginary queen of small numbers Resources SMW, read pp. 276-77 Rules for combining two sets Sec. 7.2: Combining Normal of data Random Variables Rules for means and standard Applying the rule for mean and variance when adding deviation when combining or subtracting means or random variables standard deviations
xy xy 2 2 2 xy xy a bx x x 2 2 x y y 2 2 x y y
PS, chap. 7, nos. 14, 1618, 20
26
PS, chap. 7, nos. 2426, 29 ISDA, p. 321, no. 7.26 FRQ, 2001 no. 2
b
x 22
27
Applying the probability distribution and histogram when creating dice
Resources FF, demo 22: How Errors Add, p. 83 SMW, read pp. 313-15; p. 322, nos. 2428 Activity PS, chap. 7, nos. 3439, 41 Dice activity (review for chap. 7): students create their own set of dice and generate a probability distribution along with a histogram.
163
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic Activities and Resources 28 Applying the rules for adding Homework test and subtracting means and Problem no. 47 in class variance to two independent distributions Assumptions for combining two normal variables 29 Review for test 3 Test review questions on the board
Homework PS, chap. 7, nos. 42, 4446, 48 FRQs, 2002 no. 3, 2001 no. 2
PS, chap. 7, nos. 5457, 60, 61, 67 FRQs, 2005B no. 2, 2006 no. 3A PS, read sec. 8.1 PS, chap. 8, nos. 310, 11, 13
30 31
32
33
TEST 3 (chaps. 6 and 7) Binomial distribution Sec. 8.1: Binomial Distributions Properties of a binomial distribution Parts of a binomial B(n, p) and formula for a distribution binomial distribution Problem no. 36: show students Conditions for a binomial how to read the Minitab printout. Mean and standard deviation Mean = np of a binomial distribution Standard deviation Normal approximation to np > 10 and n(1-p) > 10 binomial distributions
PS, chap. 8, nos. 19, 20, 26, 27
PS, chap. 8, nos. 2830, 33, 34
34
Using the graphing calculator to evaluate binomial distributions
35
Geometric distribution Conditions for a geometric
Resources FF, demo 13: Building the Binomial Distribution, p. 56 FF, demo 14: More Binomial, p. 59 Use working: PS, read sec. 8.2 at least, at most, the majority of binomialpdf (n, p, k) binomials (n, p, k) 1-binomialcdf (n, p, k) Sec. 8.2: Geometric Distribution PS, chap. 8, nos. 3739 P(x = k) = (1-p) (k-1)p Resources ABS, Waiting for Reggie, p. 79 FF, demo 47: Wait Time and the Geometric Distribution
164
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic Activities and Resources Homework 36 Mean for a geometric Complete guided notes for PS, chap. 8, nos. 4447, 50, 54 probability chap. 8. Find mean of geometric 1/p. FRQ, 2001 no. 3 Using the calculator to find the probability of a geometric probability 37 Review chaps. 18 Semester exam review: work on PS, chap. 8, nos. 5557, 59, 60 questions from chaps. 7 and 8. FRQ, 1998 nos. 6B, C, D, E 38 TEST 4 (chaps. 7 and 8) Semester review 39 Exam review: chaps. 5 and 6 NINE-WEEK EXAM Semester review 40 Exam review: chaps. 7 and 8 41 SEMESTER EXAM
Quarter 3 (PS Chapters 912)
Day Topic Activities and Resources 1 Sampling distributions and Sec. 9.1: Sampling Distributions sample size Mean and standard deviation Activity of a sampling distribution Students create a sampling distribution of size 2 from a population of 3. Homework FRQ, 1998 no. 1
2
Sampling distributions that involve proportions Rules for sampling distributions involving proportions
3
Resources DTD, unit 19: Sampling Distributions Complete problem no. 7 in class. PS, read sec. 9.2; also chap. 9, nos. 1217 Display the sampling distribution. Sec. 9.2: Sampling Proportions PS, chap. 9, nos. 2530 Resources FF, demo 23: Sampling Distributions and Sample Size, p. 85 FF, demo 30: Where Does That Root p (1-p) Come From? Review sec. 9.2. PS, chap. 9, nos. 3234, 3941 Sec. 9.3: Sample Mean, Sampling Error ISDA, p. 410, no. 8.9
4
Sampling distributions for problems involving means Variability of a sampling distribution (decreases as the sample size increases) Activity Central limit theorem party (see the Student Activities section)
165
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic 5 Central limit theorem Compare the CLT to the law of large numbers
Activities and Resources Central limit theorem Do problem no. 44 in class. Resources VS, The Central Limit Theorem, p. 127 Review for test 2. Board problems
Homework PS, chap. 9, nos. 43, 4549; complete guided notes for chap. 9
6
Applying sampling distributions to proportion and mean problems
PS, chap. 9, nos. 5053 FRQs, 2004B no. 3C and 3D; 2006B no. 3B
7 8
Inference as a process for drawing conclusions from data Confidence intervals
Activity Computer lab TEST 1 (chaps. 8 and 9) PS, read sec. 10.1 Sec. 10.1: Introduction to PS, chap. 10, nos. 1, 24 Inference and Estimating with Confidence CI = X z* n
9
Applying the confidence formula to an application problem
Resources DTD, unit 20: Confidence Intervals ABS, Confidence Intervals, p. 120 Activity Given a situation, have each student find his or her own confidence interval and display this on the overhead (PS, p. 541). Resources ABS, How Many Tanks?, pp. 148-50 FF, demo 32: How the Width of a Confidence Interval Depends on N, p. 110 Sample size conditions and assumptions MOE z* n Finding the z* Calculator steps Resources FF, demo 29: Capturing with Confidence Intervals
PS, chap. 10, nos. 57, 9, 10
10
Using the graphing calculator to find the appropriate confidence interval Margin of error for a given confidence interval Assumptions and conditions necessary for finding a confidence interval
PS, chap. 10, nos. 12, 13, 1720 ISDA, p. 467, no. 9.33; p. 453, no. 9.14; p. 454, no. 9.25
166
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic 11 Tests of significance Null and alternative hypothesis
Activities and Resources Sec. 10.2: Test of Significance Ho Ha level Resources DTD, unit 21: Test of Significance Outline of a test One-sided tests, two-sided tests P-value and statistical significance Calculator steps
Homework PS, chap. 10, nos. 2124; read sec. 10.2
12 13
Apply the basic part for f inding a test of significance
PS, chap. 10, nos. 27, 2932 PS, chap. 10, nos. 35, 36, 38, 39
14
15 16
17
18
How the conclusion is used in a test of significance Using the graphing calculator to find the P-value in a test of significance Conclusions for confidence Confidence intervals and twointervals and two-sided tests sided tests Conclusions Using the level of Sec. 10.3: Making Sense of significance to reject the null Statistical Significance Review calculator steps for Calculator steps inference test and confidence Homework test intervals for one- and twosided tests Type I and Type II errors Sec. 10.4: Inference as a Decision Type I and Type II errors Probability of Type I and Type II errors Activity VS, Visualizing Power, p. 209 Type I and Type II errors ISDA, p. 487, nos. 10.13, 10.14 Power of the test in Power of the test increase and relation to sample size and decrease significance level Sensitivity of the test
PS, chap. 10, nos. 4346; read sec. 10.3 PS, chap. 10, nos. 47, 5155 PS, chap. 10, nos. 58, 62, 64
PS, chap. 10, nos. 67, 68, 7981
PS, chap. 10, nos. 82, 8688
19 20
t distributions and tests of significance Assumptions and conditions necessary for a t distribution
Resources FF, demo 44: Power, p. 144 TEST 2 (chaps. 9 and 10) PS, read sec. 11.1 Sec. 11.1: Inference for the Mean PS, chap. 11, nos. 24, 79 of a Population t distributions Degrees of freedom Problem no. 5 in class Resources VS, chap. 9, p. 165
167
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic 21 Applying the one-sample t test to a matched pair design
Activities and Resources Matched pair t procedure Resources FF, demo 38: Using a t Test to Compare Means, p. 129 Power of a t test
Homework PS, chap. 11, nos. 10, 13, 15
22
Finding the power of the test using the two-sample t test
PS, chap. 11, nos. 1719
23
24
25
26 27 28
Resources FF, demo 44: Power, p. 144 Applying a test of Sec. 11.2: Comparing Two significance when comparing Means two means Conditions and assumptions Assumptions and conditions Conclusions necessary for comparing two Calculator steps means Using the graphing Resources calculator to find the P-value VS, chap. 10, p. 187 for a test of significance when comparing two means ISDA, p. 575, no. 11.55 Reading a computer printout Reading computer printouts for a two-sample t test Pooled and unpooled procedures Pooled and unpooled data Resources ISDA, p. 584, nos. 64, 65 Applying the principles One- and two-sample of a two-sample t test and procedures for test or matched pair t test using confidence intervals self-generated data Activity Hula-Hoop® activity for comparing two means Applying a t test with selfComplete Hula-Hoop activity generated data and review rubric. TEST 3 (chaps. 10 and 11) Using statistical inference Chap. 12: Inference for with categorical data Proportions Sec. 12.1: Inference for a Standard error of a proportion Population Proportion Assumptions and conditions Conditions and assumptions for a test of proportion p(1 p) n
PS, chap. 11, nos. 20, 21, 27, 29; read sec. 11.2 FRQs, 2004 no. 6, 2002 no. 5
PS, chap. 11, nos. 40, 41, 43, 47, 49 FRQs, 1997 no. 5, 2006 no. 4, 2005 no. 6 PS, chap. 11, nos. 5355, 59, 67
PS, read sec. 12.1 PS, chap. 12, nos. 4, 5, 7, 8 FRQs, 1997 no. 4, 1998 no. 5
168
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic Activities and Resources 29 Sample size and margin of Sample size and margin of error error for a proportion test Calculator steps Using the graphing calculator for a proportion test 30 Comparing two proportions Sec. 12.2: Comparing Two when doing a confidence Proportions interval Parts of the test and confidence interval Standard error for a twosample proportion 1 1 pc (1 pc ) n1 n2 Pooled and unpooled Standard error 31 Using the calculator for one- Calculator steps and two-proportion tests and for confidence intervals 32 Review chaps. 11 and 12 Review for test 4 33 TEST 4 (chaps. 11 and 12) 34 Review chaps. 912 FRQs, 1999 no. 2, 2002 no. 6 35 Review chaps. 912 FRQ, 2004 no. 5A 36 NINE-WEEK EXAM
Homework PS, chap. 12, nos. 10, 12, 15, 16; read sec. 12.2 FRQ, 2006B no. 4 PS, chap. 12, nos. 29, 30, 33, 34 FRQs, 2004B nos. 3 and 6A
PS, chap. 12, nos. 35, 3739
PS, read sec. 13.1 FRQs, 2005B nos. 4 and 6A
Quarter 4 (PS Chapters 1314, Review, and Final Project)
Day Topic 1 Chi-square test for goodness of fit and when it is appropriate Activities and Resources Homework Sec. 13.1: Test for Goodness of Fit PS, chap. 13, nos. 4, 5, 7 Activity M&Ms activity Part of the chi-square test Assumptions and conditions for chi-square test Expected counts Observed counts FRQs, 2003 nos. 2 and 6; review problems PS, chap. 13, nos. 10, 11, 13
2
Assumptions and conditions necessary for a chi-square test Determining the expected counts and the chi-square value
3
Appling the chi-square test for independence and test for homogeneity
Resources VS, chap. 13: Goodness of Fit, p. 249 Sec. 13.2: Inference for Two-Way PS, chap. 13, nos. 15, 18, 21, 29 Tables Chi-square test for independence and homogeneity Conclusions for chi-square tests Resources SMW, read pp. 518-31 and p. 537, nos. 14
169
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Topic Activities and Resources 4 Reading a computer printout Assumptions and conditions for for chi-square and linear chi-square independence test regression Calculator steps Assumptions and conditions Computer printout, pp. 787, 793 for chi-square
Homework FRQ, 2003 no. 5
5 6
Resources ABS, Is Your Class Differently Aged? (chi-square test), p. 163 TEST 1 (chaps. 12 and 13) PS, read sec. 14.1; chap. 14, nos. 2, 3 Null and alternative Sec. 14.1: Inference About the PS, chap. 14, nos. 6, 11, 12 hypothesis for inference for Model, Null, and Alternative regression Standard error for the slope Standard error for the slope Residuals and standard error Reading a computer printout Degrees of freedom for a linear regression test Assumptions and conditions for a linear regression test Sec. 14.2: Predictions and Conditions PS, chap. 14, nos. 1315 FRQs, 2005B no. 5C, 2001 no. 6B, 2006 no. 2C
7
8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17
Resources SFE, Residual Checking, pp. 183-84 TEST 2 (chaps. 13 and 14) Review: multiple-choice Practice AP multiple-choice questions problems (APS) Review: multiple-choice Practice AP multiple-choice questions problems (APS) Review: multiple-choice Practice AP multiple-choice questions problems (APS) Necessary steps for inference Sec. 15.1: Inference for for the spread of a population Population Spread F test comparing two standard Applying the F test to inference deviations Reading a computer printout comparing two standard deviations Review: describing data Review for AP Exam, chaps. 14 Review: experimental design Review: probability Review: inference Review all topics Review for AP Exam, chap. 5 Review chap. 6 Review chaps. 7 and 8 Review chaps. 912
APS, model exam 1, p. 264 APS, model exam 2, p. 274 APS, model exam 3, p. 284 Practice FRQs, 2005 no. 6, 2006 no. 6
Multiple-choice questions from the AP Statistics Course Description
170
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Topic 18 19 Binary predictors in regression 20 21 22 Trimmed mean Spearman rank Hypogeometric distribution
Activities and Resources AP EXAM Resources VS, chap. 19: Binary Predictors in Regression Resources ISDA, Trimmed Mean, p. 109 Resources ISDA, Spearman Rank, p. 161 Resources FF, demo 49: Sampling Without Replacement and the Hypergeometric Distribution
Homework
Teaching Strategies
I have often found that those students who receive a grade of 2 on the AP Exam have worked the hardest and have shown the most growth. It is important to keep these students motivated to continue their education. Sometimes they will not apply to college because they do not see themselves as successful, and academic achievement is not promoted at home. This course is their first attempt and can set the stage for college and further education. Keeping these students successful and motivated is one of the most difficult tasks in teaching AP Statistics. Setting up an environment where they can ask questions and not be intimidated by the more advanced students has been a challenge. I often seat these students in the front, where I can see if their facial expressions indicate that they do not understand. The more advanced students are on the sides of the room, where I can make sure they are on task, or in the back, where sometimes I give them more challenging problems to work through individually. A motivating factor for every student is the brag wall above the blackboard in my classroom, where I post the names of all the students who have achieved a grade of 3 or higher on the AP Exam since 1999. The names of the students who have received a 5 are larger and in bold letters. This is a strong incentive for those high-level students who define success as earning a 5. The lower-level students are ecstatic to see their names posted at all. I weave a variety of activities into the class, each of which can be adjusted according to the needs of my students. They range from short activities that engage students as they enter the classroom to larger projects that are assessed at the end of the semester. For more examples, see the Student Activities section at the end of this syllabus.
Data-Gathering Activities
Most students understand abstract concepts better when they see the connection with something they have experienced. I often have students collect data about themselves or the schoolfor example, how many numbers do you and/or your parents have stored in your cell phone? What is the average tip you leave in restaurants? How many hours do you spend reading e-mail? How many students do not have parking stickers? How long do you spend waiting in line in the cafeteria? Students enjoy collecting information that relates directly to themselves, and we discuss how data are often used to make decisions or persuade people to think in a certain manner. The data are displayed in hand-drawn graphs, and students are required to explain and interpret the distributions in written assignments. This is followed by a short demonstration to the class. After drawing graphs by hand, students use the calculator to produce the same type of display.
171
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Through exploration they find the window adjustments and scales necessary to create a useful graphical representation. I find the kinesthetic learner benefits the most from these strategies, and all students start to see the usefulness of statistics from the very beginning of the year.
Exploration Activities
Students often use the calculator to explore concepts by using simulation and trial-and-error methods. For example, they are given five data points and are directed to come up with various means and standard deviations by manipulating them. An example of the trial-and-error method is shown below. Students are given a number line from 0 to 20 and are presented with the following task:
Place the dots 2, 7, 10, 13, and 18, and estimate the mean and standard deviation. Check your estimate using your calculator. Change the data in the previous item so that the mean is the same but the standard deviation is about 3. Place the five numbers so that the mean is 15 and the standard deviation is about 3. Place four numbers so that the mean is 5, and add 3 to each number. What is the effect on the mean and standard deviation? Arrange five numbers so that the standard deviation is larger than the mean.
Jeopardy! The objective is to review previously learned material and integrate it into the new concepts. We have a variety of Jeopardy!-type games, presented in PowerPoint, that we often play for a few minutes at the end of class. The questions are fairly simplegenerally fill-in-the-blank or multiple-choice problems. The problems for the game were developed by students from earlier years, and the game parallels Jeopardy! in that the questions are categorized by the chapters in the textbook or by topic. Example: What is the rule for justifying an outlier?
Physical Movement
I have created a series of physical movements that are linked to various concepts in order to help the k inesthetic learner. For example, the four conditions of a binomial distribution are each represented by a unique physical movement. When students enter the classroom, they may be asked to indicate the four conditions for a binomial distribution by using these physical movements. (Fixed number of outcomes: stand up straight; two outcomes: hold out the left and right hands; probability remains the same: turn right and left to show that both sides of ones face are the same; independence: kick with one foot to show that it is independent of the other foot.) When students come back the next year, they still remember the movements and the four conditions for binomial distributions.
Guided Notes
Guided notes are used with each chapter to help the low-level reader better understand the material presented. These notes help students to clarify the important parts of the chapter and to see what concepts they should have gathered from the reading. Examples can be found at the Mrs. Krummel Web site listed in my Teacher Resources section.
172
Acronyms and Audiovisual Aids
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Students in the past have developed their own acronyms and musical tunes to aid in the memorization of concepts, and this helps them recall some of the basic principles involved in the course. I continually emphasize the need to be able to communicate these concepts and use the memorization device to begin that process. A visual display of two rats in a box helps students recall the three principles of experimental design: random allocation of treatment (RAT); replication (indicated by two rats); and control of the process (represented by the box). I place two plastic rats in a box as the students enter the classroom. When the bell rings, they have four minutes to explain the three principles of experimental design. For homework they begin the design of a simple experiment incorporating these principles.
Computer Lab Activities
The students go to the computer lab at least once each quarter. During this structured class, they investigate various Web sites that contain applets, online demonstrations, and simulations in order to tackle some of the harder concepts. I give them a handout that lists about seven Web sites and asks specific questions that they must answer as they explore each one. This guides the students through the discovery process, keeps them on task, and gives me the opportunity to walk around and help the weaker members of the class. Some students do not have access to computers at home and need class time and technical support to work through these activities. Although each student has his or her own computer station in the lab, I assign the students in pairs based on their technical and mathematical ability.
Scoring AP Exam Responses
During the second semester, students are assigned individual AP Exam free-response questions in class and as part of some homework assignments. The following day, the class is organized in the style of an AP Reading, and each student is assigned a partner. The partners for this venture are picked carefully. A strong mathematical student but poor writer is often paired with a student who is weak in mathematics but strong in written communication. Each pair has to assess about six responses to the same problem. The scoring guidelines are explained, and they then score their assigned free-response papers and sign their names at the bottom. Each class reads a different question, and the papers are returned the next day. This activity gives students a better understanding of the level of work expected on the AP Exam. It also helps them focus on the importance of communicating their results rather than just writing down a numerical answer. The free-response questions from all prior AP Exams are kept in a set of binders for easy access at any time. Often when a class discussion arises, it turns out that a previous question has specifically addressed that concept. Having the questions readily available saves time and makes the learning process flow more easily.
Review for the AP Exam
The review process starts with a mock AP Exam about one month before the real exam. The event, running from 9 a.m. to noon on a Saturday, is hosted by one of four participating high schools and usually attracts about 300 students. We give the free-response section first, have refreshments, and follow with the multiple-choice questions. This allows us to begin scoring the free-response questions immediately. The statistics teachers finish marking the exams that afternoon, so they can be returned to the students promptly. Using the sheet from the 2002 Released Exam that shows what factor each questions score was multiplied by, students can determine if they would have gotten a grade of 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 on the mock exam. I realize that the conversion changes every year as the questions change, but it gives students an idea of how the scoring and grading work. They can then go over their work in their home schools. Students who do well on the mock test can count it as their fourth-quarter exam. Those who do poorly are allowed to count it as a 100 percent grade on one of their tests (regardless of the grade they actually received),
173
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
which is then averaged in with their other test grades. The replacement option for the fourth-quarter exam motivates the stronger students, and the extra-credit points encourage the weaker ones to take the mock exam. If they are not able to attend on Saturday, they must stay after school two days before the scheduled event to take the exam and receive the same incentives. In addition to the mock exam, we have two major review sessions with the other schools in the county. These are held on Saturday mornings. Each teacher presents one of the four major topics of the course, with students rotating around the classrooms and hearing the topics presented. For each hour that students attend, they receive three points extra credit that may be used on any test during the fourth quarter. There are also individual review sessions at each school. At Seminole High School, these take place after school from 46 p.m. or 57 p.m. Each session is worth extra-credit points if attended. We review the material using a short PowerPoint presentation, followed by a group activity that applies these concepts. Because our class periods are only 49 minutes, these two-hour blocks present a unique opportunity to further review what students should have learned in class. Refreshments are provided. Former students have said that these review sessions, presented during the two weeks before the exam, were most beneficial to them.
After the AP Exam
Over the years I have introduced a variety of projects and/or new topics after the AP Exam. In the past, our students started school on July 31, and the term ended around May 18, so there were not too many days left at the end of the year. We are now starting school on August 20 and do not end until June 10, so I will be incorporating these same ideas, but with more detail. Some of the past activities are listed below.
