day5 - PADP 6950: Founda1ons of Policy Analysis...

Info iconThis preview shows page 1. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

Unformatted text preview: PADP 6950: Founda1ons of Policy Analysis Intertemporal Choice & Uncertainty Angela Fer1g, PhD Special cases: Different kinds of goods to choose between Before: food and other goods, etc. Intertemporal Choice: cc now vs. cc future Uncertainty: cc if state 1 (e.g. sick) vs. cc if state 2 (e.g. healthy) 1 Intertemporal Budget Constraint c 2 = m2 + (m1 - c1 ) + r(m1 - c1 ) c 2 = m2 + (1 + r)(m1 - c1 ) c 2 + (1 + r)c1 = m2 + (1 + r)m1 c2 m2 c1 + = m1 + (1 + r) (1 + r) p1 = 1 Budget constraint in present value terms: p2 = 1 (1 + r) Intertemporal Budget Line c1 + c2 m2 = m1 + (1 + r) (1 + r) Y-intercept (c2): assume c1=0 c 2 = (1 + r)m1 + m2 c1 = m1 + m2 (1 + r) X-intercept (c1): assume c2=0 Slope: transform to form y=b+mx c 2 = (1 + r)m1 + m2 - (1 + r)c1 2 Graph How does line change when interest rate changes? If r goes from 0.05 to 0.1: slope=-(1+r) goes from -1.05 to -1.1 (steeper) c2-intercept shiYs up c1-intercept shiYs back Must pivot around endowment point. 3 Intertemporal Indifference Curve If straight line (perfect subs1tutes): consumer doesn't care whether they consume today or tomorrow If L-shaped (perfect complements): consumer wants equal amounts today and tomorrow More realis1c: convex, well-behaved indifference curve What happens to a lender when r goes up? 4 What happens to a borrower when r goes up? Discount rate Discount rate () = the rate at which we discount the value of the future We usually just let =r (interest rate) A dollar today could be invested in an interest-bearing instrument (bond) and then it would be worth $1*(1+r) in the next period So, $1 in the future is worth $1/(1+r) today However, some people are more impa1ent and have a higher discount rate than r and some are very pa1ent and for them, <r Discount rates are a very important determinant of people's intertemporal choices: Risky behavior decisions Investment decisions Some say just as important as IQ in determining child's academic success 5 Net Present Value (or Discoun1ng) General formula: NPV = t =T Vt t t =1 (1 + r) Example 1: What is $100 given to me in 1 year worth to me today (assume r=0.05)? $100 NPV = = $95.24 1.05 Example 2: What is $300 given to me in 3 installments over the next 3 years worth to me today? NPV = $100 $100 $100 + + = $95.24 + $90.70 + $86.38 = $272.32 1.05 1.05 2 1.05 3 Policy Applica1on: Benefit-Cost Analysis Discoun1ng is used for comparisons of different streams of benefits and/or costs over a number of periods/years. Assume discount rate=20%. Example: Investment A: returns $20 at end of Year 1 and $20 at end of Year 2 Investment B: returns $12 at end of Year 1 and $29 at the end of Year 2 A provides a total of $40 and B provides a total $41 so should we choose B? 6 Choice under uncertainty When deciding how much insurance to buy, really deciding between consump1on in 2 states: no loss/no illness vs. loss/illness If no insurance available, then there is no choice: (mg,mb) If insurance becomes available, then you can make a choice about how much to get. Your budget line will depend on the premium charged. Assume insurance coverage K costs K (premium): If have loss, have: If no loss, have: mb + K - K = mb + (1- )K m g - K Choice under uncertainty noins ins m g - m g + K rise c g - c g - slope = = noins = = ins run c b - c b mb - mb - (1- )K (1- ) Assume indifference curve is convex as usual. If endowment isn't at the tangent point, then buy insurance. 7 U1lity under uncertainty Another factor that must be considered (besides the premium) is: What is the probability that the bad event will occur? It is taken into considera1on through an expected u#lity func#on: U = i u(c i ) i=1 i=N Expected U1lity vs. Value If just 2 possible states: U=u(c1)+(1-)u(c2) Note this is different from expected value: EV=c1+(1-)c2 8 Risk aversion We assume that the u1lity func1on with respect to wealth/money for most is upward sloping and concave: Happier if richer, but not twice as happy if twice as rich Diminishing marginal u1lity of wealth Implica1on of this concavity: having money with certainty makes you happier than having it with some uncertainty people don't like risk Example to demonstrate the connec1on between concavity of U & risk aversion W=$20; If sick (5% chance), then W=$10, U=ln(W) Expected value: E(W ) = (1- )W well + W sick = 0.95 * $20 + 0.05 * $10 = $19.50 Expected u#lity without risk: U(E(W )) = U($19.50) = ln(19.50) = 2.97 Point on the U(wealth) curve 9 Example con1nued In reality, you don't get $19.50, you get $10 with a 5% probability and $20 with a 95% probability. Expected u#lity with risk: E(U) = (1- )U(W well ) + U(W sick ) = 0.95 * ln($20) + 0.05 * ln($10) = 2.965 Point below the U(wealth) curve 10 Risk premium Risk premium is the amount people are willing to pay to avoid risk: Risk premium = E(W) w/ risk that gives U1 - W w/ certainty that gives U1 = E(W)-WE(U) In this example, E(W)=$19.50 and WE(U)=eln(W)=e2.965=$19.39, so risk premium=11 cents 11 ...
View Full Document

Ask a homework question - tutors are online