Afghanistan+Core+Neg+06-13-2010

Afghanistan+Core+Neg+06-13-2010 - J(E)DI 2010 BTW 1...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–5. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
J(E)DI 2010 1 BTW Afghanistan Core Neg Afghanistan Core Neg **Case Debate**………………………. ...2 *Stability Answers* . ................................. 1 Instability Inevitable - Canada . ................... 2 Instability Inevitable - Iran . ......................... 3 Instability Inevitable – Iraq . ........................ 4 Instability Inevitable – Corruption . ............. 5 Instability Inevitable – Failed Infrastructure6 Instability Inevitable - Pakistan . ................. 7 Instability Inevitable – Opium . ................... 8 Instability Inevitable – Geopolitics . ............ 9 A2: Government Stability – Long T/F . ..... 10 A2: Government Stability – N/U . ............. 11 A2: Democracy in Afghanistan . ............... 12 A2: Karzai Credibility Advantage . ........... 13 A2: Central Asia War. ............................... 14 A2: Afghanistan Key to Central Asia . ...... 15 A2: Indo-Pak War . .................................... 16 A2: Insurgency - Inevitable . ..................... 17 A2: Troops = Key Factor . ......................... 18 *Soft Power/Anti-Americanism Answers*19 A2: Soft Power . ......................................... 20 A2: Anti-Americanism (1/2) . .................... 21 A2: Anti-Americanism (2/2) . .................... 22 A2: Anti-Americanism Recruitment . ... 23 A2: General Terrorism . ............................. 24 A2: Nuclear Terrorism . ............................. 25 A2: Retaliation to Terrorist Attacks . ......... 26 *Withdrawal Bad* . ................................. 27 Corruption . ................................................ 28 Stability . .................................................... 29 Stability (Pakistan Fill-In). ........................ 30 Terrorism. .................................................. 31 A2: Withdrawal Solves Insurgency . ......... 32 *Drones Good* . ....................................... 33 Efficiency/Civilian Casualties . ................. 34 Intelligence/Insurgency . ............................ 35 Intelligence . ............................................... 36 Terrorism. .................................................. 37 A2: Drones Undermine SP/Legitimacy . ... 38 A2: Drones are Immoral . .......................... 39 A2: Other Weapons Solve Drones . ........... 40 A2: Drones Violate I-Law . ....................... 41 **Disads** . .............................................. 42 Withdrawal in 2011 - Yes . ........................ 43 A2: Withdrawal Now . ............................... 44 A2: Withdrawal Now – Too Early To Tell 44 A2: Withdrawal Now – T/F Distinction . .. 46 **Politics** . ............................................. 47 *Obama Bad* . ......................................... 48 Afghan Stability Popular – PC and Agenda49 Withdrawal Popular – Thumper . ............... 50 Withdrawal Popular – PC/Agenda . ........... 51 Withdrawal Popular – Public . ................... 52 Withdrawal Popular - Congress . ............... 53 *Obama Good*. ....................................... 54 Withdrawal Unpopular – McCain . ............ 55 Withdrawal Unpopular – House . .............. 56 Withdrawal Unpopular – GOP . ................. 57 *Internals* . .............................................. 58 Politics Internal – Obama Gets The Blame59 Politics Internal – Obama Pushes the Plan 60 Politics Internal – Afghanistan Key to Agenda 61 **Relations**. .......................................... 62 Pakistan-Afghanistan Relations – Yes . ..... 63 US-Afghanistan Relations – No. ............... 64 **CMR** . ................................................ 65 CMR DA 1NC - Afghanistan (1/2) . .......... 66 CMR DA 1NC - Afghanistan (2/2) . .......... 67 UQ - CMR – Yes . ..................................... 68 L – Afghanistan Withdrawal . .................... 69 A2: Withdrawal Date Set . ......................... 70 L – Implementation . .................................. 71 L – Lacking Consultation . ......................... 72 L – Obama Policy Change . ....................... 73 L – Micromanage . ..................................... 74 A2: Stability Solves CMR . ....................... 75 I/L - Policy Differences × CMR . .............. 76 ! - Pakistan ! Calc . ..................................... 77 ! - Pakistan CMR Brink . ........................... 78 ! - CMR Key to Pakistan . .......................... 79 ! – CMR Good - Heg . ............................... 80 ! – CMR Good - Terror . ............................ 81 ! – CMR Good – Military Effectiveness . .. 82
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
J(E)DI 2010 1 BTW Afghanistan Core Neg **CPs** . ................................................... 83 *Full Withdrawal PIC* . ......................... 84 Full Withdrawal PIC 1NC (1/2) . ............... 85 Full Withdrawal PIC 1NC (2/2) . ............... 86 Full Withdrawal PIC – Solvency . ............. 87 Special Forces Good . ................................ 88 ! – Terrorism Outweighs All . .................... 89 A2: Al-Qaeda Defense . ............................. 90 A2: Generic Terrorism Defense . ............... 91 *Education CP* . ...................................... 92 Education CP 1NC . ................................... 93 Education Key to Stability . ....................... 94 A2: Nobody Attends/Taliban Interference 95 *Wheat CP* . ............................................ 96 Wheat CP 1NC . ......................................... 97 Solves Eradication . ................................... 98 Opium Key to Stability . ............................ 99 Hunger Add-On . ..................................... 100 A2: Farmers Won’t Switch . .................... 101 *India Licensing CP* . ........................... 102 India CP – 1NC . ...................................... 103 Solvency Ext . .......................................... 104
Background image of page 2
J(E)DI 2010 1 BTW Afghanistan Core Neg **Case Debate**
Background image of page 3

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full DocumentRight Arrow Icon
J(E)DI 2010 1 BTW Afghanistan Core Neg *Stability Answers*
Background image of page 4
Image of page 5
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

This note was uploaded on 02/23/2012 for the course DEBATE 101 taught by Professor None during the Spring '12 term at Berkeley.

Page1 / 107

Afghanistan+Core+Neg+06-13-2010 - J(E)DI 2010 BTW 1...

This preview shows document pages 1 - 5. Sign up to view the full document.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Ask a homework question - tutors are online