I have a mathematical library in my classroom. These titles are not textbooks but popular nonfiction that explores mathematics at the secondary level. The books have been collected over the years, with some purchased from retired math teachers. Students pick a book to read, write a report about it, and then design an activity from the book and present it to the class. The report must include a summary of the book and suggest how other mathematics classes could incorporate it in their curricula. This was one of the most well-received activitiesstudents enjoyed seeing mathematics presented in a new light. Here are some of the titles in this library: Title Author Robert Gilmore Ian Stewart Paul Hoffman Jerry P. King John Allen Paulos Michael Guillen Stephen Hawking Jay Kappraff Ronald W. Doerfler Philip J. Davis and Reuben Hersh Ian Stewart Roger Penrose
Alice in Quantumland Another Fine Math Youve Got Me Into . . . Archimedes Revenge The Art of Mathematics Beyond Numeracy: Ruminations of a Numbers Man Bridges to Infinity A Brief History of Time Connections: The Geometric Bridge Between Art and Science Dead Reckoning: Calculating Without Instruments Descartes Dream Does God Play Dice? The Emperors New Mind
174
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Title The Enjoyment of Mathematics Experiments in Topology Fearful Symmetry: Is God a Geometer? The Fourth Dimension From Zero to Infinity Fuzzy Logic Game, Set, and Math Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid How to Solve Problems Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and Its Consequences Islands of Truth Mathemagics: How to Look Like a Genius Without Really Trying The Mathematical Experience Mathematical Thought from Ancient to Modern Times (three volumes) The Mathematical Tourist The Mathematical Universe A Mathematician Reads the Newspaper A Mathematicians Apology Mathematics and the Search for Knowledge Mathematics for Everyman Mathematics for the Million Mathematics in Art Mathematics in Western Culture Mathematics: People, Problems, Results (two volumes) Mathematics: The Loss of Certainty Mathsemantics: Making Numbers Talk Sense Mazes for the Mind Metamagical Themas Mind Tools: The Five Levels of Mathematical Reality The Most Beautiful Mathematical Formulas The Nature and Growth of Modern Mathematics Natures Numbers: The Unreal Reality of Mathematical Imagination Number 100 Great Problems of Elementary Mathematics On the Shoulders of Giants
Author Hans Rademacher and Otto Toeplitz Stephen Barr Ian Stewart and Martin Golubitsky Rudy Rucker Constance Reid Daniel McNeill and Paul Freiberger Ian Stewart Douglas R. Hofstadter Wayne A. Wickelgren John Allen Paulos Ivars Peterson Arthur Benjamin and Michael Brant Shermer Philip J. Davis and Reuben Hersh Morris Kline Ivars Peterson William Dunham John Allen Paulos G. H. Hardy Morris Kline Laurie Buxton Lancelot Hogben Michael Holt Morris Kline Douglas M. Campbell and John C. Higgins, eds. Morris Kline Edward MacNeal Clifford A. Pickover Douglas R. Hofstadter Rudy Rucker Lionel Salem, Frédéric Testard, and Coralie Salem Edna E. Kramer Ian Stewart John McLeish Heinrich Dörrie Lynn Arthur Steen, ed.
175
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Title Paradigms Lost The Paradoxicon The Penguin Dictionary of Curious and Interesting Geometry Pi in the Sky: Counting, Thinking, and Being Practical Reasoning Prisoners Dilemma The Problems of Mathematics Readings in Mathematics, book 2 Thinking Machines The Tinkertoy Computer
Author John L. Casti Nicholas Falletta David Wells John D. Barrow Larry Wright William Poundstone Ian Stewart Irving Adler, ed. Irving Adler A. K. Dewdney
Students have designed Jeopardy!-type games (described earlier in this section) and multiple-choice questions to be used in the following year. They have also done PowerPoint presentations showing how statistics is involved in the recycling process throughout the country. This project includes making blankets for the homeless out of recycled plastic grocery bags. Although the Web site is under construction, a picture of the weaving process for these blankets can be found at http://home.cfl.rr.com/swaynos. I have explained how probability is involved in gambling, such as card games that are played on the Internet. I have discussed different types of mortgages and how interest is determined using credit cards. The class has done exploratory activities using the financial applications on the TI-83. I have continued teaching analysis of variance.
Student Evaluation
Students receive one grade for each semester. Each nine-week quarterly grade is worth 40 percent, and the semester exam counts for 20 percent. The students quarterly grades are determined as follows: Tests Homework Participation and quizzes Nine-week exam 45 percent 20 percent 20 percent 15 percent
The schools grading scale is standard: A = 90100 percent B = 8089 percent C = 7079 percent D = 6069 percent F = Below 60 percent
176
Tests
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Approximately five tests are given during each nine-week period. They generally are spiral tests, which means that they include previously learned concepts. One of them is a take-home test, on which students may work together. Another is taken directly from the homework problems, which encourages students to complete the homework and learn the concepts. These two assessments help weaker students to succeed in the class. For the other three tests, I put a review sheet online a few days before the test, and students can see me before or after school to ask questions about it. I collect these sheets at the start of the test, and if the work has been done satisfactorily, the student may earn up to an additional 10 points on the test. Students who understand the review sheet are likely to do well on the free-response questions on the test itself. All the exams are half multiple-choice and half free-response questions and are designed to occupy a 45-minute class period. Students may use calculators and formula sheets at all times.
Homework
Homework takes approximately 3045 minutes a night. It is collected daily and graded on completeness. The classroom is open every morning at 6:15 so that students can work together to finish their homework. I am available to tutor and administer makeup tests and quizzes at that time. Students may also make appointments after school if they are behind in class or need more individual instruction. At the start of class I put a problem on the overhead and walk around to assess the students homework. If they made an attempt at every problem, then they generally get full credit for the homework. No late work is accepted, and if students are sick, they have one day to make up the work for each day of absence.
Participation
Students go to the board and complete problems at least twice a week, receiving a participation grade for this work. They have indicated that this is the most successful way of learning to solve problems, and they enjoy this part of the class. I pair weak and strong students. The less-able students then see that the stronger ones often do not fully understand the concept either, and this can make them less inhibited about asking questions. If you do not have enough board space, try small 2 by 3 foot whiteboards that the students can use at their seats. I can quickly grade the board work, especially the communication part of the problem. Students listen as I grade their classmates problems and make changes before I get to their work. Sometimes the more advanced students have poor communication skills but understand the mathematics. The weaker students may know all the details but often miss important mathematical procedures. Together they often make a good team and learn from each other. Students who are absent must take a makeup quiz the next morning to replace this participation grade. Attendance has occasionally been a problem in the past, and this practice has effectively reduced unexcused absences. Students are sometimes given three or four multiple-choice questions at the start of class and may work together on the answers as a participation grade. The questions come from the previous nights reading homework. They are posted at the start of class, and students have only a few minutes to work on the problems. This encourages them to get to class on time and begin working immediately. It also gives them more practice with multiple-choice questions.
177
Chapter 3 Chapter 1 Nine-Week Exam
This is given during one 49-minute class period at the end of each nine weeks. It is 75 percent multiplechoice and 25 percent free-response questions.
Teacher Resources
Primary Text
Yates, Daniel S., David S. Moore, and George S. McCabe. The Practice of Statistics: TI-83 Graphing Calculator Enhanced. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003.
Supplementary Books
Bock, David E., Paul F. Velleman, and Richard D. De Veaux. Stats: Modeling the World. Boston: Pearson/ Addison-Wesley, 2004. Bohan, James. AP Statistics: Preparing for the Advanced Placement Examination. New York: AMSCO, 2000. Box, George E., William G. Hunter, and J. Stuart Hunter. Statistics for Experimenters: An Introduction to Design, Data Analysis, and Model Building. New York: Wiley, 1978. College Board. 1997 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 1997. College Board. 2002 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 2002. (Note: The 2007 Released Exam has become available since this syllabus was submitted.) Doane, David P., Kieran Mathieson, and Ronald L. Tracy. Visual Statistics 2.0. Boston: McGraw-Hill/Irwin, 2001. Erickson, Tim. Fifty Fathoms: Statistics Demonstrations for Deeper Understanding. Oakland, Calif.: EEPS Media, 2002. Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. Pacific Grove, Calif.: Brooks/Cole, 2001. Scheaffer, Richard L., Mrudulla Gnanadesikan, Ann Watkins, and Jeffrey A. Witmer. Activity-Based Statistics: Instructor Resources. New York: Springer, 1996.
Technology
Fathom Dynamic Data Software. Version 2. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press. This is used as a teaching demonstration, and once every nine weeks the students have computer access. Texas Instruments. TI-83 Plus/TI-84 graphing calculators. http://education.ti.com/educationportal/sites/US/homePage/index.html.
Video
Statistics: Decisions Through Data. Written by David S. Moore. Lexington, Mass.: Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications (COMAP), 1992. Five videocassettes with users guide (total of 21 video segments).
178
Web Sites (General)
Course Organization About AP Statistics
The following represent the main Web resources used in the course. Some offer online demonstrations using Java applets that help to illustrate many of the key statistical concepts taught. AP Central. AP Statistics Course Home Page. apcentral.collegeboard.com/stats. An essential resource for all AP teachers. From here you can navigate to the free-response questions from previous AP exams. Coons, Al. BB&N AP Statistics. w ww.bbn-school.org/us/math/ap_stats. Teachers site with tests, notes, and links to other sites. Derksen, Jared. The AP Stats Top 10 FAQs. w ww.mrderksen.com/top10.htm. Fr. Chris AP Statistics. w ww.fortunecity.com/campus/anlaby/36. Teacher site with many resources. Intuitor.com. Amazing Applications of Probability and Statistics. http://intuitor.com/statistics/index.html. Lock, Robin H., Mathematics Department, St. Lawrence University. A Sampler of WWW Resources for Teaching Statistics. http://it.stlawu.edu/~rlock/maa51/www.html. Math Forum@Drexel. AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group Archives. http://mathforum.org/kb/forum.jspa?forumID=67 Minitab for AP Students. w ww.Minitab.com/education/apstatisticshighschool.aspx. Mrs. Krummel Web site. Teacher site. http://mrskrummel.com/statteacher.htm. Guided notes for each chapter of The Practice of Statistics can be found at this site, under YMM Chapter Outlines, as well as many other resources. There is a semester exam review with 200 problems and answers. Guided notes and the answer key are available for purchase, but the exam review can be downloaded for free. Mrs. Smarts AP Statistics Page. Teacher site. w ww.lhs.logan.k12.ut.us/~jsmart/stats.html. R ice Virtual Lab in Statistics. http://onlinestatbook.com/rvls.html. R ice Virtual Lab Simulations/Demonstrations. http://www.ruf.rice.edu/~lane/stat_sim/. This portion of the RVLS site has applets that allow students to interact. You can assign activities at home, if students have computer access.
179
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Schott, Brian, Georgia State University. Practice Multiple-Choice Questions for Business Statistics. w ww2.gsu.edu/~dscbms/ibs/qcontent.html. Shodor Education Foundation. Interactivate Activities. w ww.shodor.org/interactivate/activities. W. H. Freeman Co. The Practice of Statistics. 2nd ed. Companion site to the textbook. http://bcs.whfreeman.com/yates2e.
Web Sites (for Individual Chapters in The Practice of Statistics)
Chapter 2 (The Normal Distributions) Flanagan-Hyde, Peter. Is It Normal? See link under Teaching Resource Materials, Anticipating Patterns on the Statistics Course Home Page on AP Central. Chapter 3 (Examining Relationships) University of Illinois at UrbanaChampaign, Department of Statistics. Guess the Regression. w ww.stat.uiuc.edu/courses/stat100//java/GCApplet/GCAppletFrame.html. West, R. Webster, University of South Carolina, Department of Statistics. Regression Applet. w ww.stat.sc.edu/~west/javahtml/Regression.html. Students may add points and investigate how the regression changes. Chapter 4 (More on Two-Variable Data) Dallal, Gerard E., Tufts University. The Normal Distribution. Article about the purpose of transformations. w ww.tufts.edu/~gdallal/normal.htm. Chapter 5 (Producing Data) Dallal, Gerard E., Tufts University. Random Samples/Randomization. w ww.tufts.edu/~gdallal/rand.htm. Derksen, Jared. Exploration: Cheerios. Activity with worksheet. w ww.mrderksen.com/Downloads/cheerios.pdf. NCSSM Statistics Leadership Institute. An Exercise in Sampling: Rolling Down the River. http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_inst01/PDFS/river.pdf. This worksheet explains the difference between SRS and a stratified sample and when it is appropriate to use each. NCSSM Statistics Leadership Institute. The Helicopter Project: A Factorial Design. http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_Inst/PDFS/FacDesgn.pdf. Schwarz, Carl James, Simon Fraser University. Producing Data. w ww.stat.sfu.ca/~cschwarz/Stat-301/Handouts/node54.html. This site gives definitions of experimental design terms. Chapter 6 (Probability) Boggs, Rex. The Game of Greed. w ww.lhs.logan.k12.ut.us/~jsmart/greed.htm. I use this to introduce simulations.
180
Dallal, Gerard E., Tufts University. Probability Theory. w ww.tufts.edu/~gdallal/prob.htm. Article about a probability density curve and cumulative density curve.
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Chapter 8 (The Binomial and Geometric Distributions) Exner, Nicholas, University of Illinois at UrbanaChampaign, Department of Statistics. Animal Cards. w ww.mste.uiuc.edu/reese/cereal/maincereal.html. This site shows a geometric distribution. Chapter 9 (Sampling Distributions) R ice Virtual Lab in Statistics. Simulations/Demonstrations. w ww.ruf.rice.edu/~lane/stat_sim/. This applet displays the central limit theorem. Choose the sampling distribution activity. Chapter 10 (Introduction to Inference) Bock, David. Is That an Assumption or a Condition? See link under Teaching Resource Materials, Statistical Interference on the Statistics Course Home Page on AP Central. Dallal, Gerard E., Tufts University. Confidence Intervals. w ww.tufts.edu/~gdallal/ci.htm. Hayden, Robert W. 10% Assumption for Inference. See link under Teaching Resource Materials, Statistical Interference on the Statistics Course Home Page on AP Central. Chapter 11 (Inference for Distributions) Bullard, Floyd. On Power. See link under Teaching Resource Materials, Statistical Interference on the Statistics Course Home Page on AP Central. Chapter 12 (Inference for Proportions) Peltier, Charles. Why Do We Pool for the Two-Proportion z-Test? See link under Teaching Resource Materials, Statistical Interference on the Statistics Course Home Page on AP Central.
Student Activities
Foldables
Foldables are three-dimensional, interactive, graphic organizers that students make themselves and use to learn and review critical concepts and vocabulary terms. They are fashioned by folding and cutting paper, and they often have flaps that can be lifted to reveal information. Patterns for creating them are available in various styles and designs that students can adapt to any subject. Below are several URLs for Web sites with examples of foldables used in history or science classes. This same concept can easily be adapted for statistics. Making foldables gives students a visual tool to store, organize, and recall a large quantity of information.
w ww.eemes.ccs.k12.nc.us/candler/PDF/foldables.pdf w ww.dinah.com/egroup/Archives.htm
181
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
http://ushistory.pwnet.org/resources/pdf/Geography_Foldables_Photo.pdf w ww.ehhs.cmich.edu/~dnewby/DinahZikefoldables.doc
My students create graphic organizers at the end of each chapter of the textbook, defining each concept and presenting a problem that incorporates that concept. The vocabulary words that were introduced in the chapter are also included. If the foldable is graded as part of a test, it is usually worth about 10 percent. If I know the test is difficult, I use the foldable as 10 points extra credit. At the end of the quarter, I may assign a take-home test, asking students to design a foldable that could be used on their nine-week exam. Creative students often excel in this activity, whereas the stronger mathematical students sometimes have difficulty with neatness and the imaginative aspects of the task. We begin this project during a short class period, and I make sure that paper, glue, scissors, and decorative markers are available. At the beginning of the year, I display several examples from past classes, talk about the benefits of completing an organizer, and demonstrate how to use it to study. The scoring guidelines are also explained. Below is a modified rubric that I have used in the past.
Mathematical thoroughness (Have you included all the necessary concepts with examples for each? Are the vocabulary words clearly defined?) Creativity (Have you used your personality and creative imagination in the design?) On time (Due [date here], before you take your exam) Neatness (Is it clearly written and nicely displayed?) Durability (Can you continue to use it for the remainder of the year?)
45 points
25 points 10 points 10 points 10 points
Linear Regression Activity
At the end of chapter 4, when the students have completed linear regression, they engage in an activity that requires them to collect bivariate data and display it using a trifolded 11 by 13 inch piece of construction paper. They start with a question of interest and a fact that will later be defined as a hypothesis. Some examples include the following:
How are the hours you spend doing homework related to the number of hours you spend reading e-mail? How is the percentage of the tip you leave at a restaurant related to the price of your meal? How is the simulated probability from playing poker related to the theoretical probability? How is the amount of coffee you drink related to the amount of water you drink? How is your arm span related to your height?
Students usually become genuinely excited about this kind of assignment if they are addressing a question that interests them rather than being delegated a predetermined task. They collect bivariate data, indicating both the independent and dependent variable and what units were used. They create boxplots and histograms for the univariate data and scatterplots, with a residual plot, for the bivariate data.
182
Course Organization About AP Statistics
The assignment also requires defining the slope, correlation, and coefficient of determination in the context of their data. Students experience the problems that come with actually collecting their own data. They see that zeros often are problems or that a large number of outliers may require adjustments to the data. Students are then expected to connect the information in their display to their question of interest in a short presentation to the class (four minutes). They should be able to explain and interpret all numerical output and to make a reasonable prediction for some input value that will be asked for during the presentation. The small display boards that I use for this exercise are easy to store and can be brought out in future years as examples. In many ways, this activity mimics a miniature science-fair project. This small project is counted as a test grade, and the evaluation of each board follows this general format: on time (5); neatness (10); creativity (15); mathematical concepts (20); graphs (20); organization, grammar, and spelling (10); use of technology (5); and presentation to the class (15).
Central Limit Party
We have a central limit party, where each group of four students receives a different distribution (skewed, uniform, bimodal, normal). Each group takes a sampling distribution of size 5 and size 10 for each distribution. They gather 50 samples for each size. These are drawn as graphs on large sheets of paper. Each distribution is a different color. Each group then calculates the mean and standard deviation for the population and each sample. This is presented to the class, and a picture of each group is taken. Students discover that the mean of their sample is approximately equal to the mean of the population and that the standard deviation is the standard deviation of the population divided by the square root of 5 or 10, respectively. Students see that all the distributions will approach a normal distribution, but it happens faster when the sample size is larger. This helps the kinesthetic learner as we continually refer back to the graphs and their pictures.
Plant Project
When linear regression is first introduced, each student is given two paper cups filled with potting soil and four bean seeds. (Purchase seeds that germinate quickly so data can be collected within two weeks time. Usually only one or two actually germinate and grow. If more than one seed per cup germinates, the student keeps only the one that looks the strongest.) They are instructed to fertilize one cup daily with Miracle-Gro® and the other daily with worm tea, a natural fertilizer that comes from the castings of worms. They measure the height of their plants for 10 days, and then we do a linear regression with x equaling the total amount of fertilizer and y the height of the plant. The students do not follow any structured rules of experimental design. They complete a worksheet after the chapter 3 review of the concepts of linear regression. When we study experimental design in chapter 5, the same experiment is done again, this time following the correct procedures for randomization of treatment and placement of the plants. We use the first experiment as the foundation to talk about lurking and confounded variables and also how we could incorporate blocking into our design. One student is assigned to do all the watering of both groups of plants.
Hula-Hoop Activity
When testing the difference between two means, students form groups, and we gather data on how many rotations males and females can complete when spinning a plastic Hula-Hoop around their waists. We also do a matched pair design for revolving the hoop clockwise versus counterclockwise. We use one period to
183
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
collect the data, and the next day the data are analyzed. This activity gives the more coordinated students an opportunity to excel.
UNO® Cards
Often in high school a substantial number of students are pulled out of class for assemblies, senior lunch, pep rallies, field trips, band trips, photos, PSAT/NMSQT or state testing, and so on. This makes teaching new materialor even reviewing old materialdifficult. When more than one-third of my class is removed for some such event, I use this activity with the students who are left: I write an easy review question on each card in an UNO deck. As they play the game, students must answer the question before using the card. After the AP Exam, students can create their own decks of cards for next years students.
184
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sample Syllabus 8
Josh Tabor Glen A. Wilson High School Hacienda Heights, California
School Profile
Location and Environment: Hacienda Heights is an unincorporated, largely residential area, about 20 miles east of downtown Los Angeles. Its best-known landmark is the Hsi Lai Temple, one of the largest Buddhist temples in the Western Hemisphere, whose architecture mimics that of ancient Chinese monasteries. A significant proportion of students at Glen A. Wilson High come from homes where English is not the primary language. The school offers AP courses in 17 subjects; 754 AP Exams were taken in 2007, with 68 percent of the students receiving grades of 3 or better. Grades: 912 Type: Public high school Total Enrollment: Approximately 1,800 Ethnic Diversity: In 2006-07, the student population was approximately 44 percent Hispanic/Latino and 43 percent Asian American. College Record: Approximately 54 percent of graduating seniors go to four-year colleges, and an additional 39 percent go to two-year colleges.
Personal Philosophy
Teaching AP Statistics has been the most rewarding and enjoyable experience I have had as an educator. It has been a great opportunity to work with college-bound students, giving them a challenging college-level course that will prepare them for study in almost any field. Numerous alumni have returned to tell me how valuable AP Statistics was and how well-prepared they felt for college.
Class Profile
At Glen A. Wilson High School we offer between two and four sections of AP Statistics each year, with an average class size of about 32. I am the only statistics teacher. The prerequisite for the course is a passing grade in Algebra 2, although many students complete Precalculus first. Concurrent enrollment in Precalculus or AP Calculus is allowed. We are on a traditional daily schedule with 55-minute periods. The school year usually begins after Labor Day and ends in mid-June. It consists of two semesters, with progress reports mailed to the students homes every six weeks. The relatively late start proves to be a challenge each year, but I manage to finish the curriculum by the early May AP Exam date and use the time after the exam to explore additional topics, such as multiple regression and ANOVA. Students are encouraged to take the AP Exam, but it is not a class requirement. Typically, at least 80 percent of my students choose to take the exam. There is no regularly scheduled laboratory for the course; students go to the computer lab only once during the year, although they are given several assignments to do at home on a computer (or in the computer lab on their own time).
