This preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.
Unformatted text preview: (4 points) Explanation of how/why each study supports position (For EACH article: 0.25 pt for clearly stating position and 0.25 pt for justification using strengths and weaknesses identified) 3. USE OF REFERENCES (1 point) All 4 references are actively used within text and citation format is correct within text and on reference page. (For EACH article: 0.125 pt for active usage and 0.125 pt for correct format). (No article within last 2 years lose 0.2pts). 4. CONCLUSIONS (3 points) Concise summary Integration of evidence into own conclusion with all 4 articles cited 5. ORGANIZATION (3 points) Controversy, students position and its relevance in introduction Logical sequence and proper transitions 6. LANGUAGE/RHETORIC (1.5 points) Grammar, Spelling, Style and Creativity 7. OVERALL QUALITY (4.5 points) Persuasive (was data shown? Were strengths & weaknesses compared?) One copy submitted, appropriate length, fonts, etc. __________________ ( / 25) TOTAL...
View Full Document
- Fall '05