Grading Rubric (20 Points) Criteria Description Points Possible Points Earned Thesis (9 points) Clear, perceptive, and focused; leads to an interesting, incisive, creative argument; takes on interesting, complex ideas; thesis stated early on and governs the entire essay; sufficiently limited in scope. 5-4 Muddled or difficult to decipher; ordinary or uninteresting, not especially creative or insightful; disappears in portions of the essay; may lack focus, be too broad. 3-2 No thesis or a thesis that is merely descriptive, not the heart of an argument; vague, confusing, or plainly erroneous thesis. 1-0 Quality of Argument (12 points) Excellent analysis of appropriate evidence; insightful and fresh ideas; much more than summary or paraphrase; evidence supports thesis; the reader is enriched because the writer has presented something new and interesting. The argument invites complications and includes consideration of a counter-argument 8-6 At times insightful, but sometimes mere summary or missing
This is the end of the preview. Sign up
access the rest of the document.