185
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Course Overview
The primary text used in this class is the first edition of Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis by Roxy Peck, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. (See full citation in the Teacher Resources section later in this syllabus.) I begin the course with the second section of the Topic Outline in the AP Statistics Course Description, Sampling and Experimentation: Planning and conducting a study. This is the first major topic in our textbook and seems a natural place to start, as planning a study is the first step in the statistical process. We then move to the outlines first topic, Exploring Data: Describing patterns and departures from patterns; the third, Anticipating Patterns: Exploring random phenomena using probability and simulation; and finish with the fourth section, Statistical Inference: Estimating population parameters and testing hypotheses. The course objectives are that students will:
use formalized procedures to collect data in experiments and surveys; organize and interpret information using graphical displays and summary statistics; understand the basic concepts of probability and use probability theory to predict outcomes of random events; learn a variety of statistical tests and estimation procedures and understand which is appropriate for a particular study; use statistical data and reasoning skills to make inferences and communicate them in a clear written format; read and analyze articles and studies from current news sources and apply statistical methods to assess validity; and organize, summarize, and effectively present collected data using technology, including graphing calculators and computers.
Course Planner
Vacation days and student-released days are not included in the days of instruction. Thanksgiving usually occurs around day 60, winter break near day 73, and spring break just after day 134. In the chart below, FRQ refers to an AP Exam free-response question (available on AP Central). The 1997 questions are from the printed Released Exam. The newspaper articles cited are ones that I have accumulated over the years. Most of the time I just read the article to the class, although in some cases I make photocopies. HW means homework; throughout, the decimal numbers following HW refer to problem numbers.
SEMESTER 1
Day Section and Title 1 The Role of Statistics (chapter 1) 2 3 Types of Data (2.1) Sampling (2.4) Activities/Assignments Class: Sexual discrimination activity HW: Read pp. 110; problems 1.17 HW: 2.12.4 Class: Gettysburg Address activityuse Rossmanchance.coms Sampling Words (see the Teacher Resources section of this syllabus) HW: Read pp. 2022; article and questions: Pollings Dirty Little Secret, Week in Review, New York Times, Nov. 21, 1999
186
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Section and Title 4 Bias in Sampling (2.4)
5 6
Random Sampling (2.4) Stratified Random Samples (2.4) Other Sampling Methods (2.4) Experiments and Observational Studies (2.22.3) Designing Experiments (2.5) Designing Experiments, continued (2.5) More Designing Experiments (2.5) Scope of Inference (2.5)
7 8 9
Activities/Assignments Class: Putting a Reality Check on Holocaust Denial, USA Today, Jan. 12, 1994 HW: 2.16, 2.1922 HW: 2.11, 2.12; article and questions: How to Tell if Political Polls Are About Truth, or Consequences, Los Angeles Times, Jan. 30, 2000 Class: Use NCSSMs Rolling Down the River (see Teacher Resources section) HW: 2.10, 2.13, 2.17, 2.18 Class: FRQ, 2004B no. 2 HW: Sampling worksheet HW: Read pp. 1519, problems 2.5, 2.79 HW: Read pp. 2735; worksheet: Wildcat Arena. (I give students a drawing of a basketball arenadifferent levels, different sections and then ask them to use each of the sampling methods we have learned to get a sample of people from the arena.) HW: 2.23, 2.25, 2.26 Class: FRQ, 1999 no. 3 HW: 2.2830, 2.32 HW: Articles and questions: Study: Clot-busters Work in Lungs, Too, Herald-Sun (Durham, N.C.), Aug. 5, 1997; Study: Schizophrenia Drug May Help Alzheimers Patients, Herald-Sun (Durham, N.C.), Dec. 11, 1997 Class: FRQ, 2000 no. 5 HW: 2.33, 2.36, 2.3840 Class: FRQ, 2006B no. 5 HW: Articles and questions: Duke Study Measures Prayers Healing Effects, Herald-Sun (Durham, N.C.) Nov. 10, 1998; Brisk Walks Can Lengthen Your Life, Study Finds, Herald-Sun (Durham, N.C.), Feb. 11, 1998
10 11 12
13 14
Caffeine Experiment (2.5) Review: chapter 2
15 16 17
18
Test: chapter 2 Displaying Categorical HW: 3.2, 3.3, 3.7, 3.10, 3.11 Data: Bar and Pie Charts (3.1) Displaying Numerical HW: 3.12, 3.1520 Data: Dotplots and Stem-and-Leaf Displays (3.2) Displaying Numerical HW: 3.3234, 3.36 Data: Frequency Distributions and Histograms (3.3)
187
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Section and Title 19 Cumulative Relative Frequency Distributions (3.3) 20 Describing the Center of a Data Set (4.1) 21 Measures of Spread (4.2) 22 23 24 25 26 More Measures of Spread/Boxplots (4.24.3) More on Standard Deviation/Using the TI-83 (4.4) More on Standard Deviation (4.4) Shifting and Rescaling Data (not in book) Review: chapters 3 and 4
Activities/Assignments Class: FRQ, 2006 no. 1 HW: chapter 3 worksheet HW: 4.2, 4.3, 4.57, 4.9, 4.16, 4.17 Class: FRQ, 2006B no. 1 HW: 4.19, 4.21, 4.25 HW: 4.2933 Class: FRQ, 2005 no. 1 HW: 4.2224, 4.34 HW: 4.3541, 4.44 HW: Read pp. 135-37; problems 3.46, 3.49, 4.51, 4.52, 4.58, 4.59, 4.61, 4.64 Class: FRQ, 2004 no. 1; matching distributions (from Activity-Based Statistics) HW: JMP Student Edition worksheet (see the Teacher Resources section) HW: 5.19, odd Class: Use Geometers Sketchpads Least Squares applet (see the Teacher Resources section) HW: 5.26, 5.27, 5.29, 5.30 HW: 5.47, 5.48 Class: FRQ, 1998 no. 2 HW: 5.38ad + residual plot; 5.39a, b; 5.43a, d HW: 5.4042, 5.4446, 5.49 HW: Regression output worksheet HW: 5.1012, 5.14, 5.1618 HW: 5.3135 Class: Use Linear Regression applet (see the Teacher Resources section) HW: Review worksheet Class: Introduce first-semester project Class: FRQ, 1999 no. 1 HW: Work on project proposals Class: FRQ, 2005 no. 3
27 28 29
Test: chapters 3 and 4 Describing Bivariate Data with Scatterplots (5.15.2) Fitting a Line to Bivariate Data (5.3) Assessing the Fit of a Line (5.4) How Accurate Will Our Predictions Be? (5.4) 5.4 continued Understanding Regression Output (5.4) Correlation (5.2) Regression (5.3) Unusual and Influential Points (5.4) Review: chapter 5
30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37
38
Review: chapter 5
188
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Section and Title 39 Test: chapter 5 40 Review for midterm 41 Review for midterm 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 Review for midterm Review for midterm Midterm Chance Experiments and Events (6.1) Definition of Probability (6.2) Basic Properties of Probability (6.3) Conditional Probability (6.4) Independence (6.5) 6.5 continued Some General Probability Rules (6.6) Review: 6.16.6 Estimating Probabilities Using Simulation (6.7) More Simulations (6.7) More Simulations (6.7) Review: chapter 6 Review: chapter 6 Test: chapter 6 Project presentations Project presentations Discrete Random Variables (7.17.2) Continuous Random Variables (7.3) Mean of a Random Variable (7.4) Standard Deviation of a Random Variable (7.4)
Activities/Assignments Class: FRQ, 2006 no. 5 Class: Use NCSSMs The Midge Problem (see the Teacher Resources section) Class: Midge problem Class: Collect project proposals Class: FRQ, 2005 no. 1 HW: 6.13, 6.5, 6.12 HW: 6.8, 6.9, 6.11, 6.13 HW: 6.1518, 6.20, 6.21, 6.24, 6.26, 6.27 HW: 6.2935 HW: 6.3644 Class: FRQ, 2003B no. 2 HW: 6.4552 HW: 6.5361 HW: 6.6269 HW: Read pp. 285-91; problem 6.71; simulation worksheet, problems 12 HW: Simulation worksheet, problems 34 HW: 6.75 (do five runs); simulation worksheet, problem 5 HW: Review worksheet, problems 15 Class: FRQ, 2001 no. 3
62 63 64
Class: Start penny activity and continue daily (from Activity-Based Statistics) HW: 7.111 HW: 7.12, 7.14, 7.17, 7.2026 HW: 7.28, 7.35; worksheet, problems 13 HW: 7.32, 7.33, 7.36, 7.37
189
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Section and Title 65 Linear Functions and Linear Combinations (7.4) 66 7.4 continued 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 Binomial Distribution (7.5) More on the Binomial Distribution (7.5) Geometric Distribution (7.5) Review: 7.17.5 The Normal Distribution (7.6) Other Normal Distributions (7.6) Using TI-83 Distribution Menu (7.6) Combining Normal Random Variables (7.6) Normal Approximation to the Binomial Distribution (7.8) Review: chapter 7 Review: chapter 7 Test: chapter 7 Sampling Distributions (8.1) How Many Textbooks? (8.1)
Activities/Assignments HW: 7.29, 7.30, 7.34, 7.40 Class: FRQ, 2001 no. 2 HW: 7.38, 7.39, 7.41; worksheet, problem 4 HW: 7.43, 7.44, 7.46 HW: 7.47, 7.4952, 7.54 HW: 7.5558 Class: FRQ, 2005B no. 2 HW: Worksheet, 57 HW: 7.61, 7.62, 7.64, 7.65 (include illustrations) HW: 7.6670 HW: 7.7175 HW: Worksheet, problems 89 HW: 7.94 (use normal approximation), 7.115-19; worksheet, problem 10 Class: FRQ, 2006B no. 3 HW: 7.98100, 7.102, 7.104, 7.114 Class: FRQ, 2004 no. 4 HW: 8.14, 8.8
81
82 83 84
Class: Textbook activity (see the Student Activities section of this syllabus) HW: 8.710 Sampling Distribution of Class: Finish penny activity the Sample Mean (8.2) Class: Use Sampling Distribution applet at Rice Virtual Lab in Statistics (see the Teacher Resources section) HW: 8.1416, 8.20, 8.23, 8.24 Sampling Distribution HW: 8.2733 of a Sample Proportion (8.3) Review: chapter 8 / HW: 8.3440 textbook activity Review: chapter 8 / textbook competition
190
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Section and Title 85 Test: chapter 8 86 Review for final 87 FINAL EXAM
Activities/Assignments HW: FRQs, 1998 nos. 4, 6; 2002B nos. 3, 5; 2006 no. 3
SEMESTER 2
88 89 Estimation Using a Single Sample (9.1) Large-Sample Confidence Interval for a Population Proportion (9.2) 9.2 continued Interpreting the Confidence Level (9.2) Confidence Interval for a Population Mean (9.3) Confidence Intervals for a Population Mean When σ Is Unknown (9.3) 9.3 continued Review: chapter 9 Test: chapter 9 Hypothesis Testing (10.1) Errors in Hypothesis Testing (10.2) Hypothesis Tests for a Population Proportion (10.3) 10.3 continued 10.3 continued 10.4 Hypothesis Tests for a Population Mean 10.4 continued Power (10.5) Review / JMP activity HW: 9.13, 9.8, 9.9 HW: 9.12, 9.14, 9.15, 9.20
90 91 92 93
HW: 9.10, 9.11, 9.19, 9.23, 9.25, 9.27 Class: Confidence interval activity HW: 9.13, 9.22, 9.24, 9.26, 9.28 HW: 9.34, 9.4648 HW: 9.30, 9.31, 9.38, 9.40, 9.44
94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105
Class: FRQ, 2002B no. 4 HW: 9.32, 9.33, 9.41, 9.43, 9.45 Class: FRQ, 2000 no. 2 HW: 9.5053, 9.55 HW: 10.1, 10.2, 10.49 HW: 10.1016 Class: Simulation activity HW: 10.1723 Class: FRQ, 2003 no. 2 HW: 10.2729 HW: 10.31, 10.32, 10.36 HW: 10.41, 10.43, 10.44, 10.46, 10.47 Class: FRQ, 2005 no. 4 HW: 10.42, 10.45, 10.50, 10.53, 10.54 HW: 10.56, 10.65, 10.67, 10.70 HW: 10.69, 10.73, 10.74
191
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Section and Title 106 Review / JMP activity 107 108 Test: chapter 10 Inferences Concerning the Difference Between Two Population or Treatment Means Using Independent Samples (11.1) 11.1 continued 11.1 continued
Activities/Assignments Class: FRQ, 2005B no. 6 HW: JMP activity Class: Fish oil activity (see the Student Activities section) HW: Read pp. 535-47
109 110 111 112
113 114
115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122
123 124
HW: 11.6, 11.18, 11.24 Class: FRQ, 2000 no. 4 HW: 11.8, 11.14, 11.21, 11.23 Confidence Intervals for HW: 11.12, 11.28 the Difference of Two Means (11.1) Inferences Concerning HW: 11.33, 11.34, 11.37, 11.43 the Difference Between Two Population or Treatment Means Using Paired Samples (11.2) Confidence Intervals for HW: 11.32, 35, 38, 40 Paired Data (11.2) Inferences Concerning a HW: 11.4547 Difference Between Two Population or Treatment Proportions (11.3) Confidence Intervals for Class: FRQ, 2001 no. 5 the Difference of Two HW: 11.48, 11.50, 11.55, 11.57 Proportions (11.3) Introduce TI-83 test HW: 11.70, 11.74, 11.76, 11.85 menu Review: chapter 11 Class: FRQ, 2006B no. 2 Test: chapter 11 Review for midterm HW: FRQs, 1997 no. 4; 1998 no. 1; 2004 no. 6 Review for midterm HW: FRQs, 1998 no. 10; 2005B no. 4; 2006 no. 4 Midterm (chapters 811) Chi-Square Tests for Class: M&Ms activity Univariate Categorical HW: 12.1, 12.5, 12.6, 12.13 (calculations only!) Data (Goodness of Fit Tests) (12.1) 12.1 continued HW: 12.810 Chi-Square Tests for HW: 12.15, 12.17, 12.28, 12.29 the Homogeneity of Proportions (12.2)
192
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Day Section and Title 125 More HOP Tests (12.2)
Activities/Assignments Class: FRQ, 2003B no. 5 HW: 12.23, 12.30; article: The Role of Suggestion in the Perception of Satanic Messages in Rock-and-Roll Recordings, Journal of Psychology 116 (1984): 245-48. HW: 12.16, 12.21, 12.24, 12.27 HW: 12.32, 12.33; article: Sex and Time of Day as Determinants of Whether People Enter the Cafeteria Together or Alone, Psychological Reports 51 (1982): 837-38. Class: FRQ, 1999 no. 2 HW: 13.1, 13.3, 13.6, 13.8 HW: 13.21, 13.25 HW: 13.19, 13.22, 13.26 HW: JMP Student Edition worksheet (13.24) (See Teacher Resources section) Class: FRQ, 2005B no. 5 HW: FRQs, 2001 no. 6; 2006 no. 2 HW: Worksheet, problems 12 HW: Worksheet, problems 34 HW: Worksheet, problems 57 Class: FRQ, 2004B no. 1 HW: FRQ, 1997 no. 6 Use remaining FRQs (from AP Central and the Released Exams) Evening: complete practice AP Exam (2002) Use remaining FRQs Use remaining FRQs
126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148
Chi-Square Tests for Independence (12.2) Review: chapter 12 Review: chapter 12 Quiz: chapter 12 General Regression Model (13.1) Inference for the Slope of a Least-Squares Line (13.2) Confidence Intervals for the True Slope (13.2) Understanding Computer Output Review: section 13.2 Modeling Nonlinear Data (5.5) More Nonlinear Data (5.5) More Nonlinear Data (5.5) Conclusion (5.5) Quiz: chapter 13, 5.5 Review for final Review for final Review for final Final exam Final exam Review for AP Exam Review for AP Exam Review for AP Exam AP Exam
Use remaining FRQs Use remaining FRQs Use remaining FRQs
193
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Day Section and Title 149 Assign second-semester project 150 Multiple Regression (14.1) 151 Fitting a Model and Assessing Its Utility (14.2) 152 Inferences Based on an Estimated Model (14.3) 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161
Activities/Assignments
HW: 14.47 HW: 14.16, 14.25
162 163 164 165 166 167
Class: Collect project proposals HW: 14.37, 14.38 Other Issues in Multiple HW: 14.52, 14.54, 14.56, 14.58, 14.62 Regression (14.4) More Multiple HW: Multiple regression worksheet Regression (14.4) More Multiple HW: Multiple regression models for used cars Regression (14.4) Logistic Regression (not HW: Logistic worksheet, problems 12 in book) Multiple Logistic HW: Logistic worksheet, problems 34 Regression (not in book) Single-Factor ANOVA (15.1) Single-Factor ANOVA HW: 15.5, 15.17 (15.1) Using JMP Student HW: 15.28, 15.29 Edition for ANOVA (15.1) ANOVA for HW: 15.35, 15.37 Randomized Blocked Experiments and Multifactor Studies (15.2) Using JMP Student HW: 14.73, 15.38, 15.63 Edition (15.2) / review: chapters 14 and 15 Review: chapters 14 and 15 Test: chapters 14 and 15 Project presentations Project presentations Project presentations
194
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Teaching Strategies
On a normal day, class starts with a review of the homework from the previous evening. This is usually followed by a presentation of new material. To help students assimilate the large amounts of information imparted, I provide them with partially complete notes (see the example below). Students download these from my school Web site for each chapter, print them out, and bring them to class daily. Depending on the topic, the notes may include exposition with key words left out, examples, and/or problems for practice. The practice problems are to be done in class so I can check for understanding. This routine has freed up an average of 15 minutes in every class period. I use the additional time in a variety of ways: to read articles from newspapers and magazines (see the Course Planner above), to have extended discussions about the lesson, and to work on practice AP Exam free-response questions.
Example of Partially Complete Notes
The following lesson plan takes approximately two full class periods, plus an additional class period to conduct the experiment (the best part). What appears below is the teachers version. In the students version, everything that is underlined or in italics would be left blank.
Experimental Design Suppose we wanted to design an experiment to see if caffeine affects pulse rate. What is the explanatory variable?
Caffeine
What is the response variable? Pulse rate
Who will be the experimental units? The students in this class
Here is an initial plan: Measure initial pulse rate. Give each student some caffeine. Wait for a specified time. Measure final pulse rate. Compare final and initial rates.
What are some problems with this plan? If there is a change in pulse rates, we do not know if caffeine was the cause. For example, suppose I told a joke while we were waiting, and everyone laughed so hard that his or her pulse rate went up. Or, suppose we took notes and everybodys pulse rate slowed down to sleeplike levels. Finally, there are any number of other things that could occur that we may not be aware of.
195
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Some problems can be easily solved by including a control group, which does not receive caffeine. In our experiment, we can accomplish this by using two levels of caffeine: no caffeine and some caffeine. For example, we could assign each class member to one of two treatments: regular cola or caffeine-free cola. Caffeine-free cola is considered a placebo, which is a treatment that is lacking the explanatory variable but is similar to the other treatments in every other way. Why do we not give cola to one group and nothing to the other group?
Oftentimes applying any treatment can create a change in the response variable. For example, when children get hurt, they feel better if their wound is kissed or covered with a bandage, even though neither of those treatments actually eliminate any pain.
In our study, if only one group got a treatment, the fact that its members were chosen to receive free soda might make their pulses increase before the caffeine even hits their bloodstream! Having every subject receive a treatment ensures that both groups think they are being treated the same. Then, any difference between their pulse rates can be attributed to the explanatory variable and not the excitement of getting free soda. Of course, it is essential that the subjects do not know which treatment they are receiving. If a person does not know who is receiving which treatment, that person is blind. There are two classes of individuals who can influence the results of an experiment:
Those who could influence the results directly (subjects, treatment administrators, and the like) Those who evaluate the results
When every individual in one of these classes is blinded, the experiment is called single blind. If every individual in both classes is blinded, then the experiment is double blind. Can our experiment be run in a double blind manner?
Yes, if the subjects, the people handing out the treatments, and the people measuring the pulse rates all do not know which treatment is which. But doesnt someone need to know which is which? Yes, but that person should not have any interaction with the subjects at any point of the experiment.
Four Key Principles of a Good Experiment Our overarching goal when designing an experiment is to make the treatment groups as similar as possiblewith the exception of the treatments themselvesand to keep extraneous variables from affecting the treatment groups differentially while the experiment is going on. Then, if there is a change in the response, it can be attributed to the explanatory variable and not to any extraneous variables. An extraneous variable is one that is not of interest in the current study but is thought to affect the response variable. For example, sugar is an extraneous variable, as it may affect pulse rates. If one treatment group was given regular cola and the other treatment group was given caffeine-free diet cola, then sugar and caffeine would be confounded. If there was a difference in the average pulse rates of the two groups after receiving the treatments, we would not know which variable caused the change, and to what extent. To prevent sugar from becoming a confounding variable, we need to make sure that both treatment groups get the same amount of sugar.
196
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Principle 1: Direct control means holding extraneous variables constant for all treatment groups so that their effects are not confounded with the explanatory variable.
Temperature of drink Size of drink Drinking rate Amount of sugar (no diet soda) Waiting time between treatment and pulse reading Pulse rate before experiment (need to be resting) Room temperature Amount of carbonation How we measure pulse
If we do not control these extraneous variables by making them the same for all treatment groups, they could have differential effects on the response variable and thus confound the effects of the caffeine on pulse rates. For example, we may not be able to tell if it was the caffeine or the temperature that causes the higher pulse rate. Principle 2: Blocking occurs when subjects are divided into blocks (groups) of similar units based on some extraneous variable and then separated into different treatment groups. What if men react to caffeine differently than women?
This additional variability may make it more difficult to see the difference between the treatments.
Can we eliminate this source of variability? We could run the study with only one gender to exert direct control, but then we could only draw conclusions about one gender. But, to reduce this variability we could make sure there is a representative number of men and women in each treatment. For example, if there are 20 women and 30 men in the experiment, then the experimental group should have 10 women and 15 men, and the control group should have the same. In this example, we have formed two blocks: men and women. Then we assigned both treatments to the subjects within each block.
