This preview shows pages 1–2. Sign up to view the full content.
This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.View Full Document
Unformatted text preview: (1) Gaunilo Island exists in the understanding but not in reality (2) Existence in reality is greater than existence in the understanding alone (3) An island having all Gaunilo Island’s properties plus existence in reality can be conceived (4) An island having all Gaunilo Island’s properties plus existence in reality is greater than Gaunilo Island [From (1) and (2)] (5) Thus, an island greater than Gaunilo Island can be conceived [From (3) and (4)] (6) Thus, an island greater than the greatest conceivable island can be conceived [From (5) and the definition of “Gaunilo Island”] (7) But (6) is false (8) Assumption (1) entails (6) (9) Thus, (1) is false [From (7) and (8)] (10) Gaunilo Island exists in the understanding (11) Thus, Gaunilo Island exists in reality [From (9) and (10)]...
View Full Document
This note was uploaded on 01/24/2012 for the course PHIL 1 taught by Professor Lewis during the Fall '08 term at UCSB.
- Fall '08