Updated IP Peer Review.doc - Issue Proposal Peer Review...

This preview shows page 1 - 2 out of 3 pages.

Issue Proposal Peer Review Prompt English 1302: Rhetoric and Composition II Instructions: To receive credit for this peer review, you must fully answer all of the below questions for your peer. If the writer has sufficiently fulfilled the requirements listed, you must explain how the requirement was fulfilled (in other words, you cannot simply write something like “yes, all these elements are clear”). If the writer has not sufficiently fulfilled the requirements listed, you need to explain exactly what is lacking as well as give suggestions for improvement. Introduction Early in the paper, the writer should incorporate what “they say” by situating his/her paper as a response to the conversation surrounding the issue he/she has selected. The writer should also state a thesis that states why the issue is appropriate for a semester of sustained research. Finally, the writer should make it clear why the issue matters by answering the “Who cares?” and “So what?” questions. Are all these elements clear to you? If so, prove it by repeating these elements back to the writer (feel free to quote the writer directly in your response). If not, describe what is missing and suggest some options

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture

  • Left Quote Icon

    Student Picture