Blocking in experiments is similar to stratification in sampling. Blocking reduces the variability of the results, just as stratifying does. Blocks should be chosen in the same manner as strata: the units within the block should be similar but different from the units in the other blocks. You should only block when you expect that the subjects in one block will have a different response than subjects in other blocks.
What are some other extraneous factors that we can block for?
Age, weight, initial pulse rate, etc.
197
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
You should try to make the blocks as small as possible. Ideally, the size of the block should be the same as the number of treatments. For example, if there are three treatments, then there should be three subjects in each block. If each block has only two subjects, then the subjects are called a matched pair. Principle 3: Randomization is the random assignment of subjects to treatments to ensure that the experiment does not systematically favor one treatment over the other. What about all of the other extraneous variables we do not think of? What about the variables we cannot directly control or block for?
Amount of food eaten before the experiment Caffeine tolerance
If we randomly assign subjects to treatments, this should, on average, even out (but not necessarily eliminate) the differential effects of these variables, because their effects should be spread equally between the treatment groups. Note: We must always randomize, as there will always be extraneous variables we do not consider. How do we randomize?
Draw names from a hat. The first half chosen are in one group, the remaining names in the other. Number the class members from 1 to 36. Then, generate random numbers without replacement until half are chosen for one group. The remaining subjects go in the other group. For matched pairs, flip a coin to determine which subjects go into which group. If the coin comes up heads, the first person in the pair goes to group A and the other person to group B; if it comes up tails, the first person goes to group B and the other person to group A.
Principle 4: Replication means ensuring that there are an adequate number of observations in each treatment group. If each treatment group only had one experimental subject, then we would not be able to conclude that any changes in the response are the result of the treatments. It is possible that some characteristic of the individual was the cause of the change. Increasing the sample size makes randomization more effective. The more subjects we have, the more balanced our treatment groups will be. For example, if we have only 10 subjects and 2 of them have a certain unknown characteristic, it is quite likely that both of those subjects could end up in the same treatment group, simply by chance. However, if we have 100 subjects and 20 have the characteristic, it is very unlikely for all 20 to end up in the same group. There is a much better chance that the groups will be close to balanced (10/10, 9/11, 11/9, etc.) when the sample size is larger. (If you were flipping a coin and wanted to get as close as possible to 50 percent, you would flip the coin more than a few times!) Note: Replication can also refer to repeating the experiment with different subjects. This can help us feel more confident about applying the results of our experiment to a wider population. Summary: With control, blocking, randomization, and replication, each treatment group should be nearly identical, and the effects of extraneous variables should be the same in each group. Now, if changes in the explanatory variable are associated with changes in the response variable, we can conclude that it is a cause-and-effect relationship.
198
Course Organization About AP Statistics
After completing this lesson, we conduct the experiment in class. I bring in cola with caffeine and without caffeine (whatever brand is on sale) in the same cooler so the temperatures will be the same. Volunteers from the class help me pour equal amounts of soda into identical cups. There are usually a few students who do not drink soda, so make sure to let everyone know that participation is voluntary. The rest of the students measure their initial pulse rates and form two lines: males (ordered by pulse rates) and females (ordered by pulse rates). The first two males are paired, the next two males are paired, and so on. I flip a coin to assign each pair to treatments. If the coin comes up heads, the first person goes to the left side of the room and the other person goes to the right; if it is tails, vice-versa. The same is done for the female line. Then each group is given a different treatment. The students slowly drink the soda while we go over a homework assignment. After about 15 minutes, each student measures his or her final pulse rate. We compare the change in pulse rates for each pair, but because this is only the first semester, we do not do any formal inference procedures. One additional twist (that I discovered by accident one year) is to leave the door to the classroom open so that the two groups will be in slightly different environments. This is a perfect example of a confounding variable: if there is a difference in pulse rates, we will not know if it is due to the difference in caffeine content or the difference in environment. One final note: in 11 years of doing this experiment, the results have never appeared significant. This is probably because the amount of caffeine in a cup of soda is too small to make a measurable difference.
Preparing Students for the AP Exam
I use several strategies to help students get ready for the AP Exam:
I give a cumulative midterm and final each semester, with the second-semester final usually given a week before the AP Exam. Students come in during the evening or on Saturday approximately two weeks before the final exam to take the entire 2002 AP Exam. We score the exam together immediately afterward. During the year, students work in groups of four to complete previous AP Exam free-response questions, usually on a topic we are currently studying. Each member of the group is responsible for discussing the answers to the question and making sure the other group members understand. They are allowed to use their notes and textbook. Each student writes up his or her answer, and the group turns in all four papers together. I randomly select one paper to grade and give the entire group the same score, based on the scoring guidelines found on AP Central. These questions are worth 5 percent of a students semester grade, and I usually value them at 3 points instead of 4, as AP questions can be quite challenging. Some students choose to purchase an AP Statistics review book (see the Teacher Resources section below), but this is not required, and we do not use them in class.
Use of Technology
All students have a TI-83/TI-83 Plus/TI-84 graphing calculator for use in class, at home, and on the AP Exam. They use it extensively throughout the course. All students have a copy of JMP Student Edition statistical software for use at home and for demonstrations in class. I give them occasional assignments that must be completed using this program. After the AP Exam, they use this software daily when we learn multiple regression and ANOVA. Other statistical software such as Fathom and Minitab is used for demonstration purposes. Although JMP is packaged with some textbooks, our school obtained it independently. In class, I make use of a variety of applets available on the Internet (see my Teacher Resources section).
199
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Student Evaluation
Each student receives two semester grades, not one overall grade. Progress reports are sent out at 6 and 12 weeks, but each semesters grades accumulate and are not an average of each 6-week period. The semester grades are determined as follows: Tests: 65 percent Each semester there are approximately eight tests, one for each chapter, as well as cumulative midterms and f inals. A significant portion of each test assesses communication skills and connections between topics. Homework: 15 percent Students are assigned daily homework from the primary textbook. Projects: 10 percent Each semester students complete a major project (see my Student Activities section). Participation: 5 percent Participation in class discussions and activities is required. Class work: 5 percent This consists of AP Exam free-response questions done in groups and other in-class activities. The midterm is weighted the same as the other tests. The final is longer (two hours versus one hour), so it is worth more points but proportionally so. In other words, a multiple-choice question is still worth the same on the final; however, there are more of them. The format of all the tests is similarroughly onethird to one-half multiple-choice questions and the rest free-response questions. I try to make them similar in format to the AP Exam. The grading scale at Wilson High is as follows: A = 90100, B = 8089, C = 7079, D = 6069.
Teacher Resources
Basic Textbook
Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. Pacific Grove, Calif.: Brooks/Cole, 2001.
Exam Review Books
Bohan, James F. AP Statistics: Preparing for the Advanced Placement Examination. New York: AMSCO, 2000. Carroll, Anne M., Ruth E. Carver, Susan A. Peters, and Janice D. Ricks. Preparing for the Statistics AP Exam with Stats: Modeling the World, 2nd ed. AP Test Prep series. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson/ Prentice Hall, 2007. Hinders, Duane C. 5 Steps to a 5: AP Statistics. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2004. Levine-Wissing, Robin, and David Thiel. AP Statistics. 3rd ed. Piscataway, N.J.: Research and Education Association, 2006.
200
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Sternstein, Martin. Barrons AP Statistics: How to Prepare for the Advanced Placement Exam. 3rd ed. Hauppauge, N.Y.: Barrons Educational Series, 2004.
Other Texts and Resource Books
Agresti, Alan, and Christine Franklin. Statistics: The Art and Science of Learning from Data. Upper Saddle R iver, N.J.: Pearson/Prentice Hall, 2007. Albert, Jim, and Jay M. Bennett. Curve Ball: Baseball, Statistics, and the Role of Chance in the Game. New York: Springer, 2001. An introduction to statistics using baseball. Bock, David E., Paul F. Velleman, and Richard D. De Veaux. Stats: Modeling the World. 2nd ed. Boston: Pearson/Addison-Wesley, 2007. College Board. 1997 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 1997. College Board. 2002 AP Statistics Released Exam. New York: College Board, 2002. (Note: The 2007 Released Exam has become available since this syllabus was submitted.) Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. 2nd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2005. Ramsey, Fred L., and Daniel W. Schafer. The Statistical Sleuth: A Course in Methods of Data Analysis. 2nd ed. Pacific Grove, Calif.: Thomson/Duxbury, 2002. Rossman, Allan J., Beth L. Chance, and J. Barr von Oehsen. Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data and the Graphing Calculator. 2nd ed. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press, 2002. Versions to use with Fathom, Minitab, and other software packages are also available. Salsburg, David. The Lady Tasting Tea: How Statistics Revolutionized Science in the Twentieth Century. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2001. A very readable introduction to the history of statistics. Scheaffer, Richard L., Mrudulla Gnanadesikan, Ann Watkins, and Jeffrey A. Witmer. Activity-Based Statistics. New York: Springer, 1996. Watkins, Ann E., Richard L. Scheaffer, and George W. Cobb. Statistics in Action: Understanding a World of Data. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press, 2003. Yates, Daniel S., David S. Moore, and Daren S. Starnes. The Practice of Statistics: TI-83/89 Graphing Calculator Enhanced. 2nd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2003.
Periodicals
Chance. Magazine published quarterly by the American Statistical Association and Springer. Subscription information at www.amstat.org. STATS: The Magazine for Students of Statistics. Published three times a year by the American Statistical Association and Springer. Subscription information at www.amstat.org. Neither magazine is written specifically for the AP Statistics teacher, but they are both very interesting. Subscription prices are discounted for ASA members.
201
Chapter 3 Chapter 1 Software
ActivStats. CD-ROM ed. 2005-06 release by Paul Velleman. N.p.: Addison-Wesley, 2006. w ww.datadesk.com/products/mediadx/activstats. Data Desk analysis software is built into this product. Fathom Dynamic Data Software. Version 2. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press. w ww.keypress.com. JMP 6. Student Edition. w ww.JMP.com/se. Minitab. w ww.minitab.com. StatCrunch: Data Analysis on the Web. w ww.statcrunch.com. Web-based statistical software. WinStat. http://math.exeter.edu/rparris. Free download.
Videos
Against All Odds: Inside Statistics. Lexington, Mass.: Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications (COMAP), 1989. This video series of 26 half-hour segments was written by David Moore. It can be viewed online for streaming media for free at www.learner.org. Downloading is prohibited. Statistics: Decisions Through Data. By David S. Moore. Five videocassettes with users guide. Lexington, Mass.: Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications (COMAP), 1992. This series of five one-hour videos (total of 21 video segments) teaches various topics in 1015 minute segments, using some of the footage from Against All Odds. The videos are useful for introducing or reviewing a topic, or for a day when a substitute covers your class. They come with worksheets and other materials.
Web Resources
AP Statistics Course Home Page. apcentral.collegeboard.com/stats. This is a wonderful resource that includes the Course Description, previous AP Exam free-response questions, sample syllabi, tips for the AP Exam, important announcements, reviews of textbooks and other resources, and many excellent articles about the teaching of statistics. AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group (EDG). The College Boards electronic discussion group for this subject, commonly referred to as the listserv, is an open forum for discussing anything related to AP Statistics, including questions on textbook problems, how to prepare for the AP Exam, issues of pacing for different textbooks, technology questions, and questions that go beyond what we would teach our students. Register through the course home page at AP Central. AP Statistics FAQ. w ww.mrderksen.com/faq.htm. Includes resources for new teachers and sections about the AP Exam and course content.
202
Geometers Sketchpad Resource Center. Least Squares. w ww.dynamicgeometry.com/javasketchpad/gallery/pages/least_squares.php. Linear Regression. http://statweb.calpoly.edu/bchance/applets/LRApplet.html.
Course Organization About AP Statistics
Math Forum@Drexel. http://mathforum.org/kb/forum.jspa?forumID=67. This is a read-only searchable archive of all AP Statistics EDG messages over the past several years. NCSSM (North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics). An Exercise in Sampling: Rolling Down the R iver. http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_inst01/PDFS/river.pdf. NCSSM. The Midge Problem: A Mathematical Modeling Example. w ww.dlt.ncssm.edu/afm/lessons/midge_problem.doc. Rice Virtual Lab in Statistics. Sampling Distribution. http://onlinestatbook.com/stat_sim/sampling_dist/index.html. Rossmanchance.com. Sampling Words. w ww.rossmanchance.com/jsm03/activities/SamplingWords.doc.
Student Activities
How Many Textbooks?
(Adapted from the How Many Taxis? problem from the North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics [http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Talks/PDFS/Taxis%20for%20MAA.pdf] and from the How Many Tanks? activity in Activity-Based Statistics [see citation in the Teacher Resources section above]. Sample Syllabus 3 in this publication describes how the German tank activity is used in Michael Allwoods classroom.) During World War II, Allied forces noticed that all German tanks were labeled with a serial number. After observing numerous tanks, it became obvious that the tanks were numbered systematically. Thus, the Allies were able to predict the total number of German tanks and their locations using the observed serial numbers. This became known as the German Tank Problem (for more information, see w ww.guardian.co.uk/g2/story/0%2C%2C182425%2C00.html). Fortunately for our troops in the Middle East, enemy forces do not have any tanks to speak of. However, the methods used to solve the German Tank Problem can be applied to many other situations. In this assignment, your job is to develop a method to estimate the total number of AP Statistics books (or any other textbook) at our school, based on a random sample of books and the assumption that the books are numbered sequentially starting from 1. For example, suppose a random sample of n = 7 books contains the following numbers: 10, 38, 59, 61, 74, 90, 94. How can you use this information to estimate the total number of books (N )? One possible method would be to take the median value (61) and double it. In this example, 61 × 2 = 122. Thus, our estimate for the total number of books is N = 122.
203
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
For this activity you will create three other statistics to estimate the total number of books. Remember, a statistic is any quantity computed from the values in a sample. You may use any combination of the summary statistics we already know (mean, median, min, max, quartiles, IQR, standard deviation) or invent your own. The goal is to find a relatively simple statistic that reliably predicts the total number of books. To determine which of your three statistics gives the best prediction, you will perform a simulation to generate sampling distributions for each of your three statistics. For the purposes of the simulation, assume that there are 100 books total (N = 100) and that you will be taking samples of size 7 (n = 7). For each run (do 25 runs), generate seven random numbers from 1 to 100, and compute the values of each of your three statistics. What you need to turn in:
Due
An introduction describing the choice of your three statistics. Three dotplots showing the sampling distributions for each of your statistics. Make sure they are on the same scale so they can be easily compared. A written description/comparison of the three distributions. A description of which statistic you think is best and why. (one per group)
NOTE: On we will have a competition in class to see which group has the best statistic. The nominating order will be randomly selected, and no statistic will be allowed more than once. During each round of the competition, I will secretly choose N and then give you a sample of n numbers from 1-N. Each group will compute the value of its statistic based on the sample of n numbers. The closest estimate will be awarded 3 points, the second closest will receive 2 points, and the third closest will get 1 point. After several rounds, the team with the most points will get 2 extra-credit points per member.
Fish Oil Activity
The students are given the following handout: In a study on the The Antihypertensive Effects of Fish Oil, researchers randomly assigned 14 male volunteers with high blood pressure to one of two treatments. The first treatment was a four-week diet that included fish oil, and the second was a four-week diet that included a mixture of oils that approximated the types of fat present in the American diet (here called regular oil for simplicity). The response variable was the reduction in diastolic blood pressure (mm of mercury). The results of this study are shown below. (Source: New England Journal of Medicine 320 [1989]: 1037-43; cited in Ramsey and Schafer, The Statistical Sleuth, p. 23.) Fish oil: Regular oil: 8 -6 12 0 10 1 14 2 2 -3 0 -4 0 2 x f = 6.57 xr = -1.14
At first glance, it appears that the average reduction when using fish oil is higher than the average reduction when using regular oil ( f 0 ), because x f xr 7.71 0 . However, it is possible that r the oils have the same effect and that the observed difference is the result of randomization variability.
204
Course Organization About AP Statistics
To decide, we start by assuming that the null hypothesis is true H 0 : F R . That is, there is no difference between regular oil and fish oil. So, the first person in the list would have had a reduction of 8 no matter which treatment he was taking. He just happened to be assigned to the fish oil group by chance. To see how likely it is to get a difference of 7.71 because of randomization variability, we can perform a simulation. Write each reduction on a piece of paper, and re-randomize the subjects into two groups. This simulates assigning the subjects to groups when the null hypothesis is true. Once you make two new groups, find the mean of each group and then their difference x F x R . Finally, collect differences from the class to form a sampling distribution of x F x R , and estimate the probability of getting a difference as high as 7.71 by random chance.
Teachers note: Once each student has a difference of means, plot all the results on a dotplot. It is very unlikely that any of the differences will be more than 7.71. A typical conclusion to this activity might be worded in this way: Thus, assuming that there is no difference in the two oils, it is very unlikely to get a difference of sample means as high as 7.71 by random chance (p 0). Therefore, we reject the null hypothesis and conclude that f ish oil helps reduce diastolic blood pressure.
First-Semester Project: Response Bias
(Adapted from an activity in Activity-Based Statistics) You and your partner will design and conduct an experiment to investigate the effects of response bias in surveys. You may choose the topic for your surveys, but you must design your experiment so that it can answer at least one of the following questions:
Can the wording of a question create response bias? Do the characteristics of the interviewer create response bias? Does anonymity change the responses to sensitive questions? Does manipulating the answer choices change the response?
Proposal (5 points) The proposal is due Monday, October 30. Late work will be penalized 20 percent per day, even if you are absent. The proposal is worth 20 percent of the grade, so do not treat it casually. If the proposal is not approved the first time, you will need to resubmit it for a reduced grade. You must attach the original proposal to any resubmissions.
In your proposal, you should do the following: Describe your topic and state which type of bias you are investigating. Describe how you will obtain your subjects (minimum sample size is 50). This must be practical!! Your population does not need to be from this school, nor should you interrupt any classes. Describe what your questions will be and how they will be asked, including how you will incorporate the principles of a good experiment and avoid confounding variables. Convince me that you have a good design!
205
Chapter 3 Chapter 1
Poster (17 points) The poster is due Monday, November 27. Late work will be penalized 20 percent per day, even if you are absent.
The key to a good statistical poster is communication and organization. Make sure all components of the poster are focused on answering the question of interest. The poster should be standard size (about 23 by 28 inches) and not on foam board. Make sure it is light enough to be hung on the wall.
The poster should include the following components: Title (in the form of a question). Introduction: In the introduction you should discuss what question you are trying to answer, why you chose this topic, and what your hypotheses are. Data collection: In this section, describe how you obtained your data. Be specific. Graphs and summary statistics: Make sure the graphs are completely labeled, easy to compare, and help to answer the question of interest. Discussion and conclusions: In this section, state your conclusions. You should also discuss any errors you made, what you could do to improve the study next time, and so forth. Pictures of your data collection in progress.
Presentation (3 points) Each pair is required to give a five-minute oral presentation to the class. Both members must participate equally and should be prepared to answer questions.
Second-Semester Project
Purpose: The purpose of this project is for you to actually do statistics. You are to: (1) form a hypothesis; (2) design a study; (3) conduct the study; (4) collect the data; (5) describe the data; and (6) make conclusions using the data. Topics: You may do your study on any topic, but you must be able to perform all six steps listed above. Make it interesting, and note that degree of difficulty is part of the grade. For example, experiments are preferred over observational studies or surveys. Projects about response bias are not allowed. There will be a limited amount of class time for performing experiments. Group size: You may work alone or with a partner. Proposal (5 points) You must have an approved project by Wednesday, May 10. To get approval, you should be able to demonstrate how your study will meet the requirements of the project. In other words, you need to clearly and completely describe your hypotheses, what test/interval you will use to analyze the results, how you will collect the data so the conditions will be satisfied, and so forth. You must also make sure that your study will be safe and ethical, if you are using human subjects. The proposal should be typed. If it is not approved, you will have to resubmit it for partial credit until it is approved.
206
Poster (17 points)
Course Organization About AP Statistics
The poster is due Wednesday, May 31. Late work will be penalized 20 percent per day, even if you are absent. The key to a good statistical poster is communication and organization. Make sure all components of the poster are focused on answering the question of interest. The poster should be standard size (about 23 by 28 inches) and not on foam board. Make sure it is light enough to be hung on the wall.
The poster should include the following components: Title (in the form of a question). Introduction: In the introduction you should discuss what question you are trying to answer, why you chose this topic, what your hypotheses are, and how you analyze your data. Data collection: In this section, describe how you obtained your data. Be specific. Graphs and summary statistics: Make sure the graphs are well labeled, easy to compare, and help answer the question of interest. Discussion and conclusions: In this section, state your conclusion (with test statistic and P-value), and discuss why your inference procedure is valid (that is, discuss the conditions and so forth). You should also discuss any errors you made and what you could do to improve the study next time. Live action pictures of your data collection in progress. Note: You should not include the five steps anywhere on your poster. The steps should be integrated throughout the sections above.
Presentation (3 points) Each individual or pair is required to give a five-minute oral presentation to the class. Examples of successful projects:
Do students learn better in a quiet room or a room with music playing? What factors affect plant growth? Which brand of paper towel (popcorn, golf ball, whatever) is best?
207
Chapter 4 The AP Exam n Statstcs
Like all AP courses, AP Statistics prepares students for a worldwide examination administered each year in early May. Students can earn college credit and/or placement into an advanced class at many colleges and universities by achieving a sufficiently high score on this exam. This assessment is not some formulaic vehicle that requires you to teach to the test. Because the AP course and the AP Exam are designed by the same peoplethe AP Statistics Development Committeethe exam is a natural outgrowth of the course. The course goals emphasize the ability to creatively apply and implement statistical principles rather than rote memorization. Students will not be faced with trick questions; instead the AP Statistics Exam gives them the opportunity to showcase the college-level skills that they have learned throughout the year.
