PS06-solutions - MATH 681 Problem Set #6 Solutions 1. (25...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–2. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: MATH 681 Problem Set #6 Solutions 1. (25 points) Given posets ( S, S ) and ( T, T ) , let us consider the set S T subjected to the relation which is such that ( a,b ) ( c,d ) if and only if a S c and b S d . (a) (5 points) Show that is a partial ordering on ( S T ) . For any s S and t T , reflexivity of S and T guarantee that s S s and t T t , so ( s,t ) ( s,t ). Thus is reflexive. If ( a,b ), ( c,d ), and ( e,f ) are elements of S T such that ( a,b ) ( c,d ) and ( c,d ) ( e,f ), the definition of guarantees that a S c and c S e , so by transitivity of S , a S e ; likewise b T d and d T f , so since T is transitive, b f . Thus, ( a,b ) ( e,f ), exhibiting transitivity of . Finally, let us demonstrate antisymmetry. For ( a,b ) and ( c,d ) in S T , let us explore the circumstances under which it can be true that both ( a,b ) ( c,d ) and ( c,d ) ( a,b ). The former relation requires that a S c and b T d ; the latter that c S a and d T b . By antisymmetry of S , since a S c and c S a , it must be the case that a = c ; likewise, b T d and d T d requires that b = d . Thus, ( a,b ) ( c,d ) and ( c,d ) ( a,b ) only if ( a,b ) = ( c,d ), so is antisymmetric. (b) (5 points) Show that ( a,b ) is a maximal (or minimal) element of S T if and only if a and b are maximal (or minimal) elements of S and T respectively. We need only prove this for the maximal case; the argument for minimal ( a,b ) is identical with all orderings reversed. If ( a,b ) is maximal, then for all ( c,d ) 6 = ( a,b ), it follows that ( a,b ) ( c,d ); in particular, for all d 6 = b , we know that ( a,b ) ( a,d ). This will be true only if either a S a or b T d . The first possibility is clearly not true (by reflexivity of S ); thus the latter must be true, and since it is true for all d , b must be maximal in T . A similar inspection of the comparison ( a,b ) ( c,b ) will demonstrate maximality of a in S . Conversely, if a is maximal in S and b is maximal in T , then we may show that ( a,b ) is maximal in S T by considering the circumstances under which ( a,b ) ( c,d ). This can happen only if a c and b d ; however, by maximality of a and b , this is only the case if a = c and b = d . Thus, the only ( c,d ) for which ( a,b ) ( c,d ) is one equal to ( a,b ), so ( a,b ) is maximal. (c) (5 points) Show that if C is a chain in S T , then the set C S of first coordinates of elements of C is a chain in S . (similarly, it is true that the set C T of second coordinates of elements of C is a chain in T ). If x and y are elements of C S , then by the construction of C S there must be elements ( x,a ) and ( y,b ) of C . Since C is a chain in S T , it must be the case that ( x,a ) ( y,b ) or ( y,b ) ( x,a ). Thus, by the definition of , either x S y or y S x . Thus x and y are comparable; since x and y were arbitrarily chosen, it follows that any two members of C S are comparable, so C S is a chain. The argument for C T proceeds along similar lines....
View Full Document

Page1 / 5

PS06-solutions - MATH 681 Problem Set #6 Solutions 1. (25...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 2. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online