novice+lab+japan+aff - JDI 2010 Jack/Shah 1 Novice Japan Aff 1AC Inherency 2 1AC Plan 3 1AC Japan Politics Adv 4 1AC Japan Politics Adv 5 1AC Japan

JDI 2010 1 Jack/Shah Novice Japan Aff 1AC – Inherency ........................................................................................................................... 2 1AC – Plan ..................................................................................................................................... 3 1AC – Japan Politics Adv ............................................................................................................. 4 1AC – Japan Politics Adv ............................................................................................................. 5 1AC – Japan Politics Adv ............................................................................................................. 6 1AC – Alliance Adv ....................................................................................................................... 7 1AC – Alliance Adv ....................................................................................................................... 8 1AC – Alliance Adv ....................................................................................................................... 9 1AC – Alliance Adv ..................................................................................................................... 10 1AC – Alliance Adv ..................................................................................................................... 11 Inherency ..................................................................................................................................... 12 T cards .......................................................................................................................................... 13 General Ev – No Relocation ....................................................................................................... 14 Alliance UQ – Collapse Inev ...................................................................................................... 15 Alliance Link Extensions ............................................................................................................ 16 Japan Politics – Elections UQ .................................................................................................... 17 Japan Politics – A2: Protests Die Down .................................................................................... 18 Japan Politics – Link Extensions ............................................................................................... 19 Japan Politics – Tax Increase Good .......................................................................................... 20 Japan Politics – Tax Increase Good .......................................................................................... 21 A2: Deterrence DA ...................................................................................................................... 22 A2: Deterrence DA ...................................................................................................................... 23 A2: Relocation Solves ................................................................................................................. 24 A2: Co-operation CP .................................................................................................................. 25

This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document

JDI 2010 2 Jack/Shah Novice Japan Aff 1AC – Inherency First is Inherency Troops will stay in Okinawa – Kan won‘t challenge the United States VOA News, 6/8 2010 Voice of America News, Incoming Japanese Prime Minister Pledges to Honor Okinawa Deal, http://www1.voanews.com/english/news/asia/Japans-Incoming-PM-Names-New-Cabinet--95847009.html accessed 6/23/10 New Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan says he will honor a previous agreement with the United States to relocate a military air base on the southern island of Okinawa . Mr. Kan , inaugurated Tuesday, told reporters that Japan's relationship with the United States is at the core of its diplomacy . He said he hopes to meet with President Barack Obama later this month at a summit of the Group of Eight leading industrialized nations (Britain, Canada , France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia and the United States) in Canada.

JDI 2010 3 Jack/Shah Novice Japan Aff 1AC – Plan Plan: The United States federal government should remove nearly all United States military personnel from the Okinawa Prefecture.

This preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document

JDI 2010 4 Jack/Shah Novice Japan Aff 1AC – Japan Politics Adv Advantage One is Japan Politics The new base proposals will stay – but protests will intensify Schlesinger, Spiegel and Hayashi 6/3 2010 JACOB M. SCHLESINGER, PETER SPIEGEL And YUKA HAYASHI , Broad Issues in Okinawa Flap, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704515704575282484038831098.html?mod=WSJ_hpp_sections_ world Obama administration officials insist that the pact reached with Mr. Hatoyama had backing from the full DPJ leadership, and will outlast his administration . "We think we've reached a resolution of this relocation plan, and we will work with Japan to carry it out," said State Department spokesman P.J. Crowley. But Mr. Hatoyama's resignation has emboldened opponents of the plan — and are likely to make any successor much more cautious in proceeding. Yoshiyasu Iha, mayor of Ginowan City, where the unpopular Futenma helicopter base is currently located, said Mr. Hatoyama's resignation gave Okinawa an "opportunity for a new start" in its fight against U.S. bases . Hirokazu Nakaima, governor of Okinawa, repeated his assessment that getting Okinawa to agree to the plan was "extremely difficult." Mr. Nakaima previously supported the relocation plan but he has grown critical in recent months.