Exam Development and Scorng
Structure and Format
The development of each AP Statistics Exam takes two or more years. The three-hour exam consists of two sections: 40 multiple-choice questions in Section I (90 minutes) and 6 free-response questions in Section II (90 minutes), the last one of which is an investigative task. Students are expected to have a graphing calculator with statistical capabilities available for the entire exam, and they will always have access to probability tables and a formula list. It is strongly suggested that students use these tables and the formula list throughout the year so they become familiar with the layout. These materials can be found in the published Released Exams, the Course Description, or the free-response questions available on the AP Statistics Exam Page on AP Central. They are also included with the Statistics Practice Exam available at AP Central as a free PDF download to instructors who have an authorized course syllabus. College faculty who teach the introductory statistics courses that the AP course is intended to replicate write multiple-choice questions for Section I based on the course Topic Outline. These questions are reviewed by ETS content experts and then field-tested in college classes to obtain an estimate of their level of difficulty. The field-testing also helps to identify multiple-choice questions whose performance does not satisfy the statistical specifications of the exam. Once a question has been vetted and is in an acceptable form, it goes into the pool for future exams. The 40 questions for Section I are assembled according to specifications developed by the Development Committee. These specifications include details as to how the multiple-choice questions in an exam should be distributed with respect to content and level of difficulty. After several further content, editorial, and fairness/sensitivity reviews, the questions are ready for printing and administration. On the other hand, individual committee members write most of the free-response questions for Section II. The committee and the content experts review and refine these draft questions and determine which will work best for the AP Examwill the questions accurately test the course content, do they offer the appropriate level of difficulty, and will they elicit answers that allow readers to discriminate among
209
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
responses along a particular scoring scale? To ensure alignment between the free-response questions and how those questions will be scored, draft scoring guidelines are developed by the Chief Reader, a college professor who oversees the scoring of the questions, with input from the Development Committee.
The AP Reading
The multiple-choice section of the AP Exam is scanned and scored by computer. The free-response questions are evaluated at the AP Reading in June. The people who score the free-response questions on the exam are known as Readers. These are experienced statistics instructors who teach the AP course in a high school or the equivalent course at a college or university. To ensure a broad and balanced group of Readers, factors such as school locale and setting (urban, rural, etc.), gender, ethnicity, and years of teaching experience are considered. Reader applications can be completed online at apcentral.collegeboard.com/readers. It is generally expected that applicants will have at least three years of experience teaching AP Statistics. Some of the more experienced Readers are invited to serve as Exam Leaders (for some subjects that have two exams), Question Leaders (who supervise the scoring of a specific free-response question), and Table Leaders. The remaining Readers are divided into groups of six or eight, with each group supervised by one Table Leader. Under the guidance of the Chief Reader, the Exam Leaders, Question Leaders, and Table Leaders assist in establishing scoring standards, selecting sample student responses that exemplify those standards, and preparing for the training of the Readers. The primary goal of the scoring process is to have each Reader score the student responses consistently, fairly, and to the same standard as the other Readers. In other words, a student response should receive the same score without regard to which Reader scored the response or the day on which it was scored. This goal is achieved through the creation of detailed scoring guidelines, thorough training of all Readers, and the various checks and balances that are applied throughout the Reading. For example, many but not necessarily all student responses will be back-read a second time by a Table Leader to ensure that the guidelines are being applied consistently. In addition, no Reader will score more than one question from a particular students exam.
Scoring Guidelines for the Free-Response Questions
Well before the AP Reading, the Chief Reader prepares a detailed draft of the scoring guidelines (commonly referred to as the rubric) for each free-response question. These guidelines are reviewed several times at Development Committee meetings throughout the year. The Chief Reader and other Reading leadership and the content experts meet at the AP Reading site a few days before the Reading begins. They review and revise the draft scoring guidelines and test their utility by prescoring randomly selected student papers. If problems or ambiguities become apparent, the scoring guidelines are further refined and revised until a final consensus is reached. These standards allow for consistent scoring of free-response questions, including those in which different approaches are correct. Before a question is scored, the rubric refinement team for that question conducts a training session for the Readers so that they are able to assess the question in a reliable and consistent manner. Because a Reader might score two, and perhaps three, of the six questions over the course of the Reading, there are retraining sessions when Readers switch to a different question. It is also worth noting that new Readers do not operate in a vacuum. They are paired with an experienced Reader who, along with the Table Leader, can answer any questions they may have during the process and generally help them get their feet on the ground.
210
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
You are encouraged to read chapter 1, The AP Process, in any of the Released Exam publications for additional detailed information about the development and scoring of the exams, the creation of the scoring guidelines, and the training of Readers.
Holistic Scoring
The six free-response questions on the AP Statistics Exam are scored holistically; that is, each response is evaluated as a complete package. With holistic scoring, a judgment is made about the overall quality of the students response, as opposed to analytic scoring, wherein the necessary components of a students response are specified in advance, and each component is given a value counting toward the overall score. For example, suppose a student is to solve a quadratic equation, x2 2x = 7. An analytic scoring rubric might allocate a total of 4 points in the following manner: Score 1 point for rewriting the equation as x2 2x 7 = 0. Score 1 point for correctly choosing the quadratic formula. Score 1 point for correct substitution of the coefficients into the formula. Score 1 point for the correct answer. Analytic scoring is appropriate for evaluating responses to focused questions that have few response alternatives.9 Holistic scoring, in contrast, is well suited for questions where the student is required to synthesize information and respond at least partly in written paragraphs. For example, an openended question may present a real-life experiment with resulting data and ask the student not only to analyze the data but also to comment on how the experimental protocol might be enhanced. Opinions on improvement might focus on refining the sampling method, controlling confounding variables, or seeking more power through increasing the sample size. Indeed, the students justification of his or her experimental improvement could even depend on relevant contextual knowledge brought to the exam from the real world! In this context, holistic scoring represents a recognition not only of multiple reasonable approaches to a statistical analysis but an insistence about statistical synergya quality student response is more than just the sum of its parts. One method of implementing holistic scoring is to decide in advance the number of categories into which student answers will be sorted. These may be labeled A, B, C, D, and F; distinguished, proficient, and novice; or simple numbers, 5, 4, 3, 2, and 1. The AP Statistics Scoring Guidelines for each free-response question on the exam have five categories, numerically defined on a 0 to 4 scale. Each category represents a level of quality in the student response. These levels of quality are defined in two dimensions: statistical k nowledge and communication. The specific standards for each question are tied to a general template, which represents the descriptions of the quality levels as envisioned by the Development Committee. This general template is reproduced in the following table. Note that communication and statistical knowledge are given equal value.
9. Anthony J. Ntko, Educational Assessment of Students, 3rd ed. (Upper Saddle Rver, N.J.: Merrll, 2001), 194-95.
211
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
A Guide to Scoring Free-Response Statistics Questions: The Category Descriptors Score Descriptors Statistical Knowledge (Identification of the important components of the problem and demonstration of the statistical concepts and techniques that result in a correct solution of the problem) Shows complete understanding of the problems statistical components Synthesizes a correct relationship among these components, perhaps with novelty and creativity Uses appropriate and correctly executed statistical techniques May have minor arithmetic errors, but answers are still reasonable Shows substantial understanding of the problems statistical components Synthesizes a relationship among these components, perhaps with minor gaps Uses appropriate statistical techniques May have arithmetic errors, but answers are still reasonable 1 Minimal Communication (Explanation of what was done and why, along with a statement of conclusions drawn in context) Provides a clear, organized, and complete explanation, using correct terminology, of what was done and why States appropriate assumptions and caveats Uses diagrams or plots when appropriate to aid in describing the solution States an appropriate and complete conclusion
4 Complete
3 Substantial
2 Developing
Provides a clear but not perfectly organized explanation, using correct terminology, of what was done and why, but explanation may be slightly incomplete May miss necessary assumptions or caveats Uses diagrams or plots when appropriate to aid in describing the solution States a conclusion that follows from the analysis but may be somewhat incomplete Shows some understanding of the Provides some explanation of what was problems statistical components done, but explanation may be vague and difficult to interpret and terminology may Shows little in the way of a relationship be somewhat inappropriate among these components Uses diagrams in an incomplete or Uses some appropriate statistical ineffective way, or diagrams may be techniques but misses or misuses others missing May have arithmetic errors that result States a conclusion that is incomplete in unreasonable answers Provides minimal or unclear explanation of what was done or why it was done, and explanation may not match the presented solution Fails to use diagrams or plots, or uses them incorrectly States an incorrect conclusion or fails to state a conclusion
0
Shows limited understanding of the problems statistical components by failing to identify important components Shows little ability to organize a solution and may use irrelevant information Misuses or fails to use appropriate statistical techniques Has arithmetic errors that result in unreasonable answers Shows little to no understanding of statistical components
Provides no explanation of a legitimate strategy
212
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
The Composite Score
Students composite scores are determined by adding their scores for the two sections of the exam together. The maximum score is 100 points. All 40 multiple-choice questions in Section I are equally weighted, and the maximum possible score on this part is 50 points, or 50 percent of the composite score. A deduction is made for incorrect responses to discourage random guessing: one-quarter of the number of incorrect answers is subtracted from the number of correct answers. However, if a student can eliminate one or more of the choices as incorrect, it is advantageous to guess from among the remaining options. An answer that is left blank does not count against the students score. Each question in Section II is weighted so that free-response questions 15 each contribute 7.5 percent to the maximum possible composite exam score and question 6, referred to as the investigative task, contributes 12.5 percent. The maximum possible score on Section II is 50 points, which is the remaining 50 percent of the composite score. You are encouraged to read through all of the available Released Exams to see the AP Statistics Scoring Worksheet and the AP Grade Conversion Chart that are presented in each exam. This is also a good source of information about the development of AP Statistics Exams, their content and format, and scoring. Also included are the questions and scoring guidelines, examples of student responses, and commentaries on those responses. These commentaries help to explain how the score for a response was determined. In addition, free-response questions from the last several years for the operational and overseas exams (called Form B) can be accessed from the AP Statistics Exam Page. As with the Released Exams, here you will find the questions and scoring guidelines, examples of student responses, and scoring commentary. One method I started in my first year of teaching this course was to take the free-response questions, write up my solutions, and then score my work using the published guidelines. This gave me a better idea of how much detail was needed to score well on a question. I still find this to be a useful exercise.
AP Grades
The Chief Reader sets the four cut points that divide the composite scores into groups corresponding to the f inal AP grades of 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5. A variety of information is available to help the Chief Reader determine the score ranges into which exam grades should fall:
Distributions of scores on each portion of the multiple-choice and free-response sections of the exam are provided, along with the totals for each section and the composite score total. With these tables and special statistical tables presenting grade distributions from previous years, the Chief Reader can compare the exam at hand to longitudinal results from other years. For each composite score, a table summarizes student performance on all sections of the exam. A subset of the multiple-choice questions is used for equating purposes. That is, a certain number of questions from an earlier exam are included in the current one, thereby allowing comparisons to be made between the scores of the earlier group of students and those of the current group. This information, along with other data, is used by the Chief Reader to establish AP grades that reflect the level of competence demanded by the AP Program and legitimately compare this years AP grades with earlier years. Finally, on the basis of professional judgment regarding the quality of the performance represented by the achieved scores, the Chief Reader determines the students final AP grades.
213
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
Many colleges consult their incoming students AP grade reports when making placement and credit decisions. In general, an AP grade of 3 or higher indicates sufficient mastery of course content to allow placement in the succeeding college course and/or credit for and exemption from a college course comparable to the AP course. Each college develops its own criteria for making AP credit decisions. Because the grade necessary for credit and the exams that will be accepted can vary from college to college and even from department to department within a particular institution, it is important for a student to clearly understand the policies for that educational institution. Sometimes the decision is based on whether the students grade is 3, 4, or 5. Some colleges do not give AP credit at all, or only for selected courses. It is incumbent on students to ask questions about a universitys AP policy when they apply to a school or visit a particular institution. One helpful source is on collegeboard.com. Students can click on AP Credit Policy Info on the AP student page, which will take them to a search tool where they can type in the name of an institution and be linked to information on its AP credit policy.
Preparng Your Students
Needless to say, the specific topics that you teach every day of the course prepare your students for success on the AP Statistics Exam. With a firm knowledge of the subjects included in the Topic Outline, they should be able to do well on this cumulative assessment. Yet time and again we find that even students who understand all the terms, correctly apply the formulas, and can provide good answers to the stock questions in elementary statistics still may not be as well prepared as possible for the open-ended questions. Why might this be?
Free-Response Question Skills and Strategies
Statistics is a discipline where communication is an essential skill. Consulting statisticians as well as investigators in various scientific fields must be able to formulate real research questions into appropriate statistical forms and then interpret the results of their statistical analysis for others. The evaluation of student responses on the free-response section of the AP Statistics Exam reflects the importance of clear communication and developing a habit of statistical thinking in addition to mathematical ability.
Practice Makes Perfect Students need experience answering questions like those on the AP Exam. There are several ways to work these questions into your curriculum. The first is to make them part of your formal assessments. On the day prior to a unit test, I provide students with an AP review, which consists of multiple-choice questions and occasionally a free-response question that deal with the concepts covered in that unit. Every test consists of a multiple-choice section, worth 60 percent, and a free-response section, worth 40 percent. This familiarizes students with the AP Exam format (which weights the two sections equally however), and it also requires them to develop critical thinking skills and time-management strategies. Be sure to include some multiplechoice questions that require students to critically apply statistical concepts rather than just demonstrate basic knowledge. Previous AP Exam free-response questions (found on AP Central) can also be used on unit tests. In addition, many teachers use the published AP free-response questions as timed writing exercises in the classroom, allowing students approximately 1215 minutes to complete each question. Students will be surprised at how short that time can be. Most will gain confidence and learn to manage their time better as the year progresses. Be sure to score all these questions, whether on tests or as practice assignments, using the guidelines posted on AP Central. Kathy Fritz, Plano West Senior High School, Plano, Texas
214
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
AP Central contains scoring guidelines and commentaries on sample student responses for freeresponse questions from past AP Statistics Exams. This is an excellent place to become more familiar with the actual implementations of the guidelines for individual questions. However, there is a danger that the specificity of the guidelines for past questions can be misinterpreted. For example, one might be tempted to create overly narrow rules for students statistical writing. Many of the free-response questions can be integrative in nature, as illustrated by the one featured in chapter 1 that includes data analysis as well as sampling elements. A particular hypothesis-testing question might ask students to comment on how the data were collected, and this would of course be reflected in the scoring guidelines. A cursory reading of one of the question-specific rubrics could lead one to conclude that for all hypothesis-testing questions a discussion of the sampling is required. This temptation must be resisted! Each rubric is written to reflect a particular question. For example, a specific element in the response to an inference question could be crucial, less than crucial, or even irrelevant in a different question. Although it is not possible to completely codify guidelines or rules of thumb for approaching the freeresponse questions, it is possible to offer some general observations about common limitations and errors of omission and commission in student responses on past exams. Some benefits of experience from past AP Readings are provided below.
Defining Symbols and Interpreting Results
Students often fail to define symbols appropriately. For example, when writing a null hypothesis, a student should not just write μ = 75 but should state what μ represents in the particular context. A clear and complete statement of a null hypothesis would be: μ = 75, where μ is the mean of the reading test scores for all students in this school. If students practice this policy throughout the course, they will have less trouble understanding that the null hypothesis is about the population, not about the sample. Similarly, under the time pressure of the exam, students may forget which Greek letter is appropriate to use and thus provide an incorrect symbol without explanation. Defining the meaning of a symbol will, in general, protect the student against ambiguity or the presumption of error. For example, defining da to be the population-mean effect of drug A may not be considered the standard way of proceeding, but it does eliminate ambiguity. Specifically, students should distinguish between population parameters and their estimates in words or with symbols. They should mention the population mean or the sample mean, rather than simply referring to the mean. As a general rule, students should communicate in the commonly used symbols and format of statistics when writing their responses rather than using the symbols and format of their calculator (sometimes referred to as calculator-speak). For example, some calculators will perform a hypothesis test automatically and present the results on-screen differently from the commonly accepted statistical format, and students may then simply copy what they see on the calculator screen. This is seldom an appropriate form for communicating the process of hypothesis testing and should be avoided. Students will sometimes write too much or too little. The best strategy is to (a) clearly answer the question asked and (b) stop. It frequently appears that students begin writing while still formulating their thoughts, perhaps under the impression that they are using their time efficiently. Also, some students seem to feel they must fill up the space allotted for the question. These two strategies have a common effect: producing irrelevant or possibly incorrect or contradictory communication at either the beginning or end of the response. A better approach is to read the question carefully and then respond to that question. Contradictory writing will always be regarded as incorrectshould two parallel solutions be offered, both will be read, but if one solution is of lower quality, the lesser score will be awarded. Another widespread oversight is the failure to interpret the results of a statistical procedure. Many students assume that the statistical mechanics of the problem will carry the day. For example, they believe
215
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
that writing down a confidence interval or stating the null hypothesis is rejected is sufficient and that the Reader will know what was meant. Irrespective of what the student meant to write, the response will be evaluated on what was written. It is expected that beyond the mechanics, conclusions should be given in terms of the context of the question, whether it is an interpretation of the resulting confidence interval or an appropriate conclusion about the null hypothesis and how that conclusion was reached. If a question is presented in a context, the student must explicitly interpret the statistical results in that context.
Exploring Data
The graphical presentation of data is, of course, an excellent method of communicating about distributions of data and relations between variables. However, the effectiveness of graphs is compromised if the axes are not correctly labeled and scaled. In comparative displays, students frequently fail to label which group is associated with which display. Another common error is the use of different scales in a comparative setting. For example, the graphical clarity of comparative boxplots of the heights of males and females is destroyed if each boxplot has its own scale. Descriptions of distributions should as a matter of course address (in context) the center, spread, and shape, as well as unusual features such as outliers, gaps, and clusters. When comparing distributions, characteristics of each distribution should be mentioned explicitly. To say that distribution A is skewed to the right, for example, does not carry any implicit information that distribution B is not so skewed or that it may even be symmetric. In addition, comparative language must be used; for example, the median male adult height is greater than the median female adult height. This is quite different from simply listing the attributes of each distribution.
Planning Studies
Writing responses to questions about planning studies has historically been difficult for students. This is not surprising, as these questions tend to elicit the least formulaic responses and require a more exact use of statistical vocabulary. A student who, for example, struggles with hypothesis testing can demonstrate some knowledge by adhering to the stylistic form of the hypothesis-testing procedure. The writing style for discussion of methods of data collection and experimental design is almost blank verse by comparison. Some students are ambushed by this opportunity, writing long responses that may entirely fill the allotted space but that are, in effect, noncreditable answers. Possibly the best advice for responding to these questions is to know the vocabulary of sampling and experimental design and to write with precision using that vocabulary. In particular, when students are answering questions about experimental design, it is not uncommon for them to respond to questions that were not asked, leaving less time and space to respond effectively to the question that was asked. For example, if asked to identify a potential confounding variable in a particular scenario, it is not required nor is it necessarily helpful for students to provide a general definition of a confounding variable. If the intent of the question is to elicit such a definition, the wording will direct students to do so (see, for example, free-response question 3 on the 1999 exam). Some students adopt a shotgun strategy and attempt to regurgitate everything they remember about confounding variables in hopes that they will stumble on something relevant to the question. With holistic grading, it is more likely that the lack of focus in their answers will count against them. Students are advised to be careful when using statistical terms such as blocking, blinding, confounding, and the like. These words need to be used precisely and in context or a deduction is likely. The same caution applies to students use of vocabulary in sampling design versus experimental design.
216
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
Random Thoughts Students sometimes demonstrate confusion about the differing purposes of random selection versus random assignment in statistical studies. Below is a summary that my students have found helpful in clarifying this important distinction. Random selection is a method of obtaining a sample from a population of interest. Choosing a sample at random helps ensure that the individuals in the sample represent the population well. Random selection allows researchers to generalize sample results to the population as a whole. Random assignment of subjects to treatment groups in an experiment is the researchers best attempt to create groups that are as similar as possible before the treatments are administered. If the groups show significantly different responses, then researchers can attribute that difference to the treatments. In other words, random assignment helps researchers draw cause-and-effect conclusions from an experiment. Because the subjects in an experiment are usually not selected at random, this limits researchers ability to generalize findings to a larger population of individuals. Both random selection and random assignment introduce chance variation into a statistical study. Statisticians use sampling distributions to quantify this chance variation when they construct confidence intervals or perform significance tests. The distinction becomes important in determining the scope of conclusions one can draw from the study. The chart below (adapted from The Statistical Sleuth by Ramsey and Schafer) summarizes the different implications of random selection and random assignment in statistical studies.
Were subjects randomly selected? YES YES The researcher: may infer cause and effect; and may generalize findings to the population. The researcher: may not infer cause and effect; but may generalize findings to the population. NO The researcher: may infer cause and effect; but may not generalize findings to the population. The researcher: may not infer cause and effect; and may not generalize findings to the population. Daren Starnes, The Lawrenceville School, L awrenceville, New Jersey
Were subjects randomly assigned?
NO
Probability
Probability questions are the most mathlike questions on the AP Statistics Exam, and students who know how to solve these problems should be relatively comfortable doing so. The difficulties that they may have in this area tend to be more organizational than conceptual. Here are some simple strategies students can use to improve their chances of doing well on probability questions.
Students should state what formula they are using in their calculations and substitute values from the problem appropriatelyat that point, not before, they should pick up their calculator. If students are using a particular probability distribution, they should identify the distribution with appropriate parameters. For example: This is a binomial distribution with n = 24 and p = 0.35. If a problem requires a sequence of calculations, intermediate values should be shown. Generally, if a question has multiple dependent parts and a student makes an error on one of the early ones, the evaluation of successive parts will be based on whether the work presented is consistent with the work done earlier. That is, an error in part (a) will not automatically invalidate answers in parts (b), (c), and so on. Giving credit in the face of earlier errors depends on being able to trace the thread of reasoning through the problem.
