Unformatted text preview: Rational: The court has always considered life more important than property. The facts maybe different had the defendant actually were in the homes. However, no one was home, and the trap was too high of a deterrent to the crime Holding: Narrow: Traps that cost great bodily injuries cannot be set up on a property to prevent tresspasses or petty crimes that does not invovle life threatening crimes Broad:Traps, that causes serious bodily injuries cannot be installed to prevent crimes of un-felonious nature. Synthesis: Dissent/Concurrences: Dissent: states that, since there was no intent to cause great bodily injure or to kill someone when setting up the gun, then that defense could kick in. Also, he believes, no punative damages should be instated because the others broke in with the intent to steal....
View Full Document
- Fall '11
- theft, Physical trauma, Riot control, Trap shooting