1
8th April 2011
Instructions
: Answer 7 of the following 9 questions. All questions are of equal
weight. Indicate clearly on the
f
rst page which questions you want marked.
1. Answer both parts.
(a) What does it mean to say that a utility function,
u
(
·
)
, represents a preference
relation on some choice set
X
?P
r
o
v
et
h
a
ti
f
u
(
·
)
represents preference relation
±
,
this preference relation must be complete and transitive.
(b) Now suppose
X
=
R
2
+
and
(
x
1
1
,x
1
2
)
"
(
x
2
1
,x
2
2
)
when
x
1
1
>x
2
1
,
or
x
1
1
=
x
2
1
and
x
1
2
>x
2
2
.
Is this preference relation complete, transitive and continuous? Defend your
answers.
ANSWER
(a) A utility function
u
:
X
→
R
represents a preference relation
±
on the choice
set
X
if
∀
x, y
∈
X, x
±
y
⇔
u
(
x
)
≥
u
(
y
)
.
Completeness: We need to show that
∀
x, y
∈
X
,e
ither
x
±
y
or
y
±
x
or both.
Now note that
u
(
x
)
and
u
(
y
)
are real numbers so either
u
(
x
)
≥
u
(
y
)
in which case
x
±
y
or
u
(
y
)
≥
u
(
x
)
in which case
y
±
x
;i
f
u
(
x
)=
u
(
y
)
we know both are true.
Transitivity: Suppose
x,y,z
∈
X
,and
x
±
y
and
y
±
z.
We need to show
x
±
z.
Since
u
represents
±
,u
(
x
)
≥
u
(
y
)
and
u
(
y
)
≥
u
(
z
)
. Since these are real numbers
u
(
x
)
≥
u
(
z
)
⇒
x
±
z.
(b) This is an example of lexicographic preferences where good 1 is the dominant
good. Lexicographic preferences are complete and transitive but not continuous.
Completeness: Consider any two distinct points in
R
2
+
–
(
x
1
1
,x
1
2
)
(point
a
)and
(
x
2
1
,x
2
2
)
(point
b
). If
x
1
1
>x
2
1
,a
"
b.
If
x
2
1
>x
1
1
,b
"
a.
If
x
1
1
=
x
2
1
,
since
a
and
b
are
distinct, it must be that either
x
1
2
>x
2
2
in which case
a
"
b
or
x
2
2
>x
1
2
in which case
b
"
a.
Transitivity: Let
a,b,c
∈
R
2
+
where
a
=(
x
1
1
,x
1
2
)
,b
=(
x
2
1
,x
2
2
)
and
c
=(
x
3
1
,x
3
2
)
.
Suppose
a
"
b
and
b
"
c.
We want to prove
a
"
c.
Now notice that
a
"
b
and
b
"
c
⇒
x
1
1
≥
x
3
This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.
View Full Document2
x
1
1
=
x
2
1
=
x
3
1
in which case it must be that
x
1
2
>x
2
2
>x
3
2
, and thus
x
1
2
>x
3
2
which
means
a
"
c.
In case (ii)
x
1
1
>x
3
1
andthenimmed
iate
lyweknow
a
"
c.
Continuity: Suppose
{
x
n
}
⊂
R
2
+
and
lim
n
→∞
x
n
=
x
and
{
y
n
}
⊂
R
2
+
and
lim
n
→∞
y
n
=
y
and
x
n
"
y
n
,
∀
n.
Then if
"
were continuous we would be able to deduce that
x
"
y.
Here is one counterexample. Let
x
n
=(1
/n,
0)
and
y
n
=(0
,
1)
.
Then
x
=(0
,
0)
,
y
=(0
,
1)
,x
n
"
y
n
∀
n
but
y
"
x.
So lexicographic preferences are complete and
transitive but they violate continuity.
2. This question applies what we have done in class this term to think about a car
bon tax. Suppose a typical Canadian household currently buys 200 litres of gasoline
per month at $1 per litre and spends $1800 per month buying goods (and services)
This is the end of the preview.
Sign up
to
access the rest of the document.
 Fall '08
 Burbidge,John
 Utility, Transitivity, p1

Click to edit the document details