217
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
Take advantage of graphic representations of the problem and response. Displays of Venn diagrams and tree diagrams and shading of normal curves can effectively convey students understanding of probability problems, as well as reduce ambiguity in the algebraic presentation of responses. Because probability questions are mathlike, it may be easy for students to forget that the question is presented in a context. They should not stop at just getting a numerical answer; the answer should also be embedded in the context of the problem as a complete sentence: for example, the probability of a randomly selected fish weighing between 2.3 and 4.1 pounds is 0.2157, or as a probability statement such as P (2.3 < X < 4.1) = 0.2157. Continue to caution against using calculator-speak. Writing something like binomcdf (12,0.4,7) = 0.9427 does not indicate to the Reader whether the student understands what the parameters for the distribution really are, nor does this count as showing your work. A more appropriate response would be: in a binomial distribution with n = 12 and p = 0.4, P (x < 8) = 0.9427. For examples on scoring such responses, see the scoring guidelines for question 3(b) on the 2007 AP Exam and question 3 on the 2006 exam. Emphasize the importance of effective communication. Credit is never given for just an answer. Some supporting work must be shown. Students should step back and make sure their answers are reasonable: for example, no probabilities greater than 1.
Inference
Answers to inference questions tend to be stylistic in nature, although presentations in textbooks are slightly different. Complete responses to inference questions in which the student uses hypothesis testing will generally require five components: 1. The correct statement of a set of hypotheses. Null and alternative hypotheses must be stated, correctly defining any notation used. H0, μ, and α, for example, are standard symbolic notations and need not be defined. However, the use of the symbols should be specified: for example, Let μ A represent the population mean height of corn under treatment A. The symbols as presented on the formula sheet should be regarded as defined and meaningful; other notation should be defined before use. A common error is to specify the symbols μ a and μb but then fail to link them to the particular populations under discussion. 2. Identification of an appropriate test procedure. The procedure and test statistic must be clearly specified. This should be in the usual statistical notation, avoiding the calculator form or listing the procedures for button pushing. The correct formula for the test statistic is usually the least ambiguous identification of a procedure, although a statement such as two-sample t test for independent means is also acceptable. 3. Identifying and checking the validity of appropriate assumptions. An important part of using inferential procedures is recognizing that all statistical models depend on assumptions that underlie and justify the procedures used in that model. If these assumptions are violated, then the procedures may produce inappropriate conclusions. The problem is that these assumptions are t ypically about populations and models and cannot be directly verified. Many times we know little about the population, so it is not reasonable to check whether such assumptions are true or not. Some assumptions, in fact, are unverifiable, and we just have to decide whether or not we believe they are true. If we have data, we can often decide if an assumption about the population or model is reasonable by checking a related condition based on the sample data to see if it is plausible to believe that the assumption about the population is true. For example, one of the assumptions for inference
218
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
procedures about a single mean is that the data were drawn from a normal population. Since we t ypically do not have access to the population data, we have no way to verify this assumption. Instead, we look for signs that this assumption is not reasonable. So the condition we check is whether there is evidence to convince us that it is unreasonable to believe the sample data came from a normal population. With a small data set, we have to worry about outliers and skewness, and we commonly check this condition using graphs: constructing a histogram, dotplot, or probability plot of the data. If there are no outliers or other indications of skewness, then the t-procedure can be justified. For complete communication, these graphs need to be included in the student response. Simply stating that there are no outliers, without including graphical evidence, is not sufficient. With the t-procedures, even if we have reason to believe the population is not normal, the procedure is still considered valid if the sample size is large, as then the sampling distribution of the sample mean is approximately normal. Notice this large sample size in no way implies that the original population was normal. How large the sample size needs to be varies by textbook (30 or 40 are common cut-offs) and also by the level of skewness in the data. Students should also exercise care when using is normal and is approximately normal. Rarely are we working with exactly normal distributions, so the qualifier approximately is important. Similarly with categorical data, different texts will counsel slightly different requirements, and no specific requirement is enforced by the questions scoring guidelines, though a few are commonly accepted in the statistical community. For example, requirements for using the large-sample z test for a single population proportion are usually stated in the format, np k , n 1 p k , but the actual value for k will differ depending on the text. What is important is that the student knows there are assumptions that underpin inferential procedures and recognizes which are appropriate conditions for the selected procedure and explicitly checks them, including appropriate justification. A common omission is the actual checking of the condition by substituting values for n, p, k and evaluating whether the conditions are metfor example, many students will write np 10 (or use some other value for k) and then put a check mark next to it thinking that they have checked the assumption or condition. In all cases, simply stating the conditions without checking them explicitly is not sufficient for a complete response. An excellent aid to understanding the difference between assumptions and conditions is Dave Bocks article, Is That an Assumption or a Condition? It can be found on the AP Statistics Course Home Page by scrolling down to Teaching Resource Materials and then to Statistical Inference. As Dave suggests, start making this distinction early in the year. 4. The correct mechanics. This is usually a matter of showing intermediate steps in an organized manner. The correct values of the test statistic, the level of significance, and the P-value, appropriately identified in the body of the work, are essential. 5. Correct conclusions stated in the context of the problem. Test statistics must be used to arrive at the correct conclusion, either via the P-value approach or a rejection region approach. Linkage between the conclusion and test result should be stated clearly; for example: Because the P-value is less than .05, the null hypothesis is rejected. Of critical importance is the conclusion stated in the context of the problem, consistent with the defined hypotheses. That is, a rejection of a null hypothesis should then be correctly interpreted as, say, providing evidence of a difference in the population parameters.
219
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
If confidence intervals are used for making inferences about population parameters, the considerations above still apply. One particular omission that seems to occur when confidence intervals are used is the check of conditions for the procedure. Both confidence intervals and hypothesis testing are based on the sampling distribution, and both procedures require checks of the conditions! If a confidence interval approach is used, a correct confidence interval statement is also required. Students frequently err by making an incorrect probability statement, or indicate that they have confidence that a sample value rather than a population value is in a certain interval.
Rounding Answers
Remind your students that it is best not to round numbers at intermediate steps in a calculation. Answers should be rounded only at the end and then not too much. For example, a z-score should be rounded to two decimal places in order to use the table, but each step in the calculation should not be rounded at all, or the f inal z-score may be quite different from what it would have been otherwise. A very general rule of thumb is that most answers can be rounded to two decimal places. Yet even then, an exception is made for calculating probabilities, which should be kept to four decimal places, thus matching the tables students will use during the exam.
Responding to Common Prompts
As students work through the free-response questions, they will be asked to respond in a variety of ways. Some questions can be quite straightforward, such as find the probability of. . . . Others are more implicit. It is suggested that you use some of the typical examples that follow or similar prompts and instructions throughout the year as you make writing an integral part of your course.
Students may be asked to make a choice between two alternatives. Not only should they make a decision and marshal their arguments for it; they must also explain why this choice is better by pointing to the weaknesses of the alternative approach. When asked to compare two distributions, students are not likely to receive credit if they just make a list of the attributes. Comparative wordsgreater than, less than, about the sameneed to be used when comparing center and spread; for example: There is less variability in the distribution of the weights of female bears than in the distribution of the weights of male bears. Directions to justify or explain the answer mean exactly that. These usually accompany questions that require a choice between alternatives, as mentioned above, or the answer to a yes or no question. Students are expected to explain why they chose that answer, using a statistical justification. Justifying an answer can also mean showing enough work so that the Reader can follow the logic. Answers without work will not receive credit, even if the question does not explicitly ask students to justify or explain. Students are expected to read the instructions at the beginning of the free-response questions; they will not be reminded along the way that they need to show their work and justify their answers. Using your answer in part (a) questions must have some reference to the work done in that part. Students must cite evidence that includes the calculation from part (a). If there is an error in the calculation of the first part, and the incorrect value (if it is plausible for the problem) is used correctly in subsequent calculations, students will only lose credit for the first mistake. If instructions in part (c) say using only your answers in parts (a) and (b), this usually means that no further calculations are necessary to answer this part. Students should explicitly reference and synthesize previous work in answering part (c). Those who go off in a new direction are wasting precious time and might actually incur a deduction.
220
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
Instructions such as include appropriate statistical evidence may mean that students should conduct some inference procedure or calculate a probability or some other statistical analysis as part of the justification for their answer. All work should be in the context of the problem. If students are asked to interpret a value, relationship, or concept, such as slope, correlation, a scatterplot, or confounding, they should not use generic terminology. For example: There is a strong negative linear relationship between the age of a driver and the distance at which highway exit signs can be clearly read by the driver.
Prove Yourself Justify your answer. These words commonly appear on AP Statistics Exam free-response questions, but students are sometimes unsure about exactly what this phrase is asking them to do. For many of these questions the actual answer is very short, sometimes consisting of a single sentence. But along with a correct answer to the question, students must also convince the Exam Reader that they have answered as they have for a sound, statistically correct reason. My advice to students is to always think of their answer in three parts: first, make a clear statement of the answer. Next, state the statistical concept that supports their answer. Then, finally, show how the stated concept supports the answer in the context of this question. This final link demonstrates that the student can accurately and confidently connect the details of a particular problem to his or her statistical knowledge. Peter Flanagan-Hyde, Phoenix Country Day School, Phoenix, Arizona
The Investigative Task
Finally, it is important to understand the philosophy and intent of question 6the investigative task. This is always the last question on the free-response portion of the AP Statistics Exam. For many students, and some teachers, it can be the most vexing question to approach and embrace. Covering all of the course content does not mean that you or your students have encountered a problem exactly like question 6 (in fact, it is intended to be unfamiliar to students). The purpose of the question is to take students beyond the topics taught in the course; yet the question must be accessible based on the concepts that they have learned over the year. Several parts of the investigative task may look reasonably familiar to students and assess standard elements of the curriculum. This might include a test of significance, some exploratory data analysis or probability, or some element of sampling and design. The investigative part is usually the last part and likely will present students with something they have never seen beforea situation that they will have to think about carefully and creatively, and whose correct analysis will involve applying familiar concepts and skills in a new way. The important question is: do students really understand the concepts sufficiently to use sound statistical thinking when confronted by a new situation? If you look through past investigative tasks, you will see all sorts of things you did not cover, such as a test for variance, one-sided confidence intervals, an elliptical graph based on some summary statistics and a correlation, or the construction of an interaction graph to be used to draw some conclusions. The idea is to present something that is not covered in the standard curriculum, except insofar as the curriculum includes imparting general skills that are applicable to new situations. Some of your students will rise to the challenge and shine, while others will make a good attempt at the investigation but fall somewhat short. Others may not be able to successfully answer the investigative part of the question but will do a good job on the first part that evaluates standard curricular concepts. Some teachers advise their students not to wait until the end of the 90-minute period for the free-response section, when they will be most tired, to attempt to answer question 6.
221
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
How do you prepare students for the investigative task? We teachers personally have probably had little preparation for this sort of question, either in our own education or in many of the textbooks we use. Surveying past investigative tasks can be instructive as to what was off the board curriculum-wise that year, and it can help students understand what is investigative about a problem and how they can approach it based on what they do know; however, looking at past investigations will not tell us what might happen on future exams. Some teachers have tried writing their own investigations; suggestions for such activities have occasionally been posted on the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group. It is worth noting that in recent years students have been doing better on the investigative task. Readers are not seeing as many blank papers, because students are being encouraged by their teachers to think creatively and to do something reasonable on these challenging problems. The important thing for students to remember is not to panic. What they are being asked to do is step outside their comfort zone for a moment and to think statistically, going beyond just knowledge of formulas and procedures. Such a request appears as one part of one question on a three-hour exam.
Year-End Review
The best way to adequately prepare students for the AP Exam is to deliver a solid, well-grounded course throughout the school year. By this reasoning, exam preparation begins on the first day, but there is still the need to allow adequate time for exam review and preparation. For many teachers this is somewhere between two and four weeks. There are many strategies for conducting a successful review. Some of these have been illustrated in the sample syllabi in chapter 3. Others are listed below.
Use one of the available review books. A number of these are listed in chapter 5, Resources for Teachers. If you do not have the AP Released Exams in your possession, you might be able to acquire them from experienced teachers. They can also be purchased online at store.collegeboard.com. Give your students the Statistics Practice Exam available on AP Central to teachers whose syllabi have met the course audit requirements. Work with your schools AP Coordinator to ensure that students are aware of all the rules and procedures associated with the exam so that extraneous factors will not add to their stress level. Some schools hold a mock exam on a Saturday morning sometime in April, using one of the Released Exams. This event allows students to actually experience the testing conditions they will experience on exam day and helps them develop a better sense of how to manage their time so as to get though both sections of the exam, especially the free-response section. Some schools do this individually if traveling is problematic, whereas others conduct it in cooperation with other high schools in their area. (See the Review for the AP Exam section of Jeane Swaynoss syllabus for her description of the mock exam at Seminole High School.) All teachers agree beforehand not to use the problems from the proposed mock exam during the rest of the year. If you have a local AP Statistics support group, it could serve as the organizational vehicle to disseminate information and get the ball rolling. Share and discuss sample student responses and scoring guidelines when you do past AP Exam questions in class (all are available on AP Central). Additional student responses can be obtained at one- and two-day or weeklong College Board workshops. Let your students grade their classmates work, if your school has no policy prohibiting this. If such a policy exists, then have them grade their own work. I have successfully used the following approach: I choose an AP problem based on the current or a past topic and give it as an in-class, timed (12 to 15 minutes) writing assignment. Once students have completed the assignment, I review the scoring guidelines with them. Then the
222
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
class practices evaluating a set of sample student responses drawn from workshops and AP Central. They score several papers, and I discuss the score that the paper actually received and why. Finally, they score their own response to the problem given at the beginning of the period. I then pick up the papers and recheck their judgments. Incorporate old AP Exam questions either on tests or as independent problem sets. Quite a few teachers include an AP free-response question on each test throughout the year. Starting early in the year, I also give students one or two free-response problems each week, which I call an AP set (see chapter 3). Students have five or six days to work on this set and then turn it in. They may use their notes and textbook, but they must work alone. I then score their work using the published guidelines (which I share with them), return it, and discuss the questions. It is important for students to understand precisely how the AP Exam is scored and what is valued. There is no more educational moment than the revelation that computations alone do not get them very far without accompanying explanations, interpretations, and justifications. The problem-set strategy has been particularly effective for me. I direct you to several of the syllabi in chapter 3, where the authors among them Josh Tabor, Dora Daniluk, and Michael Allwooddiscuss some of their favorite AP problems. Build cumulative review exercises into your homework assignments. Most statistics textbooks do not use a spiral approach nor do they contain much in the way of cumulative reviews. Because the exam is not organized by topic, students need to have some practice in applying and integrating statistical procedures that were studied early in the course and have not been used for a while. You can also try to adopt a statistical process approach to all problems from the beginning of the course, thinking about issues of design, analysis, and scope of conclusions every time. Go to the Exam Tips: Statistics link on the AP Statistics Course Home Page. Here you will find observations from the Chief Reader and exam tips for teachers and students. Share the instructions for the exam with students. For example, some AP Exams are to be done in pen, whereas others are strictly pencil. The AP Statistics Exam can be written in pen or pencil. Review with students the acceptable use policies concerning calculator enhancements. These can be found on the AP Statistics Course Home Page. A complete set of exam instructions can be found in the Released Exams or obtained from your schools AP Coordinator.
The tone of the year-end reviews should be positive and upbeat. Students are in the home stretch and may begin to wane in their enthusiasm. A pep talk may be helpful. I try to convey my belief that they can do well on the AP Exam, but that they need to work hard and stay focused through the review to gain the best advantage they can. After all, you and your students are in this together. None of us know what questions will be on the exam. A brief perusal of the experimental design questions, for example, shows that each one has been quite different and that using past problems to predict future questions is probably not useful. The common goal for everyone is a job well done. I am their cheerleader in this. I also remind them that they should be well rested. Despite the claim of many students that they work well under pressure, last minute, late-night cramming can be highly counterproductive. My second trimester exam in February is a three-hour mock AP Exam. There are 40 multiple-choice questions, drawn from the 1997 exam, the multiple-choice questions in the several editions of the Course Description, and some of my own, along with six free-response questions from past AP Exams. Because students have already done the three-hour exam, I do not feel the necessity of repeating the experience during the intense review time at the end of the year. The first week of review is a category-by-category synopsisone day each on experimental design, exploratory data analysis, probability and random variables, regression, and sampling distributions.
223
Chapter 4 Chapter 1
Assignments during this week include some of the released free-response problems I havent yet used, several investigative tasks, and several sets of multiple-choice questions I have assembled over the years. On Friday of this review week, the students are given the 2002 Released Exam to complete on their own time. I ask them to set aside two blocks of 90 minutes over the next four days to accomplish this, using only their formula sheets and tables from the exam, plus their calculators. This extended time period allows students to schedule the exam around their other academic and family obligations. Once they turn it in, I grade it, and we go over it using the scoring guidelines for the free-response questions. We fill in any remaining review time with free-response problems remaining from past exams.
After the Exam
Every year there are suggestions on the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group concerning what to do with the gap of time that some school districts have between the administration of the AP Exam and the end of the school year. This may be an opportune time for an independent project that lets students explore an area of interest to them and display what they have learned during the year. Because students sometimes have difficulty choosing a project topic, some sources and suggestions are included in the following list.
Each syllabus in chapter 3 has some suggestions for student activities, including projects. For example, both Josh Tabor and Jared Derksen describe projects exploring the concept of bias. There are many suggestions listed in the article After the Exam: Activities and Projects, listed under Teacher Resource Materials on the AP Statistics Course Home Page. You can also find quite a few examples of past projects on several of the experienced teacher Web sites (an excellent source is Al Coons, www.bbn-school.org/us/math/ap_stats).
Below are some specific projects that students might enjoy researching: Does bread really fall butter side down? Which type of cookie (chocolate chip, sugar, or oatmeal raisin) do students prefer? Are certain golf balls better than others for putting?
A project might not suit everyones needs, so here are several other suggestions: Some teachers show one of the films or videos listed under Multimedia Resources in chapter 5. These teachers have developed several handouts and worksheets that can be found by searching the discussion archives. Chapter 5 also contains a list of suggested popular books that you might find useful. These include several titles by John Allen Paulos, Damned Lies and Statistics by Joel Best, Freakonomics by Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner, and Polling Matters by Frank Newport. Teach a few additional topics. Chapters on multiple regression and ANOVA are frequently included in textbooks and are not very hard to introduce to students who have completed the AP Statistics Topic Outline.
224
The AP Exam in Statistics About AP Statistics
Schools (Almost) Out for Summer Each year after the AP Statistics Exam, I have students complete a project of their choice. The goal is to review and use several big ideas from the field of statistics in a way that is interesting and fun. Before they can begin, each project must be approved. The project must involve collecting and analyzing data, displaying data, inference, and presenting the findings to the class. I consult and arrange administrative approval if necessary (surveys at lunch, for example). We take two or three days to present projects to the class. Students may choose to work individually or in groups of two or three. Students in the past have analyzed the mean weights of different types of Hersheys Kisses,® analyzed our state graduation exam data, compared NCAA basketball conferences by creating a rating formula and using data available on the Internet, surveyed students about various issues, compared accuracy of generic versus brand-name paint balls (by shooting at a target on a barngeneric were better), compared distance and accuracy of dimpleless versus regular golf balls, and tested whether eating a mint affects the time required to solve a simple puzzle (as their elementary school teacher once claimed). Some of the best learning has occurred from projects that did not turn out as students expected! Dave Ferris, Noblesville High School, Noblesville, Indiana
Rules for Discussing the Exam Questions with Students
Teachers should take the opportunity to talk about each years most recent AP Exam with their students, within the established boundaries. Any discussion should start with a reminder to students about their agreement not to disclose any of the actual multiple-choice questions that appeared on their exam. The reason for maintaining the security of the 40 multiple-choice questions is the inclusion of the equating questions from a past exam. If these equating questions were disclosed, they could not be used in the future, and year-to-year comparisons would be compromised. The free-response questions are posted on AP Central 48 hours after the administration of the exam. Until that time, you cannot discuss them with students, but you may fully do so afterward. If some of your students take the alternate exam during the late-testing period, you are never allowed to discuss those freeresponse questions, because the alternate exam is not released. My concern, first and foremost, is to know if there were any topics for which my students felt unprepared or felt especially well prepared. The focus needs to be on general questions. You may certainly ask students how well the course prepared them to answer questions on regression or probability, for example, without getting into the specifics of actual exam questions.
Feedback from the AP Exam
AP Grade Reports
AP grades are reported to students, their schools, and their designated colleges in July. Each school automatically receives an AP Grade Report for each student, a cumulative roster of all students, rosters of all students by exam, an AP Scholar roster for any qualifying students, and an AP Instructional Planning Report. (Note: Data for students testing late with an alternate form of the exam are not included in this report.) For a fee, schools may also request their students free-response booklets.
225
Chapter 4 Chapter 1 Using the AP Instructional Planning Report
Schools receive the AP Instructional Planning Report for each of their AP classes in September. The report compares your students performance on specific topics in the AP Exam to the performance of students worldwide on those same topics, helping you target areas for increased attention and focus in the curriculum. To get the most out of the report, please read the interpretive information on the document. It explains how the data, when used correctly, can provide valuable information for instructional and curricular assessment as well as for planning and development. Contact your schools AP Coordinator for this report. Many factors can influence exam results. Differences in performance between your students and the worldwide group may be the result of any number of factors. Some of these might be different instructional methods, differences in emphasis or preparation on particular parts of the examination, differences in curriculum during the pre-AP years, or differences in student background and preparation in comparison with the global group. Using the AP Instructional Planning Report you can compare your students performance to the global group on the multiple-choice and free-response sections of the exam. Scores are broken down into four categories: lowest, second, third, and highest quartiles. The quartiles do not correspond to the final AP grades of 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5. The report also compares the global group to your students results for the four content areas of the multiple-choice questionsexploring data, probability and simulation, statistical inference, and sampling and experimentation. For example, if your students seem to be scoring in the lowest fourth on the sampling and experimental design multiple-choice questions, it may indicate a content area to which you should devote more attention next year. Or it may mean that your students just need more practice completing multiple-choice questions about sampling and design. Each of the six free-response questions uses the same performance categories of quartiles. Examine each question carefully, looking for similarities and differences between your students performance and that of the global group. Is the mean performance for your students the same as the global mean? How difficult did your students find the question (or group of questions) compared with the global group? If your group is below the global population only on free-response questions, for example, writing and organizational skills may need to be emphasized in the future. The AP Instructional Planning Report is meant to provide valuable feedback in order to help you assess the progress of your course and point to areas of success as well as areas that may need more attention. Be sure to take advantage of it.
