{[ promptMessage ]}

Bookmark it

{[ promptMessage ]}

FMW Theory - SDI 2010 File Name File Category Theory Theory...

Info iconThis preview shows pages 1–6. Sign up to view the full content.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
SDI 2010 File Category File Name Theory Theory ..................................................................................................................................................... 1 Theory .................................................................................................................................................. 1 Conditionality Bad .................................................................................................................................. 3 Conditionality Bad ............................................................................................................................. 3 Dispositionality Bad ................................................................................................................................ 4 Dispositionality Bad ........................................................................................................................... 4 Consult CP’s Bad .................................................................................................................................... 5 Consult CP’s Bad ............................................................................................................................... 5 2NC CP’s Bad ......................................................................................................................................... 6 2NC CP’s Bad ..................................................................................................................................... 6 Agent CP’s Bad ....................................................................................................................................... 7 Agent CP’s Bad ................................................................................................................................... 7 PIC’s Bad ................................................................................................................................................ 8 PIC’s Bad ............................................................................................................................................. 8 AT: ASPEC ............................................................................................................................................. 9 AT: ASPEC ......................................................................................................................................... 9 Conditionality Good .............................................................................................................................. 10 Conditionality Good ......................................................................................................................... 10 Dispo Good ........................................................................................................................................... 11 Dispo Good ........................................................................................................................................ 11 Agent CPs Good .................................................................................................................................... 12 Agent CPs Good ............................................................................................................................... 12 PICs Good ............................................................................................................................................. 13 PICs Good ......................................................................................................................................... 13 International Fiat Good .......................................................................................................................... 14 International Fiat Good .................................................................................................................. 14 AT: No Solvency Advocate ................................................................................................................... 15 AT: No Solvency Advocate ............................................................................................................. 15 AT: No Neg Fiat .................................................................................................................................... 16 AT: No Neg Fiat ............................................................................................................................... 16 2NC CPs Good ...................................................................................................................................... 17 2NC CPs Good .................................................................................................................................. 17 2NC Amendments Good ........................................................................................................................ 18 2NC Amendments Good .................................................................................................................. 18 1
Background image of page 1

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
SDI 2010 File Category File Name 2
Background image of page 2
SDI 2010 File Category File Name Conditionality Bad Offense 1. Not reciprocal- we cant run multiple plans to find the best example of the resolution 2. Time and strat skew: They could read 14 CP texts and we’d have to at least cover them all so they don’t develop one in the block. 3. Moving Target bad- Hurts fairness as well as education, we don’t know what the issues in the debate are until the 2NR. 4. Most real world- Policy makers cant propose competing pieces of legislation and I’ve never seen a senator unroll a list of 30 bills he/she might advocate that day 5. Makes for sloppy debate- Instead of creating effective strategies, negs can just guess and check 6. Voter for fairness and education Defense: 1. Who says neg flexibility is good, the already have a thousand kritiks and disads, random T violations, and whatever CP they run as long as its dispo. 2. Perm doesn’t check abuse: It’s just a test of competitiveness, advocated perms justify intrinsicness. 3
Background image of page 3

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
SDI 2010 File Category File Name Dispositionality Bad Offense 1. Just conditionality in disguise- the neg knows we cant strategically straight turn it. 2. Kills in depth education- We don’t analyze 2 competing policies. 3. Reciprocity- The aff will only have one advocacy, the neg gets an infinite number of combinations. Justifies affirmatie conditionality, severance and intrinsic perms 4. Infinitly regressive- Neg can run an infinite number of CP’s and defend the squo, they’ll just force us to perm 5. Moving target- We cant test their advocacy if we don’t know what position they take, kills predictability and fairness 6. Race to the bottom- If you want a debate where its just who reads the most impact turns v. net benefits than accept dispo, forcing straight turns is bad. 7. Voter for fairness Defense 1. Straight turns don’t check abuse- Its suicide not to perm the CP, we have not lit. base for offense 2. Perms don’t check abuse- It’s a test of competitiveness not an advocacy, this justifies severance and intrinsic perms 4
Background image of page 4
SDI 2010 File Category File Name Consult CP’s Bad 1. Infinitely regressive- The aff cant predict an infinite number of consultable actors and plan modifications 2. Time and strat skew- They moot every second of the 1AC, we only get one constructive to generate offense 3. Multiple actor fiat illegit –The aff is stuck with only the USFG. This gives the negative one more advantage.
Background image of page 5

Info iconThis preview has intentionally blurred sections. Sign up to view the full version.

View Full Document Right Arrow Icon
Image of page 6
This is the end of the preview. Sign up to access the rest of the document.

{[ snackBarMessage ]}