226
Chapter 5 Resources for Teachers
Useful Informaton Sources
The following resources will be helpful to both new and experienced teachers of AP Statistics. Some of these sources contain information that may be at a more advanced level than the AP Statistics course, and they are included to assist teachers who wish to extend their knowledge in specific or general statistical areas. Others are relevant to the teaching of statistics in general, or to particular topics in the AP Statistics curriculum. Because such a large amount of material is available, you should approach your acquisition of resources in stages. As you expand your collection of resources, you can begin to add textbook support materials, news articles, magazines, journals, newsletters, movies, and other multimedia items. The first thing you will want to choose is the textbook that best suits the needs of your students. Next, essential information about the AP Exam can be found in the Course Description, in AP Statistics Released Exams, and on AP Central. The Course Description, discussed in chapter 1, is available in downloadable format on AP Central. In this book you will find about a dozen multiple-choice questions indicative of those that appear on the AP Exam. Note that they are not computational in nature and not calculatordriven. If you have an older version of the Course Description (before 2004) or happen to know someone who does, the multiple-choice set in that book is different. You might try to get your hands on this older set in order to have more multiple-choice questions available for your use. Printed versions of complete AP Exams are usually released every four or five years. The 2007 and 2002 AP Statistics Exams are currently available at store.collegeboard.com. Each Released Exam contains both the multiple-choice and free-response questions and solutions, along with scoring guidelines and commentary on the scoring. The Released Exam is where you can read about how the exam is developed and scored, how Readers are trained to score the free-response questions, the instructions that students will be given on the day of the actual exam, and the scoring worksheet and comments on how the actual AP grade is determined. Free-response questions and scoring guidelines from past years are available at no cost on the AP Statistics Exam Page on AP Central. This includes free-response questions from recent Form B exams (the overseas exam). In addition, there are three actual student responses for each question, along with commentary on the scoring of each response. Be sure to also avail yourself of the AP Statistics Practice Exam (which includes both multiple-choice and free-response questions) that is available as a free download if your syllabus has been approved in the AP Course Audit process. The following compilation was current as of the writing of this publication; however, the reader should be aware that new books and teaching aids are being introduced all the time. A continuing source for learning about the latest resources is the AP Central Web site, which is described in detail in chapter 2. Some of the resources included here are also listed at AP Central, with descriptions and evaluations by statisticians and teachers of AP Statistics. (Note: This list of resources is not meant as an endorsement by the College Board or the AP Statistics Development Committee of any particular publication or author.)
227
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
Print Resources
Basic Textbooks
There is no one textbook that will be the best for all students in all situations. The information presented here is meant to provide you with some of the basics of each text. Carefully consider the merits of each book as they apply to your students. You may want to obtain sample copies (available from the publishers Web sites) and look through them, comparing the style of presentation, examples provided in the body of the text, and practice exercises. Are the problems interesting, varied, and of sufficient number to provide several assignments as well as review? One way you might approach this is to choose a topic, such as one-sample confidence intervals, and read through the appropriate chapter in each text you are considering. Does the style of writing and presentation fit with your style of teaching and how you think about statistics? How accessible are the writing and problems to your students? Some of the books include calculator instructions and keystrokes in the body of the examples and reading, whereas others list them at the end of the chapter or in separate sections within the chapter. Even though it is essential that students have intimate knowledge of the statistical capabilities of the calculator, you need to consider when that instruction will occur. In addition, most of these texts have companion Web sites that contain demonstration applets for student and teacher use, test banks, solutions manuals, an instructors guide, and/or supplemental review materials. You will want to examine these as well. Some are accompanied by a CD-ROM of data sets from the textbook that are easily downloadable in various formats to statistical software. Statistical software can also be bundled with several of the texts for an additional charge. The best place to gather information about this support material is to go to the publishers Web site. Although you may be using one publishers textbook you may, in fact, prefer to use the AP review material from another. Look at the various guides, or ask someone who is currently teaching the course for advice. With that in mind, the following list includes those texts that are most often cited, discussed, and recommended on the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group (EDG). They are in alphabetical order by lead author.
Bock, David E., Paul F. Velleman, and Richard D. De Veaux. Stats: Modeling the World. 2nd ed. Boston:
Pearson/Addison-Wesley, 2007. The style of this textbook is a bit more informal and colloquial than several of the other texts. There are lots of exercises to choose from, and in some cases the same data are used in more than one context. For example, an exercise that appears in the chapter on probability may also be used in the inference chapter on comparing counts (chi-square). The teachers edition comes bundled with a CD containing ActivStats. An AP Exam review guide with four mock exams is also available (see the Exam Review Guides section later in this chapter).
Moore, David S., and George P. McCabe. Introduction to the Practice of Statistics. 5th ed. New York:
W. H. Freeman, 2006. This text can be somewhat daunting. Some of the sections are quite long, and breaking them up into manageable chunks takes some experience and a good sense of organization. On the other hand, it is very well written, and a wealth of support material is available, including a CD containing data sets and practice problems. The fifth edition has been updated with lots of new exercises, and sample output screens have been added for Minitab, SPSS, JMP, T1-83/84, and Crunchit! This text can be a bit overwhelming for a first-year teacher of the course, but if you are reasonably confident of your statistics background, it can be a very effective book. Because it is a college text, it lacks some of the flavor of AP-type problems, which you will have to find through other sources.
228
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Peck, Roxy, Chris Olsen, and Jay Devore. Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis. 3rd ed. Belmont,
Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2008. The authors are well known and have been highly involved with the AP Statistics program. Roxy Peck is a former Chief Reader for the AP Statistics Exam, and Chris Olsen was on the original Development Committee and is a very frequent contributor to the EDG. This was one of the first texts to be written specifically for AP Statistics. A large resource binder and a complete test bank are available.
Watkins, Ann E., Richard L. Scheaffer, and George W. Cobb. Statistics in Action: Understanding a World
of Data. Emeryville, Calif.: Key Curriculum Press, 2004. The philosophy of the authors, who are known nationally in the field of statistics education, is that statistical work is much more active than it was a generation ago. Gathering data, exploring data, and making inferences from data should be a hands-on experience. This text is an activity-based approach that will be familiar to those who have seen Activity-Based Statistics (see the Supplementary Textbooks section below).
Yates, Daniel S., David S. Moore, and Daren S. Starnes. The Practice of Statistics: TI 83/84/89 Graphing
Calculator Enhanced. 3rd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2007. This text is an updated version of the 1999 first edition by Yates, Moore, and McCabe (one of the first to be geared toward a high school audience) and the 2003 second edition by Yates, Moore, and Starnes. As with the other texts, the companion Web site contains plenty of fine support material, applets, and online demonstrations. Ancillary resources in the Golden Resource Binder are considered outstanding by many teachers. The third edition includes a new AP Exam prep guide (see the Exam Review Guides section below). Other textbooks will most certainly be published in the future that will align with the AP Statistics curriculum. I urge you to regularly visit the AP Statistics Course Home Page at AP Central. There you will find more than 150 reviews of teaching resources, including current and newly published textbooks, all written by experienced statistics instructors. There are lots of textbooks available, but many were not written with this course in mind. Please consider your choices carefully. A good textbook is an essential element for a successful course and for making your life a bit easier.
Supplementary Textbooks
In addition to the primary textbook that you select for your course, there are many other fine textbooks on the market that present challenging statistical concepts particularly well, for both your understanding and that of your students. Some of these are listed below. Commentaries are included for selected books in this list. Chance, Beth L., and Allan J. Rossman. Investigating Statistical Concepts, Applications, and Methods. Pacific Grove, Calif: Duxbury Press, 2005. Chatterjee, Samprit, Mark S. Handcock, and Jeffrey S. Simonoff. A Casebook for a First Course in Statistics and Data Analysis. New York: Wiley, 1995. Freedman, David, Robert Pisani, and Roger Purves. Statistics. 4th ed. New York: W. W. Norton, 2007. This is a text that I usually turn to first when I need to check some concept. Hand, D. J. et al., eds. A Handbook of Small Data Sets. New York: Chapman and Hall, 1994.
229
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
McClave, James T., and Terry Sincich. Statistics. 11th ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson/Prentice Hall, 2007. Moore, David S. The Basic Practice of Statistics. 4th ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2007. Moore, David S., and William I. Notz. Statistics: Concepts and Controversies. 6th ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2006. This is an excellent source of ideas for free-response questions and writing exercises. Peck, Roxy et al. Statistics: A Guide to the Unknown. 4th ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2006. A compendium of well-written essays and case studies on applications of statistics from the fields of business and industry, public policy and social science, biology and medicine, and others. This is an excellent source of supplemental readings to enhance any introductory statistics course. Ramsey, Fred L, and Daniel W. Schafer. The Statistical Sleuth: A Course in Methods of Data Analysis. 2nd ed. Pacific Grove, Calif.: Thomson/Duxbury, 2002. It would be difficult to find a book that matches the philosophy of the AP Statistics course as well as this one. Although it could not reasonably be used as a textbook for the AP course, it is an ideal resource for teachers. It is organized around case studies, and the data are very real and interesting. Rossman, Allan J., and Beth L. Chance. Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data. 2nd ed. Emeryville, Calif.: Key College Publishing, 2001. The third edition will be published in 2008. The Workshop Statistics books contain an excellent series of student-centered, hands-on activities that are well written and easy to follow. Students can explore statistical principles, discover statistical concepts, and apply the various statistical techniques to interesting data sets. Many teachers use this as a supplemental text to other written sources, because some AP topics are not included in this book. Technology-specific versions are also available: see the next three listings. Rossman, Allan J., and Beth L. Chance. Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data and Minitab. 2nd ed. Emeryville, Calif.: Key College Publishing, 2001. Rossman, Allan J., Beth L. Chance, and Robin H. Lock. Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data and Fathom. Emeryville, Calif.: Key College Publishing, 2001. Rossman, Allan J., Beth L. Chance, and J. Barr von Oehsen. Workshop Statistics: Discovery with Data and the Graphing Calculator. 2nd ed. Emeryville, Calif.: Key College Publishing, 2002. Salsburg, David. The Lady Tasting Tea: How Statistics Revolutionized Science in the Twentieth Century. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2001. This book is a wonderful supplement for those interested in the history of statistics. Although not an easy read, I would recommend it as independent reading for any interested student of statistics and as terrific background reading for teachers. Scheaffer, Richard L., William Mendenhall III, and R. Lyman Ott. Elementary Survey Sampling. 6th ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2006. Scheaffer, Richard L., Ann E. Watkins, Jeffrey A. Witmer, and Mrudulla Gnanadesikan. Revised by Tim Erickson. Activity-Based Statistics. 2nd ed. Emeryville, Calif.: Key College Publishing, 2004. Siegel, Andrew F., and Charles J. Morgan. Statistics and Data Analysis: An Introduction. 2nd ed. New York: Wiley, 1996. Tufte, Edward R. The Visual Display of Quantitative Information. 2nd ed. Cheshire, Conn.: Graphics Press, 2001.
230
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Utts, Jessica M. Seeing Through Statistics. 3rd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2005. Each chapter starts with several interesting and useful thought questions. These make nice writing exercises. Utts, Jessica M., and Robert F. Heckard. Mind on Statistics. 3rd ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2007. One of my favorite books, this contains lots of nice problems and data sets.
Exam Review Guides
Several exam preparation books are available for AP Statistics. Many teachers use these for end-of-year review. Others have used them for semester and trimester review as well. Some of the titles below are available only from the publishing company, whereas others can be purchased in your local bookstore. Bohan, James. AP Statistics: Preparing for the AP Examination. New York: AMSCO School Publications, 2000. (Order at www.amscopub.com.) Carroll, Anne M., Ruth E. Carver, Susan A. Peters, and Janice D. Ricks. Preparing for the Statistics AP Exam with Stats: Modeling the World, 2nd ed. AP Test Prep series. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson/Prentice Hall, 2007. (Order from the company.) Hinders, Duane. 5 Steps to a 5: AP Statistics. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2004. (Available in bookstores.) Legacy, Michael. Prep for the AP Exam Guide for Yates, Moore, and Starness The Practice of Statistics, 3rd ed. New York: W. H. Freeman, 2008. (Order from the company.) Levine-Wissing, Robin, and David W. Thiel. The Best Test Preparation for the AP Statistics Exam. Piscataway, N.J.: Research and Education Association, 2006. (Available in bookstores.) Sternstein, Martin. Barrons AP Statistics: How to Prepare for the Advanced Placement Exam. 3rd ed. Hauppauge, N.Y.: Barrons Educational Series, 2004. (Available in bookstores.)
Newspapers and Magazines
Statistics, in one form or another, can always be found in the news. This is one of the reasons that this course is particularly relevant for students! Make it a habit to check your local newspaper for current studies or news articles that have a statistical bent. For example, a good source for graphs is USA Today. The science section of the New York Times, or Science News, which your science department may receive, provide lots of useful material. You might want to pass out the articles and have students discuss the statistical aspects of the stories. Some teachers distribute a news report, then have students go online to the original journal of publication, download the study, and compare the actual study with what the news article reported. Did the reporter get it right? I have also found pertinent articles in Time, Newsweek, U.S. News and World Report, and the Economist. Collect articles and keep a file! You may use an article or clipping in class, or it may be the basis for a test question.
Popular Reading
Below is a list of suggested readings for both students and teachers, gleaned from a variety of sources and teachers recommendations. Some teachers have used these during their postAP Exam period, whereas others have assigned parts of these works for summer reading. Bernstein, Peter L. Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk. New York: Wiley, 1996.
231
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
Best, Joel. Damned Lies and Statistics: Untangling Numbers from the Media, Politicians, and Activists. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001. Crossen, Cynthia. Tainted Truth: The Manipulation of Fact in America. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1994. The author contends that we are continually awash in facts that originate from researchers beholden to corporations. Desrosières, Alain. The Politics of Large Numbers: A History of Statistical Reasoning. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1998. This is a quite demanding, complex, and sophisticated look at the history of statistics and an analysis of its function within the state. Dewdney, A. K. 200% of Nothing: An Eye-Opening Tour Through the Twists and Turns of Math Abuse and Innumeracy. New York: Wiley, 1993. Glassner, Barry. The Culture of Fear: Why Americans Are Afraid of the Wrong Things. New York: Basic Books, 1999. The book deals with popular misconceptions of the relative risk of many activities. Gould, Stephen Jay. Full House: The Spread of Excellence from Plato to Darwin. New York: Harmony Books, 1996. This one is challenging. Huff, Darrell. How to Lie with Statistics. New York: W. W. Norton, 1954. Levitt, Steven D., and Stephen J. Dubner. Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything. New York: William Morrow, 2005. Newport, Frank. Polling Matters: Why Leaders Must Listen to the Wisdom of the People. New York: Warner Books, 2004. Paulos, John Allen. Beyond Numeracy: Ruminations of a Numbers Man. New York: Knopf, 1991. Visit Pauloss interesting and thought-provoking home page at www.math.temple.edu/~paulos. Paulos, John Allen. Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and Its Consequences. New York: Hill and Wang, 1988. Paulos, John Allen. A Mathematician Plays the Stock Market. New York: Basic Books, 2003. Paulos, John Allen. A Mathematician Reads the Newspaper. New York: Basic Books, 1995. Paulos, John Allen. Once upon a Number: The Hidden Mathematical Logic of Stories. New York: Basic Books, 1998.
Professional Reading
This collection of readings will provide you with additional content and pedagogy beyond the level of the course. It may be useful for increasing your understanding of some of the courses key concepts and topics. American Statistical Association. Guidelines for Assessment and Instruction in Statistics Education (GAISE) Report. Alexandria, Va.: American Statistical Association, 2005. w ww.amstat.org/education/gaise/. Babbie, Earl. The Practice of Social Research. 11th ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson/Wadsworth, 2007.
232
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Book, Stephen A. Why n1 in the Formula for the Sample Standard Deviation? Two-Year College Mathematics Journal 10 (1979): 330-33. Box, George E. P., William G. Hunter, and J. Stuart Hunter. Statistics for Experimenters: An Introduction to Design, Data Analysis, and Model Building. New York: Wiley, 1978. Campbell, Donald T., and Julian C. Stanley. Experimental and Quasi-experimental Designs for Research. Chicago: Rand McNally, 1963. Cleveland, William S. Visualizing Data. Summit, N.J.: Hobart Press, 1993. Cobb, George W. Introduction to Design and Analysis of Experiments. New York: Springer, 1998. Cobb, George W. Teaching Statistics: More Data, Less Lecturing. In Heeding the Call for Change: Suggestions for Curricular Action, ed. Lynn Arthur Steen. Washington, D.C.: Mathematical Association of America, 1992. Cobb, George W., and David S. Moore. Mathematics, Statistics, and Teaching. American Mathematical Monthly 104 (November 1997): 801-23. Everitt, B. S. The Cambridge Dictionary of Statistics. 3rd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006. Gal, Iddo, and Joan B. Garfield, eds. The Assessment Challenge in Statistics Education. Amsterdam: IOS Press, 1997. Garfield, Joan. How Students Learn Statistics. International Statistical Review 63, no. 1 (1995): 2534. Garfield, Joan, and Andrew Ahlgren. Difficulties in Learning Basic Concepts in Probability and Statistics: Implications for Research. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 19 (1988): 4463. Garfield, Joan, and Iddo Gal. Assessment and Statistics Education: Current Challenges and Directions. International Statistical Review 67, no. 1 (1999): 112. Gelman, Andrew, and Deborah Nolan. Teaching Statistics: A Bag of Tricks. New York: Oxford University Press, 2002. Gordon, Florence, and Sheldon Gordon, eds. Statistics for the Twenty-first Century. Washington, D.C.: Mathematical Association of America, 1992. Hamilton, Lawrence C. Regression with Graphics: A Second Course in Applied Statistics. Pacific Grove, Calif.: Brooks/Cole, 1992. Hoaglin, David C., and David S. Moore, eds. Perspectives on Contemporary Statistics. Washington, D.C.: Mathematical Association of America, 1992. Law, Averill M. Simulation Modeling and Analysis. 4th ed. Boston: McGraw-Hill, 2006. Lovett, Marcia C., and Joel B. Greenhouse. Applying Cognitive Theory to Statistics Instruction. American Statistician 54, no. 3 (August 2000): 196206.
233
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
Misra, S. Chandra, Hardeo Sahai, Anil P. Gore, and Joseph K. Garrett. A Bibliography on the Teaching of Probability and Statistics. American Statistician 41, no. 4 (November 1987): 284310. Moore, David S. New Pedagogy and New Content: The Case of Statistics. International Statistical Review 65, no. 2 (1997): 123-65. Moore, Thomas L. Teaching Statistics: Resources for Undergraduate Instructors. Washington D.C.: Mathematical Association of America, 2000. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. Principles and Standards for School Mathematics. Reston, Va.: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2000. Available electronically for 120-day free access at http://standards.nctm.org. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. Thinking and Reasoning with Data and Chance: 68th NCTM Yearbook. Reston, Va.: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2006. Peters, William Stanley. Counting for Something: Statistical Principles and Personalities. New York: Springer, 1987. Rosner, Bernard. Fundamentals of Biostatistics. 6th ed. Belmont, Calif.: Thomson Brooks/Cole, 2006. Ross, Sheldon M. A First Course in Probability. 7th ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J.: Pearson/Prentice Hall, 2006. Shaughnessy, J. Michael, and Beth L. Chance. Statistical Questions from the Classroom. Reston, Va.: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2005. Singer, Judith D., and John B. Willett. Improving the Teaching of Applied Statistics: Putting the Data Back into Data Analysis. American Statistician 44, no. 3 (August 1990): 223-30.
Print/Online Journals and Newsletters
Journals and newsletters are excellent sources of information on the latest thinking and/or findings in statistics. In addition, they often provide broader perspectives as you expand your understanding of statistics. A collection of the most common journals and newsletters in the field are presented below. Many are available online. American Statistician. w ww.amstat.org/publications/tas. Published by the American Statistical Association, this publication has an interesting regular feature, Teachers Corner. Chance. w ww.amstat.org/publications/chance. Jointly published by the American Statistical Association and Springer, Chance is an entertaining magazine about contemporary uses of statistics. It is intended for anyone who has an interest in the analysis of data. Chance features articles that showcase the use of statistical methods and ideas in the social, biological, physical, and medical sciences. It also presents material about statistical computing and graphical presentation of data. Through its regular departments and columns, Chance keeps its readers informed about developments and ideas in a variety of areas, including government statistics and sports.
234
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Journal of Statistics Education. w ww.amstat.org/publications/jse. JSE is a publication of the American Statistical Association, disseminating knowledge for the improvement of statistics education at all levels, including elementary, secondary, and postsecondary education. It is distributed electronically and, in accord with its broad focus, publishes articles that enhance the exchange of interesting and useful information among educators, practitioners, and researchers around the world. The intended audience includes anyone who teaches statistics, as well as those interested in research on statistical and probabilistic reasoning. Mathematics Teacher. w ww.nctm.org/publications. This monthly magazine published by the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics offers activities, lesson ideas, teaching strategies, and problems through in-depth articles, departments, and features. Statistics Teacher Network. w ww.amstat.org/education/stn. This newsletter is published three times a year by the American Statistical Association and the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics Joint Committee on Curriculum in Statistics and Probability. STN is a free publication whose purpose is to keep grade K12 teachers informed about statistical workshops, programs, and reviews of books, software, and calculators. In addition, articles describing successful classroom statistical activities are included. STATS: The Magazine for Students of Statistics. w ww.amstat.org/publications/stats. STATS magazine, published by the American Statistical Association, contains career information, student experiences, current problems and case studies, humor, and stories from leaders in statistical science. The goal of STATS is to promote the field of statistics and make its contributions accessible to a broad audience. Teaching Statistics: An International Journal for Teachers. w ww.blackwell-synergy.com/loi/test?cookieSet=1. This journal seeks to help teachers of biology, business studies, economics, geography, mathematics, and the social sciences by showing how statistical ideas can illuminate their work and how to make proper use of statistics in their teaching. It is also directed toward those who teach statistics as a separate subject and to those who teach statistics in conjunction with mathematics courses. The emphasis of the articles is on teaching and the classroom. Its aim is to inform, entertain, encourage and enlighten all who use statistics in their teaching or who teach statistics per se.
Multimedia Resources
Multimedia, when used effectively, can be an engaging tool for students in the total learning process for AP Statistics. The following software packages and videos are just some of the many that are available.
Computer Software
Teaching Software ActivStats. w ww.datadesk.com/products/mediadx/activstats.
235
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
Fathom. w ww.keypress.com/fathom. Statistics Packages Data Desk. w ww.datadesk.com. JMP. w ww.jmpdiscovery.com. Minitab. w ww.minitab.com/products. Note: Releases 14 and 15 have many excellent upgrades for elementary data displays. Network and single-user versions are available. Other Software R statistical software. w ww.r-project/org. Available for free on the Web at the R Project for Statistical Computing. R FAQs http://cran.r-project.org/bin/windows/base/rw-FAQ.html. StatCrunch: Data Analysis on the Web. w ww.statcrunch.com. This used to be free but now must be purchased. It can be downloaded from the Web site. WinStat. http://math.exeter.edu/rparris/winstats.html. This software, by Rick Parris at Phillips Exeter Academy, will do pretty much anything statistical. It is updated regularly.
Commercial Films
And the Band Played On. 1993. Directed by Roger Spottiswoode. HBO. 140 mins. This movie is based on a book by Randy Shilts about the early years of the AIDS epidemicsomewhat controversial but contains lots of statistics. See Zack Bigners Web site (linked through the AP Statistics FAQ site listed in the Web Sites section of this chapter) for several worksheets about this movie. As in all teaching situations, it is important to know your community norms when deciding whether to use a particular resource. A Civil Action. 1998. Directed by Steven Zaillian. Touchstone Pictures. 115 mins. The subject is a lawsuit brought against a company for polluting the environment. See the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group of May 2004 for several worksheets on this movie.
Educational Films
Against All Odds: Inside Statistics. 1989. Written by David S. Moore. Lexington, Mass.: Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications (COMAP). 26 half-hour segments. VHS or DVD. Available for online viewing (not downloading). w ww.learner.org/resources/series65.html.
236
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Statistics: Decisions Through Data. 1992. Written by David S. Moore. Lexington, Mass.: Consortium for Mathematics and Its Applications (COMAP). Five hour-long videos with users guide (total of 21 video segments). VHS or DVD. w ww.comap.com/product/?idx=200.
Web Sites
American Statistical Association. Links to useful applet sites. w ww.amstat.org/sections/educ/applets.html. AP Statistics Course Home Page. apcentral.collegeboard.com/stats. AP Central is the single, best source for all information and resources relating to AP Statistics. The site is described extensively in chapter 2. Boggs, Rex. Exploring Data. http://exploringdata.cqu.edu.au. This is an excellent site for AP Statistics teaching materials and downloadable activities. Chance. Materials to help teach a Chance course (a quantitative literacy course). w ww.dartmouth.edu/~chance. Includes sample activities, videos, assessments, and archives of Chance Newsdescriptions of recent news articles involving probability and statistics along with suggested discussion questions. CIA World Factbook. w ww.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook. Consortium for the Advancement of Undergraduate Statistics Education (CAUSE). w ww.causeweb.org. CAUSE has many resources, among the most valuable to teachers being the extensive set of lesson examples and applets available for teaching statistical concepts. Among the hundreds is one using the criminal trials in the U.S. justice system to illustrate hypothesis testing; another features the creation of 95 percent confidence intervals for the theoretical mean. Coons, Al. BB&N AP Statistics. Al Coons AP Statistics class Web site. w ww.bbn-school.org/us/math/ap_stats. An excellent source of links to applets, tests, and projects. Data and Story Library. http://lib.stat.cmu.edu/DASL. Derksen, Jared. AP Statistics FAQ. w ww.mrderksen.com/faq.htm. Frequently asked questions about statistical concepts for new teachers. This site is a subdivision of MrDerksen.com (www.mrderksen.com) and is described in detail in chapter 2. It contains a wealth of information culled from the AP Statistics EDG, along with links to experienced teachers Web sites, a number of which are also listed here. Gallup Organization. w ww.gallup.com.
237
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
Lock, Robin. WWW Resources for Teaching Statistics. http://it.stlawu.edu/~rlock/maa51/www.html. An excellent place to look for data sets and other online materials with some commentary. McGrail, Sheila. AP Stat Resources. w ww.ccds.charlotte.nc.us/mcgrail/apsres.htm. Molesky, Jason. AP Statistics at Lakeville South High School in Minnesota. http://web.mac.com/statsmonkey. North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics. NCSSM Statistics Institutes. http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_Inst/links_to_all_stats_institutes.htm. NCSSM has been a great incubator for the creation of teachers material for AP Statistics. Here you will find a wonderful array of activities, lessons with teachers notes, and Web-based resources for your use in class. For a new teacher, the material produced during the 2007 institute will the most beneficial starting point. Rice Virtual Lab in Statistics. http://onlinestatbook.com/rvls.html Great site for Java applets that illustrate sampling distributions (outstanding!) and demonstrations for confidence intervals, normal approximation to the binomial, and power, among others. Smart, Joyce. Mrs. Smarts AP Statistics Page. Teacher site. w ww.lhs.logan.k12.ut.us/~jsmart/stats.html. U.S. Census Bureau. w ww.census.gov. West, Webster. Java Applets. w ww.stat.tamu.edu/~west/javahtml.
Assessment Sites
ARTIST (Assessment Resource Tools for Improving Statistical Thinking). https://app.gen.umn.edu/artist/index.html. Here students can take online multiple-choice quizzes that are topic specific. The site also offers preand post-tests, as well as a large database that can be searched for items to add to a test or quiz. It is also possible to create a test or quiz at the site, then download it to your computer in Microsoft Word. Schott, Brian, Georgia State University. Database of Sample Statistics Quiz Questions. w ww.gsu.edu/~dscbms/ibs/ibsd.html. Schott, Brian, Georgia State University. Practice Questions for Business Statistics. w ww.gsu.edu/~dscbms/ibs/qcontent.html. Through an NSF grant, the Department of Business Statistics at Georgia State University has developed a large collection of useful test questions, both multiple-choice (see the previous entry) and free-response (this one).
238
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Simon Fraser University, Department of Statistics and Actuarial Science. SFU Statistics Multiple-Choice Questions. w ww.stat.sfu.ca/~cschwarz/MultipleChoice A wonderful assortment of multiple-choice questions, with answers, that can be used on tests and for exam review preparation. See also Long Answer Questions, also on the Simon Fraser site: w ww.stat.sfu.ca/~cschwarz/LongAnswer/.
Calculator Company Sites
Casio. w ww.casio.com. Hewlett-Packard. w ww.hp.com/calculators. Sharp. w ww.sharpusa.com/products. Texas Instruments. w ww.education.ti.com.
Professional Associations
As a new teacher of AP Statistics, another way to stay current in the discipline is to join one or more professional organizations. American Mathematical Association of Two-Year Colleges Southwest Tennessee Community College 5983 Macon Cove Memphis, TN 38134 901 333-4643 www.amatyc.org E-mail: amatyc@amatyc.org American Statistical Association 732 North Washington Street Alexandria, VA 22314-1943 703 684-1221; 888 231-3473 www.amstat.org E-mail: asainfo@amstat.org Click on the Education link in the sidebar to bring up the Center for Statistics Education. The Education menu also has a link to the Statistics Teacher Network, where you can sign up to receive the newsletter, browse older issues, and link to materials for K12 statistics. A K12 school membership is currently $50. You receive STATS and Chance magazines as part of the membership, as well as the Statistics Teacher Network newsletter.
239
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
Consortium for the Advancement of Undergraduate Statistics Education Ohio State University, Department of Statistics 404 Cockins Hall 1958 Neil Avenue Columbus, OH 43210-1247 614 292-3887 www.causeweb.org E-mail: info@causeweb.org Mathematical Association of America 1529 18th Street NW Washington, DC 20036-1385 202 387-5200; 800 741-9415 www.maa.org E-mail: maahq@maa.org National Council of Teachers of Mathematics 1906 Association Drive Reston, VA 22091-1502 703 620-9840 www.nctm.org E-mail: inquiries@nctm.org This section on information sources has presented a blueprint for establishing a core group of resources and then adding to it over time. Given the large amount of material that I have assembled, this may seem to be an overwhelming task. Just as a museum builds its art collection over time, so too should this chapter be thought of as a long-term plan for the acquisition of a statistical collection. Do not expect it to happen overnight. During my first year, in 1996, I concentrated on the textbook, gathered news articles on a regular basis to use in class, screened some videos, and worked on some data-gathering activities. In subsequent years I added to my repertoire. Be realistic about what you can accomplishmaybe it is just the textbook, a review guide, some news articles, and a single project in your first year. Try to do a bit more the second year. I encourage you to regularly peruse the resources on AP Central and experienced teacher Web sites. If you go to a conference, seek out the sessions that are about statistics. Talk to other statistics teachers, and ask them not only what favorite resources they use but how they use them in the classroom. I have obtained much useful information over a cup of coffee or standing in line waiting for a session. Best wishes as you embark on a truly wonderful teaching experience. For me, AP Statistics has been a richly rewarding and fun course to teach. As many students have said to me, I never had to ask, When am I ever going to use this?
How to Address Lmted Resources
Teachers in certain schools may face distinct challenges, such as small enrollments or limited budgets. In those cases, keep in mind that the number one free resource for all teachers is AP Central. Every AP Statistics teacher should be registered there in order to take advantage of the large amount of support material conveniently available:
240
The AP Statistics Course Description Reviews of textbooks, teaching materials, and Web sites
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Section II (free-response) questions and scoring guidelines from past exams An AP Statistics Practice Exam with scoring guidelines and multiple-choice answer key Sample syllabi and articles on teaching the course Link to the AP Statistics Electronic Discussion Group, where you will find other teachers interested in statistics pedagogy Link to the College Board Store, where you can purchase Released Exams and supplemental materials, such as the sampling and experimental design module Link to information on Professional Development opportunities such as AP Summer Institutes and workshops and online events
Spending Wisely For those of us operating with a limited budget, the essential issue is how best to allocate what money is available. Two items are not negotiable, in my opinion. The textbook must be modern enough to cover the whole AP syllabus, and each student must have a graphing calculator with statistical capability. My students all own their own calculators, but a classroom set purchased by the school will suffice if they can use them at home. Next in order of priority is access to computers with statistical software. Students are expected to know how to read computer output when they take the AP Statistics Exam. Clearly, students understanding will improve if they produce the output, so even one computer for individual student use or demonstrations is advisable. At my school we bought a site license for the software and have it installed on computers in a computer lab. I just need to reserve the lab in advance to take the class there. There are creative ways to overcome either budget or size restrictions. I have been doing an experiment comparing brands of paper towels by trading classrooms with a science teacher so we have access to water. (This experiment is modeled after one done at a Statistics Leadership Institute held at the North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics; see http://courses.ncssm.edu/math/Stat_Inst/PDFS/ PaperTow.pdf.) We have also used local supermarkets for data collection activities, such as recording the sugar content shown on the boxes in the cereal aisle. Each student purchases a small bag of Skittles® so that we can check distribution of colors in the bags. These days a lot of product and/or nutritional information is available directly from stores and restaurants or can be accessed online. Finding free or inexpensive materials for your course shouldnt be difficult: a little imagination is all that is required. Dennis Holland, The Derryfield School, Manchester, New Hampshire
Here are some other strategies that may help you deal with limited resources.
Form a support group by finding other statistics teachers in your area. If you attend an AP Summer Institute (which I absolutely recommend) or a local/regional workshop, be on the lookout for others in your area. Post a sign-up list at the conference to get your local group started. Try to meet several times a year to discuss statistics. Pool your resources by sharing tests, quizzes, activities that worked well, review materials, textbooks, and supplies. Sometimes buying in bulk makes it worthwhile. You may be the only statistics teacher in your school, with no one to talk to on a regular basis. Maintain contact with your group via e-mail.
241
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
If you attend an AP Summer Institute, the lead teacher is likely to provide you with lots of good material. Try to maintain a relationship with that person. I am still in contact with participants from six or seven years ago, who will occasionally e-mail me a question. The College Board, through the AP Fellows program, can help qualified candidates with funding so that they can attend AP Summer Institutes. See the subsection on AP Grants in the Professional Development section that begins on the next page. Use free online statistical software if you are unable to purchase software or do not have direct access to a computer lab (see the list of software that appeared earlier in this chapter). Make full use of your textbooks Web site. There are likely to be lots of support materials there tests and quizzes, textbook solutions, applets, and classroom demonstrations. If you order enough textbooks, many companies will include the ancillary materials at no cost. Ask! Collaborate with a local university. Find a professor who teaches statistics, and establish a collaborative relationship. Invite the professor to give a guest lecture. Contact the ASA to find out if any members live in your area. Many are interested in helping out. Develop a plan to ensure that all students have access to a graphing calculator. Look for a local company that might be willing to partner with the statistics program in your school to provide funds for some extra teaching materials, calculators, or other useful items that would otherwise break your departments budget. Investigate whether your state has special funds for AP Programs that you can access. Look for simple things to do that might be free.
Get Creative with Small Classes In a small school setting, resources may be scarce, but that does not mean that the instruction provided must suffer. Although it is essential that each student has a text and a calculator with statistics functions that can be brought home to use on homework, a course can easily be supplemented without purchasing statistics software. An abundance of Web sites are available with applets that work very well for demonstrating major topics. Many other demonstrations and simulations can easily be conducted on a calculator. A teacher must be creative in other ways as well, especially when class sizes are very small (10 or fewer). Sampling students in a small class is not as effective as in a large one, but you might be able to collect data from the whole school. In some ways this is better, as students have to decide on reasonable ways to randomize while obtaining a sample large enough to draw meaningful conclusions. Pooling results in a simulation, for example, may require that each student repeat the process quite a few times. The data from one year can be saved and added to the next. Inexpensive materials such as breakfast cereal, colored candies, or paper clips may be used for data. Chris True, Lincoln Southwest High School, Lincoln, Nebraska
242
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
Talk Is Cheap Each year after the AP Statistics Exam, I invite a guest speaker to address my classes. The speakers have always exceeded my expectations. They describe their education-to-career journey as well as the ways they use statistics in their work. Past speakers have been a university professor, an information researcher, and two pharmaceutical statisticians. One good practice is to have students write questions ahead of time and e-mail them to the speaker. It is not hard to find engaging speakers. One was the parent of one of my students; one was discovered by simply e-mailing a company with a concise description of what I was looking for; and another was located by e-mailing the local ASA chapter for a contact. All methods have produced competent and willing (and free!) speakers. Dave Ferris, Noblesville High School, Noblesville, Indiana
Professonal Development
In this section, the College Board outlines its professional development opportunities in support of AP educators. The teachers, administrators, and AP Coordinators involved in the AP and Pre-AP Programs compose a dedicated, engaged, vibrant community of educational professionals. Welcome! We invite you to become an active participant in the community. The College Board offers a variety of professional development opportunities designed to educate, support, and invigorate both new and experienced AP teachers and educational professionals. These year-round offerings range from half-day workshops to intensive weeklong summer institutes, from the AP Annual Conference to AP Central, and from participation in an AP Reading to Development Committee membership.
Workshops and Summer Institutes
At the heart of the College Boards professional development offerings are workshops and summer institutes. Participating in an AP workshop is generally one of the first steps to becoming a successful AP teacher. Workshops range in length from half-day to weeklong events and are focused on all 37 AP courses and a range of supplemental topics. Workshop consultants are innovative, successful, and experienced AP teachers; teachers trained in Pre-AP skills and strategies; college faculty members; and other qualified educational professionals who have been trained and endorsed by the College Board. For new and experienced teachers, these course-specific training opportunities encompass all aspects of AP course content, organization, evaluation, and methodology. For administrators, counselors, and AP Coordinators, workshops address critical issues faced in introducing, developing, supporting, and expanding Pre-AP and AP programs in secondary schools. They also serve as a forum for exchanging ideas about AP. While the AP Program does not have a set of formal requirements that teachers must satisfy prior to teaching an AP course, the College Board suggests that AP teachers have considerable experience and an advanced degree in the discipline before undertaking an AP course. AP Summer Institutes provide teachers with in-depth training in AP courses and teaching strategies. Participants engage in at least 30 hours of training led by College Boardendorsed consultants and receive printed materials, including excerpts from AP Course Descriptions, AP Exam information, and other
243
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
course-specific teaching resources. Many locations offer guest speakers, field trips, and other hands-on activities. Each institute is managed individually by staff at the sponsoring institution under the guidelines provided by the College Board. Participants in College Board professional development workshops and summer institutes are eligible for continuing education units (CEUs). The College Board is authorized by the International Association for Continuing Education and Training (IACET) to offer CEUs. IACET is an internationally recognized organization that provides standards and authorization for continuing education and training. Workshop and institute offerings for the AP Statistics teacher (or potential teacher) range from introductory to topic-specific events and include offerings tailored to teachers in the Pre-AP years. To learn more about scheduled workshops and summer institutes near you, visit the Institutes and Workshops area on AP Central: apcentral.collegeboard.com/events.
Online Events
The College Board offers a wide variety of online events, which are presented by College Boardendorsed consultants and recognized subject-matter experts to participants via a Web-based, real-time interface. Online events range from one hour to several days and are interactive, allowing for exchanges between the presenter and participants and between participants. Like face-to-face workshops, online events vary in focus from introductory themes to specific topics, and many offer CEUs for participants. For a complete list of upcoming and archived online events, visit apcentral.collegeboard.com/onlineevents/schedule. Archives of past online events are available for free. Archived events can be viewed on your computer at your convenience.
AP Central
AP Central is the College Boards online home for AP professionals and Pre-AP. The site offers a wealth of resources, including Course Descriptions, sample syllabi, exam questions, a vast database of teaching resource reviews, lesson plans, course-specific feature articles, and much more. Bookmark the AP Statistics Home Page on AP Central to gain quick access to updated resources and information about AP Statistics. AP Program information is also available on the site, including exam calendars, fee and fee-reduction policies, student performance data, participation forms, research reports, college and university AP grade acceptance policies, and more. AP professionals are encouraged to contribute to the resources on AP Central by submitting articles, adding comments to Teachers Resources reviews, and serving as an AP Central Content Advisor.
Electronic Discussion Groups
The AP Electronic Discussion Groups (EDGs) were created to provide a moderated forum for the exchange of ideas, insights, and practices among AP teachers, AP Coordinators, consultants, AP Exam Readers, administrators, and college faculty. EDGs are Web-based threaded discussion groups focused on specific AP courses or roles, giving participants the ability to ask and answer questions online for viewing by other members of the EDG. To join an EDG, visit apcentral.collegeboard.com/community/edg.
244
Resources for Teachers About AP Statistics
AP Annual Conference
The AP Annual Conference (APAC) is a gathering of the AP and Pre-AP communities, including teachers, secondary school administrators, and college faculty. The APAC is the only national conference that focuses on providing complete strategies for middle and high school teachers and administrators involved in the AP Program. Conference events include presentations by each courses Development Committee, course- and topic-specific sessions, guest speakers, and pre- and postconference workshops for new and experienced teachers. To learn more about the event, please visit collegeboard.com/apac. AP professionals are encouraged to lead workshops and presentations at the conference. Proposals are due in the fall of each year prior to the event (visit AP Central for specific deadlines and requirements).
Professional Opportunities
College Board Consultants and Contributors
Experienced AP teachers and educational professionals share their techniques, best practices, materials, and expertise with other educators by serving as College Board consultants and contributors. They may lead workshops and summer institutes, sharing their proven techniques and best practices with new and experienced AP teachers, AP Coordinators, and administrators. They may also contribute to AP course and exam development (writing exam questions or serving on a Development Committee) or evaluate AP Exams at the annual AP Reading. Consultants and contributors may be teachers, postsecondary faculty, counselors, administrators, and retired educators. They receive an honorarium for their work and are reimbursed for expenses. To learn more about becoming a workshop consultant, visit apcentral .collegeboard.com/consultant.
AP Exam Readers
High school and college faculty members from around the world gather in the United States each June to evaluate and score the free-response sections of the AP Exams at the annual AP Reading. AP Exam Readers are led by a Chief Reader, a college professor who has the responsibility of ensuring that students receive grades that accurately reflect college-level achievement. Readers describe the experience as providing unparalleled insight into the exam evaluation process and as an opportunity for intensive collegial exchange between high school and college faculty. (More than 10,500 Readers participated in the 2008 Reading.) High school Readers receive certificates awarding professional development hours and CEUs for their participation in the AP Reading. To apply to become an AP Reader, go to apcentral .collegeboard.com/readers.
Development Committee Members
The dedicated members of each courses Development Committee play a critical role in the preparation of the Course Description and exam. They represent a diverse spectrum of knowledge and points of view in their fields and, as a group, are the authority when it comes to making subject-matter decisions in the exam-construction process. The AP Development Committees represent a unique collaboration between high school and college educators.
AP Grants
The College Board offers a suite of competitive grants that provide financial and technical assistance to schools and teachers interested in expanding access to AP. The suite consists of three grant programs: College Board AP Fellows, College Board Pre-AP Fellows, and the AP Start-Up Grant, totaling over
245
Chapter 5 Chapter 1
$600,000 in annual support for professional development and classroom resources. The programs provide stipends for teachers and schools that want to start an AP program or expand their current program. Schools and teachers that serve minority and/or low-income students who have been traditionally underrepresented in AP courses are given preference. To learn more, visit apcentral.collegeboard.com/ apgrants.
Our Commitment to Professional Development
The College Board is committed to supporting and educating AP teachers, AP Coordinators, and administrators. We encourage you to attend professional development events and workshops to expand your knowledge of and familiarity with the AP course(s) you teach or that your school offers, and then to share that knowledge with other members of the AP community. In addition, we recommend that you join professional associations, attend meetings, and read journals to help support your involvement in the community of educational professionals in your discipline. By working with other educational professionals, you will strengthen that community and increase the variety of teaching resources you use. Your work in the classroom and your contributions to professional development help the AP Program continue to grow, providing students worldwide with the opportunity to engage in college-level learning while still in high school.
246
...

View Full Document